
Mugshot Mysteries
Kathryn and GabrielAudio
- Format:
- Podcast
- New episodes:
- Weekly
- Typical length:
- about 45 minutes
- Latest episode:
About this show
Some stories are solved. Most aren’t. The interesting ones refuse to stay buried.
Mugshot Mysteries is a deep-dive podcast hosted by Kathryn and Gabriel, exploring true crime, conspiracies, paranormal encounters, cults, historical disasters, government cover-ups, and the stories that keep people awake long after the episode ends.
Every episode blends immersive storytelling, psychological analysis, dark humor, and the kind of rabbit holes that make you question whether history is telling the full truth.
One week it’s serial killers. The next it’s MKUltra, haunted hospitals, vanished ships, UFO encounters, or deaths that still don’t make sense decades later.
Kathryn brings the research. Gabriel brings the questions, the theories, and occasionally a comment so out of pocket it completely derails the conversation.
Expect deep dives, unexpected tangents, and at least one moment where Kathryn has to stop and say, “Wow. Wow wow wow.”
If it’s disturbing, unexplained, historically strange, or impossible to forget… it belongs in the lineup.
New episodes every week.
Covers: true crime, unsolved mysteries, paranormal, conspiracy theories, historical crime, serial killers, government cover-ups, cults
Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at rss.buzzsprout.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.
Recently on this show
Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.
Mugshot Mysteries is a podcast from Kathryn and Gabriel covering true crime, conspiracies, paranormal stories, cults and historical disasters. Recent episodes look at the Unabomber, the Bell Witch, the Angel Makers of Hungary, and Lizzie Borden.
Cosmos
Similar in subject
- Up at Night
Both cover: cults, unsolved mysteries, serial killers - Para(normal)
Both cover: historical crime, cults, conspiracy theories - The Secret Society of Strangers
Both cover: historical crime, cults, unsolved mysteries
Similar shows
Explore more
Episodes
The Flannan Isles Lighthouse: Three Men Vanished Into Thin Air (1900)
· 44 min
December 26, 1900. A relief ship reaches a lighthouse on a remote rock twenty miles off the Scottish coast and finds it dark and silent. The keeper who climbs the 160 steps finds a stopped clock, a lamp prepped but never lit, and two of three coats gone from their hooks. Three experienced lighthouse keepers, James Ducat, Thomas Marshall, and Donald MacArthur, have vanished without a trace. No bodies were ever found. One hundred and twenty-four years later, their official cause of death is still a single hedged word: "probably." This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel travel to the Flannan Isles, the cluster of rocks the locals called the Seven Hunters and avoided for centuries, and try to work out what happened on the night the light went out. First the place, because it matters. These are tiny, cliff-walled islands in the Outer Hebrides that shepherds would graze but never sleep on, a spot wrapped in rituals and the legend of a guardian presence that supposedly didn't want outsiders to stay. The lighthouse, built by a cousin of Treasure Island author Robert Louis Stevenson, was lit in 1899, barely a year before everything went wrong. We get into what the job actually did to people: the crushing isolation, and the slow mercury poisoning from the lens mechanism that gave rise to the phrase "mad as a lighthouse keeper." And we tell the genuinely horrifying story of the 1801 Smalls Lighthouse tragedy, the two-keeper disaster with the waving corpse that is the reason British lighthouses later required three men at all times, a rule that, at Flannan, didn't help at all. Then the scene itself. We walk what relief keeper Joseph Moore found, the orderly interior, the one coat left behind meaning a man went out into a December gale without his waterproofs, and the staggering storm damage on the west landing: iron railings bent, a supply track torn from its concrete, and a heavy crate destroyed in a crevice 110 feet above the sea, as high as an eleven-story building. We dig into the official explanation, a rogue wave, and the remarkable fact that science dismissed rogue waves as sailor myth until an oil platform instrument finally measured an 85-foot one in 1995. Superintendent Muirhead's conclusion was that the sea took all three men with "resistless force." But this is Mugshot Mysteries, so we go further into the dark: the psychology of isolation and small-group breakdown, the possibility of a confrontation on the cliffs, shared delusion, and the islanders' own answer, the Phantom of the Seven Hunters, the three black birds said to have risen as Moore arrived, and seventy years of unsettled keepers hearing names called in the wind. We separate the documented record from the mythology along the way, including the famous final log entries that researchers believe were invented years later. And we close, honestly, on two beliefs and no tidy resolution. This is the vanishing at Flannan Isle. