Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast

Ash StuartAudio

Format:
Podcast
New episodes:
Weekly
Typical length:
about 7 minutes
Latest episode:
Not rated yet
CosmosOpen at the sourceReport a problemIs this your show? Get a badge

About this show

Exploring innovation, progress and achievement: a first-principles approach to everything that matters; combining history, epistemology, economics, anthropology, geopolitics, finance, philology, etymology and more... for, life is short, knowledge forever.

ashstuart.substack.com (https://ashstuart.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast)

Covers: economics, personal finance, financial history, monetary history, money and banking, insurance, behavioral economics, inflation, financial crises

Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at api.substack.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.

Recently on this show

Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.

This podcast examines innovation, progress and achievement from first principles, drawing on history, economics and related fields. Recent episodes cover the Mississippi Bubble, moral hazard and insurance, bank runs, inflation, coin debasement, the origins of coins, and gold versus silver.

Report a problem with this summary

Cosmos

Similar in subject

See the full Cosmos

Similar shows

See all History shows

Explore more

Episodes

  • The Story of Money: Meeting Keynes

    · 9 min

    It’s now become a tradition that at every decimilestone of this series, we get to meet a historical figure of considerable importance to our story. We’ve met Adam Smith Episode 020 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p//ecfin020-the-story-of-money-meeting-adam-smith), Abraham Maslow Episode 030 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p//ecfin030-the-story-of-money-meeting-maslow), and today we meet John Maynard Keynes. Anyone who’s ever glanced a financial newspaper, especially in the days after the 2008 crash, is likely to have seen the term ‘Keynsian’ thrown about, and anyone who’s heard of Keynes would very likely associate him with his economic theories. But he was a lot more than that. Keynes’s early interest was in mathematics in which he graduated in 1905 from King’s College, Cambridge. It’s also notable that from the early days he was part of several close-knit associations of writers and intellectuals and cultivated an optimism that reflected the fact that in his formative years around the turn of the century, Britain was at the height of its global power. But this would be tested with the two great wars to come alongside the big economic challenges between them. In fact having started his career as a Civil Servant in the British government and left it shortly after to get into writing, he was called on by the government just before the outbreak of the Great War in 1914 to go back in, first informally, then with an official post at the Treasury -- an indication of the reputation he had already made for himself early on. The Three Pillars of Legend Keynes’s work at the Treasury, his bold decisions and moves, made him legendary, given the sheer challenge of navigating the new economic situation of WWI - “the war to end all wars”! His star rose even higher. In the Versailles peace conference that followed the armistice in 1919, Keynes attempted to ensure that the victorious powers did not impose too high a reparations burden on Germany, warning that not only would it be impracticable for Germany to pay back such high sums, but that it would severely backfire risking an even bigger war. Sadly, Britain, and especially France, were in no mood to listen, and we know all too well how it turned out. The next big challenge was of course the Great Depression that followed the crash of 1929 we covered in Episode 029 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p//ecfin029-the-story-of-money-the-great-crash-of-1929). This is when his ideas and theories as to how an economy should be managed, especially in times of such crises, came to the fore and had a huge impact on national policies across many countries. The third pillar of Keynes’s economic legacy, and arguably his most ambitious and challenging of the three was at the end of the Second World War. Keynes, now showing his age and often in poor health, represented the British Delegation at Bretton Woods, New Hampshire, the conference convened to set out the postwar world order. While he can be seen as a co-architect of the postwar order, given Britain’s precarious situation at the end of WWII, his position was significantly weaker than his American counterparts, and was thus overruled on several key points. But, it was not all just economic theory that we have to remember John Maynard Keynes for, as hinted he was about much more. Message in a Bottle But still, let’s first get the question of ‘Keynesianism’ out of the way - and we shall do so without taking ideological sides - to this date this is a very hotly debated topic. (Also, I’ll keep it extremely simple in this piece, we might have to come back to it over a series of episodes at a more advanced stage.) Keynes vehemently contested the prevailing orthodoxy in economics by insisting that markets were not always purely rational - we’ve probably had a hint of this when we explored TulipMania in Episode 028 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p//ecfin028-the-story-of-money-the-irrationality-of-rational-action) for example. Specifically, he…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Madness of the Mississippi Bubble

    · 8 min

    This is the story of one of the earliest and most spectacular bubbles and bursts in modern financial history, and how an outlaw made law and order and disorder, how a convicted murderer and fugitive and foreigner rose to amass the greatest financial clout and power in France, and fell and fled in disgrace. Let’s head to France in the year 1715. King Louis XIV is dead, the Spanish War of Succession -- a war with great consequences for Western Europe, which raged from 1701, is over, leaving France massively in debt. As an absolutist regime, the French monarch had used every means at his disposal to fund the war, such as massive coin debasement Episode 034 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin034-the-story-of-money-the-conundrum-of-coin-debasement), predatory and extractive taxation, to the effect that the impoverished French population had lost trust in French money and the State’s ability to honor the national debt - a huge portion of which was held by the citizenry. Things were desperate for the king, things were dire for the peasant. Enter a Scotsman. Paper Power John Law, an Edinburgh-born gambler and adventurer, who had developed his own theories, convicted for murdering a man in a duel over a woman, had just fled Britain and ended up in this milieu in France. The new king, Louis XV was only V, I mean 5, and his regent the Duke of Orleans was ready to try anything, anything at all. It was thus that Law managed to convince the regent about his new-fangled theories and gained his confidence. The key element was this: using gold and silver was not efficient - let’s print paper banknotes in the name of gold/silver and issue them out as backed by said gold/silver. Law thus sets up the Banque Générale in 1716 with full state authority to print and issue paper money. The new money gets a fillip when the state agrees to accept taxes paid with the paper currency. Law becomes Controller-General, ie, the finance-king of France. Who Wants to be a Millionaire But he doesn’t stop there, he buys up some of France’s colonial enterprises, in particular the Mississippi Company and thus the monopoly on trade with French Louisiana. (We must remember that Louisiana at its height was much larger, encompassing much of the Mississippi river basin and stretching right into Canada - much of what we now call the Mid West. However, this region had sparse European settlement and development at this point.) Law starts hyping up Louisiana as a magical El Dorado -- full of gold, although it was just swamp, mosquitos and crocodiles. But the French public buy into the hype, buying up shares in Law’s company -- the speculative frenzy gets so crazy, the share price jumps from 500 livres to over 10,000 livres in about a year. Given there were no stock exchange buildings in such a time, Rue Quincampoix, a street in Paris becomes the trading floor - people from all walks of life from a widowed cook to a noblemen all jostle and scramble to buy up the shares. There is a story that a hunchback (and no, he was not from Notre Dame!) rented out his back as a writing desk for the traders to record their transactions! There are stories of, for example, chimney sweeps becoming filthy rich overnight and purchasing villas. Perhaps the juiciest detail is that it was here in this frenzy that the word ‘millionnaire’ was coined! But... what goes up comes down, every bubble has a burst. By 1720, the better informed folk started to realize that the Mississippi dream was a mirage, there was no gold in Louisiana, it was just a dump. They start cashing out shares, and as we have seen in Episode 036 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin036-the-story-of-money-the-dynamics-of-a-bank-run) the institution cannot honor the shares for gold/silver - because the shares and the paper money were in end the backed by nothing of corresponding value. They were in effect worthless. So yes, climax - bank runs, riots, currency collapses, and France’s financial savior, John Law,…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Mysteries of Moral Hazard

