Skip to main content
AmigoFish

This Constitution

Savannah Eccles Johnston & Matthew BrogdonAudio

Format:
Podcast
New episodes:
Every two weeks
Typical length:
about 35 minutes
Latest episode:
Not rated yet

About this show

This Constitution is an every-two-weeks podcast ordained and established by the Center for Constitutional Studies at Utah Valley University, the home of Utah’s Civic Thought & Leadership Initiative.

Co-hosted by Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon, This Constitution equips listeners with the knowledge and insights to engage with the most pressing political questions of our time, starting with Season 1, focusing on the powers and limits of the U.S. presidency.

Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at rss.buzzsprout.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.

Cosmos

Similar by topic and creator

  • Dialogue Works
    Shares the topics Education, History and News and Politics.
  • Perun
    Shares the topics Education, History and News and Politics.
  • Plain Civics
    Shares the topics Education, History and News and Politics.

See the full Cosmos

Similar shows

See all Education shows

Explore more

Episodes

  • Season 4, Episode 15 | Disobeying Congress and Double-Crossing the French: The Treaty of Paris

    · 35 min

    The Revolutionary War ended at Yorktown, but the American Revolution was not over until the ink dried in Paris. After the British defeat at Yorktown, American independence was within reach. But securing it meant navigating competing interests, suspicious allies, difficult negotiations, and a Congress that struggled to get its members in the same room. In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon explore the Treaty of Paris of 1783 and the diplomatic negotiations that officially ended the American Revolution. They begin with Benjamin West's unfinished painting of the peace commissioners and the political fallout of Yorktown, including Lord North's resignation and Britain's growing anti-war movement. The conversation turns to America's complicated alliance with France and Spain, the competing goals of the three partners, and the role of British Prime Minister Shelburne in shaping the peace. Savannah explains how Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, and John Jay went beyond Congress's instructions, negotiated directly with the British, and secured terms that included independence, expanded western boundaries, and valuable fishing rights. They also examine the treaty's promises that went unfulfilled, including the restoration of Loyalist property, protections against wartime prosecutions, and the British withdrawal without taking enslaved people or other American property. The discussion explores the evacuation of approximately 3,000 Black men, women, and children from New York, the weakness of Congress under the Articles of Confederation, and the challenges of enforcing agreements when the national government depended on state cooperation. Tune in to discover how the Treaty of Paris ended the American Revolution, exposed the weaknesses of America's first government, and helped set the stage for the Constitutional Convention. In This Episode - [00:04] Benjamin West's unfinished painting - [01:09] After Yorktown: Lord North resigns - [03:54] Diplomats, alliances, and a winning coalition with different goals - [05:34] Britain regains ground and France wants out - [06:48] Richard Oswald and the American commissioners - [08:17] Congress’s instructions: follow the French - [09:04] Franklin opens talks and Jay arrives suspicious - [10:32] Vergennes’s secretary goes to London - [12:16] Adams’s distrust of the French pays off - [13:54] The preliminary articles and the Treaty of Alliance loophole - [14:36] Franklin’s tact and a new French loan - [15:31] Were the commissioners right to disobey Congress? - [17:53] Independence: “free, sovereign, and independent states” - [20:13] New boundaries and the Native nations left out - [21:23] How much land America gained - [24:09] Fishing rights and the Grand Banks - [26:44] The terms the states ignored - [28:12] Enslaved people, Black loyalists, and the New York evacuation - [31:18] Why Congress could only “urge” the states - [32:18] Mississippi navigation and West Florida - [35:07] The ratification scramble in Annapolis - [36:34] Signing the treaty at the Hôtel de York Notable Quotes - (05:21) “He thinks that a generous peace agreement with the Americans will pull the U.S. away from France and keep us as trading partners with the British.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston on Shelburne's strategy - (07:24) “What we’re about to tell you is the story of how the commissioners disobeyed Congress, sidestepped the French, and got a way-better deal as a result.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (08:50) “This feels like Congress saying, guys, be the JV team.” — Matthew Brogdon - (15:12) “I don’t think temerity was on it anywhere, but it should have been.” — Matthew Brogdon on Franklin’s list of virtues - (17:25) “We didn’t break the rules. This is diplomacy and war for that matter. We just killed tens of thousands of people to do this.” — Matthew Brogdon - (19:04) “In some ways it’s even more guarded than the Declaration of Independence itself.” —…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 14 | The Untold Story of Yorktown: Hamilton, Washington, and the French

    · 32 min

    The Battle of Yorktown marked a turning point in the American Revolution, leading to the British surrender on October 19, 1781. But how did George Washington and his allies achieve this decisive victory? In this episode of This Constitution, hosts Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon explore the military strategies, international alliances, and pivotal decisions that led to Britain's defeat. From the failure of Britain's southern strategy and Washington's secret march to Virginia to the French naval victory at the Battle of the Capes, they examine how American and French forces successfully trapped General Cornwallis at Yorktown. They also discuss Alexander Hamilton's daring assault on Redoubt 10, the contributions of Black soldiers and French troops, Cornwallis's failed escape attempts, and Washington's uncompromising surrender terms. Ultimately, the episode reveals why Yorktown effectively ended Britain's hopes of winning the war and how cooperation between American, French, and Spanish forces helped secure American independence, paving the way for the Treaty of Paris in 1783. Key Takeaways - The French naval victory at the Battle of the Capes prevented British reinforcements from reaching Cornwallis. - Washington's deception and the coordinated American-French march helped set the stage for victory. - Alexander Hamilton's successful assault on Redoubt 10 was a critical moment in the siege. - The contributions of French troops, American militia, Black soldiers, and Spanish financial support demonstrate the international nature of the victory. - Yorktown made continued British military efforts increasingly untenable and paved the way for the Treaty of Paris in 1783. In This Episode - [00:00] The British surrender at Yorktown - [01:02] Why Britain's Southern Strategy failed - [03:25] Washington and Rochambeau's strategic decision - [05:42] The secret march to Virginia - [07:27] Rochambeau's respect for Washington's leadership - [09:21] Virginia under British attack - [11:33] The French fleet and the Battle of the Capes - [13:37] The siege of Yorktown begins - [17:03] Alexander Hamilton and the assault on Redoubt 10 - [20:23] Black soldiers and the diverse Revolutionary forces - [22:40] Cornwallis's failed escape and counterattack - [24:38] Washington's uncompromising surrender terms - [27:27] The surrender ceremony at Yorktown - [29:04] Why Yorktown marked the beginning of the end - [30:54] The international alliance that secured victory Notable Quotes - "The Battle of Yorktown shows just how important our alliances were.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - "You've got the militia, you've got the Continentals. This was a group effort, and one of those times when you kinda have to be a little grateful to the French." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - "Battle of Yorktown is the end of the American Revolutionary War, but it was an international effort." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - "There is no victory without the land forces prevailing, but the conditions for that victory are a naval victory in the Chesapeake." — Matthew Brogdon - "You're at war with America. We're here to help them." — Matthew Brogdon (paraphrasing Rochambeau) - "It was Spanish gold, French ships, plucky American troops." — Matthew Brogdon Resources and Links This Constitution - Apple Podcast:https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/this-constitution/id1771900485 - Spotify:https://open.spotify.com/show/0IQCq5DUPWlImiAdc4t3pf?si=85085b24b55b4130 - Website:https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/projects/this_constitution_podcast.html - YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@centerforconstitutionalstu8915/videos Savannah Eccles Johnston - https://www.linkedin.com/in/savannah-eccles-johnston-515a72198 - https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/people/savannah_eccles_johnston.html Matthew Brogdon - https://www.linkedin.com/in/matthew-brogdon-8a21bb89/ - https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/people/matthew_brogdon.html

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 13 | "Remember the Ladies: From Political Invisibility to Revolutionary Backlash