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: Northern Lighthouse Board official records, including the report of Superintendent Robert Muirhead and the account of relief keeper Joseph Moore; National Records of Scotland lighthouse-keeper registers, listing the cause of death of James Ducat, Thomas Marshall, and Donald MacArthur as probable drowning; contemporaneous reporting on the December 1900 discovery; Dash, M., investigation for Fortean Times establishing that the dramatic "log entries" attributed to the keepers appear to be a later invention with no basis in the official record; Gibson, W.W., "Flannan Isle," 1912, the poem that added enduring fictional details such as the overturned chair and uneaten meal; historical accounts of the 1801 Smalls Lighthouse tragedy involving Thomas Howell and Thomas Griffith, which led to the three-keeper rule; documentation of rogue waves, including the January 1, 1995, Draupner platform measurement in the North Sea; the lighthouse engineering…
Not rated yetHell's Belle: The Belle Gunness Story — America's Deadliest Female Serial Killer
· 48 min
In 1907, lonely men across the Midwest read a newspaper ad: a comely widow with a fine Indiana farm seeks a gentleman equally well provided, with a view to joining fortunes. Triflers need not apply. At least forty men answered. They packed their bags, withdrew their savings, and traveled to La Porte to meet her. Almost none came home. The woman who wrote that ad was Belle Gunness, and when her farmhouse burned in April 1908, investigators started digging in the hog pen and stopped counting bodies at eleven. But the headless woman found in the cellar was five inches too short and fifty pounds too light to be Belle. This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel cover Belle Gunness, the woman the papers called Hell's Belle and Lady Bluebeard, one of America's first and most prolific female serial killers, and a case that more than a century later is still officially unsolved. We trace her from a poor childhood in Selbu, Norway, to the Norwegian immigrant world of 1880s Chicago, and the trail of convenient fires and insurance payouts that followed her: two confectionery and home fires, two infant children dead of "acute colitis," and a first husband who died on the single day two life-insurance policies overlapped. With the payout she bought a remote pig farm in La Porte, married a second husband who lasted eight months before a heavy sausage grinder supposedly fell off a shelf onto his head, and then turned the whole operation into a business. We walk her lonely-hearts machine: eight to ten letters a day, months of romance by mail, pointed questions about a suitor's savings, and a final invitation to "come prepared to stay forever." Andrew Helgelien sold his farm, brought nearly three thousand dollars in cash, and vanished the day after she walked him to the bank. We dig into the psychology, the real clinical distinctions between psychopathy, sociopathy, and antisocial personality disorder, and why female serial killers statistically kill differently than men, for money rather than power, and quietly, by poison. We cover the jealous farmhand Ray Lamphere, the victim's brother who refused to stop asking questions, and the fire Belle seemed to plan in advance, buying kerosene and writing a will the same day. Then the dig itself, the burlap sacks, the dismembered remains, and the fifteen thousand spectators who turned a mass grave into a carnival. And then the mystery that won't close. The body double theory and Lamphere's deathbed confession that he drove Belle to a train. The pristine gold teeth that seemed too undamaged for the fire. The 1931 arrest of a poisoner named Esther Carlson in Los Angeles who looked startlingly like Belle, and the researcher who found records suggesting Carlson was a different woman entirely, which may be the most unsettling possibility of all. We end on the 2007 exhumation and its inconclusive DNA. This is Belle Gunness, the Black Widow of Indiana. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: Schechter, H., Hell's Princess: The Mystery of Belle Gunness, Butcher of Men, 2018; contemporaneous reporting on the April 1908 fire at the Gunness farm in La Porte, Indiana, and the subsequent discovery of dismembered remains in the hog pen; the 1908 trial of Ray Lamphere, his conviction for arson and acquittal of murder, and his later confessions and death in prison in 1909; records of Belle's marriages to Mads Sorenson and Peter Gunness, the insurance payouts collected after their deaths, and the inquest into Peter Gunness's death; documentation of identified victims including Andrew Helgelien, Ole Budsberg, John Moe, Henry Gurholt, and foster daughter Jennie Olsen, and the account of Andrew's brother Asle Helgelien, whose inquiries prompted the search; reporting on the 1931 arrest of Esther Carlson in Los Angeles for the poisoning of August Lindstrom, and the competing identification claims; the research of Norwegian investigator Knut Erik Jensen…
