
Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast
Ash StuartAudio
- Format:
- Podcast
- New episodes:
- Weekly
- Typical length:
- about 7 minutes
- Latest episode:
About this show
Exploring innovation, progress and achievement: a first-principles approach to everything that matters; combining history, epistemology, economics, anthropology, geopolitics, finance, philology, etymology and more... for, life is short, knowledge forever.
ashstuart.substack.com (https://ashstuart.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast)
Covers: economics, personal finance, financial history, monetary history, money and banking, insurance, behavioral economics, inflation, financial crises
Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at api.substack.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.
Recently on this show
Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.
This podcast examines innovation, progress and achievement from first principles, drawing on history, economics and related fields. Recent episodes cover the Mississippi Bubble, moral hazard and insurance, bank runs, inflation, coin debasement, the origins of coins, and gold versus silver.
Cosmos
Similar in subject
- Rebel Economics with Professor Steve Keen
Both cover: financial crises, economics - Robinson's Podcast
Both cover: financial history, economics - The Indicator from Planet Money
Both cover: inflation, economics, personal finance
Similar shows
Explore more
Episodes
The Story of Money: Meeting Adam Smith
· 8 min
It is said about ‘the classics’, or classical literature that everyone has an opinion on them but nobody’s read them. In this decimilestone episode of the series, we meet the author of one such great classic work relevant to our subject. A Fertile Island No man is an island, it’s also said, and no great cultural and intellectual output emerges from a vacuum. Let’s explore the context and the background before we get to the person. In my parallel series on human achievement (tecc), I’ve traced the evolution of human intellectual progress from the earliest days. By the time we get to the 1700s, there arose in Scotland an effervescence of intellectual output which has been termed the Scottish Enlightenment which developed within the fertile soil of the wider British context of rapid innovation setting the stage for the industrial revolution in Britain shortly thereafter. The Enlightenment within Britain itself was part of a wider movement in Western Europe as a break from the medieval past (all of which I’ve been covering in the said other series with more to come.) It was into this milieu of extraordinary intellectual output that was born Adam Smith. Adam Smith in a sense needs no introduction. He’s widely regarded as the ‘father of economics’ or even the ‘father of capitalism’. (Although check out TecC 48 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc48-seeking-symmetry-finding-balance-making-harmony) and TecC 49 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc49-foreseeing-new-frontiers-integrating-novel-instruments-creating-unprecedented-value).) Smith is seen as having pioneered the idea of so-called ‘free-market capitalism’, and based on who you ask, unfettered economic activity and industrial expansion with profit-seeking as the sole motive, and with the State moving out of the way with no role to play. And of course such ideas are claimed to have been crystallized by him in his landmark book ‘The Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations’, or simply ‘The Wealth of Nations’. But was he really all that and was that really his tenet, message and goal? Notions and Sentiments Much as some people may love to hate this Gordon-Gekko image of Smith, I have disappointing news for them - he was indeed a very different person than his popular caricature. He was first and foremost a moral philosopher mainly concerned about understanding and improving the human condition, in particular that of the less fortunate sections of society. This manifests in what might in fact be an even greater work of his, ‘The Theory of Moral Sentiments’ published much earlier, and so thought even by the author himself. Even though some of the notions of morality and similar values have changed in the two and a half centuries that have passed since, scholarly research and opinion have pointed out some ‘surprisingly modern’ treatment by Smith on these topics, such as, as per research, around concepts like mutual empathy, egalitarianism, individual sovereignty, and human dignity. An Inquiry in Earnest So his subsequent inquiry into economic questions that form the substance of his more famous work can be traced to stem from this deep concern for improving the human condition as just mentioned. Let’s take a few examples of this as emanating from that work. We saw in the previous episode his description of the notion of division of labor as underpinning (sorry, can’t help the pun) the new economic system that was emerging leading to the Industrial Revolution in Britain, an economic system others later, approvingly or disapprovingly, have called ‘capitalism’. In the episode on specialization I mentioned how the philosopher Karl Marx, perhaps the one person most opposed to the so-called ‘capitalism’, railed against specialization. Now guess what, in fact Adam Smith in his discussion of the division of labor expressed deep concerns on the same matter. Let’s next look at the other popular misnotion: that a ‘free market’ should be allowed to operate…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: Division of Labor
· 6 min
Back in Episode 013 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin013-the-story-of-money-understanding-specialization) we looked at specialization, let’s now look at a very closely related concept. Just as in that episode, the fictional anchor for this episode is going to be the story already narrated in TecC 43 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc43-making-work-art-making-art-work-engineering-excellence), where we saw how, after a disastrous start in a joint initiative, with everyone stepping on everyone else’s toes, our four fictional friends eventually manage to allocate each of themselves specific areas of focus and work things out. The Coordinates of Cooperation What they do can be explained either as specialization or division of labor, in fact it’s kinda both - it’s the division of labor that allows for specialization to take place. And in the specialization episode, we correspondingly focused on some of the more human elements of the phenomenon, given that specifically relates to one’s role, identity etc, here let’s look at a few other parameters. We can in fact look at division of labor as related to process more than the people per se. It’s the overall system of coordination, cooperation and indeed specialization. There are thus the questions of how the overall set of activities is broken up into discrete parts each of which can be handled separately from the others but in tandem, whether simultaneously or in sequence. Beyond this, there’s the question of how the coordination/cooperation is ensured or enforced. All this said, there has to be a certain amount of scale to justify division of labor: the requirement of making artisanal jam to be sold over a full week of an annual market event justified our fictional friends in the fictional story to apply these concepts. But if it was just a matter of preparing 3 jars of jams to gift a visiting aunt, it’s probably best done solo. (Hello aunt Margaret, what time are you arriving this weekend? And don’t worry I have a team of 12 people working on a small gift for you!) Pinning it Down The classic example of division of labor in economics literature is the famous one provided by Adam Smith in his landmark work on the subject: the pin factory. He contrasts a solitary worker with a specialized team of 10 workers. Having broken down the overall task of making a pin into 18 subtasks, such as drawing the wire, straightening it, cutting it, making it a pointy on one end, adding a head on the other and so on... The contrast Smith draws is the sole worker’s handful, about 20 pins a day to the ten-worker team’s around 48,000 pins in a day! The Division that Multiplies That’s roughly 4800 per worker, where applying division of labor has yielded an improvement of 2,400 X. We can appreciate some of the factors that make any such improvement possible. Apart from allowing each worker to become more dexterous in their task at focus, and avoiding the costs of code-switching both by way of cognitive load and the time lost in the transitions, this division of labor and the intense focus can facilitate the discovery of better techniques or even newer labor-saving tools, as Smith outlines. This way, as we delegate more and more of these subtasks to technology - new tools built specifically to handle them, we save ourselves of the drudge. So paradoxically division of labor itself might be helping us rid ourselves of the monotony of division of labor? There are other advantages too, it’s more viable to find a substitute worker or quickly train one for one particular task should the original worker not be available for some reason, since there is less of a learning curve. This of course entails lower disruption and downtime and thus increased overall productivity. Division of Labor exists everywhere in our modern world. For example, much of the music we are used to enjoying would be impossible - imagine your favorite rockstar hopping between the drums, the bass and singing mic + guitar…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: Decoding Efficiency
