Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Season 4, Episode 15 | Disobeying Congress and Double-Crossing the French: The Treaty of Paris

From This Constitution · · 35 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

The Revolutionary War ended at Yorktown, but the American Revolution was not over until the ink dried in Paris. After the British defeat at Yorktown, American independence was within reach. But securing it meant navigating competing interests, suspicious allies, difficult negotiations, and a Congress that struggled to get its members in the same room.

In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon explore the Treaty of Paris of 1783 and the diplomatic negotiations that officially ended the American Revolution. They begin with Benjamin West's unfinished painting of the peace commissioners and the political fallout of Yorktown, including Lord North's resignation and Britain's growing anti-war movement.

The conversation turns to America's complicated alliance with France and Spain, the competing goals of the three partners, and the role of British Prime Minister Shelburne in shaping the peace. Savannah explains how Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, and John Jay went beyond Congress's instructions, negotiated directly with the British, and secured terms that included independence, expanded western boundaries, and valuable fishing rights.

They also examine the treaty's promises that went unfulfilled, including the restoration of Loyalist property, protections against wartime prosecutions, and the British withdrawal without taking enslaved people or other American property. The discussion explores the evacuation of approximately 3,000 Black men, women, and children from New York, the weakness of Congress under the Articles of Confederation, and the challenges of enforcing agreements when the national government depended on state cooperation.

Tune in to discover how the Treaty of Paris ended the American Revolution, exposed the weaknesses of America's first government, and helped set the stage for the Constitutional Convention.

In This Episode

- [00:04] Benjamin West's unfinished painting

- [01:09] After Yorktown: Lord North resigns

- [03:54] Diplomats, alliances, and a winning coalition with different goals

- [05:34] Britain regains ground and France wants out

- [06:48] Richard Oswald and the American commissioners

- [08:17] Congress’s instructions: follow the French

- [09:04] Franklin opens talks and Jay arrives suspicious

- [10:32] Vergennes’s secretary goes to London

- [12:16] Adams’s distrust of the French pays off

- [13:54] The preliminary articles and the Treaty of Alliance loophole

- [14:36] Franklin’s tact and a new French loan

- [15:31] Were the commissioners right to disobey Congress?

- [17:53] Independence: “free, sovereign, and independent states”

- [20:13] New boundaries and the Native nations left out

- [21:23] How much land America gained

- [24:09] Fishing rights and the Grand Banks

- [26:44] The terms the states ignored

- [28:12] Enslaved people, Black loyalists, and the New York evacuation

- [31:18] Why Congress could only “urge” the states

- [32:18] Mississippi navigation and West Florida

- [35:07] The ratification scramble in Annapolis

- [36:34] Signing the treaty at the Hôtel de York

Notable Quotes

- (05:21) “He thinks that a generous peace agreement with the Americans will pull the U.S. away from France and keep us as trading partners with the British.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston on Shelburne's strategy

- (07:24) “What we’re about to tell you is the story of how the commissioners disobeyed Congress, sidestepped the French, and got a way-better deal as a result.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston

- (08:50) “This feels like Congress saying, guys, be the JV team.” — Matthew Brogdon

- (15:12) “I don’t think temerity was on it anywhere, but it should have been.” — Matthew Brogdon on Franklin’s list of virtues

- (17:25) “We didn’t break the rules. This is diplomacy and war for that matter. We just killed tens of thousands of people to do this.” — Matthew Brogdon

- (19:04) “In some ways it’s even more guarded than the Declaration of Independence itself.” —…

Back to This Constitution · Report a problem