Not rated yetThe Hinterkaifeck Murders: A Killer Lived in Their Attic — And No One Was Ever Caught
· 53 min
In the spring of 1922, on an isolated Bavarian farmstead, the head of the household notices footprints in the snow leading from the forest straight to his property. None lead back. The family has been hearing footsteps in the attic for months. The maid quit half a year earlier, convinced the house was haunted. A set of house keys has gone missing, and a newspaper no one bought has appeared inside. A neighbor offers to lend a gun. Andreas Gruber declines. Days later, all six people at Hinterkaifeck are dead, killed with the family's own mattock. And then the killer does the thing that has haunted this case for a century: instead of fleeing, they stay. This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel cover the Hinterkaifeck murders, Germany's most infamous unsolved crime, six victims, zero convictions, and someone who was almost certainly living in the attic. We start with the family, because the darkness here begins long before the murders. Andreas Gruber was a controlling patriarch, and he and his widowed daughter Viktoria had been convicted of incest years earlier. The paternity of Viktoria's young son was an open question, hanging between Andreas and a neighbor named Lorenz Schlittenbauer, a dispute tangled up with money and a forbidden relationship. This was a household full of secrets, fear, and enemies. Then the buildup: the haunted-house feeling that drove off the maid, the unexplained footprints, the missing keys, and Viktoria fleeing into the woods the night before the killings, certain someone was watching. We walk the murders themselves as carefully as the subject allows, the victims lured one by one to the barn and found stacked under hay, the toddler and the brand-new maid killed inside the house, no robbery, money left untouched. And then the part that turns a tragedy into a nightmare: for days afterward, neighbors saw smoke from the chimney, the animals were fed, food was eaten, a bed was slept in. Someone made themselves at home with six bodies on the property. A passerby was even blinded by a lantern held up by a figure at the door. Then the investigation, which is a case study in how not to do it: a crime scene trampled by dozens of people, a neighbor who somehow had a key and rearranged the bodies, an autopsy in the barn, and the victims' skulls shipped to Munich so clairvoyants could examine them, later lost in the war. We run the suspects, Schlittenbauer foremost, plus the theory of Viktoria's supposedly dead husband returning from the war, the farmhands whose sister named them on her deathbed, and more. And we cover the 2007 police-academy cold-case review that settled on a prime suspect and then refused to name him, out of respect for living descendants. This is Hinterkaifeck. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: Bavarian state archive records of the Hinterkaifeck investigation, including the case led by Inspector Georg Reingruber and the autopsy findings of court physician Johann Baptist Aumüller identifying a mattock as the murder weapon; contemporaneous accounts of the discovery of the bodies on April 4, 1922, by Lorenz Schlittenbauer and neighbors, and the timeline of the killings on the night of March 31 to April 1, 1922; documented witness statements, including the earlier departure of maid Kreszenz Rieger, the sightings of smoke from the farmhouse in the days after the murders, and the passerby account of Michael Plöckl; the prior incest conviction of Andreas Gruber and Viktoria Gabriel and the disputed paternity of Josef; records of the more than one hundred individuals questioned over the decades, the case's official closure in 1955, and continued interrogations until 1986; the 2007 cold-case review by students at the Fürstenfeldbruck Police Academy, which named a prime suspect privately but declined to publish it out of respect for living descendants; the deathbed statement implicating the Bichler brothers; the theory…
Not rated yetThe Enfield Poltergeist: Britain's Most Haunted House — Real Phenomenon or the Greatest Hoax Ever Told?