    · 42 min

    Women in colonial America were legally invisible. Married women could not own property, vote, serve on juries, or speak publicly on politics. Yet the American Revolution was a watershed, inviting women into political life as boycotters, writers, and even voters. What opened that window, and why did it close so abruptly? In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston sits down with Rosemarie Zagarri, distinguished university professor of history at George Mason University and author of Revolutionary Backlash: Women and Politics in the Early American Republic. Together they trace women's political engagement from the colonial period through the Revolution, the 1790s, and the backlash that followed, and how it all foreshadowed 1848. They begin with the legal and social position of women before 1776, when politics was understood as an exclusively male realm. The conversation turns to how the Revolution's bottom-up resistance movement, including tax protests, boycotts, and the Daughters of Liberty, pulled women in for practical reasons: they were the chief purchasers of British goods. Zagarri explains how women like Mercy Otis Warren and Phillis Wheatley moved from private sentiment to public political authorship, and how Abigail Adams's "Remember the Ladies" captured the unintended consequences of revolutionary rhetoric. The episode explores New Jersey's 1776 constitution, whose gender-neutral language allowed unmarried women and widows with property to vote. Zagarri details how the rise of political parties in the 1790s led both Federalists and Democratic-Republicans to court female supporters, and how the 1807 New Jersey legislature disenfranchised women and free Blacks amid fraud accusations. The backlash, she argues, was reinforced by new "scientific" claims about bodily difference and the ideology of separate spheres. The conversation closes with republican motherhood, women's continued reform work, and the long road to Seneca Falls. Tune in to discover how the Revolution opened a window for women's political participation, and why that window, though forced shut, never fully closed. In This Episode - [00:07] Meet Rosemarie Zagarri - [47] Women before the Revolution: legally invisible - [03:13] How the Revolution activated women as political actors - [10:20] Women's ideological involvement: Mercy Otis Warren and Phillis Wheatley - [14:12] Did revolutionary ideology open the door to challenges against male authority? - [16:12] Unintended consequences and New Jersey's gender-neutral constitution - [19:16] The 1790s: parties court women as political participants - [23:51] The backlash and the 1807 disenfranchisement in New Jersey - [24:39] Voter fraud accusations and the story of women's removal from the polls - [28:13] Science, separate spheres, and the justification of male hierarchy - [37:11] Republican motherhood: step forward or sophisticated exclusion? - [38:40] Education, reform movements, and the road to 1848 - [42:15] Why this forgotten story matters Notable Quotes - (00:59) "The American Revolution was a watershed for women and their engagement with politics." — Rosemarie Zagarri - (04:45) "Male political leaders quickly understood that they would have to invite people into this political process that couldn't vote, and that meant lower-class white men. And it also meant women." — Rosemarie Zagarri - (14:16) "It was one of the unintended consequences of the revolutionary rhetoric... that women started to see themselves as political participants, as political actors." — Rosemarie Zagarri - (22:17) "Even if they didn't want women to vote, they would like women on their side." — Rosemarie Zagarri on the first political parties - (26:14) "Men were dressing up like women to cast their ballots... It was the easiest target to attack." — Rosemarie Zagarri on the 1807 New Jersey election - (30:23) "There grew up this literature sanctioned by science which actually started to claim that…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 12 | Was the Constitution Anti-Slavery? How Frederick Douglass Changed His Mind

    · 40 min

    America was born with a promise and a lie. Frederick Douglass lived in the gap. How did a fugitive slave become one of the nation’s most radical constitutional thinkers? Why did he reject the Garrisonian view of the Constitution as a “covenant with death” and come to see it as anti-slavery? In this episode of This Constitution, Matthew Brogdon sits down with Bradley Rebeiro, law professor at Brigham Young University and author of Until the Last Yoke Is Broken: The Constitutional Vision of Frederick Douglass. Together they trace slavery and race from the Revolution through Dred Scott, the Civil War, and Reconstruction. They begin with slavery in 1776, Somerset v. Stewart, Black enlistment in the Continental Army, Lord Dunmore’s Proclamation, and gradual emancipation in the North. The conversation turns to Black citizenship, the Naturalization Act of 1790, and Dred Scott’s claim that Blacks had “no rights which white men are bound to respect.” Rebeiro explains Douglass’s response that Taney could not change the nature of things by his words, and his view that the executive may interpret the Constitution independently. The episode explores Douglass’s 1852 “Change of Opinion Announced,” his break with Garrisonians, and his argument that the Constitution was anti-slavery in principle but betrayed in administration. That conviction drove his push for Black enlistment and his focus on suffrage as the hallmark of citizenship. Tune in to discover how Douglass’s “rational hope” challenges America to meet its founding principles. In This Episode - [00:08] Meet Brad Rebeiro - [00:47] Slavery in 1776 - [02:25] Somerset v. Stewart and natural law - [05:09] Black enlistment in the Revolution - [06:49] Gradual abolition and the Hamilton–Laurens plan - [09:33] Lord Dunmore and Britain's offer of freedom - [11:22] No clear sides for the enslaved - [13:56] Citizenship at the founding - [16:23] Taney's opinion in Dred Scott - [18:13] The dissents and the founding record - [19:35] Black voters and the ratifying conventions - [21:28] The 14th Amendment and birthright citizenship - [23:33] Frederick Douglass in public life - [25:30] Douglass answers Dred Scott - [27:59] Douglass and departmentalism - [29:16] From Garrisonian to constitutional abolitionist - [30:37] "Change of Opinion Announced" - [33:04] Why Douglass wanted Black soldiers - [34:33] Douglass meets Lincoln - [38:31] Suffrage after the Civil War - [40:50] Bringing it back to the Revolution - [43:20] Douglass's "rational hope" Notable Quotes - (02:59) “Unless you have a law specifically mandating or protecting one's property in slavery, you must free that slave.” - Brad Rebeiro - (16:58) “I respect the founders too much to think that they meant for the Declaration to be applied to Blacks because they were enslaving them.” — Brad Rebeiro on Taney’s reasoning in Dred Scott - (25:54) “There are certain rights that derive from the natural law that are eternal principles and that are held equally by all individuals.” - Brad Rebeiro - (30:49) “The Constitution, he now believes, is an anti-slavery document. It's not this covenant with death, an agreement with hell that the Garrisonians had initially espoused.” - Brad Rebeiro - (33:53) “What better way to show your allegiance and that your allegiance means something than showing it on the battlefield?” - Brad Rebeiro - (39:10) “He is almost exclusively focused on one thing, suffrage, voting rights. That for him is the hallmark of true citizenship.” - Brad Rebeiro - (43:25) “The Founding Fathers seized on eternal principles.” - Brad Rebeiro - (43:51) “The skies, they’re stormy, but they’re not rayless.” — Brad Rebeiro on Douglass’s “rational hope” - (44:27) “They actually penned in eternal principles, aspirational principles. And that's why he called at least the American project a rational hope.” - Brad Rebeiro Resources and Links This Constitution - Apple…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 11 | The Newburgh Conspiracy: When Washington Saved the Republic (Again)

    · 42 min

    Could the American Revolution have ended not on a battlefield, but in a mutinous meeting at Newburgh? What happens when the army that won independence is told there’s no money to pay it? Can a republic survive when its officers have just grievances and the power to enforce them? And how did George Washington stop a coup without firing a shot, by reaching for his spectacles? In this episode of The Constitution, Matthew Brogdon sits down with Greg Jackson, America 250 Professor in Constitutional Studies at UVU, history faculty member, National Security Studies Program fellow, and author of Been There, Done That: How Our History Shows What We Can Overcome. Greg also hosts the popular podcast History That Doesn't Suck. Together, they explore the financial crisis behind the Newburgh Conspiracy, the role of Alexander Hamilton and Robert and Gouverneur Morris, and George Washington's extraordinary intervention at the Temple of Virtue. When Washington reaches for his spectacles and tells his officers, "You'll have to forgive me. I've grown blind in service to my country," his vulnerability changes the course of the meeting. The conversation examines Washington's often-overlooked third Cincinnatus moment, his defense of civilian authority, and the lessons Newburgh offers about military power, public duty, and the fragile foundations of the Constitution. Tune in to discover how close America came to losing its experiment in self-government, and how Washington helped pull it back from the brink. In This Episode - [00:00] Meet Greg Jackson - [01:13] Season setup and Newburgh teaser - [02:34] Early 1783 war context - [03:49] The Articles of Confederation’s money problem - [05:50] The minds behind Revolutionary War finance - [08:12] Congress as a league - [10:22] Empty treasury and broken promises - [11:52] The officer pay crisis - [15:29] Understanding the Newburgh Conspiracy - [17:11] Washington suspects a plot - [19:23] The tariff plan fails - [23:12] Why coups happen - [24:44] The Newburgh Conspiracy sparks - [25:40] The Temple of Virtue meeting - [27:12] Gates challenges Washington - [28:33] Washington takes control - [29:41] The leadership behind the scenes - [34:20] Spectacles turn the tide - [39:14] Congress pays with bonds - [41:38] Speculators and the funding fight - [44:24] Washington rejects power - [46:06] Closing reflections Notable Quotes - (03:50) “Congress made all sorts of promises when things looked scary and terrifying, and they desperately needed men to fill the ranks. But now that things are looking like they’re gonna work out… it’s getting a little harder to get Congress to write those checks.” — Greg Jackson - (04:30) “Congress has the ability to mint money, has the ability to spend money, but it has no ability to ensure it actually has money.” — Matthew Brogdon - (08:36) “I prefer to think of it as almost 18th-century NATO… It’s a league of friendship. It’s an alliance.” — Greg Jackson on the Articles of Confederation - (23:32) “Many of the dictatorships and coups, uh, typically originate in what feel like credible claims of injustice.” — Matthew Brogdon - (28:41) “How inconsistent with the rules of propriety. How unmilitary. How subversive of all order and discipline. Let the good sense of the army decide.” — George Washington’s address to the officers - (37:28) “There was nothing that George said or read in that moment. It was this raw vulnerability where these officers realized, ‘Oh, my gosh, he’s given everything.’” — Greg Jackson - (44:57) “If George had said, ‘Officers, I’m with you. I will lead you. We are marching on Congress,’ he could have done it. He could have made himself king in this moment.” — Greg Jackson Resources and Links This Constitution - Apple Podcast:https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/this-constitution/id1771900485 - Spotify:https://open.spotify.com/show/0IQCq5DUPWlImiAdc4t3pf?si=85085b24b55b4130 -…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 10 | The Founders’ Hidden Weapon: American Diplomacy