· 6 min
I’ve discussed the concept of value creation in the past, both in Episode 004 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain) of this series and elsewhere in my writing on here. Let’s go further. But first a quick, and of course efficient, detour to check on our fictional friends. Steve, Bryan, Brenda and Irene are sat around the garden table discussing the week’s matters. Bruno the dog and Iris the cat are of course... well you know them by now! Recently both Steve and Bryan have taken up a new business - in parallel: shirt-making, thanks to a surplus of cotton in their region. While they don’t say as much, they each want to do a better job than the other. So Brenda and Irene are like, how’s it going lads? Steve is like, well, I keep running out of stock, in this last cycle I made 10 shirts from the stock that came through at the beginning. Bryan is like, hmm, I got the same amount of stock too, I got 15 done. Something must be done. The next day Brenda and Irene walk into Steve’s workshop, followed by Bruno and Iris, and what do they see, tons of pieces of cloth strewn everywhere. He has more equipment than can be seen in Bryan’s workshop. Brenda is like, Steve, where are your manuals? Steve’s like, what manuals? Irene’s turn, and where are your accounts, how are you keeping track of how much stock is getting consumed. Steve’s look doesn’t get any less bewildered. Bruno the dog and Iris the cat walk out in disgust. Yardstick’s Yields So it’s obvious where we are going with this. And on the face of it, we all know what efficiency is: how well we get something out of what we put in -- there is some nuance with related terms such as effectiveness and efficacy but those are for another day. And while discussing value creation previously, I’ve formalized that general concept by way of the production equation: inputs + processing = output. Only, here, with efficiency, we are concerned with more consciously measuring the inputs and outputs with some degree of accuracy. This broader notion has been expressed in slight variants severally before, for example, by Lord Kelvin and much later, Peter Drucker. In my own paraphrasing to capture that essence: if you can’t measure what you’re doing, you do not know what you’re doing. (The variants of these famous figures having ‘manage’ or ‘improve’ in the second part.) Because quite simply, unless we know the baseline for today, how can we tell how we did tomorrow? As I trust I’ve demonstrated in this series so far, economics is about more than numbers and charts. Economics straddles science (including mathematics) and the social world - areas such as psychology and anthropology. It’s an attempt to apply mathematical rigor to such aspects of human behavior, which is why it gets tricky, and one may say, economics therefore ends up disappointing both the scientific types and the humanities types. Still, the concept and application of efficiency, which reflects this desire for mathematical vigor, is vital and fundamental to the pursuit of economics, with its ultimate aim of improving the human condition within our environment. Metrics and Optics But even before such a discipline as ‘economics’ was formally constituted, there had been efforts to understand and apply efficiency, albeit haphazardly or, as the economists might say, unscientifically. But in essence, all technological progress can be seen to be part of an endeavor to achieve better efficiency: writing (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-16-outsourcing-the-mind-a-striking-impression-underscoring-an-underrated-invention-that-rewrote-the-rules-of-knowledge), printing (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc42-going-from-a-handful-rapidly-to-millions), even the wheel (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-13-turning-point-the-axis-of-progress-the-paradox-of-finding-constancy-amid-motion-stability-amid-change)! (Yeah, I mean just try tugging any amounts of material on wooden logs…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: The Dance of Supply and Demand
· 7 min
I’ve sort of touched upon this topic before, or at least skirted around it while discussing price (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin003-the-story-of-money-the-enigma-of-price) and scarcity (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin011-the-story-of-money-understanding-scarcity). But today let’s look at supply and demand in their own right. Back in the first of those two episodes, we posed a question. At the townsquare market when Brenda and Irene each inquired on the price of a sack of grain, Steve and Bryan quoted different prices for the same quantity, 8 and 10 copper coins. But why the difference? Furthermore, the question can be broadened to beyond just the same item or quantity. Without fully answering the question back in that story, we considered a few factors at play, and as we intuitively know, supply and demand are a couple of them. The Ups and Downs While we don’t need a literal textbook definition of these two words, let’s poke them around a bit. Firstly, much of this question arises because of the aforementioned reality of scarcity - things are limited in supply. And then, different people want different amounts of different things. So obviously if more people want something than there is supply of it, the effort needed to satisfy that need gets greater - and that, is signaled by the figure we call price. And of course, in a functional market, if there is less demand for something, the price will correspondingly go down. It generally works in the other direction too. If a seller jacks up the price of some item of utility, it may dissuade people from buying it. And conversely: we are all familiar with those empty shelves in the supermarket for those heavily discounted items - usually perishable goods, like your favorite yogurt brand? The Balancing Game So in a sense this is about equilibrium, every good in the economy is in this game with every other and with people seeking the goods, and in aggregate add up to then confer upon each good a certain price - hence my insistence in that episode that price is essentially a filtered-down signal of the underlying economy. Thus in other words, it’s a reflection of human behavior in aggregate as well. How well the prices reflect the economy depends on how functional (some use the word ‘free’) the market is - how freely such signals can move without the distortion of forces such as subsidies and price controls - topics for another day. And there is a feedback mechanism built in to such a system, each purchase changes the supply, and the prices and purchases act as a feedback loop which further changes the picture, ad infinitum, again, all subject to how freely these dynamics are allowed to play out. Let’s take a simple example - without even money necessarily in the picture. Imagine in your town there is a park that’s getting popular with the townsfolk as a picnic spot. As more and more people decide to go to that park for their picnic, the experience for each group will start to degrade - it’s noisier, more crowded, less fun over all - that’s the price they’re paying, the feedback loop also consisting of the ‘gossip’ or general talk about how crowded the place is getting. And then someone finds another park not really used for picnics, some folk start to go there instead, it’s pristine, initially, and then... you know where this is going. A Delicate Dance As participants in the economy, we are used to the effects of supply and demand. We know, for example, that in the unlikely event of war in the Middle East, prices go up because everything needs energy to function. We know that housing prices are highest where there’s more demand. Even human capital is entwined with the supply-demand dynamic - wages depend on the availability of certain jobs, our skills etc. Ultimately, however, the point I’m making there is supply and demand are in fact everywhere in all aspects of our lives. Consider this fun story: the dance form of the tango developed at a time when there…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: The Core Concept of Investment
· 6 min