· 48 min
August 1977, a council house in Enfield, North London. A single mother is putting her four children to bed when the beds start to shake and knocking comes from inside the walls. She runs to the neighbors, who hear it too. They call the police, and a constable watches a chair slide across the floor on its own and writes it in her official report. Over the next eighteen months, more than thirty witnesses, hundreds of hours of tape, and dozens of all-night vigils will document furniture flying, children apparently levitating, and a guttural old man's voice speaking through an eleven-year-old girl. It became the most documented poltergeist case in history. And almost fifty years later, people still cannot agree whether it was real. This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel knock on the door of 284 Green Street and tell the story of the Enfield Poltergeist, then split hard on what to believe. We start with what a poltergeist even is, the "noisy ghost," and the recurring pattern that these cases center on a child going through emotional turmoil, the so-called focus. Here that was eleven-year-old Janet Hodgson, whose parents had just separated. We walk the escalation night by night: the shuffling and knocking, the heavy chest of drawers that slid across the room, the neighbors and then the police drawn in, and the constable's report that put furniture moving on its own into the official record. Then the investigators arrive, Maurice Grosse and Guy Lyon Playfair of the Society for Psychical Research, who made 180 visits and reported marbles and Lego flying, objects floating, and the now-famous photographs of Janet apparently airborne above her bed. We get into the case's strangest feature: the voice. A deep, raspy voice that claimed to be Bill Wilkins, a man who said he died in that house, and the unsettling detail that a man by that name really had died there in a chair, confirmed later by his son. We cover the experiments, taping Janet's mouth, filling it with water, and the speech analysis suggesting the sound came from her false vocal cords. Then, because we owe it to you, the skeptic's corner: infrasound and its documented links to dread and peripheral hallucinations, electromagnetic fields and the temporal lobe, carbon monoxide, and the power of group suggestion. And we deal honestly with the "confession," the fact that the girls admitted faking some incidents, and why investigators argued that a small percentage of pranks doesn't account for the rest. We end where the evidence leaves us: with the most dramatic incidents, the wrenched-out fireplace grate, the scratches photographed as they formed, the bedclothes torn away, and with two hosts who don't agree. Kathryn lands on honest uncertainty. Gabriel believes. This is the Enfield Poltergeist. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: Playfair, G.L., This House Is Haunted: The True Story of the Enfield Poltergeist, 1980; Willin, M., The Enfield Poltergeist Tapes, 2019; the archives, case recordings, and investigator reports of the Society for Psychical Research, including the work of Maurice Grosse and Guy Lyon Playfair and commentary by committee members such as Mary Rose Barrington; the contemporaneous police account associated with WPC Carolyn Heeps; contemporaneous reporting and photography from the Daily Mirror, including photographer Graham Morris, and BBC coverage; the reported confirmation of details about a former resident of the house by his surviving family; later interviews with Janet Hodgson, 2015 to 2023; the Apple TV+ documentary The Enfield Poltergeist, 2023; the skeptical analysis of psychologist Chris French; Tandy, V., and Lawrence, T.R., "The Ghost in the Machine," Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, 1998, on infrasound; and the temporal-lobe and electromagnetic-field research associated with Michael Persinger. Discussion of carbon monoxide, suggestion, and confirmation bias…
Not rated yetThe Cost of Health: The Luigi Mangione Case - From Ivy League to Death Row - (Pt. 3 of 3)
· 56 min
Note: This episode was released on December 22, 2025. The case has continued to develop since then. In January 2026 a federal judge dismissed the count that had made the case death-penalty eligible, taking capital punishment off the table, and prosecutors declined to appeal. A New York state murder trial and a separate federal trial are scheduled for 2026. Luigi Mangione has pleaded not guilty to all charges and is presumed innocent. On the morning of December 4, 2024, the CEO of the largest health insurance company in America is shot dead on a Midtown Manhattan sidewalk as he walks to his company's investor conference. The killer escapes on an e-bike through Central Park. Police recover shell casings with words etched into the brass, "delay," "deny," "depose," a grim echo of the language used to describe how insurers avoid paying claims. Five days later, a tip at an Altoona, Pennsylvania McDonald's leads to the arrest of a 26-year-old Ivy League engineering graduate from a prominent Maryland family. And then something strange happens: a significant slice of the country treats the accused not as a villain, but as a folk hero. This is the conclusion of The Cost of Health, a Mugshot Mysteries limited series. In Part 3, Kathryn and Gabriel walk through the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, the manhunt, and the still-unfolding prosecution of Luigi Mangione, who has pleaded not guilty. We begin with the victim, a fifty-year-old father of two, and the company he led, whose size and denial practices had made it a lightning rod. Then the investigation