Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The Story of Money: The Mysteries of Moral Hazard

From Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · · 7 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Last time we explored the development of insurance. As we’ve done with other such topics before, let’s see what could go wrong!

We saw last time back in FictionTown that our friends Steve, Bryan, Brenda and Irene started off stressed about the prospect of their house getting burned down just as had just happened to a neighbor. In the end, luckily, they worked out the concept of insurance and set it in motion across the town, so that they could live happily ever after as in every good story!

The scene ended with Steve, initially the most indignant of the lot, now confidently having a barbecue indoors, right next to his books or his attached barn full of hay!

Risk-free Risk-taking

So yes, as I hinted last time, that is an example of moral hazard: as long as the risk of fire persisted, Steve would be very careful, but once that was ‘covered’ by way of payments from a common pot, he couldn’t be bothered to be careful. To generalize, when one is protected against consequences of a given risk, one might not be so careful anymore. Even where such a person may by nature tend to be somewhat cautious and careful.

Perhaps a relatable example is health insurance - without it, we may be a bit more careful, but if we are to say get full health treatment at any time under a generous healthcare package, we might go for that extra drink or the fags. If we are on the road behind the wheel after having secured a hefty driving insurance deal, we might be less mindful of good driving comportment. (”I’ve got fully comp. YOLO. Now slam the goddamn pedal, yeeehaaa!”)

Skin in the Cat-n-Mouse Game

But equally, in the modern day, those who have read the fine print of the insurance policy papers know that it’s not that simple. The insurance industry has adapted to moral hazard - no insurance policy we know of offers us unfettered coverage. There are deliberate constraints imposed by the insurer: phenomena such as co-pay, where, as the name says, the insuree pays for a portion of the benefit availed - say 20% of the overall cost; then there is excess (or deductible) where you first fund a fixed amount yourself before your insurer steps in. Some policies offer you a bonus at the end of the year if you never claim.

Fundamentally, the idea is to ensure the user has ‘skin in the game’ (call it a skin tax if you will!) that even though you’re paying the regular premiums, you have additional obligations at the point of making a claim, sufficient to deter, the insurer would hope, spurious claims. I say ‘hope’ because, some users will find a way to game the system - skin or no skin, it’s still a cat-n-mouse game?

O Insura, O Mōrēs!

We saw back in Episode 024 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin024-the-story-of-money-the-matter-of-monopoly) discussing monopoly, similar behavior change once a seller ends up in a state of monopoly - jacking up prices, not bother with the quality etc. And just like I said there, even here the change in behavior doesn’t have to suggest that the person is ‘evil’, or even, despite the term in use, ‘immoral’.

(’moral’ actually has two meanings - the original meaning of this Latin term, incidentally coined by Cicero (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-30b-the-last-of-the-romans-minds-monumental-worth-over-marble), is simply ‘customary’, referring to the customs: derived from Latin ‘mōs’ which also gives us ‘mores’!)

My point is, that it’s the incentive structure (in both cases) that drives behavior, and the adverse turn could manifest even in otherwise well-meaning people. Thus the moral-as-in-ethical connotation is a derivative of the above stated moral-as-customary sense.

Furthermore, all this is not strictly only in the realm of standard insurance. This can be seen further afield, and as applicable not just to individuals but even large organizations - such as corporations and governments.

If you live in a society where the norm (mores!) is for the final bill after dinner is to be split evenly amongst all 5 of you…

Back to Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · Report a problem