
Mugshot Mysteries
Kathryn and GabrielAudio
- Format:
- Podcast
- New episodes:
- Weekly
- Typical length:
- about 45 minutes
- Latest episode:
About this show
Some stories are solved. Most aren’t. The interesting ones refuse to stay buried.
Mugshot Mysteries is a deep-dive podcast hosted by Kathryn and Gabriel, exploring true crime, conspiracies, paranormal encounters, cults, historical disasters, government cover-ups, and the stories that keep people awake long after the episode ends.
Every episode blends immersive storytelling, psychological analysis, dark humor, and the kind of rabbit holes that make you question whether history is telling the full truth.
One week it’s serial killers. The next it’s MKUltra, haunted hospitals, vanished ships, UFO encounters, or deaths that still don’t make sense decades later.
Kathryn brings the research. Gabriel brings the questions, the theories, and occasionally a comment so out of pocket it completely derails the conversation.
Expect deep dives, unexpected tangents, and at least one moment where Kathryn has to stop and say, “Wow. Wow wow wow.”
If it’s disturbing, unexplained, historically strange, or impossible to forget… it belongs in the lineup.
New episodes every week.
Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at rss.buzzsprout.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.
Cosmos
Similar by topic and creator
- Spy Nations
Shares the topics History, Society and True Crime. - Proof Positive
Shares the topics History, Society and True Crime. - The Criminal Makeup
Shares the topics History, Society and True Crime.
Similar shows
Explore more
Episodes
Natalee Holloway: Joran van der Sloot and the Confession After 18 Years
· 48 min
May 10th, 2010. A hotel room in Aruba. A 22-year-old Dutchman counts out cash and names his price: two hundred fifty thousand dollars to lead a grieving mother to her daughter’s body. He has told that night’s story at least six ways, always on camera. This time there is one he doesn’t know about. It belongs to the FBI, and the tape will sit in a file for thirteen years. This is Natalee Holloway. Kathryn and Gabriel trace the whole arc, from an 18-year-old who vanished on a senior trip, through the lie that jailed two innocent men, a second young woman killed in Lima five years to the day later, and a 2023 confession that cost its teller almost nothing. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For bonus episodes, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries SOURCES: Wikipedia’s “Disappearance of Natalee Holloway” and “Joran van der Sloot” entries, read against primary reporting; Associated Press excerpts of van der Sloot’s 2010 Peru confession and his 2012 guilty plea; the WBRC transcript of his October 3, 2023 proffer statement; the U.S. Department of Justice release and AP reporting on the 2023 federal plea terms; CNN’s legal analysis of the plea, including its provisions on the Kalpoe brothers; AP coverage of Judge Anna Manasco’s Birmingham sentencing; NPR and the Christian Science Monitor on the FBI sting, the private funds used, and his flight to Peru; Courthouse News and the Hollywood Reporter on the Dr. Phil tape litigation and its 2015 dismissal; reporting on Peter R. de Vries’s hidden-camera broadcast and his International Emmy; the Peruvian police psychological evaluation as reported by CNN; Wikipedia on Robert Hare’s Psychopathy Checklist, which measures traits and is not a diagnosis; Netflix Tudum and TV Insider on the 2026 documentary, Aruba’s expired limitation period, and Beth Holloway’s Dutch murder complaint; and scholarship cited in the episode, including Paul Ekman on duping delight, Pauline Boss on ambiguous loss, Melvin Lerner’s just-world hypothesis, and Joel Feinberg on the expressive function of punishment. Where sources conflict, the episode notes it and omits unverified figures. DISCLAIMER: Content warning: This episode describes sexual assault, graphic violence, and the deaths of two young women. Please take care while listening. The Mugshot Mysteries podcast is independently produced and is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by any individual, family, agency, network, or news organization referenced in this episode. This episode discusses a contested legal matter. Joran van der Sloot has confessed, in a recorded statement, to causing Natalee Holloway’s death in Aruba in 2005, but he has never been charged with or convicted of that killing, and under his 2023 federal proffer the statement cannot be used against him; references to her death come from his own account and the public record and are not a finding of any court. He is imprisoned in Peru for the 2010 murder of Stephany Flores, to which he pleaded guilty in 2012, and pleaded guilty in the United States in 2023 to extortion and wire fraud. The 2023 plea agreement states that Deepak and Satish Kalpoe were not present and had no part in Natalee’s death; the two former security guards arrested in 2005 were released without charge and are innocent. Any discussion of psychological traits, including psychopathy, reflects interpretation of the public record and the hosts’ commentary, not a clinical diagnosis. Natalee Holloway, Beth Holloway, Stephany Flores, and their families are discussed with respect and on the basis of public reporting and their own statements. References to any person, living or deceased, are made in the context of public records and reporting and are not intended to defame or cause harm. Any third-party names and trademarks remain the property of their respective owners and are referenced under fair use for commentary, criticism, and reporting.…
Not rated yetThe Unabomber: The Harvard Experiment Behind Ted Kaczynski
· 59 min
April 3, 1996. Forty FBI agents close in on a ten-by-twelve plywood shack in the Montana woods. Inside lives a man most of the town couldn’t name, who for seventeen years mailed hand-carved wooden bombs to strangers, killing three and maiming more than twenty. This is the story of Ted Kaczynski, the Unabomber, and the two things that may explain him: a locked room at Harvard, and a single backwards sentence that gave him away. Kathryn and Gabriel trace the whole arc, from a 167-IQ childhood through a three-year Harvard psychological study, the bombings, the manifesto, and the brother who recognized a sentence written the way only their mother said it, and made the hardest choice imaginable. This is the Unabomber. SOURCES: Court records from the federal prosecution of Theodore J. Kaczynski, including his 1998 guilty plea; the 1998 competency evaluation by forensic psychiatrist Dr. Sally Johnson; Kaczynski’s own writings, including his manifesto “Industrial Society and Its Future” (published by The Washington Post, with The New York Times, September 19, 1995), his coded journals, and his prison letters; FBI and U.S. Postal Inspection Service materials on the UNABOM investigation and the Lincoln, Montana cabin; the account of FBI forensic linguist James Fitzgerald; Alston Chase’s reporting on Kaczynski and Harvard, and documentation of Henry Murray’s study and his OSS assessment work; contemporaneous reporting on the bombings and victims, including Hugh Scrutton, Thomas Mosser, and Gilbert Murray, and survivors including John Hauser, David Gelernter, Charles Epstein, and Gary Wright; the public accounts of David Kaczynski and Linda Patrik; Jacques Ellul’s The Technological Society (1954); and research on belief perseverance by Lee Ross and Mark Lepper. Where sources differ, the episode notes the discrepancy. DISCLAIMER: Content warning: This episode describes bombings, graphic injuries and deaths, suicide, and psychological experimentation on a minor. Please take care while listening. This episode discusses suicide; if you are struggling, call or text 988. The Mugshot Mysteries podcast is independently produced and is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by any individual, family, agency, university, or news organization referenced in this episode. This episode recounts a historical case that was resolved in court. Theodore Kaczynski pleaded guilty in 1998, was sentenced to life without parole, and died in 2023; his guilt is a matter of record and is not in dispute. The account is drawn from court records, his own writings, official reports, and contemporaneous reporting. The episode examines what influences, including his childhood, his documented participation in a Harvard psychological study, and diagnoses raised in his case, may have shaped him; these are presented as competing interpretations and genuine debate, not settled explanations, and the episode is explicit that nothing about them excuses or justifies his crimes. The diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia raised by his defense was never tested at trial, as he pleaded guilty, and is discussed as part of the record. David Kaczynski, Linda Patrik, and the surviving victims are discussed with respect and on the basis of their own public accounts and the public record. The hosts’ commentary reflects their own opinions. References to any person, living or deceased, are made in the context of public records and reporting and are not intended to defame or cause harm. Any third-party names and trademarks remain the property of their respective owners and are referenced under fair use for commentary, criticism, and reporting. Nothing in this episode constitutes professional advice. Send us your theories (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2513350/fan_mail/new) Support the show (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2513350/support) 🎧 Subscribe on Apple Podcasts or Spotify so you never miss an episode. 🔐 Join the Mugshot Family on Patreon…
Not rated yetChrista Pike: The Murder, the Death Sentence, and the Execution That Failed
· 49 min
