Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Colonial Parkway Murders: America's Forgotten Serial Killer

From Mugshot Mysteries · · 54 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

October 12, 1986. A park ranger on Virginia's Colonial Parkway finds a white Honda with the engine still running and two young women dead in the back seat, their throats cut. Cathleen Thomas, a 27-year-old naval officer, and Rebecca Dowski, a 21-year-old college student, had been on a date the night before. Over the next three years, three more young couples will vanish or be found murdered along the same dark, wooded stretch of historic roadway. Eight victims in all. Some shot, some with their throats cut, two never found at all. Thirty-eight years later, no one has ever been charged. This is the Colonial Parkway Murders, one of America's most brutal unsolved serial cases, and one almost nobody talks about.

This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel give this forgotten case the deep, careful treatment it deserves, and approach the still-living suspects with real caution, because no one has ever been arrested.

We start with the place, a beautiful 23-mile scenic drive between Jamestown, Williamsburg, and Yorktown by day, and an unlit, isolated lovers' lane by night. Then the four cases, one by one, with respect for who these young people were: Cathleen Thomas and Rebecca Dowski in 1986; David Knobling and Robin Edwards, found shot at Ragged Island in 1987; Richard Call and Cassandra Hailey, who vanished in 1988 and have never been found; and Annamaria Phelps and Daniel Lauer, whose remains were discovered off Interstate 64 in 1989. Then the murders simply stopped.

We dig into why this case has stayed cold for so long, starting with the jurisdictional nightmare, federal park land, multiple county sheriffs, state police, and the FBI all holding pieces of what may be one case, with the inter-agency friction that came with it. We walk the leading theories evenhandedly: one evolving serial killer versus a team versus copycats, and the persistent law-enforcement theory, that the killer used a badge or the appearance of authority to get couples to stop on a dark road without a struggle, which would also explain the geographic knowledge and the lack of evidence. We cover the genuinely strange Fred Atwell episode and the leaked crime-scene photos that re-traumatized a victim's family, while being clear about what is and isn't actually known. And we treat the various people investigated over the decades for exactly what they are: persons of interest who were never charged, several of whom have denied any involvement.

Finally, the hope: genetic genealogy, the technology that caught the Golden State Killer, and whether usable DNA from these 1980s scenes could still crack the case. And the families, especially Cathleen's brother Bill Thomas, who has fought for decades and just wants answers before he dies. If you know something, the FBI tip line is 1-800-CALL-FBI, or tips.fbi.gov.

This is the Colonial Parkway Murders.

New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen.

SOURCES:

FBI and Virginia State Police records and public statements on the Colonial Parkway Murders cold case; contemporaneous and retrospective reporting on the four incidents and eight victims: Cathleen Thomas and Rebecca Dowski (October 1986), David Knobling and Robin Edwards (September 1987), Richard Call and Cassandra Hailey (April 1988, still missing), and Annamaria Phelps and Daniel Lauer (September 1989); reporting on the jurisdictional structure of the investigation across the National Park Service, the FBI, and multiple Virginia county and state agencies, and the FBI Behavioral Science Unit profile; coverage of the 2014 incident in which leaked crime-scene photographs were sent to a victim's family, and the resulting FBI internal review; the public advocacy and Congressional testimony of Bill Thomas, brother of Cathleen Thomas; television treatments including segments on Unsolved Mysteries, America's Most Wanted, and the 2018 Oxygen documentary on the case; and general reporting on investigative genetic genealogy,…

Back to Mugshot Mysteries · Report a problem