    · 33 min

    The American Revolution was fought on battlefields, but victory depended on winning another fight overseas: the battle for international support. As the colonies challenged the British Empire, American diplomats had to convince foreign powers that the new nation deserved recognition, financial assistance, and a place among the nations of the world. In this episode, Matthew Brogdon and Savannah Eccles Johnston examine the diplomatic efforts that helped secure American independence. They explore the early mission of Silas Deane, Benjamin Franklin’s remarkable success in France, John Adams’ efforts to gain support from the Netherlands, and John Jay’s crucial role in negotiating the Treaty of Paris. Along the way, they examine how these diplomats navigated competing European interests and built alliances that changed the course of the Revolution. The hosts also explore why the founders viewed diplomacy as essential to America’s survival and why international reputation mattered so much to the new republic. While American soldiers won victories on the battlefield, Franklin, Adams, and Jay helped secure the recognition and independence that allowed the United States to become a lasting nation. In This Episode - [00:00] Introduction: How diplomacy won the Revolution - [03:12] Why France joined America’s fight against Britain - [04:41] The forgotten diplomat who helped the Revolution succeed - [07:09] Benjamin Franklin’s mission to win over France - [10:59] How Franklin turned charm into a diplomatic weapon - [12:31] Why great diplomats rarely receive recognition - [14:00] John Adams arrives in France - [16:09] How Adams secured Dutch support for America - [17:34] Why international reputation mattered to the founders - [20:24] Why America connected more with the Dutch than the French - [22:16] John Jay’s difficult mission in Spain - [24:27] The secret negotiations that changed America’s future - [26:58] How the Treaty of Paris secured American independence - [28:51] Why diplomats deserve more credit for creating America - [30:49] The founders’ warning about European power - [31:42] The lasting lesson of America’s revolutionary diplomacy Notable Quotes - (04:19) “Really you can summarize it as: it’s hard to say no to Benjamin Franklin.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (29:14) “American soldiers won the revolution, yes, but it’s our diplomats who win our independence and the recognition of our independence.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (08:57) “Franklin is the American as far as people in Europe are concerned.” — Matthew Brogdon - (17:34) “The founding generation really sees there being a lot of good fruit to be had from having a good reputation in the community of nations.” — Matthew Brogdon - (31:17) “They have a sense that it’s not just Great Britain; it’s all of Europe that really poses a threat to peace.” — Matthew Brogdon Resources and Links This Constitution - Apple Podcast:https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/this-constitution/id1771900485 - Spotify:https://open.spotify.com/show/0IQCq5DUPWlImiAdc4t3pf?si=85085b24b55b4130 - Website:https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/projects/this_constitution_podcast.html - YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@centerforconstitutionalstu8915/videos Savannah Eccles Johnston - https://www.linkedin.com/in/savannah-eccles-johnston-515a72198 - https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/people/savannah_eccles_johnston.html Matthew Brogdon - https://www.linkedin.com/in/matthew-brogdon-8a21bb89/ - https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/people/matthew_brogdon.html

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 9 | Why Congress Can't Run a War—But Won One Anyway

    · 28 min

    Congress went to war in 1775 against the most powerful empire in the world, but could a legislative body actually run a war? With no executive departments, no Pentagon, and little experience managing a national military, the Second Continental Congress had to figure out how to transform colonial militias into a Continental Army, appoint a commander in chief, supply the troops, and direct a war that stretched across thousands of miles. In this episode, Matthew Brogdon and Savannah Eccles Johnston examine Congress's extraordinary experiment in wartime government. They trace the creation of the Continental Army and George Washington's appointment as commander-in-chief, explore why Congress chose Washington over other experienced military officers, and examine the committee system Congress created to manage everything from military supplies to naval affairs. They also look at the disastrous invasion of Canada, where strategic theories collided with the realities of distance, supply, weather, and an inexperienced army. The hosts then explore Congress's struggles with military appointments, political maneuvering, and the Conway Cabal, while examining Washington's careful relationship with civilian authority. Finally, they show how the Revolutionary War experience influenced the Constitution's division of war powers between Congress and the president, including the crucial distinction between Congress's power to declare war and the president's responsibility as commander-in-chief. Tune in to discover why the Revolutionary experience convinced the framers that Congress could create the conditions for war, but should not be the institution directing military operations. In This Episode - [00:00] Introduction: Can Congress run a war? - [01:04] Forming the Continental Army - [02:14] Why pick Washington? - [04:17] Supervising the war by committee - [05:47] The failed Canadian expedition - [12:56] Congressional officer appointments - [13:33] The Conway Cabal - [16:03] Washington's independent actions - [19:41] A new balance of power - [21:05] Constitutional solutions: Make vs. declare war - [24:26] The president as commander in chief - [27:28] Conclusion: Can Congress run a war? Notable Quotes - (09:15) "Canada offers big threats, potentially a big reward, and it's Congress actually that creates this two-pronged offensive strategy." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (11:19) "You get this theoretical debate: would it be a good thing if we went and did this? Well, that's kind of beside the point if you don't actually have the capability to do it." — Matthew Brogdon - (12:20) "Congress is bad at directing military operations... that's what we're taking from this." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (17:31) "We really do owe him a debt for taking seriously the idea that the military is in subjection to the civil authority." — Matthew Brogdon - (22:38) "Can Congress run a war? And it seems that the answer is yes, if they'll take their hands off the steering wheel when it comes to military strategy." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (25:45) "The Constitution, in describing the president's role, uses a military term, but it's applied to a person who holds elected office." — Matthew Brogdon - (27:35) "Can Congress run a war? No. But Congress can create the conditions for war. That's what they can do." — Savannah Eccles Johnston Resources and Links This Constitution - Apple Podcast:https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/this-constitution/id1771900485 - Spotify:https://open.spotify.com/show/0IQCq5DUPWlImiAdc4t3pf?si=85085b24b55b4130 - Website:https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/projects/this_constitution_podcast.html - YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@centerforconstitutionalstu8915/videos Savannah Eccles Johnston - https://www.linkedin.com/in/savannah-eccles-johnston-515a72198 - https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/people/savannah_eccles_johnston.html Matthew Brogdon - https://www.linkedin.com/in/matthew-brogdon-8a21bb89/ -…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 8 | The American Revolution Was a Women's War