Please note: this episode discusses a brutal murder, child abuse, and a failed execution in graphic detail. Please take care while listening. On the night of September 30, 2026, the state of Tennessee tried to execute Christa Gail Pike, the only woman on its death row, and the first woman it had attempted to put to death in over two centuries. It did not work. After an execution team spent roughly fifty minutes and some ten needles trying to establish an IV line, after two full doses of pentobarbital, after witnesses heard her say “I feel like my arm is about to bust, it burns,” Christa Pike did not die. At 8:40 p.m. the prison called 911. An ambulance carried her to a hospital, where she was expected to be declared brain dead, and where, days later, she woke up and asked where she was. The Death Penalty Information Center called it the first time anyone has ever survived being injected with lethal doses of execution drugs. This is her story, and it’s the story of the nineteen-year-old she murdered. This is a hard episode, and Kathryn and Gabriel tell it carefully, holding the victim at its center. Because before any of what happened in that chamber, there was Colleen Slemmer. We go back to a federal Job Corps center in Knoxville in January 1995, where four teenagers signed out of a dormitory one winter night and three signed back in. We tell what happened to Colleen Slemmer, a nineteen-year-old studying computers, lured to an abandoned steam plant on the false promise of a truce and tortured for the better part of an hour over Pike’s baseless jealousy about a boy, a killing so savage the medical examiner said the skull was shattered, with a pentagram carved into her chest. We cover Pike’s taped confession, the fragment of Colleen’s skull she carried back in her pocket and showed off at breakfast, and the detail a jury would weigh heavily: that she returned to the scene to watch the police work it. We examine the case honestly. The Satanic-Panic framing that made it famous (and the plainer truth that a sign-out log and a search solved it, not a cult). The trial, the rejected plea deal, and the mitigation her jury never heard, a childhood of almost unimaginable abuse and neglect, documented in binders that stayed in a box. The wildly different outcomes for her two co-defendants. And why Pike shattered the established profile of women who kill, drawing on researcher Marissa Harrison’s landmark study and the show’s recurring thread about how courts treat women at the defense table, from Lizzie Borden’s acquittal to Pike’s death sentence in under ninety minutes. Then the chamber, reconstructed minute by minute from her attorney’s sworn declaration, and the competing theories for what went wrong: blown veins, a protocol with no page for a failed second dose, a physician who was also present at an hour-long failed execution months earlier, and Pike’s own blood disorder, which her lawyers had warned about in January. And we lay out the question no court has ever truly had to answer, whether a state that completed an execution and failed can lawfully try again, walking through the chilling precedents of Willie Francis and Romell Broom. Throughout, we return to where this has to return: Colleen Slemmer was nineteen. Remember her name. Note: This episode reflects the case as of late October 2026 and it is developing rapidly. As of recording, Christa Pike had survived, returned to prison, and issued a public statement; a state-ordered review was underway; her method-of-execution lawsuit and a clemency request to the governor were pending; and no court had decided whether Tennessee may attempt a second execution. Please consult current reporting for the latest. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For bonus episodes, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries Stay curious. Stay kind. SOURCES: The sworn 108-paragraph declaration of attorney Randy Spivey, who…
Not rated yetHalloween: The True History of the Night the Dead Come Home
· 40 min
Ireland, more than two thousand years ago, the last night of October. The harvest is in, the cattle are penned, and every hearth fire in the village has been deliberately put out. The only light for miles is a single bonfire on a distant hill. Inside a pitch-black house, a family eats in total silence, with one place set at the end of the table, a full plate, a cup, and an empty chair for whoever is coming. Before they sat down, they smeared ash on their faces and pulled animal skins over their heads, because the door between the living and the dead is open tonight, and not everything that comes through it will be your grandmother. Sometime after midnight, the empty chair scrapes back across the floor. And the rule, the only rule, is that you do not look up. For the last Monday of October, Mugshot Mysteries isn’t doing a case. Kathryn and Gabriel are doing the night itself: two thousand years of people putting out their lights and setting a plate for the dead, and what happened when that night crossed the ocean to America and we slowly forgot what any of it was for. We start with Stingy Jack, the drunk who conned the Devil twice and got himself locked out of both heaven and hell, doomed to wander the dark with a single coal inside a hollowed-out turnip, the original jack-o’-lantern, and the carved face you put in your window to tell him this house is already taken. We trace how the Great Famine carried that turnip to America, where it became a pumpkin, and how the scariest thing in the Irish countryside became the thing your kid paints a smiley face on. We follow the church’s thousand-year campaign to absorb the night, All Saints’ Day laid right on top of the old fire festival, “souling” and soul cakes, and the guising that became going door to door as the dead. And we tell the genuinely rowdy American chapter: the 1920s and ’30s, when Halloween was a night of real urban chaos, and how trick-or-treating was invented not as an ancient tradition but as a civic bribe to stop kids from sawing down telephone poles. Then the three dark American turns that shaped the holiday we have now. The 1938 War of the Worlds broadcast and the panic that, it turns out, the newspapers largely invented. The 1974 murder of eight-year-old Timothy O’Bryan by his own father, a church deacon who poisoned a Pixy Stix for the insurance money and tried to blame a stranger at a dark door, the case that taught a nation to check its candy, even though sociologist Joel Best has shown there was never a real “candy man” at all. And the 1980s Satanic Panic, the Geraldo special, the cancelled school parties, the police “occult crime” seminars, and the churches that figured out they could stop fighting Halloween and start running “Hell Houses” for a $300 kit. Through all of it runs the thread that ties this month together, from Lizzie Borden’s hatchet to a bowl of candy on a dark porch: every generation looks at the thing that scares it most and decides to dress up as it instead of running. We never stopped setting the offering at the door. We just stopped knowing why. Happy Halloween from Mugshot Mysteries. Check your candy, check the man holding the umbrella, and whatever you do, don’t look up. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For 12+ bonus episodes and the Original Case Files vault, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries SOURCES: Standard histories of Samhain and the Celtic festival of the dead, including the bonfire tradition associated with Tlachtga (the Hill of Ward); Victor Turner’s The Ritual Process (1969) and the concept of liminality (building on Arnold van Gennep); folklore of Stingy Jack and the jack-o’-lantern, and the carved turnip lantern held in the National Museum of Ireland’s Country Life collection; the folklore of souling and soul cakes, and Shakespeare’s reference in The Two Gentlemen of Verona; Lisa Morton’s Trick or Treat: A History of Halloween (2012), the…
Not rated yetThe Bell Witch: The Only American Death Ever Blamed on a Ghost
· 47 min
Support Mugshot Mysteries and unlock 12+ bonus episodes on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries Tennessee, December 1820. On a log farmhouse by the Red River, a seventy-year-old farmer named John Bell doesn’t wake up. His son goes to the medicine cabinet and finds the usual bottle gone, and a strange dark vial in its place. From the ceiling, a voice, no body, no face, the voice the family had been living with for three years, brags that it gave “Old Jack a big dose last night.” They test the vial on the family cat. The cat is dead within minutes. John Bell dies the next morning, and the thing in the house spends his entire funeral singing a drinking song over the grave. He is remembered as one of the only people in American history whose death was formally blamed on a ghost. The spirit called itself Kate. The world calls it the Bell Witch. This week, still in October and fresh off a village of poisoners, Kathryn and Gabriel wanted a straight-up haunting, and this is the most famous one America has. Four years, one family, a disembodied voice that quoted Scripture and sang hymns and cursed like a sailor, a teenage girl it would not leave alone, and a house full of people too frightened to leave. The approach is the show’s usual one: tell what the people who were there said happened, and take them seriously, because they were dead serious. We set the world first, the Second Great Awakening and the camp-meeting fervor that made the supernatural utterly real to frontier Tennessee, and the uglier foundations of the Bell farm, built and worked by nine enslaved people whose side of this story the legend almost entirely erased. We make sure to tell Dean’s, the enslaved man who, walking a dark road to see his wife on another farm, reported being followed by a two-headed dog, and who may have encountered the thing more than anyone, yet gets a paragraph where the Bells got a book. We cover the business feud over the sale of an enslaved child that set the whole thing in motion, and how it landed the “witch” label on Kate Batts, an odd, outspoken neighbor who was never charged with anything and has worn the word for two centuries. Then the haunting itself, the creature in the cornfield, the knocking and gnawing and dragging chains, the covers pulled off beds, and the relentless torment of young Betsy Bell, slapped hard enough to leave a handprint with no one beside her. We follow the voice as it learns to speak, recites two sermons delivered miles apart at the same hour, knows things it shouldn’t, and fixates on the girl at the center of the house. And we bring in the frameworks that make this episode more than a campfire tale: the eerie parallel to the Enfield Poltergeist, William Roll’s “recurrent spontaneous psychokinesis” and the way poltergeist cases orbit a stressed adolescent (the idea behind Stephen King’s Carrie), Pierre Janet on dissociation, René Girard’s scapegoat mechanism, and the darker, unproven abuse theory that the spirit was a wounded girl’s pain given a voice. We weigh the Andrew Jackson legend (almost certainly embellished), the hoax theories pointing at the schoolteacher who later married Betsy, the problem that most of this comes from a book written seventy-three years later, and Bartlett’s memory science, which cuts both ways. And we land where this case always does, unsolved, with a quietly perfect modern coda: Bell and Batts descendants discovering, in the same church pew, that the other family is still around. This is the Bell Witch. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For 12+ bonus episodes and the Original Case Files vault, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries SOURCES: M.V. Ingram’s An Authenticated History of the Bell Witch (1894), which incorporates Richard Williams Bell’s firsthand account Our Family Trouble (written 1846), as the primary and much-debated source for the haunting; genealogical records for the Bell…