Thank you for holding on for a whole week from the end of reading the last episode on delayed gratification, so you have my undiluted gratitude! In line with my promise to you when I ended that piece, let’s take that concept to its logical next step. The word investment conjures up some rather advanced images - of complex mathematics, overbearing financial advisers and glassy-facade banking institutions. The core of it is much simpler and more relatable than all that fancy stuff. Let’s also clear out the notion that investment = saving, it’s certainly not as passive as that. Investment is essentially the process of marshalling the other elements of economics we discussed in previous episodes - capital, the time value of money, opportunity cost, and especially risk and putting them to use, implementing, or as I previously said, crystallizing delayed gratification. Let’s see how all this adds up. The Vestment of Progress Let’s start with capital, Episode 005 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin005-the-story-of-money-is-capital-just-money) where I insisted that capital is not the same as money, and indeed in the episode on money, Episode 001 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin001-the-story-of-money-what-is-money-anyways) that money itself has no intrinsic value. Capital is anything, any resource, including human skills, that we put to productive use. In other words, investment is capital put to work! And the time value of money, Episode 007 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin007-the-story-of-money-time-and-its-relationship-with-money) comes into the picture because well, any investment takes time to bear fruit and we have to be confident that it’s worth that time we waited for it. Which then brings us to opportunity cost, Episode 009 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin009-the-story-of-money-what-is-opportunity-cost), for every investment involves decisions made, and for the investment to be viable, we have to assess each decision against the alternatives. And despite all that, the investment may not pay off. If you join the financial advice industry, for the first three months of your financial advisor internship, you’re supposed to chant every single day all day “Past performance is not indicative of future result”. Well, ok ok, it’s not quite so, but that’s the one they are trained to mention in every single communication with you without fail. (I suspect still that financial advice professionals won’t say that about themselves in an interview or a first date!) To get back on track, my point is of course about risk. Risk is perhaps the most important concept and component surrounding the whole story of investment. In fact it goes both ways, the entire industry of ‘investment banking’ can be said to be built on the core need to manage risk. But more on that angle another time. Divested Interests So let’s see where we would be without the idea of investment, without the activity of investing, and the connection to the previous episode. Let’s start perhaps with the more obvious ones, ones that are perhaps more conspicuous in our life, ones we more easily recognize as investments. Those roads, bridges, skyscrapers would never get built. (Manhattan would just be a very expensive swamp, an improvement, some would argue.) No skilled professionals, for without the investment of one’s childhood in education and training, no skilled work would be possible. (Your surgeon would essentially be a very confident guesser with a sharp stick!) No better tools or techniques. By extension, we wouldn’t have dedicated disciplines such as science and technology. (We’d have to carve our angry tweets on stone!) So yes, no cars, no homes to be owned after 30 years... (silver lining? No worries about mortgage payments either!) Going back to the very basics, last time I touched upon the idea of planting seeds in the ground and tending to them in the expectation of harvesting a crop a few months down the line. Investment…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: How Delayed Gratification Matters
· 7 min
I mentioned the concept of delayed gratification in passing back in Episode 010 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin010-the-story-of-money-the-core-foundations-of-trade) while talking about certain elements alongside the phenomenon of trade. Let’s not delay any more! We haven’t met our fictional friends in a while, so let’s go back to the setting in Episode 012 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin012-the-story-of-money-understanding-property-rights) where Steve, Bryan, Brenda and Irene are sat in the garden looking around as Bruno the dog and Iris the cat are doing doggy and catty things around. Specifically, Bruno brings in a bone and buries it next to his kennel, which leads them to digress from their task at hand to philosophize. It’s a sunny afternoon after all and the beer won’t drink itself! Brenda is like, isn’t that clever of little Bruno? Irene going, yeah, he’s saving up for the future, very prudent. Bryan reacts by saying, pah, what’s the big deal, he’s just burying a bone, with Steve adding, well, I mean humans don’t do such silly things, if I have a good sandwich in my hand, I’d eat it right away, why let it rot. Brenda snaps back, no Steve, that’s not it, Bruno is showing restraint now for enjoyment later. Bryan starting to see, oh wait, that’s right, Steve, we do such things all the time as well, with Irene adding, that’s true. Steve, I mean after every harvest don’t you store up some of the produce for the next season’s planting, surely you don’t eat it all right away? When the Waiting’s Worth It Yes, that’s it, it’s that simple. Delayed Gratification is simply about sacrificing the prospect of immediate reward in favor of something likely more valuable at a future point in time. While this is mainly treated under the discipline of psychology, this, like many other concepts in that domain, has significant economic bearings as well. So let’s explore it from that angle. This can be compared in many ways to the notion of the time value of money we discussed in Episode 007 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin007-the-story-of-money-time-and-its-relationship-with-money), along with capital we saw in Episode 005 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin005-the-story-of-money-is-capital-just-money) - money, or using money and capital can be put to good use right now rather than later, allowing it to produce a return, a sort of a mirror image of delayed gratification. It could even be human capital, like even though you want to stay in bed, it’s Monday morning after all, you resolve to and do get up early to write, as scheduled, that new piece about, let’s say, forgoing immediate enjoyment for long-term gain! In making such choices, we are also applying the idea of opportunity cost. The cost of the lost opportunity of doing something productive and thus more rewarding longer-term is what you pay by snoozing and staying in bed (although there are times it may be justified!) The most famous experiment around this is the 1970s Stanford University ‘marshmallow experiment’, where 4-year-olds were offered either one marshmallow they could eat right now or had to wait, in a closed room unsupervised, to get two later. (It’s almost as if one cannot ever write a piece on this topic without mentioning this particular experiment - it’s the marshmallow tax!) Kids who turned out to show restraint in that experiment were generally seen to be more competent and successful later in life. But let’s look at more specifically economic ramifications. As you Slow So Shall You Reap Back in TecC 10 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-10-seeds-of-civilization-the-first-great-bargain-sowing-time-reaping-change) in my other series here on the story of human innovation and progress, I spoke about the advent of farming - human existence in sedentary agricultural lifestyle is like the last 5 minutes of a 24-hour day, compared to the hunter-gatherer living over the rest of that 24-hour analogy. And the central dilemma there was…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: Exploring Standardization
· 7 min
So, much like with the previous episode, I have indeed written earlier about standardization, but as I said there in the context of innovation. Here we take a slightly different angle. Once more, that older innovation-series article, TecC 19 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-19-footprints-in-dust-how-hidden-hands-once-worked-unlikely-wonders) demonstrates by way of fiction how the idea might have arisen. So taking that as our standard, let’s proceed! We saw in the very first episode of this series, Episode 001 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin001-the-story-of-money-what-is-money-anyways), that money can be seen as a social contract, which essentially works only if people agree to give the same meaning, value, to a certain piece of paper or other artefact. Back there I also likened this aspect of money with language. With small differences, a standard is the same, isn’t it. From the perspective of this series, standardization would have been the logical outgrowth of the foundational concepts we’ve previously touched upon, especially trade, Episode 010 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin010-the-story-of-money-the-core-foundations-of-trade), and specialization, Episode 011 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin011-the-story-of-money-understanding-scarcity). Let’s dig a bit deeper into what might be different or unique about this concept. Intuition to Institution In the earliest times of human interaction via practices such as trade, especially as the scale and scope of such exchange expanded beyond a small isolated community, the need to identify compatible agreed-upon ways of doing things across group divisions, or at least the benefit of doing so would have at