    · 46 min

    The American Revolution wasn't fought only on battlefields. It unfolded in homes, farms, towns, and military camps, where women faced shortages, violence, displacement, and the enormous responsibility of keeping families and communities alive. In this episode, Savannah Eccles Johnston speaks with historian Carol Berkin, Presidential Professor of History (Emerita) at Baruch College, and author of Revolutionary Mothers, about the essential and often-overlooked role women played in the Revolution. They explore how women became central to colonial boycotts, managed farms while men were away, worked alongside the Continental Army, carried military intelligence, and sometimes disguised themselves as men to enlist. Carol also explains how the Revolution changed women's civic identity. Their wartime contributions challenged long-standing assumptions about women's intellectual and moral abilities and helped expand educational opportunities after independence. Tune in to discover why the Revolution cannot be fully understood without women and how adding their experiences transforms the story from a series of military campaigns into a complex home-front war involving an entire society. In This Episode - (00:00) Intro - (00:16) Introduction to Carol Berkin - (00:59) The myth of women as passive observers - (03:13) How the Revolution politicized women - (07:21) Why were women essential to colonial boycotts - (10:27) Women as spies, couriers, and participants - (11:05) Running farms while men were at war - (15:27) Violence against women during the Revolution - (18:24) Why did women follow the Continental Army - (22:42) Who the camp followers really were - (23:45) The real story behind Molly Pitcher - (26:10) Women disguising themselves as soldiers - (27:00) Deborah Sampson Gannett's military service - (29:52) Women as spies and military couriers - (37:29) How the Revolution changed women's education - (42:56) Three overlapping revolutions for liberty - (44:09) How including women changes the Revolution - (49:06) Recommended books on women and the Revolution Notable Quotes - (00:59) “The first thing I'd like to tackle is this myth of women as passive observers of a revolutionary war.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (08:17) “If women refused to join the boycott, we would still be singing Hail to the King.” — Carol Berkin - (29:52) “The idea that the war itself didn't involve women is nonsense.” — Carol Berkin - (42:56) “The revolution was a woman's war as well as a man's war.” — Carol Berkin - (44:09) “When you include women in the story of the revolution, it changes the nature of the revolution itself.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (45:31) “You're giving more than half the country an ability to see themselves in the American Revolution and to feel like they're part of it.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston Resources and Links This Constitution - Apple Podcast:https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/this-constitution/id1771900485 - Spotify:https://open.spotify.com/show/0IQCq5DUPWlImiAdc4t3pf?si=85085b24b55b4130 - Website:https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/projects/this_constitution_podcast.html - YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@centerforconstitutionalstu8915/videos Savannah Eccles Johnston - https://www.linkedin.com/in/savannah-eccles-johnston-515a72198 - https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/people/savannah_eccles_johnston.html Carol Berkin - Biography: https://www.womenshistory.org/about-us/supporters-and-sponsors/museum-advisory-council/carol-berkin-phd - Books: https://www.amazon.com/Books-Carol-Berkin/s?rh=n%3A283155%2Cp_27%3ACarol%2BBerkin

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 7 | Why George Washington's Greatest Victory Wasn't Winning Battles

    · 31 min

    The American Revolution wasn't won by ideals alone. It required an army. But how do you build a fighting force from scratch when your citizens believe standing armies are the tools of tyrants? And how does that ragtag collection of farmers, apprentices, and adventurers end up creating something far more lasting than military victory: a shared national identity? In this episode, Matthew Brogdon and Savannah Eccles Johnston examine the extraordinary challenge of forging the Continental Army. They trace the journey from the spontaneous militia mobilization around Boston to Washington's desperate Christmas gamble at Trenton, from the crisis of expiring enlistments to Baron von Steuben's legendary training regimen. Along the way, they explore the remarkable story of Deborah Sampson, who served 17 months disguised as a man, and consider what motivated ordinary people to endure years of deprivation, disease, and danger. The hosts also examine Washington's deliberate strategy to transcend regional loyalties by mixing regiments from different states, establishing uniform drills and symbols, and creating an institution where shared suffering forged common purpose. They reveal how this experience shaped Washington's postwar vision for a national university and federal city, and why the Continental Army became the training ground for America's first generation of national leaders. Tune in to discover how a desperate, underfed, perpetually dissolving army became the crucible of American nationhood, and why Washington believed that what worked for the army could work for the entire country. In This Episode - (00:00) Introduction - (00:16) Creating an American identity through the Army - (01:55) Why the Minutemen couldn't win a long war - (04:03) The challenges of short-term enlistments - (04:34) How Revolutionary soldiers differed across the colonies - (07:53) Why Americans chose to fight - (08:11) Deborah Sampson's extraordinary military service - (11:34) Honor, duty, and the motivations of Revolutionary soldiers - (14:52) Why recruiting the Continental Army remained difficult - (16:13) Washington's struggle to keep his army together - (17:18) The Delaware campaign and an army on the brink - (20:32) Incentives, pensions, and recruiting soldiers - (21:25) Drafts, substitutes, and military service - (23:00) Building a national army from state militias - (24:13) Washington's strategy for creating unity - (26:39) Shared sacrifice and the birth of American identity - (27:03) How the Continental Army shaped future national leaders - (28:22) Washington's vision for a national university - (30:07) Why the Continental Army made Washington the Father of the Nation - (30:25) Final reflections Notable Quotes - (01:25) "This notion of the yeoman farmer... steps out into public life to take part in a militia and defend the community." — Matthew Brogdon - (11:34) "There's simply the bare fact of the notion that it's a matter of honor, to defend your home, your country." — Matthew Brogdon - (13:08) "People don't risk their lives for things they don't believe in... but young men especially don't necessarily need good reasons to go to war." — Matthew Brogdon - (16:08) "Long-term, there are good reasons why enlistments struggle. But there's also a difficulty in keeping soldiers at all." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (18:12) "Washington's own troops are going to have little reason to stick around if it looks like all we're going to do is lose." — Matthew Brogdon - (23:17) "You have to rely on states to make this army function, but you're trying to make it a national army... into a national institution." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (26:43) "If you put a bunch of Americans from different parts of the country... into one thing, and you just make them suffer next to each other, you can actually forge a national identity." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (29:27) "The Union wants to fly apart. And the question is, what kind of…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 6 | When Americans Fought Americans: The Southern Campaign of the Revolution

    · 28 min

    The Southern Campaign is one of the most overlooked turning points of the American Revolution. This episode asks a sharper question: what happened when the fight for independence stopped looking like British regulars against American patriots and started looking like Americans fighting Americans? In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon examine why the British turned south after failing to defeat Washington in the North. The British believed the South offered better odds because of loyalist support, economic dependence on British trade, and cultural ties to England. At first, the strategy seemed to work. Savannah fell, Charleston was captured, and Camden shattered much of the Southern Continental Army. But the South changed the character of the war. Johnston and Brogdon explore how the Revolution became deeply personal, dividing families, communities, and regions between loyalists and patriots. They discuss Southern honor culture, violent reprisals, backcountry resistance, and why some historians describe this period as America’s first civil war. Tune in to learn how Nathanael Greene, Daniel Morgan, and the militia fighters helped reverse British momentum. The episode covers Kings Mountain, Cowpens, Guilford Courthouse, and the collapse of Cornwallis’ Southern strategy. It reveals one of the Revolution’s clearest lessons: holding territory is not the same as controlling a people. In This Episode - (00:00) Podcast Introduction - (00:12) Welcome to This Constitution - (00:16) Why does the episode focus on the Southern Campaign - (00:30) How the Revolution became more like a civil war - (00:54) Why the British strategy in the South failed - (01:00) Why the British pivoted south after Saratoga - (01:49) Loyalists, royalists, and Tory support in the South - (03:35) Southern elites and British cultural ties - (04:28) The South’s economic dependence on British trade - (05:30) Rice, indigo, tobacco, and the Southern economy - (05:48) Cornwallis and early British success - (06:00) Savannah, Charleston, Camden, and American defeat - (08:31) Patriots vs. loyalists in the South - (09:04) Honor culture, violence, and family reprisals - (12:34) Why the British overestimated loyalist support - (13:11) Nathanael Greene takes command - (14:09) Washington’s Fabian strategy moves south - (15:14) Kings Mountain and the Overmountain Men - (18:25) Cowpens and Daniel Morgan’s victory - (20:28) Why Cowpens changed the psychology of the war - (21:48) Guilford Courthouse and costly British victory - (22:06) The collapse of the Southern strategy - (22:38) Cornwallis moves toward Virginia and Yorktown - (26:43) Why the Southern Campaign deserves more attention - (27:44) Closing Credits Notable Quotes - (00:30) “It becomes much more like a civil war than a revolutionary war.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (05:15) “There are lots of reasons to think culturally, to think in terms of the elite and the society there, that you would have affinity with the British.” — Matthew Brogdon - (09:04) “The American South is a bit of an honor culture.” — Matthew Brogdon - (14:21) “We cannot win large-scale engagements.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (21:03) “The most compelling argument you can make in this kind of debate is a victory on the battlefield.” — Matthew Brogdon - (27:37) “If you don’t win, you can’t make a new constitutional order.” — Matthew Brogdon Resources and Links This Constitution - Apple Podcast:https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/this-constitution/id1771900485 - Spotify:https://open.spotify.com/show/0IQCq5DUPWlImiAdc4t3pf?si=85085b24b55b4130 - Website:https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/projects/this_constitution_podcast.html - YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@centerforconstitutionalstu8915/videos Savannah Eccles Johnston - linkedin.com/in/savannah-eccles-johnston-515a72198 (http://linkedin.com/in/savannah-eccles-johnston-515a72198) -…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 5 | The Fourth-of-July Question America Needs to Ask