Not rated yetThe Angel Makers: The Village Where Women Poisoned Their Husbands
· 46 min
Support Mugshot Mysteries and unlock 12+ bonus episodes on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries A whitewashed kitchen in rural Hungary, sometime in the 1920s. A woman boils strips of flypaper in a pot, skims the arsenic residue off the top, and bottles it. In the next room her husband coughs. Outside, the church bell rings and someone hangs laundry. In the tiny village of Nagyrév, about sixty miles from Budapest, this was a routine that lasted some twenty years, and the whole village, it seems, was in on it. When investigators finally started digging up the graves in 1929, they reportedly opened around fifty and found arsenic in forty-six. Husbands, mostly. Also fathers, in-laws, boyfriends, and some children. The newspapers called the women the Angel Makers, and the region the murder district. This week, for October, Mugshot Mysteries went looking for something spooky and found a story where the scariest part is how ordinary murder became. Kathryn and Gabriel go to Nagyrév, and what starts as a creepy-village tale turns into something closer to a seminar on how good, church-going people talk themselves into the unthinkable. The story begins in 1911 with a stranger: Zsuzsanna Fazekas, a midwife with solid references and a husband who had vanished, whom the village came to call Auntie Suzy. In a place with no doctor, the midwife was the entire medical system, the one who delivered the babies, set the bones, ended the pregnancies, and heard every secret too dangerous to tell a priest. Arrested something like ten times and acquitted every time, she taught the village a lesson it wouldn’t forget: nothing happens. We trace how World War I emptied the village of men and handed its women four years of running the farms themselves, how the men came home broken and traumatized to wives who had changed while the old rules hadn’t, and how, into that pressure, came a recipe: boil the flypaper, skim it, stir it into the soup. Arsenic that mimicked cholera, in a village with no one to test for it, even though the test had existed since 1836. And we build the real argument, because this is where the episode lives. Why did one dead husband become a cemetery? We walk it through the great social thinkers, Bandura’s moral disengagement (you don’t say poison, you say remedy), Durkheim’s anomie and Merton’s strain theory for a world whose rulebook had stopped matching reality, Milgram’s obedience experiments and the “agentic state,” the bystander effect at the village well, Vaughan’s normalization of deviance (every funeral that drew no police made the next one safer), and finally Arendt’s banality of evil, because the women of Nagyrév didn’t kill in a frenzy. They killed like it was a chore, then went to Mass. We cover the disputed death toll (forty-five to fifty confirmed, possibly well over a hundred and sixty, with regional estimates as high as three hundred), the anonymous letter that may have ended it, the graves that arsenic had kept eerily intact, Auntie Suzy’s death before she could be tried, and the Szolnok trials that followed. This is the Angel Makers of Nagyrév. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For 12+ bonus episodes and the Original Case Files vault, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries SOURCES: Historical accounts of the Nagyrév/Tiszazug arsenic poisonings (roughly 1911-1929) and the Szolnok trials of 1929-1931, including Béla Bodó’s scholarly history of the case and Patti McCracken’s The Angel Makers; contemporaneous 1929 Hungarian newspaper coverage of the investigation, exhumations, arrests, and trials, and the statement attributed to government minister Kuno Klebelsberg; the 2004 BBC reporting from the village, including the interview with resident Mária Gunya; and the documented history of arsenic as a poison and the 1836 Marsh test. The social-science framework referenced throughout is drawn from standard citations in psychology…
Not rated yetLindsay Clancy: Postpartum Psychosis, a Mistrial, and the Case That Divided Us
· 37 min
Support Mugshot Mysteries and unlock 12+ bonus episodes on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries Please note: this episode discusses the deaths of three young children, suicide, and postpartum mental illness. If you are a new mom and you are not in a good place right now, it is okay to skip this one. Support resources are listed at the end of this description. In October 2022, a labor and delivery nurse in Duxbury, Massachusetts texted her mother: "I'm really sick. Something is wrong." Three months later, her three children were dead. This week, in a solo episode, Kathryn tells the story of Lindsay Clancy, and asks a hard, honest question about why so many women looked at this case and, unlike almost any other, did not see a monster. This is a difficult, personal episode, and Kathryn approaches it with that weight. She lays out what came out at trial, the parts that help Lindsay and the parts that don't, and she is careful throughout to separate what was proven, what is alleged, and what remains for a court to decide. Lindsay was charged with first-degree murder and pleaded not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility, Massachusetts' version of the insanity defense, where the burden falls on the prosecution. In September 2026, after seven days of deliberation, the jury hung. Reporting indicated eleven jurors found her not criminally responsible; one did not. A mistrial was declared. We walk the documented record with care: the months in which, by trial testimony and her own later malpractice suit, Lindsay sought help again and again, a dozen medications, multiple emergency rooms, a day program, an inpatient stay, and psychiatrists who testified she never told them she intended to harm anyone. We cover the prosecution's timeline and its argument that she acted with planning and intent, and the defense's case that she was overmedicated and in postpartum psychosis. We lay out the dueling expert testimony fairly, including that not one doctor on either side called her mentally well, and that even a prosecution expert diagnosed bipolar disorder. And Kathryn draws on the psychology of why this case landed so differently from Casey Anthony's, defensive attribution, the just-world belief, and the cultural trap of "intensive mothering" that leaves only two boxes, perfect mother or monster, that so many women refused to accept here. We also hold space for what rallying behind Lindsay can erase: Cora, Dawson, and Callan, five, three, and eight months old, who lost the most. And we are unequivocal about Patrick Clancy, their father, who lost everything and who has publicly forgiven his wife: the court's record and cited GPS and surveillance evidence place him out of the house, and the online theories that have tried to implicate him are, in his own words, deeply harmful, and have no basis in the evidence. We cover them only to set them aside. Note: This episode reflects the case as of early October 2026. On October 1, 2026, the judge denied a defense motion for a required finding of not guilty; a double-jeopardy motion, a defense request regarding the holdout juror, and a prosecution gag-order request were pending for a November 2 hearing, and the district attorney had not announced whether he would seek a retrial. The case has likely developed since release; please consult current reporting for the latest. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For bonus episodes, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries If you are pregnant or have had a baby in the past year and any of this sounds familiar, please reach out. The National Maternal Mental Health Hotline is free, confidential, and available 24/7 at 1-833-852-6262 (1-833-TLC-MAMA). Postpartum Support International's helpline is 1-800-944-4773. If you are thinking about hurting yourself, call or text 988. If you are afraid you might hurt someone else, call 911 or go to your nearest emergency…
Not rated yetLizzie Borden: The Hatchet Murders Everyone Got Wrong
· 43 min
