Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The DC Sniper: One Got the Needle. The Other Is Still Inside. Pt. 3

From Mugshot Mysteries · · 41 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

November 10, 2009. Inside a Virginia execution chamber, the man at the center of one of the most infamous killing sprees in American history is asked if he has any final words. He says nothing. No confession, no apology, no reason, the same thing he offered every stranger he killed. Minutes later, John Allen Muhammad is pronounced dead. If this were a simpler story, that would be the ending. But the seventeen-year-old pulled from that car beside him is very much alive, and the courts of this country will spend the next fifteen years arguing not about whether he did it, but about what he is. Same crimes. Two completely different questions. One got answered with a needle. The other may never close.

This is Part 3 of our three-part DC Sniper series: the reckoning.

Kathryn and Gabriel open with the strange auction that decided where these men would be tried, six jurisdictions competing, and a federal government that chose Virginia in part precisely because it could execute a juvenile. We walk Muhammad's trial and the legal knot at its center: Virginia largely reserved the death penalty for the person who pulled the trigger, and with two shooters and a car built so either could fire unseen from the trunk, the state often couldn't prove which man fired the fatal round. So prosecutors reached for a post-9/11 antiterrorism statute and built their capital case on the ransom letter he'd pinned to a tree. The mastermind was, in the end, sentenced to die less for any shot than for what he wrote. And the motive this whole series has argued, that the target was always his ex-wife Mildred and the strangers were camouflage, was ruled not sufficiently proven and kept out of the courtroom entirely. We're honest with you about exactly what that means: it's what the evidence convinces us of, believed by investigators and by Mildred herself, but never declared by a jury.

Then the second trial, and the harder question. Lee Boyd Malvo's jury was asked not whether he did it but what he was. The defense put the grooming itself on trial, the abandonment, the control, the indoctrination laid out in Part 2. The jury rejected the insanity defense but also refused to recommend death, landing on the honest, difficult verdict of responsible, but still a child. We follow the law slowly catching up to that instinct, from Roper v. Simmons ending the juvenile death penalty, through Miller and Montgomery, to Malvo's own case reaching the Supreme Court, and then dissolving unresolved when Virginia changed its law underneath it. Today he remains in prison, parole denied once, a Maryland resentencing he legally won now indefinitely postponed because two neighboring states cannot arrange to get him into the same room.

We also tell the reckoning that has nothing to do with either man: the rifle, stolen from a Tacoma gun shop that had lost hundreds of firearms, and the victims' families whose lawsuit produced the first time a gun maker paid for the criminal use of its weapon, a door Congress promptly bricked shut, and a fight the Sandy Hook families would pick up years later. And we close on the question the whole series has been building toward: how much of what a groomed child does belongs to the child, and how much to the man who built him.

This concludes our three-part DC Sniper series.

New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen.

SOURCES:

Court records, trial proceedings, and sentencing from the Virginia prosecutions of John Allen Muhammad (for the murder of Dean Harold Meyers) and Lee Boyd Malvo (for the murder of Linda Franklin), the subsequent Maryland prosecutions, and Malvo's Alford pleas in Spotsylvania County; the Virginia antiterrorism statute under which Muhammad was charged and the Virginia Supreme Court's affirmance; documentation of Muhammad's November 10, 2009 execution at Greensville Correctional Center, Governor Timothy Kaine's denial of clemency, and the U.S. Supreme Court's denial of a stay with…

Back to Mugshot Mysteries · Report a problem