    · 7 min

    Last time we explored the development of insurance. As we’ve done with other such topics before, let’s see what could go wrong! We saw last time back in FictionTown that our friends Steve, Bryan, Brenda and Irene started off stressed about the prospect of their house getting burned down just as had just happened to a neighbor. In the end, luckily, they worked out the concept of insurance and set it in motion across the town, so that they could live happily ever after as in every good story! The scene ended with Steve, initially the most indignant of the lot, now confidently having a barbecue indoors, right next to his books or his attached barn full of hay! Risk-free Risk-taking So yes, as I hinted last time, that is an example of moral hazard: as long as the risk of fire persisted, Steve would be very careful, but once that was ‘covered’ by way of payments from a common pot, he couldn’t be bothered to be careful. To generalize, when one is protected against consequences of a given risk, one might not be so careful anymore. Even where such a person may by nature tend to be somewhat cautious and careful. Perhaps a relatable example is health insurance - without it, we may be a bit more careful, but if we are to say get full health treatment at any time under a generous healthcare package, we might go for that extra drink or the fags. If we are on the road behind the wheel after having secured a hefty driving insurance deal, we might be less mindful of good driving comportment. (”I’ve got fully comp. YOLO. Now slam the goddamn pedal, yeeehaaa!”) Skin in the Cat-n-Mouse Game But equally, in the modern day, those who have read the fine print of the insurance policy papers know that it’s not that simple. The insurance industry has adapted to moral hazard - no insurance policy we know of offers us unfettered coverage. There are deliberate constraints imposed by the insurer: phenomena such as co-pay, where, as the name says, the insuree pays for a portion of the benefit availed - say 20% of the overall cost; then there is excess (or deductible) where you first fund a fixed amount yourself before your insurer steps in. Some policies offer you a bonus at the end of the year if you never claim. Fundamentally, the idea is to ensure the user has ‘skin in the game’ (call it a skin tax if you will!) that even though you’re paying the regular premiums, you have additional obligations at the point of making a claim, sufficient to deter, the insurer would hope, spurious claims. I say ‘hope’ because, some users will find a way to game the system - skin or no skin, it’s still a cat-n-mouse game? O Insura, O Mōrēs! We saw back in Episode 024 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin024-the-story-of-money-the-matter-of-monopoly) discussing monopoly, similar behavior change once a seller ends up in a state of monopoly - jacking up prices, not bother with the quality etc. And just like I said there, even here the change in behavior doesn’t have to suggest that the person is ‘evil’, or even, despite the term in use, ‘immoral’. (’moral’ actually has two meanings - the original meaning of this Latin term, incidentally coined by Cicero (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-30b-the-last-of-the-romans-minds-monumental-worth-over-marble), is simply ‘customary’, referring to the customs: derived from Latin ‘mōs’ which also gives us ‘mores’!) My point is, that it’s the incentive structure (in both cases) that drives behavior, and the adverse turn could manifest even in otherwise well-meaning people. Thus the moral-as-in-ethical connotation is a derivative of the above stated moral-as-customary sense. Furthermore, all this is not strictly only in the realm of standard insurance. This can be seen further afield, and as applicable not just to individuals but even large organizations - such as corporations and governments. If you live in a society where the norm (mores!) is for the final bill after dinner is to be split evenly amongst all 5 of you…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: Scrutinizing the Innards of Insurance

    · 8 min

    Way back in Episode 006 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin006-the-story-of-money-what-is-risk) while exploring the concept of risk I said that much of the banking industry was founded upon the need to and with the goal of managing risk. Let’s now look deeper into one of the most widespread and relatable of such instruments. But first we go to FictionTown. Steve, Bryan, Brenda and Irene are sat in the frontyard of one of their houses and having a sombre chat. News is that one of the houses in their community burned down. Obviously our friends are terrified at the possibility of this happening to their house. Steve starts, astutely as usual: this should not happen! Bryan’s like, Steve, you can’t control certain things. Brenda chips in, well, if we can’t control it, we should manage the damage, like save up to rebuild or something. Irene interjects, hmm, it’d be too hard for each of us to save up that much, wait, what if we all saved up in one collective pot, how many houses are there in our community? Steve says it’s about 50 but cannot see how that matters. But Bryan’s like, wait, Irene, that way you mean it can be used if any one house burns down? But how much do we each put? Brenda makes a different point, wait, it’s not just present quantity, how often does a burndown fire happen - the last one was 5 years ago. Irene gets it all - right, we should check the pattern at the Mayor’s office records, but, assuming on average there’s one such fire in 5 years, and we are 50 houses, we each pay a two-hundred-and-fiftieth (1/250) of the pot each year, which becomes even easier to foot if paid in monthly than in a lumpsum! Pot Luck That’s it, that’s insurance in a nutshell, or in a nice collective pot! Obviously, the mathematics of it in the real world is a lot more complicated, and the whole thing is managed by distinct commercial outlets - the insurance companies, who inevitably charge a cut for their services, but this encapsulates the concept with the basic elements in place. Let’s see what’s actually happening here. As we discussed in the risk episode, everything in life is contingent - we can never tell what’s going to happen next. But based on past performance (which by the way is no guarantee of the future), the best we can do is calculate future probability. So if in FictionTown, the last burndown was 5 years ago, the one before 11 years ago and the one before 15 years ago, we can cautiously take 5 years as the average frequency. Generally, the larger the scope of our past dataset, the easier it is to identify patterns. And we saw how there is the ‘pooling’ of risk among all 50 houses, which as we noticed, and as we might intuitively know, softens the blow on any individual. We must also be aware that such a scenario as depicted implies an insurance based solution manifests ‘after the fact’ - it cannot prevent the fire in the first place, but as we’ll see, even there, there’s nuance. Can you Count on it? The key goal of statistics and probability, the cornerstone sciences of risk management is to put a number on the innumerable, express the unquantifiable in exact money terms. Ultimately, how do you measure risk, really? Why is my insurance premium $100 and not $50? While I’ll get to these more complex topics when the time’s right, what we take away at the moment is the simple idea of turning scary unpredictable losses into a small predictable cost. Again, this is not perfect, and based on changing circumstances, the insurance premiums we have to pay might keep changing constantly, and with advances in data collection and similar technologies, this could become even more fluid. But we all know we are required, often by law, to foot insurance bills: car insurance, health insurance, travel insurance, whatever it may be. It may be frustrating to see money you could’ve used elsewhere go into some external source which, unless a stated calamity materializes, you never get back. (consider this weird paradox:…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Dynamics of a Bank Run

    · 7 min

    You may have lived through a bank run, if you’re lucky, you may have not! Distant as it may seem on normal days, you never know. Let’s take a first look at the phenomenon today. This one’s juicy enough to merit a bit of fiction first. Steve, Bryan, Brenda and Irene have reservations for a grand dinner party the coming weekend at a rather posh restaurant in town - a very rare occasion. While awaiting the weekend, Bryan is like, hmm, this one’s gonna be big, the estimated bill for the dinner is around 90-100 bucks per person, but wait I don’t have that kinda money. So he asks Steve, who happens to have a 100 bucks, but Steve’s like, wait this is for the dinner party, but heck, I’ll borrow it back to pay on the night, so hands over the 100 without questions. Somewhat similarly, and independently, Brenda is having similar thoughts, so when she runs into Bryan, she asks to borrow a hundred, and, that’s right, Bryan now thinks he can borrow it back to pay his share of the bill on the night. Next up Irene... you see where this is going... yes, she borrows the hundred from Brenda. None of them knows what’s happened all along. Come dinner night and moment of truth with bill on table; 399 bucks! Steve, Bryan and Brenda each turn to the next person and go: can I have back the 100 I lent you, I’d saved that up for this dinner, and that’s all I have. Borrow Peter Lend Paul You can see what’s going on here. Having each borrowed a hundred bucks -- the same hundred bucks unbeknownst to them, assured they can get it back in time for the bill, there is only one hundred bucks going around. Back in Episode 023 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin023-the-story-of-money-the-intricacies-of-money-supply) we saw how money supply works, and more importantly, we followed that up with Episode 027 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin027-the-story-of-money-the-rabbit-hole-of-money-creation) where I introduced fractional reserve banking (with the promise that I’d get to this topic soon.) In essence, banks engage in a roughly similar sort of activity as depicted above: each time a user deposits their money, the bank lends out a good portion of that money (typically as a loan or other long-term instrument charging a hefty price while offering the depositor a paltry interest!) And quite simply, if all the depositors turn up at the bank one day demanding their money back, the bank simply doesn’t have enough cash to honor them all. And that is a classic bank run. A Debt Spiral A key part of the problem is this - because the banks own use of the deposits are for longer-term instruments, such as a 30-year mortgage, they cannot be redeemed immediately (but this is attractive because of the higher yields the banks can expect.) But the depositors naturally expect to be able to withdraw their cash at any time. In technical terms, banks promise liquidity - your cash can flow back freely to you on demand, but having made long-term investments with your money elsewhere, banks are stuck with illiquid instruments. This works fine most of the time but not when everyone wants their money back at the same time. What causes a bank run? Usually there is some triggering event - some piece of really bad news, such as a disclosure or even just a rumor of losses at the bank, a reputationally damaging incident such as a credit downgrade, economic shocks, scandals, and even contagion from other bank runs and failures - yes, bank runs can spread from bank to bank. And this is a downward spiral. Once the panic starts, people run to the bank to get their own money out, but the more people do that the more people join in: who wouldn’t want to get their money out before the bank runs out of money? And for the bank, the more such demands, the more the strain to honor them - typically addressed by selling their existing assets in fire sales, which means at much lower prices than on a normal day, which means the bank’s balance sheet is weaker, which means the panic only…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Incantation of Inflation