Support Mugshot Mysteries and unlock 12+ bonus episodes on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries You know the rhyme. Lizzie Borden took an axe, gave her mother forty whacks. Almost every word of it is wrong. It wasn't an axe, it was a hatchet. Not her mother, her stepmother. Not forty whacks, nineteen for Abby Borden and ten for Andrew. But the rhyme got one thing right, the name, and Fall River has been singing it for over a hundred and thirty years. On a sweltering August morning in 1892, two people were hacked to death inside a locked house on Second Street with two other people home. A church-going Sunday school teacher was tried for it, and acquitted by twelve men in about ninety minutes. No one else was ever arrested. Not then. Not ever. This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel go to Fall River, and argue that everything strange about this case started long before the murders, two doors down, decades earlier. We build the world first: the boomtown of "Spindle City," and Andrew Borden, a genuinely wealthy bank president so miserly he sold eggs from a basket and kept his family in a plumbing-free house on the flat, noisy part of town instead of the mansions on The Hill. We walk the sick architecture of the home itself, no upstairs hallways, rooms opening into rooms, bedroom doors barricaded on both sides, a family that ate in shifts to avoid each other, and the money tensions curdling under it: the property Andrew put in Abby's name, the two grown, unmarried daughters waiting on an inheritance a healthy stepmother stood in front of, and the 1891 daytime burglary of a locked house that Andrew quietly told police to drop, as if he suspected who did it. And we tell the detail that haunts the whole episode: two doors down at that same address, in 1848, a Borden relative drowned her three children in the cellar cistern and cut her own throat. Then the week itself. The whole household violently ill; Abby crossing the street to say she believed she'd been poisoned; a woman matching Lizzie's description trying to buy prussic acid, cyanide, at a local pharmacy the day before the killings, turned away for lack of a prescription. And August 4th, told carefully from the trial record: Abby killed first, upstairs, nineteen blows to a woman already down, an hour before Andrew came home to a nap and ten more blows on the sitting-room sofa. The vanished note no one ever wrote. The barn loft with undisturbed dust where Lizzie said she'd stood. The spotless dress. And the blue dress Lizzie was seen burning in the kitchen stove three days later, "old paint," she said. We lay out the trial that turned on gender: the suppressed inquest testimony and suppressed cyanide evidence, the defense attorney who had appointed one of the judges, and the closing that fit in a single line, "You must believe she is a fiend. Does she look it?" We make the case's most interesting argument, that Victorian America knew female killers well but only as quiet poisoners, so a jury looked at a hatchet and concluded no woman could have swung it, never considering that the poison had simply been tried first and failed. And we close on the aftermath: Maplecroft, the house on The Hill she bought and refused to leave for thirty-four years while the town threw eggs at it; the sister who moved out and never spoke to her again; and the bed-and-breakfast that same murder house has become, where guests pay to sleep beside where Abby died and report a figure in Victorian dress still making the bed, and children's voices no child in that house ever owned. This is Lizzie Borden. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For 12+ bonus episodes and the Original Case Files vault, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries SOURCES: Contemporaneous coverage and the surviving court records of the 1892 murders of Andrew and Abby Borden and the 1893 New Bedford trial of Lizzie Borden, including…
Not rated yetHex Hollow: The 1928 Witch Murder of Nelson Rehmeyer
· 45 min
Support Mugshot Mysteries and unlock 12+ bonus episodes on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries The last week of November, 1928. York County, Pennsylvania. In an isolated hollow that has carried one family's name for generations, a neighbor finds sixty-year-old potato farmer Nelson Rehmeyer dead on his kitchen floor, beaten, bound, and burned. Someone had poured lamp oil over him and set the house alight, expecting it to burn to the ground. It didn't. The fire scorched a hole through the floorboards, charred the body, and went out. The house refused to burn. And when word spread through the valley, some neighbors didn't call it luck. They said the house couldn't burn, because of what Nelson Rehmeyer was. The men who killed him weren't there to rob him. They walked away with less than three dollars. They came because they believed, completely, that he was a witch who had hexed them, and that killing him was the only cure. This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel go to Hex Hollow, and to understand the murder, they start not with the crime but with the magic. We trace the real folk tradition at the heart of it: Braucherei, or "powwowing," the Pennsylvania Dutch healing practice German immigrants carried to America in the 1700s, a devoutly Christian tradition of charms, Bible verses, and cures for fevers, burns, and sick livestock, practiced openly by ordinary neighbors. We cover its most famous text, John George Hohman's 1820 The Long Lost Friend, a remedy book still in print two centuries later, said to protect whoever carries it from fire, a promise that returns, darkly, at the end of this story. And we cover the tradition's shadow: if a healer can bless, someone can curse, and the "hex doctor" whose whole business depends on witches existing, because every diagnosis of a hex is also an accusation of a neighbor. Then the people. John Blymire, born into powwowing, a sickly man powwowed fifteen times before age ten, who spent roughly a decade convinced an unseen curse was draining his health and luck, drifting from hex doctor to hex doctor asking one question: who is doing this to me? The elderly woman across the river in Marietta, remembered in legend as "Nellie Noll" though the records suggest another name entirely, who finally gave him a face in a dollar bill: Nelson Rehmeyer, a man who had once powwowed to heal Blymire as a boy. And Rehmeyer himself, a big, quiet, separated-but-amicable farmer who healed on the side and became "the Witch of Rehmeyer's Hollow" only at the moment someone needed a witch. We walk the recruitment of two teenagers and a desperate, failing farm family, the prescribed cure (bury a lock of the witch's hair, or burn his copy of the book), the strange overnight visit where Rehmeyer fed his eventual killers dinner, and the night of November 27 itself, told carefully from the confessions and trial record, where a retrieval mission became a killing, and where Blymire claimed that the instant Rehmeyer died, his own curse lifted and he could finally sleep. Then the "witch trial" that made global headlines and the county's determined effort to keep witchcraft out of its own courtroom by calling a three-dollar killing a robbery. And finally the aftermath: the hollow renamed, the house that still stands with its burned floor under plexiglass and a clock stopped at 12:01, the reported hauntings, and the way the scandal drove an entire folk tradition underground. The episode's real chill isn't whether Rehmeyer was a witch. It's that a curse doesn't have to be real to work. It only needs one person who believes it is. This is Hex Hollow. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For 12+ bonus episodes and deep dives, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries SOURCES: Contemporaneous coverage of the November 1928 murder of Nelson Rehmeyer and the 1929 York County trials of John Blymire, John Curry, and Wilbert Hess,…
Not rated yetCERN: The God Machine, the Weasels & the Courtyard Ritual Pt. 2:
· 41 min
Support Mugshot Mysteries and unlock 12+ bonus episodes on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries In 2008, six months before the Large Hadron Collider switched on, two men filed a federal lawsuit in Honolulu to stop it, arguing the machine might create a black hole and swallow the Earth. A year earlier, two credentialed theoretical physicists had published a real, peer-reviewed paper suggesting something even stranger: that the collider kept suffering bad luck because the future itself was reaching back to sabotage it. And in August 2016, a video filmed inside the lab at night appeared to show hooded figures staging a human sacrifice at the foot of a statue of a Hindu deity called the Destroyer. This is CERN, Part 2 of 2, the God Machine, and this time the accusations aren't about your memory. They're about everything else. Kathryn and Gabriel are upfront, again, that this is a romp: they tell you what's documented, what's claimed, and which claims Gabriel is leaning into "like a man leaning into a buffet." Part 1 was the Mandela Effect. Part 2 takes the largest machine ever built to court, and calls its first witness from the future. We walk the doomsday lawsuit filed by Walter Wagner and Luis Sancho against the U.S. Department of Energy, the NSF, Fermilab, and CERN, and its three ways the collider might end the world: a runaway microscopic black hole, "strangelets" that convert everything they touch, and magnetic monopoles. We give CERN's actual answer, cosmic rays far more energetic than anything the collider produces have been striking Earth for billions of years, and the Earth is still here, and we cover the memorable moment Wagner told The Daily Show the odds of the world ending were "50/50: either it happens or it doesn't." The suit was thrown out; the Ninth Circuit rejected the appeal; the planet remained a planet. Then Gabriel's favorite: the genuinely published work of physicists Holger Bech Nielsen and Masao Ninomiya, whose model proposed that the universe "disfavors" mass production of the Higgs boson so strongly that the future nudges the past to prevent it, an idea they said explained why an earlier American supercollider in Texas was killed by a 1993 budget vote. Nine days after startup, the collider suffered a catastrophic helium explosion that damaged dozens of magnets. Then, during a later cooldown, a bird reportedly dropped a piece of baguette onto an electrical substation. Then a weasel chewed through a transformer in 2016 and knocked the machine offline just as a tantalizing new-particle "bump" in the data was building, a bump that vanished by August. A second weasel died the same way months later; it is now stuffed and on display in a Rotterdam museum. Bad luck, or the future installing better weasels? The theory, the hosts note cheerfully, cannot lose, which makes it a horoscope. And we cover the "occult file": the 666-shaped logo, the Shiva Nataraja statue India gifted the lab in 2004, the town whose name conspiracy sites tie to a Roman "gateway to the underworld," a real 2015 art film shot inside the facility, the goat-headed Gotthard Tunnel opening ceremony, storm clouds called portals, and the 2016 courtyard "sacrifice" video, which CERN investigated and stated was a staged prank by visitors whose sense of humor went too far. The machine is dark until 2030. Four years with no beam, four years in which every theory here gets tested against a world that keeps being weird anyway. This concludes our two-part CERN series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For bonus episodes and our full case vault, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries SOURCES: Court records from Sancho v. U.S. Department of Energy et al. (2008), filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Hawaii, including the September 2008 dismissal and the Ninth Circuit's 2010 rejection of the appeal; CERN's published Large Hadron Collider safety…