    · 30 min

    Are Americans Declaration People or Constitution People? The Declaration of Independence and the Constitution are two of America’s most important founding documents, but this episode asks a deeper civic question: which one actually defines who Americans are? In this Fourth of July episode, Savannah Eccles Johnston is joined by Dr. Leah Murray, Brady Presidential Distinguished Professor of Political Science and Philosophy and Director of the Walker Institute of Politics & Public Policy at Weber State University. Together, they explore whether Americans are more emotionally shaped by the Declaration’s ideals or more practically shaped by the Constitution’s institutions. The conversation examines the Declaration as the “heart” of America and the Constitution as its “head.” The Declaration gives the country its moral purpose: equality, liberty, natural rights, and the pursuit of happiness. The Constitution gives the country a structure for living together despite disagreement, ambition, self-interest, and competing visions of the good. Tune in to learn why the Fourth of July is not just a celebration of independence, but a reminder of the truths America is still trying to live up to. Johnston and Murray discuss civic education, local politics, legitimate disagreement, the meaning of equality, and why Americans may need to recover the founding ideas they have forgotten. In This Episode - (00:00) Podcast Introduction - (00:39) Introduction to Dr. Leah Murray - (01:17) Are Americans Declaration people or Constitution people? - (01:32) The Declaration as America’s heart and the Constitution as its head - (03:02) Why Americans connect more emotionally with the Declaration - (05:25) How the Constitution responded to the failures of early American government - (07:30) Rights, civic behavior, and the Bill of Rights - (10:24) Do Americans still believe in universal truths? - (13:00) Why citizenship has to be taught - (13:59) Equality, opportunity, and America’s unfinished work - (15:51) What “the pursuit of happiness” really means - (18:03) Do Americans actually like representative democracy? - (20:00) Whether Americans still believe disagreement is legitimate - (22:19) Why constitutional government depends on local relationships - (24:32) What happens when the Declaration and Constitution clash - (27:18) Why America needs both founding documents - (31:19) What every American should do on the Fourth of July Notable Quotes - (02:23) “To me, the Declaration is the heart, the Constitution is the head, and both of these are right.” — Dr. Leah Murray - (09:12) “The Constitution is my favorite... but when you ask me what America is and where we resonate, I think it’s the Declaration.” — Dr. Leah Murray - (13:07) “Citizenship has to be taught. It is a habit.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (17:35) “It’s not just I get to do whatever I want. It’s about being the best version of myself in the community I find myself in.” — Dr. Leah Murray - (18:34) “It’s not a concierge planet.” — Dr. Leah Murray - (22:21) “A return to local to be able to save our ability to be a constitutional people.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (27:29) “The Constitution is nothing without the beauty of the Declaration, and the Declaration is just noise without the vehicle.” — Dr. Leah Murray - (31:30) “They need to know the Declaration of Independence, and if on the Fourth of July all they’re doing is lighting off fireworks and not reading that document, they are doing themselves a disservice.” — Dr. Leah Murray Resources and Links This Constitution - Apple Podcast:https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/this-constitution/id1771900485 - Spotify:https://open.spotify.com/show/0IQCq5DUPWlImiAdc4t3pf?si=85085b24b55b4130 - Website:https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/projects/this_constitution_podcast.html - YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@centerforconstitutionalstu8915/videos Dr. Leah Murray - LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/leah-murray-wsu - Bio:…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 4 | Valley Forge: When the Revolution Almost Froze to Death

    · 37 min

    What Happens When an Army Freezes and a Government Can’t Supply It? Valley Forge is remembered as one of the great symbols of American endurance, but this episode asks a deeper constitutional question: what happens when a revolution depends on a government too weak to supply its own army? In this episode, co-hosts Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon tell the story of the Continental Army’s brutal winter after the British captured Philadelphia. Washington chose to camp just 18 miles from the occupied city, close enough to pressure the British but far enough to avoid surprise attack. What followed was a six-month test of survival: 9,000 soldiers entered, thousands lived in cramped log cabins, and hunger, disease, cold, and supply failures pushed the army to the edge. The episode explores what Valley Forge revealed about the weakness of Congress, the limits of state cooperation, and the danger of relying on civic virtue when food, clothing, and money disappear. Johnston and Brogdon also discuss Martha Washington’s role in restoring morale, the performance of Cato, Baron Friedrich von Steuben’s transformation of the army, and how Black soldiers’ service helped shape Washington’s changing views on slavery. Tune in to learn why Valley Forge was not only a military turning point, but also a constitutional warning. The army survived, but barely, and the lessons learned there would help shape the case for a stronger national government. In This Episode - (00:00) Introduction - (00:22) Why Valley Forge became an iconic American story - (01:32) The British capture of Philadelphia - (03:43) Why armies stopped fighting during winter - (04:34) Washington responds to critics - (05:16) Why Washington chose Valley Forge - (06:28) 9,000 men enter, and 7,000 come out - (08:04) Hunger, disease, and brutal conditions - (09:23) Why Congress could not supply the army - (13:14) Washington’s circular letter to the states - (16:26) Farmers, profit, and civic virtue - (18:15) Martha Washington arrives - (21:53) Cato and republican virtue - (27:08) Baron von Steuben disciplines the army - (31:00) Black soldiers join the Continental Army - (35:18) Final lessons from Valley Forge Notable Quotes - (00:37) “Valley Forge... is this kind of iconic moment in American history of suffering and perseverance and ultimate triumph.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (00:56) “It’s also a moment that rings warning bells about the weakness of Congress.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (17:32) “The profit motive is not always patriotic.” — Matthew Brogdon - (35:32) “What emerges from Valley Forge is not the same as what went into Valley Forge.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston Resources and Links This Constitution - Apple Podcast:https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/this-constitution/id1771900485 - Spotify:https://open.spotify.com/show/0IQCq5DUPWlImiAdc4t3pf?si=85085b24b55b4130 - Website:https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/projects/this_constitution_podcast.html - YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@centerforconstitutionalstu8915/videos Savannah Eccles Johnston - linkedin.com/in/savannah-eccles-johnston-515a72198 (http://linkedin.com/in/savannah-eccles-johnston-515a72198) - https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/people/savannah_eccles_johnston.html Matthew Brogdon - https://www.linkedin.com/in/matthew-brogdon-8a21bb89/ - https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/people/matthew_brogdon.html

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 3 | How Do You Govern When You’re Also Fighting a War?

