The Story of Money: Is Capital just Money?
From Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · · 6 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
So far, in a series about money, I’ve never once mentioned the c-word. More than the terms ‘money’ or ‘profit’, ‘capital’ is perhaps the most loaded one in the field. But let’s look at what capital really is.
Now for an extremely brief fictional detour. In fact you get to hear the full story when TecC 48 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc48-seeking-symmetry-finding-balance-making-harmony) goes live, where these ideas are dealt with in some more depth.
But the gist of it is that Steve, Bryan, Brenda and Irene are making great strides in their business, rearing livestock and selling them on the big market day every month. The problem is, how to keep count of things, because the sales, and the stock, are growing. As you’ll see in that episode, they decide to take stock by counting the heads of the cows they own. Now that might seem weird, but keep that in your head, for it’ll very soon make sense.
Getting a Head Start
Let’s first go back in time, 5000 years no less, to the Proto-Indo-Europeans who we met in TecC 15 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc-15-imperishable-fame-or-immeasurable-impact-the-ultimate-integration-when-separate-streams-of-progress-combine-and-converge-to-reshape-the-entire-landscape-and-leave-a-lasting-echo), and occasionally after. We saw in that episode that what distinguished them -- who at that time inhabited the Pontic-Caspian Steppe, and were soon to spread their genes, culture and especially language across a vast expanse of Eurasia, from Ireland and Britain on the one end to Persia and India on the other -- from other groups they encountered, was their extensive domestication and utilization of livestock - cows in particular, as I’ve described in detail there.
Let’s consider their word péḱu meaning “livestock”, which is seen in many descendant languages, but I’ll mention three. In Sanskrit, it became páśu with the same meaning. In Latin it became pecu, whence our words such as ‘pecuniary’ and ‘impecunious’. And, in Proto-Germanic, it became fehu, whence the modern English word ‘fee’!
So it’s not hard to see the, well, pecuniary, or monetary connotations of livestock. And by now you can see that our fictional story was in fact not entirely fictional: the ancient habit of counting cow heads led to the Latin word form for ‘head’ being applied to the concept: capital (similar to ‘per capita’), and that’s it! Let’s say it out loud: that’s capital! Full marks for getting it right! (Not you, Groucho!)
In fact, the words ‘cattle’ and ‘chattel’ are evolved forms of the same word ‘capital’! But now that we’ve milked the etymological cash cow to the max, let’s move on.
Capital Gains
But I trust that backstory still illuminates something: that capital is more than just money, in fact, if you think back to Episode 001 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin001-the-story-of-money-what-is-money-anyways), we can even say money is not capital. It would be inaccurate to conflate ‘capital’ with just ‘cash’.
Fundamentally, it refers to resources, and specifically, in our context, the resources we put to work to, as we saw in Episode 004 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/ecfin004-the-story-of-money-on-the-worth-of-value-and-gain), create value. And that’s what drives the entire engine of the economy, from the simple act, as we saw last time, of making an edible meal from raw ingredients to the most complex industrial process.
While some might say we’re splitting hairs here, this distinction and its clarification are important. Taken together with the other concepts we’ve covered so far, such as ‘money’ ie currency, a measure of value, the market, the pricing mechanism and value creation (and its measure, ie, profit), this I hope should sharpen our understanding of how the economic engine works.
And this reframing is also crucial for other concepts I’ll be covering in this series, which will be building on top of this (even complex ones, we’ll grab the bull by the horns!), so, again, do keep this in…
Back to Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · Report a problem