    · 7 min

    We have previously looked at money creation - how currency actually comes into being, Episode 027 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p//ecfin027-the-story-of-money-the-rabbit-hole-of-money-creation), and money supply, the amount of this currency available for people to use to measure and transact all the goods and services they wish to in an economy. Let’s today get closer to the heart of a matter that we likely think of a lot more. On the face of it, inflation does not need explained. Anyone who’s gone to the grocery store has experienced it - you see that carton of milk with a price tag of 5 bucks, but wait a minute! Only yesterday it was 4 bucks!! So yes, that’s all it is. On the face of it. There is indeed more to explore about the phenomenon though, so stick with me, even though I can’t give you the secret to how to get that milk price to go back to 4 bucks. The Upward Currents of Currency In fact if you’ve been following this series, we have skirted around this idea quite a few times, when we discussed price (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p//ecfin003-the-story-of-money-the-enigma-of-price), the Spanish silver tragedy in Episode 022 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p//ecfin022-the-story-of-money-the-mafia-of-mercantilism), and perhaps most vividly, in supply and demand (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p//ecfin017-the-story-of-money-the-dance-of-supply-and-demand). Even the very last episode, on coin debasement, was very much inflation in action. As we saw when discussing those topics, there are a great many factors that bear upon the price of an item, and therefore the presence of inflation - a rise in the price over time: a rise in demand, a greater amount of money supply, and other factors that would devalue the currency, some of which deserve their own episodes, which I hope is of, at any rate, interest! The coin episode offered an old-school way of the devaluation of money, but in the modern world, scenarios such as the ones just hinted at, all fundamentally decrease the worth of that cash in hand, hence the need for more of it to purchase the same item, compared to yesterday. (Ok, ok, inflation doesn’t happen every single day, but my yesterday-today depiction was just representative.) But here’s thing, while we may wince at the idea of a rise in the prices of goods, governments actually actively want inflation! Inflation Nation We’ve looked at inflation from a buyer’s angle, to understand all this deeper, let’s look at it from other angles. Imagine you owe someone a 500 dollars. Between yesterday and today, continuing our grocery example, that same amount today buys less milk, or any other amount whose price has risen. Which means, if you’re paying back that money today or tomorrow, you’re in effect paying back less than when you borrowed it earlier on. Thanks to inflation, you’ve enjoyed the effects of debt erosion! (Now apply this to that mortgage going 30 years.) Imagine you are an employer with salaries to pay. The costs of production have gone up, or some other variable has worsened the situation, and you want to manage this by cutting pay. With inflation, say of 2%, freezing pay simply means the employer executes an effective pay cut of 2%, essentially by stealth -- much easier than announcing pay cuts right? Now who in the land is one of the biggest debtors and employers? It’s the state. Furthermore, the state is the entity that handles the currency - it can print more of it and deploy other levers in its toolkit to manipulate it. This is why government officials put on some trim suits and grim ties and go on TV to announce that their policy is working - for the stated period, they have achieved their targeted inflation! Using bigger numbers to measure the growth of the economy (the GDP, I’ll come to it too), makes for better headlines - nominal growth looks more impressive than real growth, and isn’t that politically convenient? The Devil You Know Cynical as that may sound, it may not be that…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Conundrum of Coin Debasement

    · 7 min

    We traced in Episode 031 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin031-the-story-of-money-why-gold) the emergence of gold and silver as ‘pure’ and ‘noble’ metals perfectly suited to serve our economic needs in the form of money, and then in Episode 032 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin032-the-story-of-money-gold-or-silver) their comparative importance and finally in Episode 033 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin033-the-story-of-money-the-origins-of-the-coin) how money took shape - in the form of coins. Remember the final words in that piece? “What could go wrong?” And oh boy wrong it did go so many times, and sometimes so spectacularly, that you’d think it was farce, vaudeville and tragedy rolled into one! In this piece, I’ll briefly touch upon the broad forces and phenomena at play in this context, but we will definitely come back with specific stories from specific events in history. With the advent of coinage, the issuance of a standard specie - ie, with a certain fixed size and weight, by the king or state meant that the unit of measure of value was now fixed and established as uniform. The implicit understanding was that if the coins were melted down and sold in the market, it would be worth the same as if the coins were spent, they would both fetch, say, 10 sacks of grain. In other words, the face value of the coin is the same as its value by weight. And then the fun begins! A Clippery Slope Let’s say I’m looking at a shiny new silver coin and it says “One Denarius” on it, so I can be sure of buying that much by face value. Now what if I chip or shave off a small portion of the edge of the coin - which is not that hard given silver is not that hard, what if I do this for a 100 such coins, even a 1000. Now I have all these clippings I can melt and voila, I have new money! As the Dire Straits didn’t sing: money for nothing and chips for free! Apart from this method, which is called clipping, there were other ones, but the idea was the same, leech off a small, seemingly imperceptible quantity of the metal from each coin while also trying to pass off the counterfeited coin as if it were the real thing. Incidentally, coin-clipping as a problem is attributed to have been solved by our good friend the Master of the Mint at Britain’s Royal Mint we met back in episode 032 - yes, Isaac Newton! The legacy still stands even though we don’t engage in clipping - ridges, reeds or grooves you see around the side of a coin, the process being called reeding or milling. And needless to say kings and states came down heavily on individuals engaging in such debasing of coins. But was it only the ordinary people who did such stuff? An Alloyed Bad Oh no! Coin debasement gets even spicier when the king himself got down to it. Not by clipping mind you, but let’s look into how. Issuing coinage has a cost, obviously the metal being used, plus the process of minting the coins, the labor thereof etc. So I’m sitting on my throne, I have these ‘One Denarius’ coins of silver serving the economy, but hold on, I have a brilliant idea (or a cunning plan if you watch the comedy Black Adder, very apt for the current context!) For the next batch I’m going to print, why don’t I use a tiny bit of copper, like about 5% of the weight that goes into the minting process. I mean, nobody will know right? My subjects aren’t that smart, even if a few are, it’ll still look the same to most of them? What could go wrong? Face of Base And to that refrain, we can add another one - and where will it all end? Because, spoiler alert, it always ended in tragedy. In a system where the face value of a coin is understood by everyone to be the same as the intrinsic value of the weight of the coin, it’s not hard to see how detrimental this is - and this was very tempting for kings and governments, because when done in seemingly small measures of adulteration, they could hope to get away with it. But if you’ve done it once why not do it again, with a bit more…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Origins of the Coin