Not rated yetThe Mandela Effect: Did CERN Change Your Memories? Pt. 1
· 45 min
Support Mugshot Mysteries and unlock 12+ bonus episodes on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries June 2026. One hundred meters beneath the border between Switzerland and France, two beams of protons that have circled a 27-kilometer ring for eighteen years are steered out and dumped into a block of graphite one final time. The Large Hadron Collider, the largest machine humanity has ever built, is powering down for four years of upgrades. Its public status page, after nearly two decades of beam reports, displays a single word: "Goodbye." Within seventy-two hours, the posts begin. Time feels slower. Dreams are suddenly vivid. And across millions of posts, a conviction takes hold: with the machine off, reality itself is quietly snapping back into place. This is CERN, Part 1 of 2, and tonight, Mugshot Mysteries is going weird. Fair warning from Kathryn and Gabriel up top: there's no murder tonight, nobody dies, and sometimes your soul just needs that. What there is instead is the largest machine ever built, the internet's absolute keyboard-hammering conviction that it broke reality, and one host who has fully, joyfully bought in while the other plays the world's most reluctant skeptic. The show usually walks a careful line between what's documented and what's claimed. Tonight, everything is on the table. Part 1 belongs to the Mandela Effect. We start in a Dragon Con hospitality suite in 2009, where paranormal researcher Fiona Broome mentions Nelson Mandela's death in prison in the 1980s, an event that never happened, and discovers a roomful of strangers who remember it exactly as vividly as she does. From there we build the theory the internet assembled brick by brick: CERN's history from its 1954 founding and its accidental invention of the World Wide Web, through the 2008 startup of the collider, to the July 4, 2012 announcement of the Higgs boson, the so-called "God Particle." Because weeks after that announcement, a blog post noticed a children's book series had apparently always been the Berenstain Bears, not Berenstein, and the internet went looking for something with enough cosmic horsepower to shift a whole population's memory one letter to the left. It found a machine under Switzerland that recreates the Big Bang forty million times a second. Then the tour every listener will lose at least once: the Fruit of the Loom cornucopia that the company swears never existed, "Luke, I am your father" (a line never actually spoken), Smokey Bear versus Smokey the Bear, Ed McMahon and the sweepstakes check he never delivered, the monocle the Monopoly man never wore, and the beloved genie movie "Shazaam" starring Sinbad, a film that does not exist and that thousands of people can describe scene by scene. We give the documented record and the shared memory for each, and we give memory science its due: recollection is reconstruction, rebuilt and re-corrupted every time you recall it, and false memories have been implanted in labs for decades. The internet has reviewed that explanation and given it two stars, not because it's wrong, but because it's boring and doesn't explain the feeling. We close on the six weeks since the "Goodbye," the snap-back posts, the Risky Business sunglasses that may or may not have always been there, and a teaser for Part 2, which trades memory for matter: a real federal lawsuit filed to stop the collider from ending the world, physicists who published papers suggesting the machine was being sabotaged from its own future, and the night in 2016 when hooded figures staged what looked like a human sacrifice in the courtyard, which the lab called a prank taken too far. This is Part 1 of our two-part CERN series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For bonus episodes and our full case vault, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries SOURCES: Public information from CERN, the European Organization for Nuclear Research, on the…
Not rated yetRuth Snyder: The Jazz Age Murder That Invented True Crime
· 1 hr 16 min
Support Mugshot Mysteries and unlock 12+ bonus episodes and original case files on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries January 12, 1928. Inside Sing Sing, hardened crime reporters stand shoulder to shoulder in the witness room, and at the center sits a woman: hair shorn for the electrodes, wrists and ankles strapped, swallowing hard but not crying. In seconds Ruth Snyder will become the first woman executed in New York in over thirty years. And as the current surges, a reporter named Tom Howard raises his trouser leg, where a camera is strapped to his ankle, and squeezes the shutter. By dawn, the image of her death fills the entire front page of the New York Daily News beneath a single savage word: DEAD. But before she was that photograph, Ruth was a bored, resentful Queens housewife who wanted more. This week, Mugshot Mysteries reaches back into the vault for the second of its original case files: Kathryn tells the story start to finish, then she and Gabriel dig into what it meant. And this one, more than almost any case, is where American true-crime spectacle was born. Kathryn traces Ruth from working-class girl to Queens Village housewife, married to Albert Snyder, a quiet, older art editor who openly mourned a dead fiancée and kept her mementos around the house like shrines, a ghost Ruth felt she could never compete with. We follow the affair with Henry Judd Gray, a nervous, pliable corset salesman; the life insurance policy with the double-indemnity clause that turned Ruth's restlessness into something lethal; and the reported string of earlier attempts on Albert's life before the final one. Then the night of March 20, 1927 itself, the botched, chaotic killing that was nothing like the clean accident they'd imagined, and the staged burglary that fell apart almost immediately, undone in part by Ruth herself, who blurted her lover's name to a detective before anyone had named a suspect. Gray, picked up in Syracuse, folded at once and named her the mastermind. We cover the trial that became a carnival, the "Vampire Wife" and "Ice Woman" headlines, the vendors selling sash-weight-shaped pens on the courthouse steps, and the near-inevitable verdict that sent both to the chair. And we sit with the aftermath that made Ruth Snyder a permanent cultural landmark: the sold-out Daily News, the first published photograph of an American execution, and the fierce question it forced, whether death should be private justice or public entertainment. Her case echoed straight into noir, inspiring James M. Cain's Double Indemnity and Sophie Treadwell's Machinal. Then Kathryn and Gabriel turn to the uncomfortable questions the case raises about how we mythologize female killers, why a calculating woman gets recast as a "femme fatale," a figure almost too theatrical to be real, when a man would simply be called a murderer, and what that says about the anxieties of a decade in which American women had only just won the vote. They're candid that the show tells "cheeky" crime stories, and equally candid that this one is a genuine tragedy, and that glamorizing murder is exactly what they're not here to do. This is a Mugshot Mysteries original case file. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For 12+ bonus episodes and the original case files, with the real records we dug up, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries SOURCES: Contemporaneous coverage of the 1927 murder of Albert Snyder and the 1927-1928 trial and execution of Ruth Snyder and Henry Judd Gray, including the reporting and famous execution-photograph front page of the New York Daily News; trial records and testimony from the Queens County proceedings, including Gray's confession and account of the crime; documentation of the insurance policy and its double-indemnity provision; New York State Department of Corrections records relating to the January 12, 1928 executions at Sing Sing; histories of…
Not rated yetVictor Lustig: The Con Man Who Sold the Eiffel Tower Twice
· 1 hr 17 min