some stage become apparent. It would lower the barriers to the matters of exchange - in modern parlance, it would lower transaction costs - an economics term that I believe may be more widely used and understood beyond the field. (My intent in my writing is to use purely non-technical terms to describe these phenomena, but this one’s a glaring violation!) But perhaps, the phenomenon of standardization deviates from the emergence of money, and especially language, somewhat sooner, in the involvement of a centralized body to oversee its use. This could be a standards body constituted of the different participants defining and policing the rules of engagement, comparable to the developments we traced in Episode 002 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin002-the-story-of-money-what-is-the-market) around the growth of the market, or it could be an even more overarching institution, the State, especially as the scale increases. Quite often, such bodies may be semi-autonomous arms of the state. So one might say that even if at first emergent, practices at some stage undergo a certain formalization to become a standard. The Standard-Bearers In both this and the innovation (TecC) series, time and again there has arisen the question of the dichotomy between two systems of organizing anything: top-down vs bottom-up. Usually, as we’ve seen, the forces at play in each case have appeared somewhat in opposition to the forces in the other dynamic. However, standardization is one of those things that’s pertinent in not just top-down systems, where it’s easy to conceive of it, but also in bottom-up systems. The classic telephone system was built as a top-down, central exchange-based standard. The Internet, a bottom-up system where any node can join the internetwork, is an expressly protocol-based design, where the protocol serves as the standard. One may even argue that standards, by way of the just-mentioned protocols, are even more fundamental in bottom-up systems. And as I’ve said before, the best clues to this come from nature / biology. It can be argued that every aspect of planetary behavior, and every aspect of cellular behavior, operate on the basis of some kind of a ‘standard’, whether encoded in the laws of gravity or embedded in the codes of DNA.…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: Understanding Specialization
· 7 min
In fact, I’ve previously written about specialization, in the context of exploring how innovation accelerated at a crucial historical juncture - TecC 43 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc43-making-work-art-making-art-work-engineering-excellence). However, let’s look at this from the perspective of our story here. And indeed, apart from the historical angle, I do have a fictional depiction around how this arose, in that episode. But, fiction and history apart, let’s now focus on the core concept itself, in other words, let’s specialize! In Episode 010 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin010-the-story-of-money-the-core-foundations-of-trade) we touched upon the specific concept of trade. Whilst in the smallest isolated communities, every member would have bothered with every aspect of making things they need, from trade, ie the ability to get certain items from someone else in exchange for what you have or can make, it naturally proceeds that different individuals could focus on making the different things they need. This proffers a few striking advantages to the group as a whole. Different individuals have different propensities, so they might be inclined to do, or learn to do, one type of work better than another. It has been shown that broadly it’s easier to focus on a few things than to keep switching tasks all the time: code-switching is hard, it’s a cognitive load (just imagine ejecting and inserting separate CDs into your working personal computer every few minutes!) Furthermore, there is a limit to how many skills single person can master - the classic jack of all, master of none, stuff. As communities get larger therefore, with their needs growing, it becomes quite compelling for such division to emerge or be enforced. Divide et Coopera The classic explanation of this phenomenon, division of labor is of course that by the economist Adam Smith in the late 1700s. But let’s take a look at a more recent example or argument of this at play. There is this question, should a very highly skilled professional, say a brain surgeon, wash one’s own car before heading to work in the morning? The answer economists (and the Association of Car-washers) would give is, no, they should hire someone to do the job for them! If we think about this, especially having considered opportunity cost in Episode 009 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin009-the-story-of-money-what-is-opportunity-cost), the brain surgeon would utilize one’s time and exertions to far better outcomes in the operating theater than outside the house. The car-washing can be done by someone with far less training and expertise than the brain surgeon: your time has a market value, act accordingly! (Of course, if our professional expert finds the car-washing act itself therapeutic there can be a carveout made here, but how about we relegate that to Saturdays...) Twixt Skills and Wills So yes, in a nutshell that’s what specialization is about, a concept we are so used to in the modern day, that one may be justified to ask, what’s the big deal? Allowing different members of a group to focus on different areas of work, whether it’s in a small village or a big industrial setup, allows them to, by way of gaining experience in that area, become much more skilled at it. Again something we take for granted. But this helps significantly increase the overall quality of output, and when combined with innovation as I’ve demonstrated in the quoted piece, even build much better, far superior, more ambitious things. Therefore specialization is an accelerant of value creation, Episode 004 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain). However, there are a few problems with specialization, and we cannot ignore them. Most obviously, specialization leads to interdependence, which is generally seen as a good thing, but it relies on the larger system of trade and cooperation to continue to function. And then, the inability or…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: Understanding Property Rights
· 8 min
I trust we’ve seen so far that the story of money involves a lot more than just cash and coins. In this spirit we’ve dug into some of the core concepts that make up the foundation of economics, today let’s explore one more such. Let’s first do a quick fictional round. Our friends Steve, Bryan, Brenda and Irene are sat in the garden, some of them halfheartedly taking stock of their recent business activities to keep the books up to date, but mostly in the mood to just take it easy - it’s a sunny afternoon, the birds are chirping. Bruno the dog and Iris the cat are playing out there. So they just need an excuse. That’s when they notice Bruno bringing in a piece of bone with a very proud look on his face. He buries it carefully making a place for it next to his kennel almost as if it were a sacred ritual of a treasure deposit. He then goes away to sip some water and.. Iris the cat sneakily saunters over and just sits on it (cats are not particularly into bones, remember!) Bruno is seething, he starts barking at Iris furiously but the cat won’t budge. Our four friends, amused watching this, have found their theatrical excuse to digress from work for a fine philosophical treatment of the just-observed phenomenon. Bring on the beers! From Bare Bones to Smartphones Yes, so we now know the burning question. Who does that bone belong to? Or to come back to human reality, who does anything belong to? This has been a question thinkers in many societies have grappled with. Let’s do the same (start stroking your chin..), and let’s get down to first principles first. Back in Episode 004 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain), when we discussed value creation, we saw that things exist in nature as such. And the starting point for value creation is that we take something from the pristine surrounding and do something with it making it suitable for human use. In other words, there is a difference between something unused in nature and ‘appropriately taken’ (the proper word here would have more aptly been ‘appropriate’ with its inherent meaning of ‘proper’ and ‘property’, but sadly there are too many judgemental connotations to that now loaded word that I hesitate. Given our goal for now is to get to the concepts without any ideological baggage. As promised before in the stated episode, I’ll come back to the thorny questions of... impropriety in due course.) But yes, the etymology there is quite clear, all those words, derived from Latin ‘proprius’, do have those shared and related senses, also add in ‘proprietor’ and ‘proprietary’ to that list. High-hanging Fruit So at the conceptual level, this line of reasoning offers a framework for the core question posed above. And once someone has taken a said natural resource, put their own labor into it (in the simplest theoretical example, the mere act of stretching out and plucking an apple from the tree), they have attribution. But who’s to say someone else won’t lay claim to the labor of someone, just as we saw in our silly story above? How is one to affirm that attribution in practical terms? How can such a system as outlined above practically work? That’s where the enforcer comes in: the State. In most practical cases, it is only with the State, the legal apparatus that sets the rules of engagement, that we can really have a functional system of property rights. Let’s think about this for a moment, in practical terms, any functioning ‘right’ is indeed a construct of the State? Otherwise, we are just whistling in the air, shouting in the wind? We may say, in principle, we have a right to something, but in practice it needs enforced? (Don’t get me wrong there’s a lot of well-constructed argument along moral lines for a theoretical basis of rights, but I’m only refering to the practical application in this case. And that said, this remains a highly debated area, so take this with that in mind.) The First Principal Let’s now go…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: Understanding Scarcity
