Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The Story of Money: The Mafia of Mercantilism

From Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · · 7 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Back in Episode 020 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin020-the-story-of-money-meeting-adam-smith) I said that the system that existed in Adam Smith’s time, which he worked to overthrow, was a lot worse than what he ushered in, without in as much naming that older system. Let’s get to it now.

In the High Middle ages there existed a system called feudalism, centered around serfs living a miserable life bound to their lords, and the system of guilds which were essentially rackets - these I have explored in some detail in TecC 39 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc39-alchemys-forbidden-fruit-a-deadly-cocktail) and TecC 43 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc43-making-work-art-making-art-work-engineering-excellence) in my series on innovation and progress.

However with an increase in economic activity in Europe that marked the end of the Middle Ages and ushered in the Renaissance/Early Modern Ages, there arose a new system, driven by the increased competition between rival polities and emerging nation-states. This is what we call mercantilism.

Madness in the Methods

The idea was simple, or one might say, simplistic: in any exchange, one party wins and the other party loses, that it was always a zero-sum game, the economic pie was fixed and wouldn’t grow. Furthermore, the idea of wealth was solely the amount of gold and silver stockpiled in the country, that’s it!

The consequence of this was, given bullion was the means of international trade, countries gripped by mercantilism sought to minimize imports and maximize exports: after all, if you bought goods from abroad it might a drain on your gold/silver reserves, and vice versa. In summary, trade was seen as a war, not as a dance.

This led to a raft of restrictive measures promulgated and enforced by the State, notably trade restrictions on imports including the imposition of tariffs, which is simply an onerous tax levied on the goods making the inflow of goods prohibitive by raising the costs to the consumers in the importing country.

You Scratch my Back I Stab yours

But here’s the thing, as I hope we’ve seen in the course of the last 21 episodes, with the concepts of value creation (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain) in particular, in a normal, emergent scenario, trade happens when both parties see a benefit to it. You might not necessarily like the price of something but you might buy it anyway because that’s a better course than not having the said item. Sometimes it’s the best course available given the vagaries of scarcity of goods and resources.

So why didn’t that apply, as was asserted by the proponents of mercantilism, to nation-states across international borders? Again, we have seen the answer to this - it’s in fact what we started this series with: money itself has no intrinsic value, it’s simply a measure of value. And given gold and silver have been used to measure value, since they have acted as ‘money’ this value proposition applies to bullion too. It’s akin to hoarding measuring tapes instead of using it to carry out productive tailoring.

And the pursuit of maximizing exports and minimizing imports had ruinous consequences.

Mighty Cannons and Silver Bullets

If, as it became the done-thing in Europe in the early 1500s, you want to export lots to hoard up gold and silver, what do you do, you go overseas and aggressively seek buyers abroad, and given this mindset, the aim is not mutually beneficial trading partners, but captive markets, that captivity being enforced by the force of the cannonball. Sound familiar?

The poster-boy in this enterprise was the Kingdom of Spain, freshly united and having expelled its Muslim population after 8 centuries of their presence in the Iberian peninsula. (There are other factors at play such as being fired by a fervor never to be invaded, and the missionary zeal, as part of that fervor, to spread their Catholic religion far and wide, but let’s stick to…

Back to Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · Report a problem