Support Mugshot Mysteries and unlock 12+ bonus episodes and original case files on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries Paris, 1925. The Eiffel Tower is rusting, expensive to maintain, and quietly rumored in the papers to be a candidate for demolition. To most Parisians, that's background noise. To a sharply dressed man in a suite at the Hotel de Crillon, forged government stationery in his briefcase, it's an opportunity. He is not a politician, not a diplomat, not even French. But he is about to sell the Eiffel Tower for scrap, not because he owns it, but because he says he does. And the truly astonishing part: after he pulls it off and slips away, he comes back weeks later and tries to sell it a second time. This week, Mugshot Mysteries reaches back to the format the show started with: a single case file, told start to finish, followed by Kathryn and Gabriel digging into the psychology of it. Today's subject is Victor Lustig, the con man who sold the impossible and made the world believe it was real. Kathryn walks his whole career, because with Lustig it truly was a career, not a spree. Born in Bohemia in 1890, fluent in five languages by his teens, he learned early that if you couldn't be important, you could look the part. We trace the "Romanian money box," the little brass contraption he sold to marks by convincing them it duplicated hundred-dollar bills, the forged letter naming him a deputy director of the French Ministry of Posts and Telegraphs, and the ambitious young scrap dealer, André Poisson, whose shame at being conned kept him from ever calling the police. Then the audacious American second act: the aliases, the passport fraud, and the almost unbelievable episode in which Lustig took fifty thousand dollars from Al Capone, sat on it untouched for two months, returned every cent, and walked away with a five-thousand-dollar "thank you," having read one of the most dangerous men in America like a book. We follow him into his most sophisticated operation, a counterfeiting ring so precise, built with a former pharmacist named William Watts, that the bills reportedly fooled banks, businesses, and even the Treasury, until a 1935 Secret Service raid on a Times Square locker turned up the plates. There's a bedsheet-rope escape from federal detention, a quiet guilty plea, and a final address at Alcatraz, inmate number 300, listed occupation: apprentice salesman. And there's the quiet, unglamorous end in 1947: no shootout, no last con, just pneumonia and a hospital bed, and a man who kept his routine and never dropped the act. Then Kathryn and Gabriel turn to the real question, what makes a con artist tick, and why Lustig thrived in an age of Prohibition, get-rich-quick schemes, and smooth-talking salesmen. His genius, they argue, wasn't preying on the ignorant. It was preying on ego: making his victims feel brilliant and chosen for trusting him. And in a wide-ranging, very off-the-rails conversation about meaning, belief, variable-ratio reinforcement, and why a thing marked down from sixty-nine dollars feels like a steal, they land on why Lustig is, in a sense, still working: in every phishing email, every too-good-to-be-true pitch, every deal that makes you feel like the smartest person in the room. The con only works if you want it to be true. This is a Mugshot Mysteries original case file. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For 12+ bonus episodes and the original case files, with the real documents we dug up, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries SOURCES: Contemporaneous American newspaper coverage of Victor Lustig's crimes, arrest, and death, including reporting from the Des Moines Register, The Evening Sun, and the St. Louis Globe-Democrat; United States Secret Service records relating to the 1935 investigation and raid that recovered counterfeit notes and printing plates, and Lustig's subsequent prosecution; Federal…
Not rated yetSon of Sam: Did David Berkowitz Act Alone? Pt. 3
· 42 min
Support Mugshot Mysteries and unlock 12+ bonus episodes on Patreon (https://www.patreon.com/c/MugshotMysteries) Yonkers, 1976. Above the Hudson sits the ruin of what was once the grandest garden estate in America, its terraces gone feral, its old stone gatehouse renamed the Devil's Cave by local teenagers. And through 1976 and into 1977, people walking the trails keep finding dead German shepherds. Nobody calls it a case, because it isn't one. A year later, a man from this same neighborhood confesses to eight shootings and blames a demon that lived in a dog. The city files that under madness and moves on. But the park is still there. So are the questions. This is Part 3 of our three-part Summer of Sam series, the finale, and it's everything that refused to stay closed after the guilty plea. Kathryn and Gabriel are upfront about what this episode is: some of it is documented record, and some of it rests on the word of one convicted, self-admitted liar and the lifelong work of one investigator. We hold both against the light and tell you exactly where the documentation stops. We start with the recant. Two years into his sentence, after surviving a throat-slashing in prison he refused to explain, David Berkowitz told the psychiatrist who examined him that the demon-dog story was an invention, built for an insanity defense he never used. He knew what he was doing. He did it anyway. That recant kills the demon, but it also proves, from his own mouth, that this man can lie convincingly for years, which stamps a warning on every word he says afterward, including everything still to come. We follow his 1987 conversion, his "Son of Hope" rebrand, and his decades of mostly declining to seek his own parole. Then the reporter. Maury Terry, a corporate writer who couldn't accept an answer with a hole in it, spent his life on the anomalies: police sketches that never matched each other or Berkowitz, a small yellow car at the final scene that was never his, timelines he couldn't make work for a single shooter. We're honest that anomaly-hunting on a huge case always yields loose ends, and also that Terry wasn't a lone crank, the Queens DA formally reopened his files in 1979 and publicly doubted the lone-gunman finding, though nothing was ever charged. Terry's 1987 book advanced a stark claim: not a man, but a network, an occult circle operating out of Yonkers with Berkowitz as one hand among several. We walk that chain link by link and mark every weak one. The Carr family, whose son John's real childhood nickname, "Wheaties," appeared in a Son of Sam letter a year before anyone connected the killer to that family, and who, with his brother Michael, died within twenty-six months of the arrest, one a ruled suicide, one a ruled car accident, neither ever questioned. We are explicit that these are dead men, never charged, and that the theory naming them as shooters comes largely from Berkowitz. We cover the park, the aqueduct trail, the dead dogs, and the real but never-charged Process Church at the far end of Terry's chain. And we stage the honest reckoning: in the 1990s prison tapes, Berkowitz assigned triggers only to people who were dead, sued, or otherwise unable to answer, and the single most checkable claim of the whole theory, that the network committed the 1974 Arlis Perry murder in California, collapsed in 2018 when DNA identified a lone Stanford security guard with no connection to any of it. We end where a case like this has to: unresolved. A closed case you can build honestly, one man and one gun. An open one you can build too, on real ground with soft patches. What you cannot do, fifty years on, is force both into one clean story. And we give the last human word to the survivors, who never got a hearing to skip. This concludes our three-part Summer of Sam series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For 12+ bonus episodes and deep dives, join us on Patreon…
Not rated yetSon of Sam: How a Parking Ticket Caught David Berkowitz Pt. 2
· 38 min
Brooklyn, July 31, 1977, a few minutes past two in the morning. A patrol officer writes up a yellow Ford Galaxie parked too close to a fire hydrant, tucks the ticket under the wiper, and drives on. He never looks inside the car. He has no reason to. That parking ticket will do more to end the biggest manhunt in NYPD history than hundreds of detectives managed in a year, and no one will understand its importance for another ten days. This is Part 2 of our three-part Summer of Sam series, and it's the letter, the blackout, the anniversary, and the ticket, the hunt and the end of the hunt. Late in this episode, for the first time in the series, the man gets a name. Kathryn and Gabriel open in the newsroom of the New York Daily News, where a second letter in familiar block capitals lands on the desk of columnist Jimmy Breslin, the outer boroughs' patron saint. Its opening line, "Hello from the gutters of N.Y.C.," becomes tabloid legend. When the paper runs it, circulation clears a million copies, and a shape with a gun becomes a voice, theatrical, taunting, and completely unafraid. We follow what that letter did: detonated an already-overwhelmed tip line, spawned a wave of fake copycat letters, and turned the promised anniversary of the first killing into a public countdown. The city doesn't get its quiet weeks. In late June, Judy Placido and Sal Lupo are shot in a parked car outside a Queens disco, both survive, on a night Judy had spent talking about how frightening the Son of Sam summer had become. We set it against the split screen of that exact moment: the peak of disco, Saturday Night Fever filming a few miles away, and police decoys sitting in the parking lots of the nightlife. Then July 13, when lightning knocks out power to nine million people for twenty-five hours in the middle of a heat wave. We cover the blackout honestly, the accidental block parties on one side, and on the other, over a thousand fires, some fifteen hundred stores looted, and the largest mass arrest in the city's history, and the pointed contrast with how calmly New York had handled the 1965 blackout, before the city was this frayed. Tellingly, the one thing that doesn't happen during the blackout is a Son of Sam shooting. Then the anniversary. The NYPD blankets the Bronx and Queens, the pattern boroughs, with the largest single-night deployment of the case. The date passes. Nothing. And in the early hours of July 31, he breaks his own pattern and strikes in Brooklyn, a borough the case had never touched, shooting Stacy Moskowitz and Robert Violante on their first date. Robert survives with catastrophic injury to his sight; Stacy, twenty years old, becomes the sixth and final person killed. She was blonde, shattering the long-dark-hair rule thousands of women had bought wigs to escape. And then the paper trail closes the case. A woman named Cacilia Davis, who walked her dog past the shooter minutes before, comes forward four days later with two things: his face, and the memory of a police cruiser ticketing cars on that block. Detectives pull every summons written in that sector that night. One car isn't local, a yellow Galaxie registered to an address in Yonkers, and a name: David Berkowitz. In one of the strangest coincidences in American crime, the detective's call to Yonkers is answered by a switchboard operator whose own father, Sam Carr, owned a dog Berkowitz was already suspected of shooting, the "Sam" the whole city had spent a summer trying to identify. We take you through the stakeout at 35 Pine Street, the arrest that took about a minute, the smiling twenty-four-year-old postal worker who asked what took them so long, the .44 in the paper bag, the confession and the demon-dog story, his guilty plea, and the courtroom explosion at sentencing. The man is caught. The case is closed. Which, on this show, is never quite the end. This is Part 2 of our three-part Summer of Sam series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot…