· 6 min
Last time, I concluded on the suggestion that economics is a lot more ubiquitous than we tend to think. Let’s dig deeper into the fundamental question of why we even need economics at all. Let’s in fact take this forward from where we last left off on one particular point. Back in Episode 009 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin009-the-story-of-money-what-is-opportunity-cost) discussing opportunity cost, we were faced with a few dilemmas, such as which of the two full-time job offers to take, or even something as mundane as whether to go out for the evening or stay in. That’s when the idea of scarcity came to the fore. The Specter of Scarcity The fact of the matter is quite simple: almost everything - every resource we consume, is scarce, in other words, in finite supply. This in itself is not a revelation to us. We are all aware that the natural resources on our planet are finite (even if perhaps as a species we should’ve recognized this sooner?) Land is scarce, our skills are finite, our attention is limited. We are aware perhaps more than anything else that time is scarce: how many of us have wished we had more than 24 hours in a day? But scarcity cuts through other dimensions of reality as well. You could say that the traffic lights are a response to scarcity - streams of vehicles cutting across a perpendicular thoroughfare cannot all drive on at the same time. So we are forced to allocate. Striking Deals Scarcity forces choice. And choice reveals values. Let’s think about this for a moment. If we could have any amount of anything at any moment at no cost whatsoever, in some sense you’d never need to bother to choose anything, you’d just have everything. But because we don’t live in such a universe, we have to pick. And as we saw in Episode 003 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin003-the-story-of-money-the-enigma-of-price), price is a signal that gives us information of the relative affordability of the different choices we are confronted with, representing the underlying reality of their availability in the system as a whole. And that connects to value - what we value more, how much we think a thing is worth, and thus whether the price on offer is viable for me or not. This throws up moral, even philosophical, questions: the choices I make in my spending reveal my values, could I have made better choices and thus led a life of better value? How do we define this whole ‘value’ thing in the myriad nuances of that word I’m using? But it also has practical ramifications. At the very least you don’t want to go broke, or have buyer’s remorse, or in general get a bad deal. Enough’s Enough? And then there is the question, if resources are scarce and technology or innovation is about reducing the scarcity of resources by means of improved production (my whole TecC series since early 2025 is dedicated to exploring this), assuming we do increase the availability of a certain resource: how much is enough? This is a thorny question, because, human needs and wants are infinite - as soon as a previous, projected yardstick of ‘enough’ is met, our wants expand, we want more. So in fact this is not just a puzzle in the physical realm, but also a bit of a quandary in the psychological. Consider for example, the phenomenon of artificial scarcity, taking as an example diamonds. Sidestepping the question of what diamonds are actually worth or why they tend to become best friends with some of us, are they even scarce in the first place? Given diamond is just carbon, if we devise a laboratory method of crafting the perfect diamond completely indistinguishable from the ‘real thing’ how would the dynamics shift? (Also, maybe they already have done lab stuff, don’t quote me on this, this is just a thought experiment.) Still, and leaving the glitter aside, while not perfect, economics is humanity’s best known attempt to handle the specter of scarcity. Given the pace of technological progress, there is a chance that many more…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: The Core Foundations of Trade
· 6 min
This series is already ten articles old! I’ve covered some of the most fundamental concepts so far, some that might have seen too basic to bother. But hopefully I’ve shed some new light. Let’s take stock and consolidate. A Decimilestone We started with the very question of money itself, because the popular perception of it in some quarters can be somewhat blurred; we saw that it can be similar with the market, price, but especially profit and capital - its general use has diverged from the conceptual reality to the point of making for confusion or even conflict. We then considered aspects such as risk, the time value of money, interest, debt and opportunity cost - many of these may seem outside the scope of a series on money but fundamentally speaking they are not. Taken together, this set is intended to serve as the first layer of an introduction to economics and finance, hence, as you may have guessed, the series ref ‘EcFin’. Let’s now briefly look at one last concept that ties this all together. Taking Stock in Trade Yes - trade! Again, like some of the other topics one could say, what? I know what trade is! But again, let’s peel the surface. Of course, in its simplest definition trade is the exchange of goods, a practice that started off with the simplest barter between two individuals in the earliest of times. How early?! Here’s the thing, trade is almost entirely a human activity, none of our relatives in the animal kingdom really carry out anything that can be seen as trade in any sustained and deliberate way. All animals still do manage resources, seek profits (see Episode 004 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain)), hoard capital (in different ways as different from the squirrel stashing away nuts to the camel doing it ‘in-house’!). Some of our primate cousins have developed systems of reciprocity and political factionalism, which means they deal with risk and especially debt: you scratch my back today, I’ll scratch yours tomorrow - literally! But not trade as we do it! Alongside a handful of other attributes such as the opposable thumb, highly developed vocal chords, which allows for language, trade is the other primary human trait. Note that this list starts with the more physical ones - the opposable thumb turned out to be rather handy 👍, our hominid ancestors could grip a club and thwart a predator, but increasingly it’s the more advanced intellectual systems that come to define us, or at least distinguish us from the rest of the animal kingdom. Of these, I’ve time and again spoken about language - TecC 15 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-15-imperishable-fame-or-immeasurable-impact-the-ultimate-integration-when-separate-streams-of-progress-combine-and-converge-to-reshape-the-entire-landscape-and-leave-a-lasting-echo) where I first discussed the Proto-Indo-Europeans and the origins of most of the main languages of Eurasia, TecC 28 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-28-de-numero-indorum-novum-nihil-sub-sole) where I got into the roots of our number terms again going back to the PIE-folk, but also others. So let’s pause to appreciate the other one. A Fine and Worthy Trade-on To be able to trade requires developing mindsets and institutions, first and foremost trust, as we all know only too well, whether in the positive or in the negative. We need disciplines such as delayed gratification. On top of the bottom-up emergence of trade, as we saw in the market episode, we also need other institutions around it to ensure fair play (whatever our notions of that may be.) In sum, and combining the two human traits I’ve just mentioned, economics is simply an extension or formalization of our language, our ideas, our practices. And of course, as this field has developed over the thousands of years it has, this technical language has become rather jargon-heavy to the casual outsider, and contributes to the dismal image of economics as a social…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: What is Opportunity Cost?