    · 39 min

    When we talk about America's founding, we tend to jump straight from the Declaration of Independence to the Constitution. But what held the country together in the eleven years between? What happened after independence was declared? Who ran the war? Who paid for the army? And how did thirteen quarreling states manage to hold together long enough to win? In this episode, co-hosts Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon dive into the much-maligned Articles of Confederation, the nation’s first written constitution. They ask whether the Articles deserve their bad reputation, or whether they were actually a surprisingly effective revolutionary government. Topics include the tension between “perpetual union” and state sovereignty, the five-year ratification battle over western lands, the complete absence of an executive or judiciary, and how George Washington’s personal restraint prevented a military coup. The episode also explores the Articles’ genuine successes: the Northwest Ordinance, which governed slavery in the territories for 70 years, the creation of ad hoc executive departments run by people like Robert Morris, and the lessons that shaped the 1787 Constitution. Along the way, Johnston and Brogdon debate the European Union as a modern analogy, mourn the death of geography education, and ask whether a government that can’t tax but can win a war deserves more credit than it gets. Tune in to learn why the Articles of Confederation, clunky, slow, and underpowered, might just be the most underrated constitution in American history. In This Episode - (00:00) Introduction - (01:02) What problem were the Articles designed to solve? - (02:08) Drafting the Articles of Confederation - (03:44) Was America building a nation or a league of states? - (04:15) “Perpetual union” versus state sovereignty - (05:24) Why federalism was still an unfinished idea - (06:23) Building a government while fighting a war - (07:12) Comparing the Articles to the European Union - (09:02) The rise of an American identity distinct from Europe - (10:42) The structure of the Confederation Congress - (11:28) Why Congress struggled to function effectively - (13:22) Why deliberative assemblies struggle during wartime - (16:05) The dangers of having no executive branch - (18:08) Committees, enforcement, and the limits of the Articles - (19:02) How America still managed to win the Revolution - (19:41) Why ratification took five years - (20:22) Western land disputes and Maryland’s veto - (21:02) Did the Declaration itself function as a constitution? - (22:24) Sea-to-sea charters and the fight over western territories - (24:03) Why geography matters in civic education - (25:56) The Confederation Congress and Western Lands Policy - (28:11) Fear of tyranny versus fear of ineffective government - (28:35) Madison, factions, and the logic of federalism - (31:19) Did the Articles accomplish their real purpose? - (32:01) The Northwest Ordinance and territorial expansion - (33:32) Why foreign affairs exposed the Articles’ weaknesses - (34:04) “The plane did fly,” reassessing the Articles - (34:17) George Washington and civilian control of the military - (35:53) How America avoided military dictatorship - (37:04) The ad hoc executive departments of the Revolution - (37:53) Final reflections on America’s first government Notable Quotes - (01:02) "If you're going to win a war, you have to have a government. Armies don't equip themselves." — Matthew Brogdon - (06:18) "They really are building the plane while flying it. They are engaged in the act of constructing these institutions in the middle of fighting a war." — Matthew Brogdon - (12:41) "The Articles of Confederation treated things as though this was a league of sovereign states — and then it gives the confederation responsibilities that belong to a government, not just a diplomatic assembly." — Matthew Brogdon - (18:01) "A government without an executive and a judicial power to…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 2 | Splitting Sovereignty: How the Colonies Defended Local Control

    · 54 min

    Was the American Revolution really about breaking away from Britain? Or was it first a fight over who had the right to govern local communities? In this episode, host Matthew Brogdon sits down with constitutional scholar Sean Beienburg to unpack the forgotten federalism debate at the heart of the American Founding. Long before the Declaration of Independence or the Constitution, Americans were already arguing that Parliament could not truly represent people living thousands of miles away. What began as a dispute over taxation quickly became a much deeper constitutional conflict about sovereignty, local self-government, and the dangers of concentrated power. Together, Brogdon and Beienburg trace how ideas first argued during the Stamp Act crisis eventually shaped the Articles of Confederation, the Constitution, and the 10th Amendment itself. They explore why early Americans believed states retained most governing authority, how federalism helped anti-slavery movements spread across northern states, and why the Civil War debate over “states’ rights” is far more complicated than modern political narratives suggest. The conversation also dives into prohibition, Reconstruction, the Progressive Era, and modern fights over marijuana, immigration, and federal authority, revealing how constitutional federalism continues to shape political battles across the ideological spectrum. Tune in to discover why the struggle between local self-government and centralized power has been part of the American story from the very beginning. In This Episode - (00:15) Introduction Sean Beienburg - (00:47) The American Revolution and local self-government - (03:58) The British Constitution debate - (06:40) Continuity from colonies to states - (08:05) The First Continental Congress's Declaration and Resolves - (11:20) Federalism in early state constitutions - (14:18) The Massachusetts Constitution of 1780 - (17:54) British sympathy for the American argument - (21:02) The Articles of Confederation - (27:44) From the Articles to the Constitution - (31:01) Federalism and the abolition of slavery - (38:27) Federalism during the Civil War and Reconstruction - (42:04) The "Lost Cause" narrative - (42:51) Federalism in later American politics - (45:43) Prohibition as a federalism debate - (50:42) The enduring relevance of federalism Notable Quotes - (01:06) "The American Revolution is obviously about the idea of self-government, but the question is self-government by whom? And I think that if you look at the debates, what jumps out is that the grounds cited were about power being vested in the provincial, the colonial legislatures." — Sean Beienburg - (08:56) "They're not saying give us representation in Parliament. They're saying: we are entitled to a free and exclusive power of legislation in their several provincial legislatures. This is the assertion that the English colonies in North America are self-governing states that are part of a broader empire." — Matthew Brogdon - (13:34) "All of the northern state constitutions — the states that are rewriting a new one — they put this language in there. I've got the goods on this. Federalism, the idea that most stuff stays in-house at the states, is a value they assert repeatedly." — Sean Beienburg - (17:07) "The Federal Constitution is only part of the people's constitution. If you want to know the rest of the Constitution that governs the people of the state of Utah, you'd have to go look at our state constitution." — Matthew Brogdon (citing Troy Smith) - (35:06) "If you look at the secession manifestos from the Southern states, they are as angry or angrier at northern states invoking federalism against slavery, like they're mad that the northern states aren't participating in extradition or the Fugitive Slave act kind of stuff.." — Sean Beienburg - (52:34) "Constitutional federalism is a part of all of our constitutional heritage, and I think we've sort of lost track of that. I hope…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 4, Episode 1 | A Watery Revolution: How the Sea Decided American Independence

    · 48 min

    When we picture the American Revolution, we see George Washington on horseback, minutemen at Concord, and the signing of the Declaration. But what if the real story of independence was written not on land, but on water? In this season premiere, host Matthew Brogdon sits down with National Book Award–winning historian Nathaniel Philbrick (author of Bunker Hill, Valiant Ambition, In the Heart of the Sea, and Travels with George) to explore the revolution as a maritime conflict. From the siege of Boston to the desperate crossing of the Delaware, from Benedict Arnold’s makeshift “mosquito fleet” on Lake Champlain to the French naval victory at the Battle of the Chesapeake that sealed Cornwallis’s fate at Yorktown, Philbrick reveals how control of rivers, lakes, and oceans determined the war’s outcome. Philbrick also discusses the power of visiting historical sites, the essential role of Washington’s resilience and leadership, and why the coming America 250 anniversary is the perfect moment to get on the road and see these places for yourself. He shares how moving to Nantucket first ignited his passion for history, why the Revolution was far longer and more fragile than most textbooks suggest, and how a hurricane in the Caribbean, not a land battle, set the stage for victory at Yorktown. Tune in to learn why the American Revolution was, in Philbrick’s words, a “watery revolution” and how understanding the sea changes everything we thought we knew about the fight for independence. In This Episode - (01:37) Meet Nathaniel Philbrick - (02:10) Why physically visiting Revolutionary War sites matters - (04:30) America 250 and renewed interest in historic travel - (06:39) From Nantucket to becoming a historian and writer - (09:01) The next book: the gold rush and the western frontier - (12:25) The sea as a key force in America’s origins - (13:55) Why the Revolution was more naval than we remember - (15:10) Rivers, lakes, and controlling movement during the war - (16:39) Boston, New York, and British naval dominance - (20:09) The Hudson River and the fight for key waterways - (21:19) Washington’s crossing of the Delaware: myth and reality - (24:38) Washington’s leadership under pressure - (25:27) Creativity and leadership during moments of crisis - (28:39) Benedict Arnold and Lake Champlain’s role in the Revolution - (33:05) Ingenuity and the “Mosquito Fleet” at Valcour Island - (36:25) Saratoga, Arnold, and the New York campaign - (37:35) Yorktown, Washington, and the French fleet - (40:07) What if Washington had joined the British Navy? - (42:01) Why the French nearly abandoned the American cause - (45:25) Hurricanes and the overlooked role of the French Navy - (46:40) The Battle of the Capes and the road to Yorktown - (48:16) Leadership, statesmanship, and chance in the Revolution - (49:00) Where to go for America's 250th - (49:57) Final reflections Notable Quotes - (06:04) "You don't take a trip, the trip takes you. There's always something unexpected." — Nathaniel Philbrick, quoting John Steinbeck - (13:56) "The narrative of the revolution for most of us begins with the minutemen at Lexington and Concord. And then each battle is like a stepping stone that inevitably leads us to Yorktown. The fact is, this war went on forever — for close to a decade." — Nathaniel Philbrick - (16:48) “Washington began to realize, wow, I need to really consider the water if we're ever going to have a chance of winning this battle.” — Nathaniel Philbrick - (25:30) "There was a military tradition at that time that your army went into winter quarters and the fighting stopped. Washington decided one last gamble — one roll of the dice — was worth it." — Nathaniel Philbrick - (34:48) "Benedict Arnold, during a naval battle fought inland on a lake, saved America in the fall of 1776." — Nathaniel Philbrick - (44:48) "Three successive hurricanes hit in the fall of 1780, including the Great Storm of 1780, where 20,000 people…