as prosecutors have laid it out: the bus from Atlanta, the hostel check-in under a fake ID where a flirtatious clerk's request for a smile produced the photo that would define the manhunt, the alleged reconnaissance, and the minute-by-minute surveillance timeline of the morning itself. We get into the recovered firearm, described in the criminal complaint as a partially 3D-printed "ghost gun" with no serial number, and what investigators say it revealed about the suspect's technical sophistication. We cover the five-day manhunt, the fingerprints on discarded food wrappers, and the McDonald's tip that ended it. Then the harder questions. Who is Luigi Mangione? A prep-school valedictorian and University of Pennsylvania engineering graduate from a well-known real estate family, by his friends' accounts a thoughtful, gifted young man whose life seemed to turn after a debilitating back condition and chronic pain pulled him into isolation. We discuss the writings prosecutors recovered, which we characterize rather than quote: a short document the state calls a manifesto, and a notebook prosecutors describe as a diary showing months of planning and a chillingly cold rationale for the choice of target. We're careful throughout to mark these as the prosecution's allegations, not proven fact. And we lay out where the case stood at the time of recording, a landscape that has since shifted. We close on the part that makes this case a mirror: not whether a killing can be justified, it can't, but what it says about a country where so many people looked at this one and felt something other than horror. This concludes our three-part Cost of Health series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: Court filings and indictments from the Manhattan District Attorney's Office, the New York State Supreme Court, and the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York; the federal criminal complaint describing the recovered firearm and silencer; testimony and rulings from the 2025 and 2026 pretrial and suppression hearings, including Justice Gregory Carro's September 2025 dismissal of the New York terrorism charges, and U.S. District Judge Margaret Garnett's January 2026 dismissal of the federal count that had made the case death-penalty eligible, which removed capital punishment as a possible sentence; reporting that federal…
Not rated yetThe Cost of Health: Delay, Deny, Defend - The Insurance Denials Behind Luigi Mangione (Pt. 2 of 3)
· 44 min
Fourteen point six billion dollars in intended fraud, uncovered in a single 2025 enforcement action, the largest healthcare fraud takedown in Justice Department history. And that's just the criminal kind. While the government chases stolen billions, insurers are legally denying billions more in claims, sometimes with AI tools that families and lawsuits say get it wrong far more often than they get it right. This is the episode where Kathryn and Gabriel map out exactly how the money moves, and how a system ends up both wasteful and stingy at the same time. This is Part 2 of The Price of Care, a three-part Mugshot Mysteries series on American healthcare. Where Part 1 traced the history, this episode digs into the machinery of fraud and denial, and they work hard to keep it evenhanded, giving the legitimate version of each side rather than picking a team. We start with the outright criminals. Operation Gold Rush, an alleged transnational scheme that billed Medicare for more than a billion urinary catheters using the stolen identities of over a million Americans. An Arizona couple with no medical training who, prosecutors say, directed nurses to apply expensive wound grafts to patients who didn't need them, billing more than a billion dollars in under two years. These are the easy villains, and we give them their due. Then the harder, more uncomfortable territory: practices that are technically legal. We unpack the phrase "delay, deny, defend," its real origin in a 2010 book on insurance, and how it became shorthand for an industry strategy. We walk through the numbers that make the system hard to defend, the share of marketplace claims denied, the tiny fraction ever appealed, and how often those appeals succeed when someone finally reviews the case, which raises the obvious question of what the original denials really were. We tell some of the individual stories, a heart patient denied after pre-approval over a procedure he never had, a denial letter mailed to a newborn in the NICU, and we're careful to also give the insurers' real argument: that overutilization is genuine, that someone has to say no sometimes, and that not every denial is wrong. We get into the rise of AI in coverage decisions and the lawsuits now testing it, the claims against UnitedHealthcare's nH Predict tool and Cigna's PXDX system, while noting clearly that these are unproven allegations the companies dispute and that the cases are ongoing. We cover the human cost, the policy fight playing out across the states, and the bipartisan frustration with prior authorization. And we zoom out to the big picture: the trillions America spends for middling outcomes, the medical debt so many carry, the executive pay, and why public trust in the whole system has hit rock bottom, setting up the Mangione case at the center of Part 3. This is Part 2 of our three-part Price of Care series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: U.S. Department of Justice materials on the 2025 National Health Care Fraud Takedown and the 2024 takedown; DOJ filings in the Operation Gold Rush case and in the Arizona wound-graft fraud prosecution of Alexandra Gehrke and Jeffrey King; the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General; the October 2024 report of the U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations on Medicare Advantage prior-authorization denials; the class-action complaint in Estate of Gene B. Lokken v. UnitedHealth Group, filed November 2023, regarding the nH Predict tool, and the February 2025 ruling allowing it to proceed, alongside UnitedHealth's denials of the allegations; the July 2023 litigation regarding Cigna's PXDX system, alongside Cigna's denials; Feinman, J.M., Delay, Deny, Defend: Why Insurance Companies Don't Pay Claims and What You Can Do About It, 2010; Kaiser Family Foundation surveys and research on claim denials; American Medical Association surveys on prior…