    · 7 min

    Over the last couple of episodes we’ve explored the use of gold and silver as money and the tussle between the two. Let’s now get to the question of ‘form factor’: To appreciate the value of coins, something we’re so used to and thus take for granted, we have to position ourselves to the earlier reality. We have a broad idea that from the earliest time that communities traded widely, they simply exchanged goods with each other - barter. I’ve discussed aspects of this in some of the earliest episodes. From there on, as we traced in Episode 031 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin031-the-story-of-money-why-gold), with gold and silver emerging as useful means to represent value by weight of either metal, the practice of carrying out trade using ingots or bullions - pieces of the metal, arose. Think of it as chocolate or soap bars - in the former case, it may even have functioned as money on the playground back when you were a kid in school! Except that these were made of metal, cast into similar moulds as these more familiar objects are. (Just ask Charlie Bucket or Willy Wonka!) But this presented a few problems. Firstly, these metal bars were bulky. And then they were typically worth way more than could be used for normal goods on a general basis. (Let’s call it the rich man’s cash?) Also, given the potential for adulteration of these metal bars with inferior metals, each load of metal had to be weighed every time to assess their purity. All Loads Lead to Lydia Enter Lydia! A wealthy and prosperous kingdom in Western Anatolia, around the years 600 before our era. Located at the crossroads of a growing Greece to the west, Egypt to the south, and the Persians to the east (and even some Central Asian groups in the north), Lydia was very well placed as a trade corridor leading to the said prosperity. It was here that a certain king Alyattes is attributed to have taken a more systematic approach to the whole affair: mint a circular piece with specific images on both sides, sort of like simple medals. These early coins were made of electrum, an alloy of gold and silver, abundantly available in the rivers of the region. The Point of Crisis But the relative quantities of gold and silver in these electrum coins varied, sort of recreating a similar problem as we saw in the previous episode but in alloy form! Practically, it was hard to assess the exact value of any given coin. The next breakthrough is attributed to his successor, king Croesus, yes he who still lives on in our idiom “as rich as Croesus”! His primary innovation was to switch to issuing coins in standardized pure gold or pure silver, around the year 550 BCE. In fact, he is said to be the inventor of the world’s first bimetallic system. To Coin a New Phase So yes, Croesus’s innovation we may say helped him become, well, as rich as Croesus! But let’s explore how revolutionary it was at the time. The idea of coins, and their use, quickly spread across the wider region, with polities such as the Greek states and soon the Persians adopting them rapidly, marking a new phase in the history of money. Coins were significantly more useful than the older ways - unlike the previous, somewhat grassroots and voluntary methods, coins were issued by the state, you may say money was nationalized. Why did this matter? For one, it meant, there was a standard, and the standard was backed by the authority of the state. This meant it solved the problem of independent verification, which was as we saw a huge barrier to trade. As we can imagine -- and even though some of the early coins were still too valuable to fetch a loaf of bread, they were lighter, more portable and eventually more granular in allowing for the measure of value of a greater variety of goods. In the tailoring analogy I’ve taken a few times previously in this series, imagine that tailors used to measure cloth simply by their fingers and hands - Croesus gave them a proper, standard measuring tape to use…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: Gold? Or Silver?

    · 7 min

    We established in the previous episode that two metals emerged across history and across cultures as the most suitable units of measuring value, ie, money. As promised there, let’s now look at the tussle between the two. Quite simply, silver is much cheaper than gold - given the dynamics of their availability for us to extract, and thus the relative scarcity of each. Even though we don’t these days trade in gold and silver, this is something we broadly recognize. Because of this, gold has generally enjoyed greater prestige, being used much more in jewelry and as a display of one’s wealth and status. Correspondingly, silver has had more value as a practical day-to-day transaction choice. (You may have been born with a silver spoon in your mouth but you soon grew up to flaunt your gold!) But yes, how much was the relative value of gold and silver? This of course varied over time, there being often other factors at play, but primarily it went back to the relative availability. But as, within a given society, the relative availability could vary, there was this constant game of trying to take advantage of the variation. The Good, The Bad, The Shifty To understand this, let me first mention what’s known in the field as Gresham’s law, which quite simply states that “bad money drives out good money”. Let’s say you have 10 coins of either metal, which can buy you certain amount of goods in the market. Now if you melt those coins, the bullion (or ingots or whatever way you’ve shaped them) has the same value as the face value of the coins. That’s good money. On the other hand, if the melted metal is valued less than the face value imprinted on the coins, then you have bad money. It’s not hard to see how tempting it can be for governments to issue ‘bad money’, it means it would cost them less to mint those coins - this topic, debasement is juicy on its own, so I’ll reserve it for an episode in the near future. Under the same logic, governments would never want to denominate coins at face value lower than commodity value. Because what would you do if the face value of those 10 coins were lower than their price in weight? You’d melt them, you’d hoard them, these coins would disappear from circulation. Now let’s take a real-world historical example of one case of how this panned out specifically in the battle between the two metals - there are several such cases, but we have to pick one. Elements of Surprise In 1717, the ‘Master of the Mint’ in Royal Mint, Britain’s official coin-issuer, made a fateful move. He set the price of roughly one part of gold to 15 parts of silver. (I’m quoting rough figures here to keep the math simple.) However, in Continental Europe, it cost 14.5 parts of silver to buy one part of gold. Again, let’s see how this works out. Essentially what this meant was gold was artificially overvalued by the Mint relative to silver, whereas on the Continent, silver fetched more gold. So what would I do, I’d scoop up all the silver I could get hold of, make a trip across the English Channel, and, given silver buys more there and gold is cheaper, buy up all the gold I could for my silver and bring that gold back to Britain. What would I do once I’m back home? (After having a cup a tea, of course!) I’d buy up all the silver I can for that gold, because, that gold buys more silver in jolly old Blighty! And then... time for another trip to the Continent (Only delayed if the weather report reads “Fog in the Channel, Continent cut off”) The consequence of this was that soon all the silver disappeared from Britain, and a lot of gold flowed in, inadvertently pushing Britain, with eventually wider consequences beyond the island, onto a de facto gold standard! We would wonder who the hell was this guy who couldn’t even calculate the relative worths of gold and silver? Well, it was none other than Sir Isaac Newton! Yes, Newton! I mean, in the midst of writing his great work that essentially defined modern physics, we can say…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: Why Gold?

    · 7 min

    It’s perhaps one of the most obvious and well-known things in human life - that gold and silver are or at least were used as money. But let’s step back and see how and why this happened. I have reiterated a few times in this series that money has no intrinsic value, it’s just a measure of value. And we generally know that across history and cultures, other objects other than metal and paper have been used as money at one time or another. However, there’s something special about the use of gold and silver as money. The Good Gold Days Back in TecC 14 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-14-blending-forces-breeding-innovation-when-elements-embraced-change-forging-the-path-forward) I discussed the origins of humans figuring out the non-obvious and high-temperature process of extracting metal from ores and even combining them, with the rest of that decimile exploring the social and historical impacts specifically of bronze (copper + tin) until TecC 20 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-20-systems-scaling-systems-shattered-from-command-to-collapse-innovations-hidden-vulnerabilities-and-points-of-failure) and then again in TecC 22 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-22-renewing-resolve-stealing-the-march-when-scarcity-sparks-substitution-and-impels-innovations-asunder) with iron followed by another similar exploration of its effects - we call those periods the Bronze Age and Iron Age respectively, the key point being that these metals and alloys have come to define entire technological-historical epochs. But we don’t talk about a ‘Gold Age’ or a ‘Silver Age’ - not literally, largely only figuratively. Gold and silver have been known to mankind from much earlier in human timespan than tin and iron and other metals - there have been great civilizations that extensively used gold or silver that never got to bronze or iron - the Aztecs for example. Quite simply gold and silver offer many of the same advantages being also metals, as I’ve discussed at length in the stated articles. But they offer more. Gold and silver are ‘Noble’ metals - they are resistant to corrosion and are thus found in pure state in nature as opposed to as ores - in combined form requiring the extensive metallurgy suggested. That said, they are very rare and its not easy to find gold. And that is the key. Slow and Steady We have seen, for example when discussing money supply (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin023-the-story-of-money-the-intricacies-of-money-supply), that there can be problems if there is too much or too little money in circulation in the economy. The relative difficulty of mining gold and silver thus introduce that much required scarcity factor. Furthermore it can also add to stability, since, with the exception mainly of extensive explorations such as in the mid 1500s by Europeans beyond the Atlantic, the supply of gold and silver would largely remain a constant and change only gradually. So you’ve got two metals - easily shapeable into different shapes, resistant to corrosion and hence to destruction or decay, durable, scarce and stable, and finally with the cherry-on-top quality of being shiny and attractive. What’s not to like eh? A Silver Bullet of Solid Gold So even if a society started off with cowrie shells or pebblestones, there was a good chance that many of them ended up with gold or silver as their eventual choice of money. In fact, this is an important point - we have seen that other technologies that we now take widely for granted given their ubiquitous presence in our lives, the wheel (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-13-turning-point-the-axis-of-progress-the-paradox-of-finding-constancy-amid-motion-stability-amid-change), zero (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-28-de-numero-indorum-novum-nihil-sub-sole), paper (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc37-finding-the-medium-turning-the-page) all more or less emerged in only one culture in each case. But the use of gold and silver as money emerged…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: Meeting Maslow