    Not rated yet
  • Season 3, Episode 19 | Saving Principles: Frederick Douglass, the Declaration, and the Soul of Civic Education

    · 52 min

    Why has civic education taught students to look to Washington, when citizenship starts in their own neighborhood? In this episode, host Matthew Brogdon sits down with David Bobb, president of the Bill of Rights Institute, to explore the state of civic education in America as the country approaches its 250th birthday. Together, they make the case that civic life begins not in Washington, D.C. but in local communities, mediating institutions, and the habits formed early in life. Bobb introduces BRI's expanding library of free resources, including BRI Jr. for elementary students, and argues that civic education has overindexed on government and underinvested in the kind of local, associational life Tocqueville recognized as the beating heart of American self-governance. The conversation delves into Frederick Douglass's landmark July 5 oration of 1852, unpacking his image of the Declaration as a "ring bolt," the anchor to which the ship of American destiny must cling. Brogdon and Bobb trace how the Declaration's "saving principles" of freedom and equality have served as the touchstone for abolition, suffragists, and the civil-rights movement, and why those principles must be actively chosen, not passively inherited. They also wrestle with what it means to demote politics in favor of human dignity, how Lincoln warned of the danger of alienation from our laws, and why the appeal to universal principles through a specifically American inheritance is not a contradiction but a necessity. In This Episode - (01:29) BRI's offerings: thinking about the next 250 years - (03:09) Why local civic engagement matters more than national politics - (06:37) Civic engagement vs. political engagement - (09:05) The telos of civics - (11:37) Storytelling as civic education - (13:51) American citizenship vs. "global citizenship." - (16:16) Lincoln's Lyceum Address and the danger of losing attachment to law - (20:39) The shift to primary sources: why textbooks are being set aside - (26:25) The Declaration as the "ring bolt" of American destiny - (30:01) Frederick Douglass's July 5 oration - (39:52) The Declaration as an anchor in storms of change - (42:28) The "positive-good" school, Woodrow Wilson, and the fight over the Declaration - (49:39) Limited government as ground for consensus Notable Quotes - (06:00) "Tocqueville said, if you want to draw an American out of their kind of individual orbit, you propose to build a road through their property." — David Bobb - (07:29) "Being engaged in a productive activity, benefiting your community, employing people, bringing services and goods to the public is in fact the fulfillment of a civic role, I think that people play." — Matthew Brogdon - (14:06) "I don't understand what the term 'global citizenship' means. It seems to me an oxymoron. We do American citizenship, an education in universal principles, instantiated in the American experiment." — David Bobb - (16:16) "About 30 percent of Americans are willing to say that we need a leader who is willing to break or bend things that can lead to the mobocratic spirit. We have to be very careful about that." — David Bobb - (30:11) "Frederick Douglass speaks with admiration and alienation, two complex emotions woven through a message of hope and hopelessness. The 'you' is bracing. A ring bolt is an anchor, but also the thing to which an enslaved person could be shackled." — David Bobb - (35:13) "You have a choice to cleave to these principles or not. You can choose to abandon them, or you can choose to move into greater conformity with them. It's a powerful reminder." — Matthew Brogdon - (48:05) "To demote politics is to elevate the limitless opportunity of every human person. That's the message of ultimate dignity." — David Bobb

    Not rated yet
  • Season 3, Episode 18 | Who Counts as the Press? From Printing Presses to Afroman

    · 32 min

    Does the freedom of the press protect only journalists with printing presses or everyone with something to say? From the founding era to social media, the line between “speech” and “press” has blurred. In this episode, host Savannah Eccles Johnston talks with legal commentator and former DOJ official Sarah Isgur about how the First Amendment’s protection of the press has evolved and whether it has gone too far. They explore three eras: the original understanding in 1791 (when “press” meant owning a printing press), the Supreme Court’s twentieth-century expansion of free speech, and today’s dilemmas over influencers, citizen journalists, and government access. Sarah explains why she’s a textualist free-speech absolutist (and why that means Jefferson is the bad guy in her bedtime stories), revisits the infamous Skokie Nazi march as the “apotheosis of the First Amendment,” and breaks down two very different recent cases: Afroman (lemon pound cake, police mockery, and a jury victory) and La Gordil Loca (a citizen–journalist arrested for asking a state employee for information). The conversation also covers New York Times v. Sullivan, the Pentagon press access fight, and why Sarah’s new book, Last Branch Standing, argues the Supreme Court is more Ted Lasso than Game of Thrones. In This Episode - (00:00) Introduction - (00:11) Meet Sarah Isgur and episode overview - (01:32) What did “the press” mean in 1791? - (03:03) Freedom of the press vs. freedom of speech - (03:46) Defamation and truth at the founding - (05:43) Are Americans freer today than ever before? - (06:17) New York Times v. Sullivan and modern defamation law - (09:21) Free speech and the search for truth - (09:47) Originalism vs. textualism - (12:57) The Skokie Nazi march - (13:35) Free speech in extreme cases - (14:01) Is Mill wrong in 2026? Echo chambers, algorithms, and truth - (17:18) Crisis and the dangers of “this time is different.” - (17:26) The Afroman case and viral speech - (20:41) Citizen journalism and the Priscilla Villarreal (“La Gordiloca”) case - (22:19) Profit, media, and credibility - (23:05) Juries and American free speech instincts - (24:46) Pentagon press access rules - (26:31) The complexity of press freedom in practice - (28:09) Viewpoint neutrality and unintended consequences - (29:57) Sarah’s book: Last Branch Standing - (32:06) Outro Notable Quotes - (05:07) “An American living in 2026 has a greater protection under the First Amendment for their speech than at any time in the rest of our history. And it’s not even close.” — Sarah Isgur - (10:42) “A textualist would simply look at the text of the First Amendment that says, ‘Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech.’ Sorry, that’s an absolutist statement. I don’t really care what you thought you were doing at the time.” — Sarah Isgur - (12:11) “Jefferson is the bad guy in every story. When I tell my kids bedtime stories, it’s Jefferson who is the boogeyman coming after them in the night.” — Sarah Isgur - (12:58) “The greatest moment in American legal history is when the Nazis marched through a neighborhood of Holocaust survivors in Skokie, Illinois. 99.9% of people found it repugnant. As a country, we said, fine, say it. See who you can convince.” — Sarah Isgur - (17:26) “Doesn’t every road lead us to Afroman?” — Sarah Isgur - (31:46) “Congress isn’t doing its job. The President is trying to take over all the jobs of the other branches. The Supreme Court is the last branch standing.” — Sarah Isgur (on her book title)

    Not rated yet
  • Season 3, Episode 17 | Congress Underrated: Representation, Gridlock, and What We Miss