Not rated yetThe Cost of Health: The Broken System That Made Luigi Mangione Inevitable (Pt. 1 of 3)
· 42 min
How did America end up with a healthcare system that a huge chunk of the country views not as a safety net but as an adversary? The answer isn't a conspiracy. It's ninety-six years of accidents, wartime tax quirks, political compromises, and quiet corporate transformations, each step sensible to someone at the time, adding up to the system we have now. To understand why the killing of a health insurance CEO drew tens of thousands of laughing emojis instead of horror, you have to go back to the beginning. And the beginning is a Dallas hospital trying to survive the Great Depression. This is Part 1 of The Cost of Health, a three-part Mugshot Mysteries series on American healthcare. Kathryn and Gabriel set the true-crime angle aside for now and tell the origin story, fair, factual, and upfront that healthcare is inherently political, without telling you what to believe. We start in 1929, when there was no such thing as health insurance, and a hospital administrator named Justin Ford Kimball offered Dallas schoolteachers up to twenty-one days of care for fifty cents a month, accidentally inventing the model and solving the problem that had scared off commercial insurers. That's the Baylor Plan, the seed of Blue Cross and Blue Shield, and crucially, both began as nonprofits with a community mission. Remember that, because it matters later. Then the accident that shaped everything: World War II wage controls pushed employers to compete with benefits instead of pay, the government ruled health insurance wasn't taxable as wages, and just like that, your coverage got welded to your job, not because anyone designed it that way, but because of a tax loophole. We trace Truman's failed push for national coverage and how "socialized medicine" became a Cold War slur, while Europe went the other direction. We cover LBJ's creation of Medicare and Medicaid in 1965 (with the late Harry Truman as the first enrollee), and the cost spiral baked into their original design. We get into the Nixon Oval Office tape that birthed the HMO, the gatekeepers and prior authorization that followed, and the 1990s managed-care backlash, the "drive-through delivery" outrage, and the pivotal moment the nonprofit Blue plans went for-profit, bringing a legal obligation to maximize shareholder value into the business of paying for care. We give you the practical decoder ring most people never get, HMO versus PPO versus EPO versus POS, what those letters actually mean for your wallet and your choices. Then the ACA: what it really did, the pre-existing-conditions ban, the marketplaces, the individual mandate, the three Supreme Court fights, and what it didn't fix. And we land in the present: rising premiums, climbing denial rates, the tiny fraction of denials ever appealed, executive pay, and the AI-denial lawsuit now testing all of it, which we flag clearly as an unproven allegation the company disputes. This is Part 1 of our three-part Cost of Health series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: The National Archives and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services on the 1965 Social Security Amendments creating Medicare and Medicaid; histories of the 1929 Baylor Plan and the founding of Blue Cross and Blue Shield, including materials from the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association; the AMA Journal of Ethics, "The U.S. Health Care Non-System, 1908-2008"; research on the origins of employment-based health benefits and the wartime tax treatment of insurance; the Nixon White House tapes of February 17, 1971, and the Ehrlichman exchange on HMO incentives, and the 1973 HMO Act; Stanford Medicine analysis on the shift of health insurance from protecting patients toward seeking profit; the 1994 Blue Cross Blue Shield decision permitting for-profit conversions; the text and history of the Affordable Care Act of 2010 and the Supreme Court decisions in NFIB v. Sebelius (2012) and King v. Burwell (2015), with…
Not rated yetThe Mary Celeste Ghost Ship Mystery: 10 People Vanished. Only the Ship Survived.
· 55 min