    · 7 min

    So far we have been talking mainly about the basics of economics (and finance). Let’s today, as it were, take things up a notch. A brief detour into our fictional world: remember back in Episode 006 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin006-the-story-of-money-what-is-risk) the one about risk, where Steve had a failed harvest the previous season and was staring down the abyss of starvation. When Bryan, Brenda and Irene are sat with Steve discussing the predicament, imagine Bryan was like, hey Steve, there is this very prestigious horseracing tournament in town in two weeks’ time and I’m told the Premium tickets offer spectacular views of the events, plus that’ll put us very close to the Duke himself. It’ll be a fun week of partying. How about you and I both buy tickets and go check it out?! From Thoughts to Sentiments I’d safely bet that the ridiculousness of such a proposition by Bryan would be obvious to most of us. It was American psychologist Abraham Maslow who built a neat framework around human needs, which we will explore today. Now, Maslow as hinted worked in the field of psychology, so why bring him up here? I suppose we can see that the question of needs gives his work relevance from an economics perspective as well. And as we saw about the Father of Economics Adam Smith’s own preferences and perspective (Episode 020 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin020-the-story-of-money-meeting-adam-smith)), and as I hope I’ve demonstrated now and then, the ultimate goal of economics can be described as wanting to improve the human condition within our environment. From Needs to Wants to Worth Put simply, in his ‘hierarchy of needs’ later depicted as Maslow’s Pyramid, he proposed that human motivation can be driven by five distinct sets of needs. These sets can be named physiological, safety, love & belonging, esteem and finally self-actualization, depicted in that pyramid from bottom to top in that order. The core point here is that if we are at the bottom of the pyramid, preoccupied with physiological needs such as food and shelter, we have or can afford very little attention for the higher needs. It’s only once we have fulfilled that set of needs can we adequately focus on the next set higher up the hierarchy and so on. Thus our hierarchy of needs progresses from the most basic to what may be termed ‘growth’ needs. Therefore one cannot afford to focus on the ‘esteem’ level with elements in it like confidence, respectability, status, or the ‘self-actualization’ one at the top with questions of morality, creativity, spontaneity and such if they’re still scrambling to put dinner on the table for the day. From Sentiments to Concepts This concept is in fact applied in a few different areas of modern life. We’ve all seen billboards of that smiling blissfully happy couple in an ad for a car or, hmm, a kitchen tap/faucet, or a bar of chocolate. They’re in a sense fooling you into thinking you’re buying a ticket to the next stage of Maslow’s hierarchy. In organizations, apart from a well-stocked vending machine and varieties of tea and coffee, these days there are pool tables, discounted gym memberships, what not. (”We can’t pay you more, but here’s a ping pong table, please feel actualized”) So yes, fields such as marketing & advertising, and HR and management have applied such ideas, by some measures at least, quite effectively (or we may take a cynical view, quite cunningly!) But I’d reiterate that Maslow’s pyramid has greater relevance than has generally been appreciated within the area of economics, especially when viewed broadly from the stated goal of human well-being. Let’s go back to the fictional story we started with. In the event, in that episode, thanks to Brenda and Irene’s suggestions, Bryan offers Steve 10 sacks of grain from his own grain from his bumper harvest, against collateral, should the harvest fail again -- as fully set out there, as part of risk management, a key component of economics.…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Great Crash of 1929

    · 8 min

    Last time we looked at the phenomenon of supposedly ‘rational’ behavior leading to wild aggregate market outcomes. Let’s now look at what’s arguably the most spectacular and devastating real-world example of this. For, even as the 20s in this article series come to an end at 029, we shall trace how the Roaring Twenties ended with this extraordinary crash in 1929! We won’t be featuring our fictional friends on this topic, the real-world characters involved here, as we shall meet in due course, themselves go beyond what fiction could conceive. And there’s a lot of ground to cover! Let’s first set the historical stage to provide enough context. After the First World War, the United States was set on the road of massive economic expansion, in good part thanks to the rapid growth of electrification and thus the manufacture of electrical appliances and related goods. This rapid expansion in industrial manufacturing with a large number of such goods entering the market meant that the purchasing power, or at least the purchasing intent, of the public at large had to grow. Thus eventually emerged the concept of consumer credit, where organizations would lend money to people wanting to buy such goods, and on the cheap - you could get a loan of 100 dollars by just putting up 10 dollars as initial payment! However, given the interest rates were very low, meaning you got very low yield for your cash sitting in a bank’s savings account, people starting using such loans to buy stocks and shares in the booming industry - also a relatively new phenomenon for most people. Just as we saw with the Tulip Mania in the previous episode, all this led to asset prices only going up and people becoming complacent in expecting that it would keep going up forever (Now, where have we heard of that in our own lifetime?!) Humpty Dumpty sat on Wall Street And then it all came crashing down, because just as we think the prices of such assets will keep going up and up, once that bubble burst, as it always eventually does, the sentiment goes right into reverse - everyone wants to sell of theirs before others do, leading to a free fall of the prices. Fundamentally, there were structural weaknesses in the economy that were masked by the exuberance. Importantly the agricultural sector hadn’t been doing well all this while but most folk in the cities and towns were busy enjoying the party! Also, despite all the industrial expansion, actual wage growth was low, but then again, the cheap credit phenomenon served to obscure that anomaly. The major turning point came when Benjamin Strong, a very astute and influential banker heading the Federal Reserve Bank (of New York) died in 1928 leaving a massive intellectual vacuum and even paralysis at the Fed. And then the music stopped. There had been minor panics prior to the main historic crash but the market managed to brush it off. There had been siren voices warning that things had gone too far and there was a massive speculative bubble that would burst any time, but they were promptly ignored. Until they could be ignored no more! The two dates etched in historical memory would be Black Thursday, October 24, 1929 and Black Tuesday the following week. There’s a lot of gory, or if you prefer juicy, detail about what ensued, all good enough to read in a thriller novel but you wouldn’t want to be there. On Black Thursday, within the first 3 minutes 3 million shares are said to have changed hands. The selloff was so intense that the ticker-tape... the printed paper tape that displayed prices simply couldn’t keep up and was delayed by hours resulting in total chaos. But Black Tuesday is seen as the worst day - about 16 million shares were traded and the index fell 12%. Dealing with It All This account barely scratches the surface of what happened - both the bubble and the crash. It took the authorities 3-4 years to even grapple with the situation, especially given the then president Herbert Hoover didn’t think it…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Irrationality of Rational Action