· 6 min
Yes, opportunity cost is indeed one of those strange things, it sounds like one of those classic terms in economics one would prepare to explain in a job interview or one would hear from one of those experts in a panel making a strokey-beard pronouncement. But it’s more relevant to you and me than we might think. Let’s imagine a few situations in life: you’ve got a job offer (maybe you did blurt out a good explanation in that interview after all!), maybe you’re deciding whether to buy that house we touched upon last time, or even something rather simpler - like are we eating out or staying in tonight. The Untold Tolls When it comes to making many such decisions, Opportunity Cost is simply the value of the best alternative you did not choose. It’s the ‘cost’ of the ‘second best’ opportunity -- if we assume the best choice was made. This arises, or is seen as a ‘cost’, because you chose to forego something, it’s a ‘loss’, a potential benefit you did not enjoy. The decision path was constrained by the fact that the alternatives were mutually exclusive which is because of limits on the resources and reality: you can’t both accept this full-time job offer and that one, you can’t both stay in and eat out at the same time... And given economics concerns itself with best managing limited resources, this is a central theme in the field, the objective being analysing the quality of decisions, and ultimately that of resource management. But, as I hinted, this pervades every area of our lives. The Thousand Roads not Taken It indeed does, even outside the realm of formal and conscious application of economic theory, because quite simply almost anything we do is a bunch of decisions each of which we may choose one way or the other. Every yes is a thousand nos, every path taken is a thousand not taken. (Not precisely a thousand but you get the idea.) So while this might seem like it has nothing to do with money, given the centrality of this concept in economics, or if you prefer here: ‘lifestyle optimization and results maximization’, being able to assess or quantify this ‘cost’ can be valuable. And even more simply, just being aware of this whole idea can take us towards making better, more informed decisions. In fact we have seen opportunity cost earlier in this very series, just not so named. Remember in Episode 007 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin007-the-story-of-money-time-and-its-relationship-with-money) Bryan hesitating to lend out Steve his 100 silver coins because he had his own plans of deploying it usefully, with the idea becoming palatable only after the arrangement involved Steve paying an additional 5 silver coins for each month held? The Twin Sisters of Chance and Choice Back in Episode 006 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin006-the-story-of-money-what-is-risk), while discussing chance, we saw the word contingent with regard to all the things in this world that may or may not happen (with the epistemological foundations of the concept laid out in TecC 33C1 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc33c1-the-golden-crescendo-the-very-architect-of-existence)). If contingency is about forces beyond our control, opportunity cost is for things we decide. The paths we take. The thing is, decisions are hard, even simple or silly things like what color socks do I put in this morning... decisions are a cognitive load. (Our word ‘decide/decision’, similar to ‘incision’ and ‘precision’, comes from the Latin dē + cid-, literally “to cut off”) Furthermore, if decisions are hard enough, the later regret of what turned out to be a bad decision can be even more painful. (There’s some interesting research on how offering more choices on a menu led to increased stress levels among customers.) Across human history much effort has been expended on offloading decision-making: to the planets, to the birds, to dice. (I’ve discussed the rationale of this in TecC 24…
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: Understanding the Intricacies of Debt
· 6 min
In the previous episode we discussed the concept of interest, the price of lending money, I also made this huge claim that much of the modern economic engine and elements of our prosperity hinges on the core concept. Let me add some flesh to the bones, getting into a very closely related concept: debt. I don’t think it’s even necessary for me to give a formal definition for the concept of ‘debt’, we sort of know it instinctively, certainly I may safely assume, more so than say ‘interest rates’ or ‘capital expenditure’. Going back to the fictional story of the previous episode, when Bryan lent Steve 100 silver coins, or conversely when Steve borrowed that sum from Bryan, Steve went into debt (formally he became a debtor and Bryan the creditor, but I’ll come to the nuances of credit itself another time.) (A quick note, at this stage of the series I want to focus mainly on the conceptual aspects of each topic coming back to a greater focus on the socio-political and similar elements later. But debt is one of those things where this seems harder to ensure.) So let’s touch briefly on the psychological and social dynamic that our fictional friends are in having gotten into the arrangement in the previous episode. (And yes, it’ll help to read that story once at this point.) Steve now obviously carries the ‘burden of debt’. Brenda and Irene, who suggested that the lending/borrowing take place might also have a sense of responsibility, what if Steve doesn’t pay back, or soon enough. And of course, Bryan is the most emotionally invested in the outcome, because it’s his money after all! As You Owe so Shall You Let’s now take a brief look at how the notion of debt and its connotations are deeply ingrained in the language we use. The German word for ‘debt’ is ‘Schuld’ -- which is cognate with English ‘shall/should’, but guess what, that word also means “fault”, “blame” and “guilt”! Also consider ‘owe’ and ‘ought’, but again note that ‘owe’ is also connected with ‘own’, what does that say? Or the Latin word ‘dēbitum’, the source of our word, is connected to ‘dēbilis’, “weak” as in debility. But despite all these sombre connotations, debt has a significant economic utility. Connecting the Debts In Episode 005 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin005-the-story-of-money-is-capital-just-money) we discussed one of the most fundamental ideas in economics - resource management, which normally goes under the name of ‘capitalism’, and then in Episode 006 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin006-the-story-of-money-what-is-risk) we looked at risk management. These last 3 episodes in summary build up to this one in a fundamental way. Because all productive activity in human society involves the question of resource and risk management, both of which use money as a unit of measure and thus as a core enabling instrument in all such management. And this is where debt comes in, because, as I’ve said in the previous piece, at any time there’s someone with a deficit of money (ultimately the resources/capital they need) and someone else has a surplus of it, and it helps that it can be transferred, temporarily, from one party to the other, to enable productive activity. This is what I was referring to when I concluded my previous piece with my claim, linking such activity to much of modern prosperity. Home Truths Let’s take an example closer to home, or rather at home! Most of us do not earn enough to be able to walk up to a Building Society, dump a suitcase of cash (or equivalent) and walk out with a brand new house in your name. (I know we all wish we could but a more viable option perhaps is building castles in the air!) It thus goes without saying that, whether we like it or not, without debt, we wouldn’t stand a chance of looking like that happy couple on the mortgage billboards all smiling next to a shiny new house keys in hand. I’m not trivializing the matter though, but I hope we are now at least a bit closer to answering the…
Not rated yetTecC 49 - Foreseeing New Frontiers, Integrating Novel Instruments, Creating Unprecedented Value
· 16 min