December 4, 1872. Four hundred miles off the Azores, the crew of the Dei Gratia spots a ship drifting strangely, sails torn, no one at the wheel. They watch for two hours, then board her. She is completely deserted. Ten people, a respected captain, his wife, their two-year-old daughter, and seven experienced sailors, are simply gone. The cargo is intact. Six months of food and water remain. Personal belongings sit undisturbed, a child's toys scattered in the cabin. The only lifeboat is missing. The last log entry is nine days old. One hundred and fifty-two years later, no one knows what happened to the people who walked off the Mary Celeste. This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel take on the most famous ghost ship in history, and start by throwing out almost everything you think you know about it. Because the popular version, the warm meals still on the table, the cat asleep below deck, the blocks arranged mid-play, is fiction. Most of it traces to a young doctor named Arthur Conan Doyle, who in 1884 published a sensational short story that got so many details wrong (including misspelling the ship as "Marie Celeste") that people still repeat his inventions as fact. So we go back to the original sources: the Gibraltar salvage inquiry, the surviving log notes, and the letters of Captain Benjamin Briggs and his wife Sarah. We trace the ship's genuinely unlucky history, built as the Amazon, a dead captain on her maiden voyage, collisions, a grounding, abandonment, and a hopeful rename that didn't take. We meet Briggs, a careful, devout family man who'd invested his savings and brought his wife, baby daughter, and a harmonium aboard for what was meant to be one last voyage. We walk the discovery in detail: the open hatches, the disassembled pump, the missing navigation instruments, the compass knocked from its stand, the three and a half feet of water that sounds alarming but wasn't, and the rope trailing off the stern that may have been the key to everything. And we cover the Gibraltar inquiry, where an attorney general was so determined to find murder that he saw bloodstains on a sword that turned out to be rust. Then we methodically knock down the wild theories, piracy, mutiny, insurance fraud, giant squid, the Bermuda Triangle (wrong ocean), aliens, before laying out the explanations modern investigators actually take seriously: the alcohol-vapor explosion theory, vindicated by a chemist's 2006 experiment that produced a hatch-blowing fireball with no scorch marks; the clogged-pump-and-faulty-chronometer theory; and the seaquake theory, with a real documented parallel from 1885. The common thread: Briggs almost certainly evacuated because he believed his ship was about to be destroyed, and was tragically wrong. The ship sailed on without a soul for hundreds more miles. The lifeboat was never found. This is the Mary Celeste. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: The records of the 1872 Gibraltar Vice Admiralty Court salvage inquiry, including the notes of Attorney General Frederick Solly-Flood and the testimony of Dei Gratia first mate Oliver Deveau and ship co-owner James Winchester; surviving documentation of the Mary Celeste's log entries through November 25, 1872; letters of Captain Benjamin Briggs and Sarah Briggs; the experimental work of Dr. Andrea Sella of University College London (2006) testing the alcohol-vapor explosion theory; the research of documentary filmmaker Anne MacGregor for the Smithsonian Channel on the faulty chronometer and clogged-pump theory; the seaquake theory advanced by Captain David Williams and the documented 1885 abandonment of the Alhama of Arendal near the Azores; the 1884 Cornhill Magazine story "J. Habakuk Jephson's Statement" by Arthur Conan Doyle, identified as the origin of many enduring myths and the "Marie Celeste" misspelling; the documented later history of the ship, including her 1885 deliberate wrecking…
Not rated yetD.B. Cooper: He Hijacked a Plane, Jumped Into a Storm, and No One Ever Found Him
· 55 min
The night before Thanksgiving, 1971. A calm, polite man in a business suit hands a flight attendant a note saying he has a bomb. He asks for $200,000 in twenty-dollar bills and four parachutes, releases all thirty-six passengers once his demands are met, and then, somewhere over the dark forests of southwest Washington, lowers the rear stairs of a Boeing 727 and jumps into freezing rain at 200 miles an hour. He is never seen again. No body, no parachute, no trace. Fifty years later, the FBI has investigated more than a thousand suspects and closed the case unsolved. They call him D.B. Cooper, though that wasn't even the name he gave. This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel take a break from the bodies for the only unsolved air piracy case in American history, and have a genuinely good time doing it. We walk the hijacking minute by minute: the bourbon and the obscure Raleigh cigarettes, the flight attendant who pocketed his note assuming it was his phone number, the briefcase of red cylinders and wires the FBI later suspected was a fake, and the eerie courtesy that defined the whole ordeal, this was a man who offered to order meals for the hungry crew mid-hijacking. We get into the clever details: why he demanded twenties, why four parachutes was a stroke of self-protective genius, and how the 727's rear airstairs (since disabled by a device now literally called the "Cooper vane") made his escape physically possible. Then we open the floodgates on theories, because that's the fun of this one. The 1980 discovery of $5,800 of the ransom by a boy on the Columbia River, and why those intact rubber bands bother investigators to this day. The leading suspects, the Boeing-savvy Kenneth Christiansen, the copycat hijacker Richard McCoy, and the deathbed confessors, weighed against the physical descriptions and the limits of the evidence. The disgruntled-Boeing-employee theory, the dying-man theory, the intelligence-operative theory, and the genuinely intriguing possibility that Cooper was a woman in disguise, including the Barbara Dayton claim. Along the way we have an honest conversation about why eyewitness memory is so shaky, why America keeps turning outlaws into folk heroes, and how this one stunt changed air travel forever, metal detectors, the end of walk-on-with-anything flying, and fifteen copycat attempts in 1972 alone. No murder this time. Just the last great American mystery, and two hosts cheerfully refusing to agree on how it ends. This is D.B. Cooper. