The Story of Money: Time and its Relationship with Money
From Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · · 7 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
Last time we saw how the seemingly simple concept of ‘risk’ can have profound consequences in the story of money and our life in general. This time let’s explore another underrated idea in relation to money: time.
Previously on fictional TV, we had our friend Steve in dire straits struggling with a disastrous harvest, unlike Bryan’s bumper one. This time however, they’ve both had a great harvest, in fact Steve’s has been so great that he has not enough room to store his surplus produce. He’s in pressing need to build a new barn, so as to make the best of it, but he has no money to get any of this going.
Steve and Bryan are sat there with Brenda and Irene looking on as this issue surfaces. Eventually Brenda is like, well Bryan, why don’t you lend Steve a 100 silver coins, he’ll give them back to you once he’s able to manage the storage and sell some of the produce.
Bryan’s reaction is instant: wait, what? No, I’ve had plans to build a well etc, I could use that money myself! Brenda tries to coax him, why don’t you do it in a few months time, once you get the 100 coins back from Steve... but Bryan’s like, but why should I have to wait for months for something I could do now and benefit from...
And Irene then steps in, look, Bryan, you can take the temporary hit of not using your money and help Steve out, and in return, Steve will pay you back not the exact same money but an extra 5 coins on the hundred for every month he keeps the money. Brenda is like, yeah that makes sense, that additional payback compensates Bryan for his temporary sacrifice, but also means Steve will be keen to give all the money back asap. Are you both interested?
Sins Time Immemorial
An arrangement of this kind may seem logical and sensible to most of us, but the funny thing is for much of pre-modern times and in many of the great religious traditions, such a practice - of charging money for money - was seen either as illegal or even downright sinful. A great many of the leading religious figures and philosophers spoke out squarely against this idea, including Moses, Aristotle and the Buddha.
I’m of course referring to the specific concept of charging interest on money lent, with the older term being usury. Our modern concept of interest is certainly not alien to us, who doesn’t expect to get some interest paid out, however paltry, on the money we put in a savings account left there to be used later on? What was the bloody fuss about? Let’s take a brief look.
The Other Side of the Coin
Let’s take Aristotle, for example, who has found a good few mentions in my TecC series, but let’s say it’s because he had opinions on everything! (Wonder what he thought about iPhones and Quantum Physics, okay sorry..) But practically also because a great many people heeded his opinions, from the Islamic scholars to the European scholastics of medieval Christendom.
In this context, I have dealt with the topic of usury in rather more detail, including how Early-Modern bankers in Italy circumvented it in some juicy detail in TecC 49 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc49-foreseeing-new-frontiers-integrating-novel-instruments-creating-unprecedented-value), but here’s the gist of it: Aristotle opined that money, such as a bag of coins, did not reproduce itself over time (say unlike, you guessed it, cattle!), and so it would be wrong to charge any money for its lending. So, said Aristotle, money is sterile.
And Thomas Aquinas, the influential medieval scholastic, who with help from the Islamic Scholars -- see TecC 33C1 (https://ashstuart.substack.com/p/tecc33c1-the-golden-crescendo-the-very-architect-of-existence) for example, keen to reconcile Aristotle with Christianity, took the concept even further, embedding it into the Catholic Church’s moral framework.
But here’s the thing: money in the form of cash or coins can be resourcefully used by either you or me, and as we saw in the above story, if Steve needs it more than Bryan, surely he must pay a price for it?…
Back to Vīta Brevis, Wit Artefāctōrum Ætērna Podcast · Report a problem