    · 35 min

    Is Congress the most underrated institution in American government? Widely criticized for gridlock, partisanship, and dysfunction, it’s often seen as the weakest branch. But what if that frustration reflects a misunderstanding of what Congress is designed to do? In this episode of This Constitution, Matthew Brogdon sits down with Princeton professor Frances E. Lee, author of A Case for Congress, to challenge the narrative that Congress is broken. They begin by rethinking “gridlock.” While fewer individual laws are passed today, modern legislation is far more expansive, often bundling multiple policies into single bills. By that measure, Congress is doing more, not less. They then delve into what really holds Congress back. It’s not just partisan opposition, it’s internal division. Narrow majorities and cross-pressured members make sweeping agendas difficult, even when one party holds power and procedural barriers like the filibuster are removed. Lee also reframes Congress as one of the most representative institutions in government. Its partisan makeup closely tracks the national electorate, and its members are deeply rooted in the communities they serve. Tune in to challenge what you think you know about Congress and discover why the institution we trust the least may be working more as intended than we realize. In This Episode - (00:38) Why Congress is underrated - (01:45) Is Congress really gridlocked? - (03:53) Congress as an obstacle to parties - (05:12) Unified vs. divided government - (08:27) Role of cross-pressured members - (09:39) The filibuster’s real impact - (10:25) Budget-reconciliation process - (11:54) Filibuster as a scapegoat - (13:01) Congress as a mirror of America - (15:03) Diversity and local ties in Congress - (18:20) Geographical representation & pluralism - (19:51) Bipartisanship in lawmaking - (22:32) Voice votes and consensus - (24:46) Why Congress is unpopular - (26:39) When parties enact big agendas - (29:15) Quality of rushed legislation - (31:04) Improving Congress: institutional patriotism Notable Quotes - (00:54) “The ratings for Congress have been low for a long time. It's really nothing new.”— Frances Lee - (03:25) “The contemporary Congress actually passes substantially more legislation than the Congress of the middle 20th century.” — Frances Lee - (11:45) “What the filibuster does for a majority party is that it often allows them to hide their divisions behind the other party.” — Frances Lee - (13:15) “It’s credibly representative in partisan terms that the parties are getting the share of seats in the House and the Senate that reflects the party’s strength in the national electorate.” — Frances Lee - (23:28) “It will surprise you if you take a look back, how many matters go through without any dissent.” — Frances Lee - (26:28) “Checking and balancing, when neither party really has the confidence of the American people, is that something we would say is dysfunctional? I tend to think it’s not dysfunctional.” — Frances Lee - (32:32) “I would like to see Congress operate in a more pluralistic way; I think it works better when the committees are able to work through the legislative issues, rather than have it all happen behind the scenes in leadership offices.” — Frances Lee - (33:27) “I do think members of Congress feel a sense of personal honor that they've been selected as representatives, but I think they also need to feel a sense of pride in the institution of which they're part” — Frances Lee

    Not rated yet
  • Season 3, Episode 16 | Religion in the Public Square: When Protestants, Catholics, and Jews Learned to Get Along (Mostly)

    · 32 min

    How did America move from the religious pluralism of the founding era to the “Judeo-Christian consensus” of the twentieth century? Why did that consensus begin to fracture? In this episode of This Constitution, Matthew Brogdon continues his conversation with James Patterson, associate professor of public affairs at the Institute for American Civics at the University of Tennessee. They explore how religious pluralism evolved during the twentieth century as immigration, world wars, and political movements reshaped the nation’s religious landscape. They begin the conversation with the massive immigration waves of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, which dramatically expanded America’s Catholic population while also bringing German Lutherans, Scandinavian Protestants, and other religious communities. These demographic shifts sparked political battles over public education, sectarian funding, and the role of religion in civic life, illustrating how deeply religious differences shaped American politics. The discussion then delves into the emergence of the “Judeo-Christian consensus” after World War II. Influential figures such as Archbishop Fulton Sheen and civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr. helped articulate a vision of American public life in which Protestants, Catholics, and Jews could cooperate while maintaining distinct theological traditions. The conversation wraps up with an examination of our present moment: the resurgence of religious affiliation after decades of decline, the arrival of significant Muslim and Hindu populations, and the internal tensions within contemporary conservatism between what Brogdon calls ‘South Park conservatives’ and religious traditionalists. The First Amendment consensus, they suggest, remains very much a work in progress. In This Episode - (00:00) Introduction and recap of previous episode - (01:11) Religious diversity and immigration in the 20th century - (04:31) Post–Civil War religious conflicts and school controversies - (07:43) Religious violence and media adaptation - (09:15) Rise of the Judeo-Christian consensus - (11:36) Jewish immigration and inclusion - (13:03) Visionary leadership and civil religion - (15:00) Religious leaders and the civil rights movement - (16:21) Rise of the Moral Majority and partisan religion - (21:02) Changing religious and political dynamics - (22:28) Media, technology, and generational shifts - (25:40) Increasing religious diversity beyond Judeo-Christianity - (26:18) Religion, politics, and the Trump era - (29:37) Internal tensions among conservatives - (30:40) Summary and end of conversation Notable Quotes - (01:18) "Even though we're a very religious people, we've got broad freedom to form our own associations and worship freely." — Matthew Brogdon - (05:41) "The reason why this was such a harm isn't just because I'm a partisan of Catholicism, but it actually contributes directly to the ignorance of the population." — James Patterson - (15:32) "We can't meet in the same pew, the same church, but we can all meet on our knees in prayer." — James Patterson - (17:53) "American government is of the people, by the people, and for the people. And at the moment, in spite of the people." — Jerry Falwell (quoted in discussion) - (25:05) “American religious institutions have been very adept at using either old but still effective technology or using new technology to reach souls." — James Patterson - (30:30) "We have religious pluralism in America. We have great religious diversity in the country. And across those lines, we typically have a very strong attachment. You call it a sort of First Amendment consensus, a strong attachment to the idea that government doesn't tell us what to believe and how to worship." — Matthew Brogdon

    Not rated yet
  • Season 3, Episode 15 | For God and Country: How Religious Pluralism Shaped the American Founding

    · 33 min

    When we think of the American Founders, we typically imagine figures like Washington, Jefferson, and Madison—all Protestant gentlemen. But what about the Catholics? And how did a nation built on religious establishments become a model for religious pluralism? In this episode of This Constitution, Matthew Brogdon and James Patterson, associate professor of public affairs at the Institute for American Civics at the University of Tennessee, explore the religious landscape of early America and the surprising role that Catholics, Baptists, Quakers, and other minority groups played in shaping the nation’s commitment to religious freedom. The conversation begins with the often-overlooked Catholic founders, including Charles Carroll of Carrollton, a signer of the Declaration of Independence, and John Carroll, the first Catholic bishop in the United States and founder of Georgetown University. Their experiences reveal how religious minorities helped shape the early republic. Brogdon and Patterson then turn to the debates that led to disestablishment in the states, focusing on Virginia’s struggle over whether the government should tax citizens to support clergy. Ultimately, Americans discovered that removing religion from political competition lowered tensions among religious groups and protected liberty of conscience for all. The result was a uniquely American approach to religion and politics: a system where many faiths could flourish without direct state control. Let’s dive in. In This Episode - (01:12) Catholic founders and Maryland’s history - (02:19) Catholic experience in colonial America - (03:17) Catholic representation and treatment - (04:34) Religious pluralism in colonial America - (07:27) Suspicion of Catholics and religious freedom - (09:13) Reasoning behind religious pluralism - (10:01) Jefferson, Madison, and the religious freedom bill - (12:33) Weakness of the Anglican establishment in the South - (15:57) Class and financial issues in church establishments - (19:29) Disestablishment and religious pluralism - (20:24) Harvard and the concentration of religious power - (21:14) Support for pastors vs. modern vouchers - (23:30) Patrick Henry’s defense and its limits - (24:23) Religious schools vs. church subsidies - (27:15) Catholic bishops and American ecclesiology - (29:02) John Carroll’s appointment and Georgetown - (31:24) French Catholic influence and Washington’s support Notable Quotes - (06:52) "They were also very upset that the British, after winning Quebec, retained its Catholic establishment. They could not believe this.” —James Patterson - (08:05) "One of the causes for unique suspicion of Catholics was a very legitimate concern that Catholics were trying to usurp political authority. I mean, this is the thing that happened with Mary, Queen of Scots. There was the Guy Fawkes attack on Parliament, and then there had been the tumult of James II. And so there was a very big concern." —James Patterson - (08:59) "So religious freedom was, as Michael Breidenbach puts it, it was 'dear-bought,' right? " It was one that they fought on the battlefield to secure, and it was important that they did so in order to earn that trust that was maybe not so earned yet." —James Patterson - (13:08) “Madison actually traveled to see one of these people preach from his prison cell. Their congregants would gather outside, and they would preach through the prison bars.” —Matthew Brogdon - (24:00) "Why do people have to tithe to the state first for the state to then give that to the church? Can't they just tithe to their own church?" —Matthew Brogdon - (25:55) “You mutually benefit from the protection of conscience rights much more than you do from the competition over state patronage.." —James Patterson

    Not rated yet