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: FBI records on the November 24, 1971, hijacking of Northwest Orient Flight 305 and the Operation NORJAK investigation, including the agency's 2016 suspension of active investigation; contemporaneous accounts and crew recollections, including those attributed to flight attendants Florence Schaffner and Tina Mucklow; documentation of the evidence recovered from the aircraft, including the tie, tie clip, and two parachutes; the 1980 discovery of ransom bills by Brian Ingram near the Columbia River and the matching of their serial numbers; reporting on the principal suspects examined over the decades, including Kenneth Christiansen, Richard Floyd McCoy, Sheridan Peterson, Robert Rackstraw, Duane Weber, William Gossett, and the claim associated with Barbara Dayton, as well as FBI statements ruling various suspects out; Himmelsbach, R., and Worcester, T.K., NORJAK: The Investigation of D.B. Cooper, 1986; documentation of the post-hijacking aviation security changes, including the "Cooper vane" and the 1973 mandate for passenger screening; and standard histories and journalism on the case. The Netflix documentary D.B. Cooper: Where Are You?! is referenced as a cultural treatment. DISCLAIMER: Content warning: This episode discusses a hijacking, a bomb threat, and a likely fatal parachute jump, along with speculation about the death of an unidentified person. Nothing…
Not rated yetColonial Parkway Murders: America's Forgotten Serial Killer
· 54 min
October 12, 1986. A park ranger on Virginia's Colonial Parkway finds a white Honda with the engine still running and two young women dead in the back seat, their throats cut. Cathleen Thomas, a 27-year-old naval officer, and Rebecca Dowski, a 21-year-old college student, had been on a date the night before. Over the next three years, three more young couples will vanish or be found murdered along the same dark, wooded stretch of historic roadway. Eight victims in all. Some shot, some with their throats cut, two never found at all. Thirty-eight years later, no one has ever been charged. This is the Colonial Parkway Murders, one of America's most brutal unsolved serial cases, and one almost nobody talks about. This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel give this forgotten case the deep, careful treatment it deserves, and approach the still-living suspects with real caution, because no one has ever been arrested. We start with the place, a beautiful 23-mile scenic drive between Jamestown, Williamsburg, and Yorktown by day, and an unlit, isolated lovers' lane by night. Then the four cases, one by one, with respect for who these young people were: Cathleen Thomas and Rebecca Dowski in 1986; David Knobling and Robin Edwards, found shot at Ragged Island in 1987; Richard Call and Cassandra Hailey, who vanished in 1988 and have never been found; and Annamaria Phelps and Daniel Lauer, whose remains were discovered off Interstate 64 in 1989. Then the murders simply stopped. We dig into why this case has stayed cold for so long, starting with the jurisdictional nightmare, federal park land, multiple county sheriffs, state police, and the FBI all holding pieces of what may be one case, with the inter-agency friction that came with it. We walk the leading theories evenhandedly: one evolving serial killer versus a team versus copycats, and the persistent law-enforcement theory, that the killer used a badge or the appearance of authority to get couples to stop on a dark road without a struggle, which would also explain the geographic knowledge and the lack of evidence. We cover the genuinely strange Fred Atwell episode and the leaked crime-scene photos that re-traumatized a victim's family, while being clear about what is and isn't actually known. And we treat the various people investigated over the decades for exactly what they are: persons of interest who were never charged, several of whom have denied any involvement. Finally, the hope: genetic genealogy, the technology that caught the Golden State Killer, and whether usable DNA from these 1980s scenes could still crack the case. And the families, especially Cathleen's brother Bill Thomas, who has fought for decades and just wants answers before he dies. If you know something, the FBI tip line is 1-800-CALL-FBI, or tips.fbi.gov. This is the Colonial Parkway Murders. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: FBI and Virginia State Police records and public statements on the Colonial Parkway Murders cold case; contemporaneous and retrospective reporting on the four incidents and eight victims: Cathleen Thomas and Rebecca Dowski (October 1986), David Knobling and Robin Edwards (September 1987), Richard Call and Cassandra Hailey (April 1988, still missing), and Annamaria Phelps and Daniel Lauer (September 1989); reporting on the jurisdictional structure of the investigation across the National Park Service, the FBI, and multiple Virginia county and state agencies, and the FBI Behavioral Science Unit profile; coverage of the 2014 incident in which leaked crime-scene photographs were sent to a victim's family, and the resulting FBI internal review; the public advocacy and Congressional testimony of Bill Thomas, brother of Cathleen Thomas; television treatments including segments on Unsolved Mysteries, America's Most Wanted, and the 2018 Oxygen documentary on the case; and general reporting on investigative genetic genealogy,…
Not rated yet