The Story of Money: Understanding Specialization
From Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · · 7 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
In fact, I’ve previously written about specialization, in the context of exploring how innovation accelerated at a crucial historical juncture - TecC 43 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc43-making-work-art-making-art-work-engineering-excellence). However, let’s look at this from the perspective of our story here.
And indeed, apart from the historical angle, I do have a fictional depiction around how this arose, in that episode. But, fiction and history apart, let’s now focus on the core concept itself, in other words, let’s specialize!
In Episode 010 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin010-the-story-of-money-the-core-foundations-of-trade) we touched upon the specific concept of trade. Whilst in the smallest isolated communities, every member would have bothered with every aspect of making things they need, from trade, ie the ability to get certain items from someone else in exchange for what you have or can make, it naturally proceeds that different individuals could focus on making the different things they need.
This proffers a few striking advantages to the group as a whole. Different individuals have different propensities, so they might be inclined to do, or learn to do, one type of work better than another. It has been shown that broadly it’s easier to focus on a few things than to keep switching tasks all the time: code-switching is hard, it’s a cognitive load (just imagine ejecting and inserting separate CDs into your working personal computer every few minutes!)
Furthermore, there is a limit to how many skills single person can master - the classic jack of all, master of none, stuff. As communities get larger therefore, with their needs growing, it becomes quite compelling for such division to emerge or be enforced.
Divide et Coopera
The classic explanation of this phenomenon, division of labor is of course that by the economist Adam Smith in the late 1700s. But let’s take a look at a more recent example or argument of this at play.
There is this question, should a very highly skilled professional, say a brain surgeon, wash one’s own car before heading to work in the morning? The answer economists (and the Association of Car-washers) would give is, no, they should hire someone to do the job for them!
If we think about this, especially having considered opportunity cost in Episode 009 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin009-the-story-of-money-what-is-opportunity-cost), the brain surgeon would utilize one’s time and exertions to far better outcomes in the operating theater than outside the house. The car-washing can be done by someone with far less training and expertise than the brain surgeon: your time has a market value, act accordingly! (Of course, if our professional expert finds the car-washing act itself therapeutic there can be a carveout made here, but how about we relegate that to Saturdays...)
Twixt Skills and Wills
So yes, in a nutshell that’s what specialization is about, a concept we are so used to in the modern day, that one may be justified to ask, what’s the big deal?
Allowing different members of a group to focus on different areas of work, whether it’s in a small village or a big industrial setup, allows them to, by way of gaining experience in that area, become much more skilled at it. Again something we take for granted. But this helps significantly increase the overall quality of output, and when combined with innovation as I’ve demonstrated in the quoted piece, even build much better, far superior, more ambitious things.
Therefore specialization is an accelerant of value creation, Episode 004 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain). However, there are a few problems with specialization, and we cannot ignore them.
Most obviously, specialization leads to interdependence, which is generally seen as a good thing, but it relies on the larger system of trade and cooperation to continue to function. And then, the inability or…
Back to Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · Report a problem