    · 6 min

    A key thread running through all my writing in this series is how each of these topics, and how economics as a whole, relate to each of us, here and now. So let’s today tackle the question of how human behavior impacts markets and how that impacts each of us back. The key tension here, as I’ve noted before, is that economics tries to be a precise science while seeking to describe messy human reality. In this spirit, economics, or at least some branches of it, have posited that humans are rational - not in the sense that we normally understand that term, but in the sense that they behave in ‘economically optimal’ ways, given that particular branch’s definition of optimal. There is even a term for this: homo economicus. Under this line of thinking, it is said that one rationally carries out a cost/benefit analysis of every action prior to a decision. (Mind you, this needn’t be with a spreadsheet and 3 pie charts, it could be intuitively and even inexplicably.) In practical terms this is said to mean that as consumers/producers we seek to maximize utility/profit. (For a more precise and unadulterated definition of the oft-misunderstood word ‘profit’ see Episode 004 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain).) Weighing Wants To get to the heart of this, we have to look closer at the term value, which I introduced in the aforesaid episode, and have discussed elsewhere in this series. Specifically we have to consider perceived value, a fundamentally subjective concept. As an example, when we discussed price in Episode 003 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin003-the-story-of-money-the-enigma-of-price) we saw how it’s a sort of ‘negotiation’ between the buyer and seller. In the current terminology we’d say they’re each seeking to maximize their utility/profit, ie, they’re being rational. This could depend on several factors, including, for example, supply and demand which we discussed in Episode 017 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin017-the-story-of-money-the-dance-of-supply-and-demand) but ultimately if something is subjective, how do we pin it down with precision? How do we put a number to it? Furthermore, how do we satisfactorily explain or predict such perceptions of value among individual actors in the economy? For we have also seen, as I’ve noted previously, if we can’t measure something do we even know it well enough? All this goes to the very tension of economics I was referring to. In Fool Bloom So far we have considered the question of a single entity, but let’s see how this pans out in aggregate. Imagine it’s 1600s Europe, the early age of exploration, and an exotic and rare new flower is introduced into a country. Instantly, it becomes a status symbol for the rich and everyone’s after them - the price of the flower skyrockets, so much so that at its peak, one variety of the flower is sold for several times the salary of a skilled craftsman! If you think this is contrived it’s not, this actually happened in the 1630s in the Dutch Republic, then undergoing the Dutch Golden Age - the Tulip Mania. It may be irrational, in our normal sense, for a buyer to be rational (an alcoholic seeking to buy more alcohol and thus find more ‘utility’?) but if this is scattered about among individuals here and there it’s one thing. But we can see what happens when everyone joins the bandwagon of this irrationally rational behavior, such as in the Tulip Mania mentioned. If tulips can be sold at such exorbitant prices as hinted, why would anyone be incentivized to grow wheat or other essential crop? Given that buyers are valuing, and thus paying, more for a shiny new flower than food? But how does that perceived value of the rational actor square with the real and proper value lost in the economy as a whole, and ever in the long term, by such collective irrational exuberance? So the price of the given asset-in-obsession goes up and up and up - and the more it goes up the…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Rabbit Hole of Money Creation

    · 8 min

    Back in the day when I worked in banking, in a workshop the presenter asked “What do banks do?”, and I said “they make money”, to which his reply was “of course every institution needs its earnings”. But that’s not what I meant. Let’s today discuss the concept of money creation. Let’s meet our fictional friends to start with. Steve and Bryan have been in the silversmith and pawn-brokerage business for some time now. In recent days however, having gained the reputation of the town, they have found a way to extend their activities. The townsfolk are tired of having to carry around silver for all the payments, and as the only shop in town dealing with large amounts of silver, Steve and Bryan have offered to let customers deposit their silver in their vault in exchange for a written and signed note representing the amount deposited. Since that note represents a certified quantity of silver, the depositor can then use that note instead of actual silver on a day-to-day basis. Given Steve and Bryan are trusted people around, their promise on the note is enough to satisfy the depositor that any time they want their silver back, they can simply return the note for the amount. One weekend after a couple of weeks of such activity, Steve and Bryan are sat in the garden with Brenda and Irene and having a chat. Steve is like, so yeah we have all this silver sitting in our vault, Bryan adding, but the curious thing is nobody has come to claim their silver back even though we gave them a written promise. Brenda chimes in, well given that you’ve mentioned the amount of silver on each note, and anyone can use any note to come back to claim the silver at any time, they’re not in a hurry, after all it’s easier to handle such notes rather than heavy sacks of silver. Irene then goes, but wait, if you are sitting on all this silver, and they won’t come back to claim any of it because it’s easier to handle the notes, maybe you shouldn’t leave the silver idle, you should maybe lend some of it out? In Gold We Trust, But... So yes, that’s the birth of paper money. (And Steve and Bryan were the proto-Goldman Sachs? Or is it Silverman Sacks?!) But if you look closely something else is happening here. Imagine our friends have a thousand pounds by weight in silver in deposit, against which they have given out those notes representing a thousand pounds. And then, going by Brenda and Irene’s observation, they lend out a 100 pounds of the silver, to other people who need money. That silver goes into the economy and... you guessed it, someone along the line deposits that silver back into the vault in return for notes promising 100 pounds of silver. So now, we have 1100 pounds in the economy -- against ONLY a thousand real pounds of silver. This may sound like jiggery-pokery, but this is practically what EVERY bank does when lending you out money. Economists even give it a respectable-sounding name - Fractional Reserve Banking. In other words, only a fraction of the gold or silver representing the issued paper money is actually in the vault at any time. And guess what, governments are fine with it. Based on the state of the economy and other factors, governments have even encouraged banks to engage in such activity. You will recognize this from the following sentence on many currency notes: I promise to pay the bearer the sum of 10 pounds (or whatever other original indicator of weight, such as peso, libra/lira etc.) And different forms of this have had different names across history: in some versions, a bill of exchange, a promissory note, or an IOU (literally “I owe you”, with kind of the same gravitas as ‘BRB’ and ‘OMG’ I hear you say?) The Preserve of Reserve The reality here is the fact that, if this is done within limits, it can actually stimulate the economy. Imagine in our story that the economic activity -- the sum total of stuff being bought and sold -- in the town was in fact to the tune of 2000 pounds of silver by value, but the actual…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: Meeting Malthus

    · 7 min

    You might have heard of the Malthusian Trap in some TV programme, say as part of a solemn, strokey-beard pronouncement by an expert on a panel of very wise-looking, sagely-nodding, well, experts. Let’s unravel it today. We haven’t met our fictional friends lately. Brenda has news for Steve, Bryan, and Irene. The coming weekend is to be another one of those once-a-few-years lavish banquets thrown by the Lord Mayor to all the townsfolk. This is a tradition when there has been a bumper harvest that year. Steve’s first to exult, he’s like, yess, this is great! (Simple guy alert!) And then Bryan’s like, wait so this banquet only happens when we have a surplus harvest, not if we just break even, or worse. (Perceptive fella him!) Brenda confirms, yes, this year we have a surplus of 200 bushels, they’ll be put to good use for the banquet. (Facts-girl is back!) And then Irene... Irene goes, wait a minute, if all the surplus is used up in one grand party after harvest, what progress are we making in the long term by way of additional grain accumulation and reinvesting?! Oh, What’s the Point! So can see the contours of the trap emerging. Thomas Malthus in the late 1700 posited this cycle: an increase in a population’s food production leads to an improvement in their condition, but only temporarily as it leads to greater population, which leads to resource depletion on account of greater consumption, then starvation, famine and disease, and thus a drop in the population, and back to square one. In other words, suggesting that prosperity would always cancel itself out and human lot can never really be improved beyond some sort of a subsistence common denominator. One might see a kind of zero-sum-game cruel gruel with lots of oh-what’s-the-point toppings thrown in. Being an Anglican cleric, he explained this suffering as ordained by God to impose virtuous behavior. Furthermore, Malthus had certain “ideas” around population control and dealing with “the lower classes”, ideas of the sort we wouldn’t be particularly comfortable talking about in decent discourse. So, was Malthus right at all? Time-Warp Traps and Steam Valves I think by now the answer is fairly clear to us. I mean, some of the initial observation holds true, that an increase in production leads to an increase in population. Among others, I’ve discussed the effects of this swing in TecC 36 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc36-from-knowing-to-growing-the-hallowed-cathedrals-of-learning) and TecC 40 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc40-when-a-grim-and-gruesome-guest-came-knocking) where I discuss the effects of it against the great rise in population in the first centuries after the first millennium and then its drastic fall closer to the mid-millennium. In fact, this had indeed been the lot of human societies since the dawn of agriculture and sedentary civilization (TecC 10 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-10-seeds-of-civilization-the-first-great-bargain-sowing-time-reaping-change)). But the funny thing is, by the time Malthus was writing this, the Industrial Revolution was picking up steam in Britain, (steam puns intended oh yes!) making his observations obsolete in his own country first and then further afield. This is because the sudden increase in technological output the Industrial Revolution wrought for the first time ever in history gave humanity the escape velocity to overcome that trap. Realization that there were such drastic changes afoot was gaining ground in the late 1700s, notable mention being Adam Smith’s description of the emerging system in his landmark book, published 2 decades before Malthus’s. So can we say Malthus was trapped in a trap of his own making? There are other ironies too. As I hinted, Malthus insisted on adverse effects on the population and thus his controversial ideas such as “preventive checks”. It has been the case in the ensuing centuries and especially over the last 100 years or so that industrial-grade…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Concept of Competition