What if I told you of the grandson of a peasant writing a letter in 1500s Europe to the most powerful man in the continent if not the world, Emperor of the Holy Roman Empire (modern-day Germany and a bit more), King of Spain and thus of the vast Spanish dominions in the Americas, Archduke of Austria, Lord of the Netherlands and some small change, of this son of a weaver writing this letter to the Emperor telling him you wouldn’t be emperor without me, so now better pay up the debts you owe me?! This is the story we’ll be following today, as part of the advent of the Early Modern Era, of the shift from power coming from land, bloodlines and armies to commerce, business, and banking. But this is still also a story of technology, so let’s apply our technocentric view to dig out the innovations and achievements, which happen to be relevant to us to this day. Read full article here. (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc49-foreseeing-new-frontiers-integrating-novel-instruments-creating-unprecedented-value) Article written by Ash Stuart Images, voice narration and some footnotes generated by AI Further Reading & Reference * Hunt, Edwin S.. (1994). The Medieval Super-Companies: A Study of the Peruzzi Company of Florence. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-89415-9. * de Roover, Raymond. (1966). The Rise and Decline of the Medici Bank, 1397-1494. W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 978-0-393-00350-5. * Parks, Tim. (2005). Medici Money: Banking, Metaphysics, and Art in Fifteenth-Century Florence. W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 978-0-393-05827-7. * Steinmetz, Greg. (2016). The Richest Man Who Ever Lived: The Life and Times of Jacob Fugger. Simon & Schuster. ISBN 978-1-451-68856-6. * Häberlein, Mark. (2012). The Fuggers of Augsburg: Pursuing Wealth and Honor in Renaissance Germany. University of Virginia Press. ISBN 978-0-813-93244-6. * Strieder, Jacob. (2001). Jacob Fugger the Rich: Merchant and Banker of Augsburg, 1459-1525. Beard Books. ISBN 978-1-587-98109-8. * Morris, Charles R.. (2006). The Tycoons: How Andrew Carnegie, John D. Rockefeller, Jay Gould, and J.P. Morgan Invented the American Supereconomy. Henry Holt and Co.. ISBN 978-0-805-08134-3. * Josephson, Matthew. (1934). The Robber Barons: The Great American Capitalists, 1861-1901. Harcourt, Brace and Company. ISBN 978-0-156-76790-3. * Isaacson, Walter. (2014). The Innovators: How a Group of Hackers, Geniuses, and Geeks Created the Digital Revolution. Simon & Schuster. ISBN 978-1-476-70870-6. * Isaacson, Walter. (2011). Steve Jobs. Simon & Schuster. ISBN 978-1-451-64853-9. * Wallace, James; Erickson. (1992). Hard Drive: Bill Gates and the Making of the Microsoft Empire. Wiley. ISBN 978-0-471-56886-5. * Frenkel, Sheera; Kang. (2021). An Ugly Truth: Inside Facebook’s Battle for Domination. Harper. ISBN 978-0-062-96067-2. * Wynn-Williams, Sarah. (2025). Careless People: A Cautionary Tale of Power, Greed, and Lost Idealism. Flatiron Books. ISBN 978-1-250-39123-0. * Soni, Jimmy. (2022). The Founders: The Story of PayPal and the Entrepreneurs Who Shaped Silicon Valley. Simon & Schuster. ISBN 9781501197260. * Vlismas, Michael. (2022). Elon Musk: Risking It All. Jonathan Ball. ISBN 9781776191857. * Berger, Eric. (2021). Liftoff: Elon Musk and the Desperate Early Days That Launched SpaceX. William Morrow. ISBN 9780062979971. * Vance, Ashlee. (2015). Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future. Ecco / HarperCollins. ISBN 9780062301253. * Isaacson, Walter. (2023). Elon Musk. Simon & Schuster. ISBN 9781982181284. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit ashstuart.substack.com (https://ashstuart.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: Time and its Relationship with Money
· 7 min
Last time we saw how the seemingly simple concept of ‘risk’ can have profound consequences in the story of money and our life in general. This time let’s explore another underrated idea in relation to money: time. Previously on fictional TV, we had our friend Steve in dire straits struggling with a disastrous harvest, unlike Bryan’s bumper one. This time however, they’ve both had a great harvest, in fact Steve’s has been so great that he has not enough room to store his surplus produce. He’s in pressing need to build a new barn, so as to make the best of it, but he has no money to get any of this going. Steve and Bryan are sat there with Brenda and Irene looking on as this issue surfaces. Eventually Brenda is like, well Bryan, why don’t you lend Steve a 100 silver coins, he’ll give them back to you once he’s able to manage the storage and sell some of the produce. Bryan’s reaction is instant: wait, what? No, I’ve had plans to build a well etc, I could use that money myself! Brenda tries to coax him, why don’t you do it in a few months time, once you get the 100 coins back from Steve... but Bryan’s like, but why should I have to wait for months for something I could do now and benefit from... And Irene then steps in, look, Bryan, you can take the temporary hit of not using your money and help Steve out, and in return, Steve will pay you back not the exact same money but an extra 5 coins on the hundred for every month he keeps the money. Brenda is like, yeah that makes sense, that additional payback compensates Bryan for his temporary sacrifice, but also means Steve will be keen to give all the money back asap. Are you both interested? Sins Time Immemorial An arrangement of this kind may seem logical and sensible to most of us, but the funny thing is for much of pre-modern times and in many of the great religious traditions, such a practice - of charging money for money - was seen either as illegal or even downright sinful. A great many of the leading religious figures and philosophers spoke out squarely against this idea, including Moses, Aristotle and the Buddha. I’m of course referring to the specific concept of charging interest on money lent, with the older term being usury. Our modern concept of interest is certainly not alien to us, who doesn’t expect to get some interest paid out, however paltry, on the money we put in a savings account left there to be used later on? What was the bloody fuss about? Let’s take a brief look. The Other Side of the Coin Let’s take Aristotle, for example, who has found a good few mentions in my TecC series, but let’s say it’s because he had opinions on everything! (Wonder what he thought about iPhones and Quantum Physics, okay sorry..) But practically also because a great many people heeded his opinions, from the Islamic scholars to the European scholastics of medieval Christendom. In this context, I have dealt with the topic of usury in rather more detail, including how Early-Modern bankers in Italy circumvented it in some juicy detail in TecC 49 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc49-foreseeing-new-frontiers-integrating-novel-instruments-creating-unprecedented-value), but here’s the gist of it: Aristotle opined that money, such as a bag of coins, did not reproduce itself over time (say unlike, you guessed it, cattle!), and so it would be wrong to charge any money for its lending. So, said Aristotle, money is sterile. And Thomas Aquinas, the influential medieval scholastic, who with help from the Islamic Scholars -- see TecC 33C1 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc33c1-the-golden-crescendo-the-very-architect-of-existence) for example, keen to reconcile Aristotle with Christianity, took the concept even further, embedding it into the Catholic Church’s moral framework. But here’s the thing: money in the form of cash or coins can be resourcefully used by either you or me, and as we saw in the above story, if Steve needs it more than Bryan, surely he must pay a price for it?…
Not rated yetTecC 48 - Seeking Symmetry, Finding Balance, Making Harmony
· 18 min
In writing about the march of innovation and progress from my first-principles multi-disciplinary perspective, I’ve often sought to connect seemingly mundane developments with much bigger even universal concepts. Today I’m going to, in that vein, connect something with the very concept of the law of conservation, something very fundamental to resource management. And despite my use of ‘mundane’ in the previous sentence, this phenomenon I’m talking about underpins the emergence of the modern world and the material prosperity most of us enjoy. Read original article here. (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc48-seeking-symmetry-finding-balance-making-harmony) Article written by Ash Stuart Images, voice narration and some footnotes generated by AI This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit ashstuart.substack.com (https://ashstuart.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: What is Risk?
