Christa Pike: The Murder, the Death Sentence, and the Execution That Failed
From Mugshot Mysteries · · 49 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
Please note: this episode discusses a brutal murder, child abuse, and a failed execution in graphic detail. Please take care while listening.
On the night of September 30, 2026, the state of Tennessee tried to execute Christa Gail Pike, the only woman on its death row, and the first woman it had attempted to put to death in over two centuries. It did not work. After an execution team spent roughly fifty minutes and some ten needles trying to establish an IV line, after two full doses of pentobarbital, after witnesses heard her say “I feel like my arm is about to bust, it burns,” Christa Pike did not die. At 8:40 p.m. the prison called 911. An ambulance carried her to a hospital, where she was expected to be declared brain dead, and where, days later, she woke up and asked where she was. The Death Penalty Information Center called it the first time anyone has ever survived being injected with lethal doses of execution drugs. This is her story, and it’s the story of the nineteen-year-old she murdered.
This is a hard episode, and Kathryn and Gabriel tell it carefully, holding the victim at its center. Because before any of what happened in that chamber, there was Colleen Slemmer.
We go back to a federal Job Corps center in Knoxville in January 1995, where four teenagers signed out of a dormitory one winter night and three signed back in. We tell what happened to Colleen Slemmer, a nineteen-year-old studying computers, lured to an abandoned steam plant on the false promise of a truce and tortured for the better part of an hour over Pike’s baseless jealousy about a boy, a killing so savage the medical examiner said the skull was shattered, with a pentagram carved into her chest. We cover Pike’s taped confession, the fragment of Colleen’s skull she carried back in her pocket and showed off at breakfast, and the detail a jury would weigh heavily: that she returned to the scene to watch the police work it.
We examine the case honestly. The Satanic-Panic framing that made it famous (and the plainer truth that a sign-out log and a search solved it, not a cult). The trial, the rejected plea deal, and the mitigation her jury never heard, a childhood of almost unimaginable abuse and neglect, documented in binders that stayed in a box. The wildly different outcomes for her two co-defendants. And why Pike shattered the established profile of women who kill, drawing on researcher Marissa Harrison’s landmark study and the show’s recurring thread about how courts treat women at the defense table, from Lizzie Borden’s acquittal to Pike’s death sentence in under ninety minutes.
Then the chamber, reconstructed minute by minute from her attorney’s sworn declaration, and the competing theories for what went wrong: blown veins, a protocol with no page for a failed second dose, a physician who was also present at an hour-long failed execution months earlier, and Pike’s own blood disorder, which her lawyers had warned about in January. And we lay out the question no court has ever truly had to answer, whether a state that completed an execution and failed can lawfully try again, walking through the chilling precedents of Willie Francis and Romell Broom. Throughout, we return to where this has to return: Colleen Slemmer was nineteen. Remember her name.
Note: This episode reflects the case as of late October 2026 and it is developing rapidly. As of recording, Christa Pike had survived, returned to prison, and issued a public statement; a state-ordered review was underway; her method-of-execution lawsuit and a clemency request to the governor were pending; and no court had decided whether Tennessee may attempt a second execution. Please consult current reporting for the latest.
New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen. For bonus episodes, join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/MugshotMysteries
Stay curious. Stay kind.
SOURCES:
The sworn 108-paragraph declaration of attorney Randy Spivey, who…