    · 6 min

    In the last episode we looked at monopoly, let’s now turn to its antidote, competition. To the extent that competition is at the opposite end of monopoly, and given monopoly literally refers to ‘one-seller’, the phenomenon we are talking about here should translate to ‘many-sellers’. (I wonder why, unlike for ‘monopoly’ and ‘oligopoly’ “few-sellers”, we don’t use a Greek-derived term for this related phenomenon - I guess ‘polypoly’ would sound like a parrot trying to do economics?) But yes, it’s quite simply just that: there are several sellers offering you the same or similar thing. This we have seen requires a functional (or free) market allowing for additional sellers - competitors, to naturally emerge without the existing players hindering them, which as we’ve seen doesn’t always work along ideal lines. Competition as it operates in such a functional market gives the buyers more choice. Which means the pricing is likely to be more competitive, in line with the dynamic I outlined in Episode 003 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin003-the-story-of-money-the-enigma-of-price) while discussing price. Competition is also in dichotomy with cooperation, but within the realm of sellers trying to offer similar goods, ‘cooperation’ can morph into its shadier cousin collusion, and as Adam Smith derisively observed, the only thing competitors trying to cooperate would lead to is cartelization - in other words collusion to charge the same (high) prices and thus negate the benefits of competition for the buyer. Furthermore, just like supply and demand which we discussed in Episode 017 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin017-the-story-of-money-the-dance-of-supply-and-demand), competition is a dynamic that goes beyond the simple market-square buyer-seller demand: it’s a lot more pervasive. Best Foot Forward Let’s explore the benefits of competition. Competition fosters innovation. If you are vying to offer the same goods as others, you are motivated to find better ways of doing it - a better technique to make the goods so you can offer better quality, or a lower price, or better yet, both. We have seen this at play all the time. (For an in-depth historical example of how this would pan out, I can offer, among others, TecC 43 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc43-making-work-art-making-art-work-engineering-excellence) from my other series here dedicated to innovation and progress.) Of course competition also means the seller having to be on the toes all the time. But in the economy as a whole, this is a net positive for society - we are all sellers in only one small set of things, but buyers of many more - our consumer footprint is much larger. Besides, most large-scale production being the domain of corporate entities with deep pockets, it’s competition that allows individual consumers like you and me some say in the whole process. But even producers, including the large-scale ones, have hidden benefits of competition. It both means there’s a valid demand for a certain good or service in the market, but also gives them insights as to how such demand operates and how the buyers behave. Picture the widespread phenomenon of several hairdressers or Japanese restaurants clustered on the same street - this is of course deliberate, and demonstrates that in some sense, given they cannot eradicate competition, producers in some sense seek to embrace it? Tying it All Up Going back to the topic of price, we saw back there how price is essentially a signal, each item’s price distilling, in its own way, the sum aggregate of the entire economy. And consumer behavior in response to such prices allow for the dynamics of supply and demand to play out forming a constant feedback loop regulating the proper allocation and use of the limited resources that make up the entire economy. Similarly, back in Episode 002 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin002-the-story-of-money-what-is-the-market) where I asked an even more fundamental…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Matter of Monopoly

    · 6 min

    Back in Episode 022 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin022-the-story-of-money-the-mafia-of-mercantilism) while on the topic of mercantilism, we touched upon the idea of cartels - a small band of merchants grouping together for market abuse and unfair advantage. Let’s take it a notch up. Let’s first go back to where we left our fictional friends way back in Episode 003 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin003-the-story-of-money-the-enigma-of-price) when discussing price. Back then, at the idyllic townsquare market, Brenda and Irene strolling around, on inquiring the price of a sack of grain, get quoted 8 and 10 copper coins by Steve and Bryan. They may have been surprised by the difference in price, maybe they first thought of shopping around a bit more. Maybe they were happy to pay either price, the lower for obvious reasons, the higher for the less obvious reasons I explored back in that piece. A fortnight later, when Brenda and Irene are both out again, they only find Steve. And this time he’s charging them 15 copper coins! When they grumble, he’s like take it or leave it (with a look of it’s my way or the highway!) So Few For So Many So what’s going on here then eh? Maybe by undercutting the other seller, he gained an edge and the other seller moved shop to the next town. Maybe the other seller found a better market to sell his goods at a better price anyways. Or some other set of circumstances. But right over here, potential buyers are left with only one choice of seller. Intentionally or not, Steve has a monopoly. In the much more complex world of modern commerce, there could be a myriad other factors that lead to monopolies, although underhanded measures like deliberate undercutting (charging lower while taking a profit cut until bleeding your rivals out), can and do occur. To extend the phenomenon we discussed in the mercantilism episode, where a few sellers got for themselves an unfair advantage by using the corrupt and coercive arm of the State to block newcomers, and thus formed an oligopoly, taking that process to its ultimate end is what leads to monopoly - “a few sellers only” to “only one seller”. Sole Seller or Sold Soul? We have all likely seen and dealt with monopolies in our lives. We might even use the word ‘monopolize’ in non-commercial contexts. But let’s look at its repercussions in the wider context here. We saw back in the price episode that in a functioning market price is not purely in the hands of the seller, but subject to a bunch of other factors, including what other sellers are offering. Now, obviously, some such constraints are weakened, and the sole seller can charge higher prices without restraint - and thus even distort the market equilibrium I touched upon back there. Alongside that, in line with the newly found take-it-or-leave-it nonchalance of the seller -- I mean if the potential buyer has nowhere else to go..., the seller doesn’t have to bother so much about the quality of their goods, again leading to worse outcomes for the buyers and the economy as a whole. It’s also important to note that the monopolist seller, such as Steve here, might not even be a bad person, but the whole incentive structured is so skewed to enable such undesirable behavior - whether on an individual or an institutional level. So what is the answer to this? We all perhaps instinctively know the answer, but from an economic angle I’ll elaborate on the matter in the next episode. Furthermore there are some services that can, in many cases, not be provided by the market, and falls into the arms of the state to deliver. The obvious ones are defense, justice, what we call public infrastructure and indeed the apparatus of the state itself - which is by definition, within a sovereign realm, a monopoly. (Oh you don’t like this army? Go subscribe to that army down the road, they do Tuesdays half price!) And then there are often politicians who, fairly or unfairly, denouncing a particular industry for…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Intricacies of Money Supply

