Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The Story of Money: The Conundrum of Coin Debasement

From Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · · 7 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

We traced in Episode 031 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin031-the-story-of-money-why-gold) the emergence of gold and silver as ‘pure’ and ‘noble’ metals perfectly suited to serve our economic needs in the form of money, and then in Episode 032 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin032-the-story-of-money-gold-or-silver) their comparative importance and finally in Episode 033 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin033-the-story-of-money-the-origins-of-the-coin) how money took shape - in the form of coins. Remember the final words in that piece? “What could go wrong?”

And oh boy wrong it did go so many times, and sometimes so spectacularly, that you’d think it was farce, vaudeville and tragedy rolled into one! In this piece, I’ll briefly touch upon the broad forces and phenomena at play in this context, but we will definitely come back with specific stories from specific events in history.

With the advent of coinage, the issuance of a standard specie - ie, with a certain fixed size and weight, by the king or state meant that the unit of measure of value was now fixed and established as uniform. The implicit understanding was that if the coins were melted down and sold in the market, it would be worth the same as if the coins were spent, they would both fetch, say, 10 sacks of grain. In other words, the face value of the coin is the same as its value by weight.

And then the fun begins!

A Clippery Slope

Let’s say I’m looking at a shiny new silver coin and it says “One Denarius” on it, so I can be sure of buying that much by face value. Now what if I chip or shave off a small portion of the edge of the coin - which is not that hard given silver is not that hard, what if I do this for a 100 such coins, even a 1000. Now I have all these clippings I can melt and voila, I have new money! As the Dire Straits didn’t sing: money for nothing and chips for free!

Apart from this method, which is called clipping, there were other ones, but the idea was the same, leech off a small, seemingly imperceptible quantity of the metal from each coin while also trying to pass off the counterfeited coin as if it were the real thing. Incidentally, coin-clipping as a problem is attributed to have been solved by our good friend the Master of the Mint at Britain’s Royal Mint we met back in episode 032 - yes, Isaac Newton! The legacy still stands even though we don’t engage in clipping - ridges, reeds or grooves you see around the side of a coin, the process being called reeding or milling.

And needless to say kings and states came down heavily on individuals engaging in such debasing of coins. But was it only the ordinary people who did such stuff?

An Alloyed Bad

Oh no! Coin debasement gets even spicier when the king himself got down to it. Not by clipping mind you, but let’s look into how. Issuing coinage has a cost, obviously the metal being used, plus the process of minting the coins, the labor thereof etc.

So I’m sitting on my throne, I have these ‘One Denarius’ coins of silver serving the economy, but hold on, I have a brilliant idea (or a cunning plan if you watch the comedy Black Adder, very apt for the current context!) For the next batch I’m going to print, why don’t I use a tiny bit of copper, like about 5% of the weight that goes into the minting process. I mean, nobody will know right? My subjects aren’t that smart, even if a few are, it’ll still look the same to most of them? What could go wrong?

Face of Base

And to that refrain, we can add another one - and where will it all end? Because, spoiler alert, it always ended in tragedy.

In a system where the face value of a coin is understood by everyone to be the same as the intrinsic value of the weight of the coin, it’s not hard to see how detrimental this is - and this was very tempting for kings and governments, because when done in seemingly small measures of adulteration, they could hope to get away with it. But if you’ve done it once why not do it again, with a bit more…

Back to Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · Report a problem