Not rated yetSon of Sam: Fear City and the Year New York Didn't Know Pt. 1
· 39 min
Summer 1975. Tourists landing at JFK are handed a pamphlet by off-duty police officers. On the cover is a hooded skull. The title is "Welcome to Fear City," and inside is a survival guide advising visitors to stay off the streets after six, never ride the subway, and if at all possible, not to come at all. It is a real document, printed by the unions representing the men whose job was protecting New York. The city is broke, burning, and shedding thousands of cops. And into that city, one year later, walks a man with a five-shot revolver chambered in .44. This is Part 1 of our three-part Summer of Sam series, and it covers the year before New York knew what it was afraid of. One note before you press play: this episode does not name him. For a full year the city didn't have a name either, and Kathryn and Gabriel keep it that way. Tonight he is what he was in 1976, a shape in the dark, a caliber, and eventually a letter. We begin with the city itself, because you cannot understand this case without it. A near-bankrupt New York, the famous "Ford to City: Drop Dead" headline, layoffs that gutted whole precincts, blocks of the Bronx burning, and a population that had learned to carry a private map of where you could and couldn't go. The map worked because street crime had rules: muggers want wallets. What arrives in July 1976 doesn't want anything. Then the attacks, in the order they happened and with the people at the center of them treated as people. Donna Lauria, eighteen, a medical technician, killed outside her own building in Pelham Bay while sitting in a parked car with her friend Jody Valenti, who survived. Carl Denaro, weeks from reporting to the Air Force, shot through a car window in Flushing. Donna DeMasi and Joanne Lomino, teenagers, approached on a stoop in Bellerose by a polite stranger asking directions. Christine Freund, twenty-six, killed in Forest Hills while she and her boyfriend talked about the engagement they both felt coming. And Virginia Voskerichian, nineteen, a Barnard student walking home from the subway at half past seven in the evening with her textbooks raised in front of her. We explain why it took eight months and five separate shootings for anyone to connect them: different boroughs, different precincts, different filing cabinets, in a department running on carbon paper and index cards while absorbing more than fifteen hundred murders a year. Hunting for a pattern was a luxury the NYPD of 1976 could not afford. Then, in March 1977, ballistics matched the bullet that killed Virginia Voskerichian to the one that killed Donna Lauria the previous July. Same gun. Two boroughs. One case. The commissioner and the mayor said it out loud on camera, the press named him for his weapon, and a city that had been afraid of everything learned what it feels like to be afraid of one specific thing. We close on the night in April 1977 that changed the investigation completely. Valentina Suriani and Alexander Esau are shot in a parked car in the Bronx, the fifth and sixth people killed. And this time the killer doesn't run. He leaves an envelope in the street, addressed by name to the police captain whose quotes had been in the papers all spring. Inside, in block capitals, is a letter arguing with his own press coverage, describing the streets as hunting ground, and introducing a name no one in New York had ever heard. Part 2 is the letter that lands on Jimmy Breslin's desk, the blackout, and the worst July in the city's memory. This is Part 1 of our three-part Summer of Sam series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: NYPD investigative records and public statements from the 1976-1977 .44 caliber case, including the March 1977 ballistics determination linking the killings of Virginia Voskerichian and Donna Lauria and the subsequent joint announcement by the police commissioner and the mayor; documentation of the Operation Omega task force under…
Not rated yetEscape from Alcatraz: Did They Survive? The 60-Year Manhunt Pt. 2
· 43 min
San Francisco, 2013. A letter arrives at a police station with no return address. The writer says his name is John Anglin. He says he escaped Alcatraz in June 1962 with his brother Clarence and Frank Morris. He says he is eighty-three now, and sick, and the last one left. And he makes an offer: promise me a year in prison and medical care, say it on television, and I will tell you exactly where I am. Fifty-one years of official history say the man who wrote that letter drowned in San Francisco Bay on the night of the escape. The letter has one sentence for the official history: yes, we all made it that night, but barely. This is Part 2 of our two-part Alcatraz series, and it's everything that came after the raft slipped into the dark: the manhunt, the ending the government wrote, and the sixty-four years of cards, photographs, experiments, and one letter that keep prying that ending back open. The whole episode lives inside a single gap, three men declared dead, and not one body ever recovered. Kathryn and Gabriel walk the largest manhunt the Bay had ever seen, Coast Guard cutters, Army helicopters, soldiers beating the brush of Angel Island, and the strange days that followed: a handmade paddle recovered, a waterproofed packet of the brothers' letters and photos, shreds of raincoat, a life vest with teeth marks on the valve, and a body glimpsed from a freighter beyond the Golden Gate that no one ever saw again. On land, the quieter half of the hunt turned up nothing, no stolen car, no burglary, no missing boat, which the FBI read as men who never made it ashore. We cover why the Bureau needed a specific thing to be true (in twenty-eight years, missing had always meant drowned, because the alternative meant Alcatraz had finally lost), and the two events that quietly punched holes in that certainty: the inmate who swam to shore alive with inflated kitchen gloves six months later, and the closure of the prison itself nine months after the escape. Then the parts that keep the file breathing. The Anglin family's decades of accounts, the Christmas cards their mother received in her sons' familiar handwriting, the roses with no name, the two unusually tall strangers at her funeral, told here as what the family has long maintained, not as established fact. The 1975 Brazil photograph and the childhood friend who produced it seventeen years later with a story that contradicted the raft entirely, examined honestly from both sides, one analyst calling it likely the brothers, working investigators calling it impossible to verify. And the science that reframed everything: the MythBusters raft that reached the Marin shore intact, and the Dutch hydraulic model of the Bay that ran the actual tides of that night and found the answer was never really about the water. It was about the clock. Launch before eleven and the ebb takes you to sea; launch closer to midnight and it carries you, cold and off-target, onto land near the Golden Gate. And the debris the government held up as proof of drowning drifts, in the model, exactly where the leftovers of a successful landing would. We end back at that 2013 letter, the inconclusive lab results, the televised sentence that was never spoken, the family that didn't learn the page existed until 2018, and the Point Reyes remains that DNA finally excluded. The FBI's answer is probable drowning. The Marshals still hold active warrants. And no one, in sixty-four years, has ever proven either ending. This concludes our two-part Alcatraz series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. SOURCES: The FBI case file on the June 1962 Alcatraz escape, now digitized and publicly available, including the Bureau's December 1979 conclusion of probable drowning; the U.S. Marshals Service's ongoing investigation and active warrants, its statements that the case remains open, and its 2022 age-progressed images of the three men; documentation of the recovery of the paddle, the sealed packet of the Anglins' belongings,…
Not rated yetEscape from Alcatraz: How 3 Men Beat the Rock Pt. 1
· 46 min
June 12, 1962. 7:15 in the morning, Alcatraz. A guard reaches through the bars of cell 138 to wake a sleeping inmate, and the man's head rolls off the pillow and shatters on the concrete. It is made of soap, toilet paper, and real human hair. Frank Morris has been gone for nine hours. And he is not the only one. On the most secure island in America, a prison the government spent twenty-eight years promising could not be beaten, three convicted bank robbers have just walked out through walls they dug with sharpened spoons, past guards who spent all night saying goodnight to dummy heads. This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel bring you something rare for this show, a story where, as far as anyone can prove, everybody walks away. Part 1 of two: how they did it. We start with the Rock itself, the twenty-two acres of salt-corroded stone that held Al Capone and Machine Gun Kelly, and the real secret of its security, which was never the bars. It was the water: a mile of fifty-two-degree Bay with a current that pulls out to sea. The Bureau let the myth of sharks and freezing death do its work, because fear of the water was free security, right up until the day the wrong three men stopped being afraid of it. We meet them: Frank Morris, an abandoned foster kid with a 133 IQ and a résumé of institutions he kept escaping, and brothers John and Clarence Anglin, Georgia field hands who grew up swimming in cold Lake Michigan and never stopped trying to break out of anywhere together, until the federal system solved the problem of two inseparable escape artists by reuniting them on an island. Then the plan, which plays like a comedy until the moment it doesn't. A load-bearing wall poured in 