    · 7 min

    I started this series by emphasizing that money is rather simply a measure of value than having intrinsic value itself. (Episode 001 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin001-the-story-of-money-what-is-money-anyways).) Later, in Episode 017 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin017-the-story-of-money-the-dance-of-supply-and-demand) we looked at the dynamics of supply and demand. Let’s now look at the interplay of these with money itself. Specifically, when we talk about supply and demand, it’s with regard to, in this strict sense, the items we want or can offer in exchange, and not the measure itself. Can there be such a thing as ‘too much money’ in the economy? Too little? What are the repercussions of either? Especially now that we have clearly categorically distinguished between ‘money’ and ‘wealth’ in the previous episode. Let’s go back to the metaphor I offered there to depict this: that money is like the measuring tape rather than any actual tailoring. If a tailoring team completes 5 suits a week, there might be a need for, say up to 5 tapes in the course of working on those suits, perhaps 10, two for each. (Note to professsional tailors, this is just an example, tailor-made for non-tailors by a non-tailor!) So as in the example last time, if a tailor hoards several dozen tapes while still at 5 suits at any time, what’s the point of all those tapes? In quite the same way, the amount of money - the money supply in an economy must reflect the real economic output, the value being created, to measure it adequately. Simply jacking up by printing lots of cash simply recreates this tailor-made problem across the economy. Similarly if there is only one tape that has to go around managing 5 suits being worked on by the team, it’s not hard to see how it slows down the work. Everyone’s fighting to get their hands on that one tape. So correspondingly, a fall in the money supply can have severe repercussions. Like There’s no Tomorrow Most of us might have a sense of what happens when there’s too much money chasing the same goods - inflation, and as we saw in the very first episode, when governments overdo this, hyperinflation. We instinctively know that inflation is undesirable, you don’t want to see the price of goods in the supermarket keep climbing every day you’re out shopping. But deflation, the opposite phenomenon, can have its problems too, in particular in raising the costs of servicing a debt. We will dedicate specific articles to each of these to be explored in their own right. And more broadly, the question of money supply has had such rigorous research and debate that a lot more can be said later on at a more advanced stage of this series, which is some way off. But even before we get into the depths of Monetarism and monetarist policies, terms we routinely hear in the news, I may add that a huge part of the focus and attention of Central Banks, the banks that print money in an economy, has come to be dedicated to controlling the money supply. After the 2008 financial crash, the term quantitative easing was thrown around quite a bit. Quite simply it referred to printing tons of money to alleviate the damage done by developments such as the credit crunch that followed the sudden loss in trust. Some commentators bemoaned that central banks were printing money like there’s no tomorrow. But the counterargument is that it was this that stopped a repeat of the Great Depression, at which point there was a severe drop in the money supply. So regulators and authorities did learn something from that catastrophe, and we may say, didn’t repeat those mistakes. The Pain in Spain I will in due course have a lot to tell about these two recent crises, but for now, keeping it simple, let’s look at that older case which I presented in the last episode as the classic case of getting this wrong, that being perhaps the most dramatic case in history. The Spanish crown, among other kingdoms in the vicinity, back in the 1400-1500s…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: The Mafia of Mercantilism

    · 7 min

    Back in Episode 020 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin020-the-story-of-money-meeting-adam-smith) I said that the system that existed in Adam Smith’s time, which he worked to overthrow, was a lot worse than what he ushered in, without in as much naming that older system. Let’s get to it now. In the High Middle ages there existed a system called feudalism, centered around serfs living a miserable life bound to their lords, and the system of guilds which were essentially rackets - these I have explored in some detail in TecC 39 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc39-alchemys-forbidden-fruit-a-deadly-cocktail) and TecC 43 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc43-making-work-art-making-art-work-engineering-excellence) in my series on innovation and progress. However with an increase in economic activity in Europe that marked the end of the Middle Ages and ushered in the Renaissance/Early Modern Ages, there arose a new system, driven by the increased competition between rival polities and emerging nation-states. This is what we call mercantilism. Madness in the Methods The idea was simple, or one might say, simplistic: in any exchange, one party wins and the other party loses, that it was always a zero-sum game, the economic pie was fixed and wouldn’t grow. Furthermore, the idea of wealth was solely the amount of gold and silver stockpiled in the country, that’s it! The consequence of this was, given bullion was the means of international trade, countries gripped by mercantilism sought to minimize imports and maximize exports: after all, if you bought goods from abroad it might a drain on your gold/silver reserves, and vice versa. In summary, trade was seen as a war, not as a dance. This led to a raft of restrictive measures promulgated and enforced by the State, notably trade restrictions on imports including the imposition of tariffs, which is simply an onerous tax levied on the goods making the inflow of goods prohibitive by raising the costs to the consumers in the importing country. You Scratch my Back I Stab yours But here’s the thing, as I hope we’ve seen in the course of the last 21 episodes, with the concepts of value creation (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain) in particular, in a normal, emergent scenario, trade happens when both parties see a benefit to it. You might not necessarily like the price of something but you might buy it anyway because that’s a better course than not having the said item. Sometimes it’s the best course available given the vagaries of scarcity of goods and resources. So why didn’t that apply, as was asserted by the proponents of mercantilism, to nation-states across international borders? Again, we have seen the answer to this - it’s in fact what we started this series with: money itself has no intrinsic value, it’s simply a measure of value. And given gold and silver have been used to measure value, since they have acted as ‘money’ this value proposition applies to bullion too. It’s akin to hoarding measuring tapes instead of using it to carry out productive tailoring. And the pursuit of maximizing exports and minimizing imports had ruinous consequences. Mighty Cannons and Silver Bullets If, as it became the done-thing in Europe in the early 1500s, you want to export lots to hoard up gold and silver, what do you do, you go overseas and aggressively seek buyers abroad, and given this mindset, the aim is not mutually beneficial trading partners, but captive markets, that captivity being enforced by the force of the cannonball. Sound familiar? The poster-boy in this enterprise was the Kingdom of Spain, freshly united and having expelled its Muslim population after 8 centuries of their presence in the Iberian peninsula. (There are other factors at play such as being fired by a fervor never to be invaded, and the missionary zeal, as part of that fervor, to spread their Catholic religion far and wide, but let’s stick to…

    Not rated yet
  • The Story of Money: Exploring Abundance

    · 7 min

    They say things like love and hate are two sides of the same coin. Back in Episode 011 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p//ecfin011-the-story-of-money-understanding-scarcity) we looked at scarcity, let’s now flip the coin! Furthermore, under that topic we explored how scarcity is indeed the mother of the invention of the very discipline of economics, so is this about, given a future state of abundance, in fact escaping economics? We broadly know what abundance is, it’s what our political leaders have been promising us from time immemorial, a promise whose fulfilment, one might say, remains perpetually an election cycle away! Anyways, now that we have established what it isn’t, let’s take a proper look at what it might be. Abundance can be a bit formally defined as the presence of unlimited, or practically unlimited, quantity of a given resource. Abundance of any resource can occur naturally, like water next to a large river, or is man-made. As we’ve explored previously for example in discussing value creation (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p//ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain), human wants being much greater than what’s naturally available (Nature: here’s some water, berries, a few trees. Man: cool cool, but how about a thousand types of cheese, a hundred varieties of fermented hop and grape with fancy names and notes, a pocket device to send unlimited cat pictures), we humans have to step up to produce them - raw materials to finished goods. And is thus born a discipline such as economics to help direct the act of production in the best possible way -- not just in maximizing production but also ensuring an ecologically sound way of doing so -- leading to a whole bunch of concepts we’ve already covered in this series (capital/resource, the market, price, risk, debt, specialization, standardization etc) Rolling Dice or Flipping the Coin? Thus the logical progression has been to explore how to utilize fields such as economics to improve technology such that we can arrive at a state of abundance in many areas, a few obvious high-priority ones being food, clothing and other essentials. But then, if we say economics is concerned with scarcity, there can arise the reasonable question: is seeking abundance via this discipline not a contradiction, will it not be counterproductive, is it a paradox? I would offer that there need be no problem on those grounds - but I’ll caveat that different political philosophers have taken strongly different positions on this. But here’s one line of thinking: scarcity and abundance being two sides of the same coin, it’s by understanding and managing scarcity well that we may even seek to mitigate or eliminate it. (Doctors study diseases not to spread them but cure them?) In other words, isn’t it the case that if economic concepts and their practical applications are managed properly, there is room for ushering in greater abundance, as we have seen in a great many items since the dawn of the industrial age (just compare the modern middle class and their consumptive insistence with the medieval peasantry and their precarious subsistence.) And the onus of getting that right is on us humans rather than anything else? From Paucity to Plenty Let’s go back to the middle ages, imagine you happened to do some time-travel, back to the year 1000. Imagine you told a peasant tilling the field that one day in the future you will be able to send a message to the other end of the earth for practically zero cost. Forget one message, you could even send a thousand, and in fact folk would be tired of how many messages they’re getting from across the world every single day! We may safely guess that they would have you burnt at the stake for witchcraft! But let’s pause to think about this witchcraft! Back in the year 1000 only kings, and a few noblemen, could afford to send out a message beyond the confines of their town or local region. It required a man on a horse, food and…

    Not rated yet