· 7 min
We all have a sense of what risk is, alongside our notions of whether it’s good or bad, and how to deal with it. We’ve also seen the intersection of risk and money, but let’s dig a bit deeper, for risk and money dance a strange dance together. First let’s meet our fictional friends as per usual. There’s breaking news all over town - someone from a neighboring land has devised a new type of hybrid grain seed which is said to yield a much better crop - quicker and with less effort needed. Steve and Bryan are chatting about it, but of course it’s a risk. While they’re both enthusiastic -- and that merchant from the neighboring land is offering an initial seed batch for a big discount. They’re both keen to try it out, because what if it’s really true. And as they’re chatting, with Brenda and Irene listening in, Steve is like, well Bryan, you had a great harvest last season, but mine was a disaster, the weather gods weren’t so kind to the particular crop I was growing. Irene chips in, yes, it’s a dilemma, you can’t stick to that crop given that disaster, but can you safely try out the new one instead? There’s a long pause. And then Brenda is like, listen, Bryan has a good stock of grain from the previous harvest. Why don’t you both go ahead with trying out the new grain, but if the harvest fails, so Bryan say you commit to helping Steve out with 10 sacks of grain from your store should it fail. Bryan’s like, wait, just like that? Irene replies, no no, let’s say Steve hands over 3 of his cows for Bryan to hold on to until harvest time. Bruno the dog and Iris the cat looking up in disdain as if going, pah we both do such stuff all the time with our bones and mice! The Wings of Chance Right ok, these days, most of us may not have harvests and cows to worry about ourselves, but it’s safe to say that we’ve gone through such emotions and dilemmas in our day-to-day decision making. But as I said, let’s dig deeper. Back in TecC 33C1 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc33c1-the-golden-crescendo-the-very-architect-of-existence) I discussed some of the very fundamental questions of life, in particular around being and becoming and how philosophers have grappled with these questions over centuries. On the question of being, specifically, there is a word we used: ‘contingent’. We don’t tend to use that word often, but here’s the thing: everything that happens is contingent, in other words, it may or may not happen. It depends on a myriad other prior events to go one way or the other. (a modern treatment of this of course is the butterfly effect.) So we may say, outside of controlled setups, pretty much everything is largely unpredictable. So here’s a simple definition of risk: the chance that something might not turn out as we desire. This applies both to natural phenomena but especially to outcomes that proceed from decisions we have made. At the Crossroads So yes, some of us may have this notion that risk is ‘bad’, we may chide someone for taking risks. But, like I said, it’s not about good or bad, but about undesirable, because every single act of ours, is a decision -- you cross the street here or further there -- and thus carries risk, however big or small. (Imagine for a moment a Greek god, let’s say named ‘Rhyskos’, up there, Stinging, I mean singing: every breath you take, every move you make... I’ll be watching you..) But, while we cannot eliminate risk, we can manage it, in particular we can transfer risk, because as we saw in the fictional story, different people have different risk appetites. It may not be simply because of one’s circumstances as in that case, but it could be one’s own nature, some people are more willing to take risks, which to others might seem reckless. And then there is the whole thing about ‘high risk high reward’. Some of us are willing to take more risks because we want a bigger reward: call it ambitious or greedy, but it’s human nature. Show me the Money! I’ve come this far and haven’t…
Not rated yetTecC 47 - Giving Ideas Shape: Crystallizing Inventiveness
· 14 min
The last four episodes released have served as a mini-series, or a tetralogy, deviating chronologically to lay the foundation for some important aspects of earlier innovation still of relevance to us. Let’s now come back to the current point in our story - the 1400s. Read full article. (http://tecc47-giving-ideas-shape-crystallizing-inventiveness) Article written by Ash Stuart Images, voice narration and some footnotes generated by AI Further Reading & Reference - Lane, Frederic C.. (1973). Venice: A Maritime Republic. Johns Hopkins University Press. - Molà, Luca. (2000). The Silk Industry of Renaissance Venice. Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN 978-0-8018-6189-5. - Long, Pamela O.. (2001). Openness, Secrecy, Authorship: Technical Arts and the Culture of Knowledge from Antiquity to the Renaissance. Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN 0-8018-6606-5. - Berveglieri, Roberto. (1995). Inventori stranieri a Venezia, 1474-1788: Importazione di tecnologia e circolazione di tecnici artigiani inventori. Repertorio. Istituto Veneto di Scienze, Lettere ed Arti. - Berveglieri, Roberto. (2021). Ingegnosi artificij. Serenissima Repubblica di Venezia: Trecento anni di storia della scienza, della tecnica e dell'innovazione (1474-1788). Volume 1. Cierre Edizioni. - Madden, Thomas F.. (2012). Venice: A New History. Viking. ISBN 978-0-670-02542-8. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit ashstuart.substack.com (https://ashstuart.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
Not rated yetThe Story of Money: Is Capital just Money?
· 6 min
So far, in a series about money, I’ve never once mentioned the c-word. More than the terms ‘money’ or ‘profit’, ‘capital’ is perhaps the most loaded one in the field. But let’s look at what capital really is. Now for an extremely brief fictional detour. In fact you get to hear the full story when TecC 48 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc48-seeking-symmetry-finding-balance-making-harmony) goes live, where these ideas are dealt with in some more depth. But the gist of it is that Steve, Bryan, Brenda and Irene are making great strides in their business, rearing livestock and selling them on the big market day every month. The problem is, how to keep count of things, because the sales, and the stock, are growing. As you’ll see in that episode, they decide to take stock by counting the heads of the cows they own. Now that might seem weird, but keep that in your head, for it’ll very soon make sense. Getting a Head Start Let’s first go back in time, 5000 years no less, to the Proto-Indo-Europeans who we met in TecC 15 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-15-imperishable-fame-or-immeasurable-impact-the-ultimate-integration-when-separate-streams-of-progress-combine-and-converge-to-reshape-the-entire-landscape-and-leave-a-lasting-echo), and occasionally after. We saw in that episode that what distinguished them -- who at that time inhabited the Pontic-Caspian Steppe, and were soon to spread their genes, culture and especially language across a vast expanse of Eurasia, from Ireland and Britain on the one end to Persia and India on the other -- from other groups they encountered, was their extensive domestication and utilization of livestock - cows in particular, as I’ve described in detail there. Let’s consider their word péḱu meaning “livestock”, which is seen in many descendant languages, but I’ll mention three. In Sanskrit, it became páśu with the same meaning. In Latin it became pecu, whence our words such as ‘pecuniary’ and ‘impecunious’. And, in Proto-Germanic, it became fehu, whence the modern English word ‘fee’! So it’s not hard to see the, well, pecuniary, or monetary connotations of livestock. And by now you can see that our fictional story was in fact not entirely fictional: the ancient habit of counting cow heads led to the Latin word form for ‘head’ being applied to the concept: capital (similar to ‘per capita’), and that’s it! Let’s say it out loud: that’s capital! Full marks for getting it right! (Not you, Groucho!) In fact, the words ‘cattle’ and ‘chattel’ are evolved forms of the same word ‘capital’! But now that we’ve milked the etymological cash cow to the max, let’s move on. Capital Gains But I trust that backstory still illuminates something: that capital is more than just money, in fact, if you think back to Episode 001 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin001-the-story-of-money-what-is-money-anyways), we can even say money is not capital. It would be inaccurate to conflate ‘capital’ with just ‘cash’. Fundamentally, it refers to resources, and specifically, in our context, the resources we put to work to, as we saw in Episode 004 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain), create value. And that’s what drives the entire engine of the economy, from the simple act, as we saw last time, of making an edible meal from raw ingredients to the most complex industrial process. While some might say we’re splitting hairs here, this distinction and its clarification are important. Taken together with the other concepts we’ve covered so far, such as ‘money’ ie currency, a measure of value, the market, the pricing mechanism and value creation (and its measure, ie, profit), this I hope should sharpen our understanding of how the economic engine works. And this reframing is also crucial for other concepts I’ll be covering in this series, which will be building on top of this (even complex ones, we’ll grab the bull by the horns!), so, again, do keep this in…
Not rated yetTecC 36B2 - Melting Mind's Molds: The New Clear Option
· 15 min
This is the fourth of a thread in our study of the understanding how knowledge itself works. We started with the very questions of reality and how we can know anything. We explored the fight between competing approaches to addressing these fundamental questions. And we saw what progress was made or attempted in this direction. We now come to the turning point in this story, a radical pivot, a watershed. Read full article here (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc36b2-melting-minds-molds-the-new-clear-option) Article written by Ash Stuart Images, voice narration and some footnotes generated by AI This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit ashstuart.substack.com (https://ashstuart.substack.com?utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=CTA_1)
Not rated yet