The Story of Money: The Dynamics of a Bank Run
From Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · · 7 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
You may have lived through a bank run, if you’re lucky, you may have not! Distant as it may seem on normal days, you never know. Let’s take a first look at the phenomenon today.
This one’s juicy enough to merit a bit of fiction first. Steve, Bryan, Brenda and Irene have reservations for a grand dinner party the coming weekend at a rather posh restaurant in town - a very rare occasion.
While awaiting the weekend, Bryan is like, hmm, this one’s gonna be big, the estimated bill for the dinner is around 90-100 bucks per person, but wait I don’t have that kinda money. So he asks Steve, who happens to have a 100 bucks, but Steve’s like, wait this is for the dinner party, but heck, I’ll borrow it back to pay on the night, so hands over the 100 without questions. Somewhat similarly, and independently, Brenda is having similar thoughts, so when she runs into Bryan, she asks to borrow a hundred, and, that’s right, Bryan now thinks he can borrow it back to pay his share of the bill on the night. Next up Irene... you see where this is going... yes, she borrows the hundred from Brenda. None of them knows what’s happened all along.
Come dinner night and moment of truth with bill on table; 399 bucks! Steve, Bryan and Brenda each turn to the next person and go: can I have back the 100 I lent you, I’d saved that up for this dinner, and that’s all I have.
Borrow Peter Lend Paul
You can see what’s going on here. Having each borrowed a hundred bucks -- the same hundred bucks unbeknownst to them, assured they can get it back in time for the bill, there is only one hundred bucks going around. Back in Episode 023 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin023-the-story-of-money-the-intricacies-of-money-supply) we saw how money supply works, and more importantly, we followed that up with Episode 027 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin027-the-story-of-money-the-rabbit-hole-of-money-creation) where I introduced fractional reserve banking (with the promise that I’d get to this topic soon.)
In essence, banks engage in a roughly similar sort of activity as depicted above: each time a user deposits their money, the bank lends out a good portion of that money (typically as a loan or other long-term instrument charging a hefty price while offering the depositor a paltry interest!)
And quite simply, if all the depositors turn up at the bank one day demanding their money back, the bank simply doesn’t have enough cash to honor them all.
And that is a classic bank run.
A Debt Spiral
A key part of the problem is this - because the banks own use of the deposits are for longer-term instruments, such as a 30-year mortgage, they cannot be redeemed immediately (but this is attractive because of the higher yields the banks can expect.) But the depositors naturally expect to be able to withdraw their cash at any time.
In technical terms, banks promise liquidity - your cash can flow back freely to you on demand, but having made long-term investments with your money elsewhere, banks are stuck with illiquid instruments. This works fine most of the time but not when everyone wants their money back at the same time.
What causes a bank run? Usually there is some triggering event - some piece of really bad news, such as a disclosure or even just a rumor of losses at the bank, a reputationally damaging incident such as a credit downgrade, economic shocks, scandals, and even contagion from other bank runs and failures - yes, bank runs can spread from bank to bank.
And this is a downward spiral. Once the panic starts, people run to the bank to get their own money out, but the more people do that the more people join in: who wouldn’t want to get their money out before the bank runs out of money? And for the bank, the more such demands, the more the strain to honor them - typically addressed by selling their existing assets in fire sales, which means at much lower prices than on a normal day, which means the bank’s balance sheet is weaker, which means the panic only…
Back to Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · Report a problem