1912 and left to rot in salt air until it crumbled like stale cake. Spoon handles sharpened into chisels. An accordion during the warden's new "music hour" to cover the sound of digging. A hidden workshop on top of the cell block, behind blankets the guards themselves approved. And out of the Bureau's own inventory, more than fifty stolen government-issue raincoats, vulcanized against steam pipes into a six-by-fourteen raft, with life vests, plywood paddles, and a gutted concertina repurposed as an air pump. The dummy heads, sculpted from soap and prison dust and finished with hair swept off the barbershop floor, that let three men be in bed and gone at the same time. We take you through the night itself hour by hour: the loosened roof cap that rang out like a gunshot and was swallowed by the prison's own certainty that no one escapes; the climb down a kitchen vent pipe; the fences; and the raft inflating at the waterline by accordion. And the fourth man, Allen West, still clawing at the one patch of good concrete on the whole island, the cement he'd poured himself, who came up into the empty workshop to find open sky and no ride. When the siren finally sounded at 7:15 the next morning, three men were gone into the dark water of the Bay, and no one had the slightest idea where. Where they went is Part 2. This is Part 1 of our two-part Alcatraz series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: Records of the June 1962 escape from Alcatraz Federal Penitentiary, including the FBI case file and the U.S. Marshals Service's still-open investigation; Bureau of Prisons documentation of the island's operation, costs, security procedures, and physical deterioration; the account of the surviving fourth participant, Allen West, and the physical evidence recovered from the cells, the utility corridor, and the rooftop, including the dummy heads, the tools, and the raincoat-raft materials, later documented in the official investigation and in exhibits held by the National Park Service, which now administers Alcatraz; histories of the prison's earlier escape attempts, including the 1937 disappearance of Theodore Cole and Ralph Roe, the 1945 attempt by John Giles, and the 1946 "Battle of Alcatraz";…
Not rated yetThe DC Sniper: One Got the Needle. The Other Is Still Inside. Pt. 3
· 41 min
November 10, 2009. Inside a Virginia execution chamber, the man at the center of one of the most infamous killing sprees in American history is asked if he has any final words. He says nothing. No confession, no apology, no reason, the same thing he offered every stranger he killed. Minutes later, John Allen Muhammad is pronounced dead. If this were a simpler story, that would be the ending. But the seventeen-year-old pulled from that car beside him is very much alive, and the courts of this country will spend the next fifteen years arguing not about whether he did it, but about what he is. Same crimes. Two completely different questions. One got answered with a needle. The other may never close. This is Part 3 of our three-part DC Sniper series: the reckoning. Kathryn and Gabriel open with the strange auction that decided where these men would be tried, six jurisdictions competing, and a federal government that chose Virginia in part precisely because it could execute a juvenile. We walk Muhammad's trial and the legal knot at its center: Virginia largely reserved the death penalty for the person who pulled the trigger, and with two shooters and a car built so either could fire unseen from the trunk, the state often couldn't prove which man fired the fatal round. So prosecutors reached for a post-9/11 antiterrorism statute and built their capital case on the ransom letter he'd pinned to a tree. The mastermind was, in the end, sentenced to die less for any shot than for what he wrote. And the motive this whole series has argued, that the target was always his ex-wife Mildred and the strangers were camouflage, was ruled not sufficiently proven and kept out of the courtroom entirely. We're honest with you about exactly what that means: it's what the evidence convinces us of, believed by investigators and by Mildred herself, but never declared by a jury. Then the second trial, and the harder question. Lee Boyd Malvo's jury was asked not whether he did it but what he was. The defense put the grooming itself on trial, the abandonment, the control, the indoctrination laid out in Part 2. The jury rejected the insanity defense but also refused to recommend death, landing on the honest, difficult verdict of responsible, but still a child. We follow the law slowly catching up to that instinct, from Roper v. Simmons ending the juvenile death penalty, through Miller and Montgomery, to Malvo's own case reaching the Supreme Court, and then dissolving unresolved when Virginia changed its law underneath it. Today he remains in prison, parole denied once, a Maryland resentencing he legally won now indefinitely postponed because two neighboring states cannot arrange to get him into the same room. We also tell the reckoning that has nothing to do with either man: the rifle, stolen from a Tacoma gun shop that had lost hundreds of firearms, and the victims' families whose lawsuit produced the first time a gun maker paid for the criminal use of its weapon, a door Congress promptly bricked shut, and a fight the Sandy Hook families would pick up years later. And we close on the question the whole series has been building toward: how much of what a groomed child does belongs to the child, and how much to the man who built him. This concludes our three-part DC Sniper series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: Court records, trial proceedings, and sentencing from the Virginia prosecutions of John Allen Muhammad (for the murder of Dean Harold Meyers) and Lee Boyd Malvo (for the murder of Linda Franklin), the subsequent Maryland prosecutions, and Malvo's Alford pleas in Spotsylvania County; the Virginia antiterrorism statute under which Muhammad was charged and the Virginia Supreme Court's affirmance; documentation of Muhammad's November 10, 2009 execution at Greensville Correctional Center, Governor Timothy Kaine's denial of clemency, and the U.S. Supreme Court's denial of a stay with…
Not rated yetThe DC Sniper: The Woman Who Knew Who the Killer Was Pt. 2
· 32 min
While five million people were afraid of a stranger, one woman was afraid of a name. She lived in the Maryland suburbs of Washington with her three children, watched the same coverage as everyone else, the faceless sniper, the white van, the lone white male the experts kept describing, and did not believe a word of it. Because she was the one person in America who understood that this was not really about strangers at all. Her ex-husband had given himself a new name the year before: John Allen Muhammad. For two years she had been telling anyone who would listen that he intended to kill her. The country spent twenty-three days asking who and why. She never had to ask either one. This is Part 2 of our three-part DC Sniper series, and it answers the question Part 1 left hanging: the randomness was the design. Kathryn and Gabriel trace the case back years before the killings began. We follow John Allen Muhammad, born John Allen Williams, from a cold childhood in Louisiana through the Army, where he qualified as an expert marksman, not, despite what the country was told for three weeks, a trained military sniper, just a soldier the Army certified could put a round where he aimed. We cover the troubled service record and an unproven wartime allegation, and then the thing that actually explains everything: a marriage to Mildred that curdled into control and fear, a custody fight, protective orders, and the moment in 2000 when he abducted all three of their children and vanished overseas for more than a year. The grievance everyone went hunting for, a cause, a faith, a politics, was never there. The real motive was a custody order. Then the darker thread: Antigua, where a man who collected children met a quiet, badly neglected, fatherless teenager named Lee Boyd Malvo. We walk, carefully, through what the record describes as grooming, the control of diet, body, schedule, and mind, the rifle training that left rounds buried in a tree stump for investigators to find later, and the slow remaking of a lonely boy into an instrument. By the time the shooting started, the partner pulled from that car may not have been a partner at all. How much of what Malvo did belongs to Malvo is the question we hold for Part 3. We lay out the grandiose plan Malvo later described, the ten-million-dollar extortion, the fantasized compound and army of recruited boys, and the cross-country trail of earlier shootings, in at least seven states, that no one connected until both men were caught. And we arrive at the answer that reframes the entire case: of every city in America, why Washington? Because that is where Mildred had moved to get away from him. The map of the terror was drawn around her front door. Ten strangers were not killed instead of her. They were killed so that her death, when it came, would vanish into the noise as one more random name on the list. He came within one undelivered shot of walking away clean from his own wife's murder. The person who understood this case most completely, from the first week, was the woman it was built to kill. This is Part 2 of our three-part DC Sniper series. New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. SOURCES: Court records and trial proceedings from the Virginia and Maryland prosecutions of John Allen Muhammad and Lee Boyd Malvo, including Malvo's own later accounts of the plan and the period of his recruitment; the U.S. Army service record of John Allen Muhammad, including his marksmanship qualification, and reporting on the unproven Gulf War allegation against him; family-court and custody records and protective orders relating to Mildred Muhammad, and her own subsequent memoir and public advocacy describing the marriage, the 2000 abduction of the children, and her belief during the spree that she was the intended target; documentation of the earlier 2002 shootings later attributed to the pair across multiple states, including the killing of Keenya Cook in…
Not rated yet