Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The Hinterkaifeck Murders: A Killer Lived in Their Attic — And No One Was Ever Caught

From Mugshot Mysteries · · 53 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

In the spring of 1922, on an isolated Bavarian farmstead, the head of the household notices footprints in the snow leading from the forest straight to his property. None lead back. The family has been hearing footsteps in the attic for months. The maid quit half a year earlier, convinced the house was haunted. A set of house keys has gone missing, and a newspaper no one bought has appeared inside. A neighbor offers to lend a gun. Andreas Gruber declines. Days later, all six people at Hinterkaifeck are dead, killed with the family's own mattock. And then the killer does the thing that has haunted this case for a century: instead of fleeing, they stay.

This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel cover the Hinterkaifeck murders, Germany's most infamous unsolved crime, six victims, zero convictions, and someone who was almost certainly living in the attic.

We start with the family, because the darkness here begins long before the murders. Andreas Gruber was a controlling patriarch, and he and his widowed daughter Viktoria had been convicted of incest years earlier. The paternity of Viktoria's young son was an open question, hanging between Andreas and a neighbor named Lorenz Schlittenbauer, a dispute tangled up with money and a forbidden relationship. This was a household full of secrets, fear, and enemies. Then the buildup: the haunted-house feeling that drove off the maid, the unexplained footprints, the missing keys, and Viktoria fleeing into the woods the night before the killings, certain someone was watching.

We walk the murders themselves as carefully as the subject allows, the victims lured one by one to the barn and found stacked under hay, the toddler and the brand-new maid killed inside the house, no robbery, money left untouched. And then the part that turns a tragedy into a nightmare: for days afterward, neighbors saw smoke from the chimney, the animals were fed, food was eaten, a bed was slept in. Someone made themselves at home with six bodies on the property. A passerby was even blinded by a lantern held up by a figure at the door.

Then the investigation, which is a case study in how not to do it: a crime scene trampled by dozens of people, a neighbor who somehow had a key and rearranged the bodies, an autopsy in the barn, and the victims' skulls shipped to Munich so clairvoyants could examine them, later lost in the war. We run the suspects, Schlittenbauer foremost, plus the theory of Viktoria's supposedly dead husband returning from the war, the farmhands whose sister named them on her deathbed, and more. And we cover the 2007 police-academy cold-case review that settled on a prime suspect and then refused to name him, out of respect for living descendants.

This is Hinterkaifeck.

New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen.

SOURCES:

Bavarian state archive records of the Hinterkaifeck investigation, including the case led by Inspector Georg Reingruber and the autopsy findings of court physician Johann Baptist Aumüller identifying a mattock as the murder weapon; contemporaneous accounts of the discovery of the bodies on April 4, 1922, by Lorenz Schlittenbauer and neighbors, and the timeline of the killings on the night of March 31 to April 1, 1922; documented witness statements, including the earlier departure of maid Kreszenz Rieger, the sightings of smoke from the farmhouse in the days after the murders, and the passerby account of Michael Plöckl; the prior incest conviction of Andreas Gruber and Viktoria Gabriel and the disputed paternity of Josef; records of the more than one hundred individuals questioned over the decades, the case's official closure in 1955, and continued interrogations until 1986; the 2007 cold-case review by students at the Fürstenfeldbruck Police Academy, which named a prime suspect privately but declined to publish it out of respect for living descendants; the deathbed statement implicating the Bichler brothers; the theory…

Back to Mugshot Mysteries · Report a problem