
This Constitution
Savannah Eccles Johnston & Matthew BrogdonAudio
- Format:
- Podcast
- New episodes:
- Every two weeks
- Typical length:
- about 35 minutes
- Latest episode:
About this show
This Constitution is an every-two-weeks podcast ordained and established by the Center for Constitutional Studies at Utah Valley University, the home of Utah’s Civic Thought & Leadership Initiative.
Co-hosted by Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon, This Constitution equips listeners with the knowledge and insights to engage with the most pressing political questions of our time, starting with Season 1, focusing on the powers and limits of the U.S. presidency.
Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at rss.buzzsprout.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.
Cosmos
Similar by topic and creator
- Dialogue Works
Shares the topics Education, History and News and Politics. - Perun
Shares the topics Education, History and News and Politics. - Plain Civics
Shares the topics Education, History and News and Politics.
Similar shows
Explore more
Episodes
Season 3, Episode 14 | From London to Paris: How the World Received America's Breakup Letter
· 33 min
Did you know that while Americans were celebrating independence on July 4, 1776, it took until August for the news to reach London? Across the Atlantic, the reaction was far more muted, highlighting how information traveled slowly in the 18th century and how the bold step of declaring independence was experienced differently on each side of the ocean. In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon explore how the world reacted to America’s bold declaration of independence. They trace the document’s uncertain journey across the Atlantic, with copies lost in shipwrecks and others seized by British vessels, and examine how foreign governments and the press responded once the news finally reached them. In Britain, officials publicly dismissed it, but the press debated it vigorously. Some magazines printed the full text alongside loyalist rebuttals. Jeremy Bentham issued a sharp critique, and King George III cast American leaders as reckless agitators misleading their people. France paid close attention, but real support only came after the American victory at Saratoga proved the revolution could succeed. Savannah and Matthew also examine the Declaration’s built-in restraint, especially its warning against changing governments for light and transient causes. That note of prudence may explain the world’s initial shrug. Military victory secured independence, but over time, the Declaration’s ideas reshaped global thinking about liberty and self-government. In This Episode - (00:00) Opening and introduction - (00:17) International reaction overview - (01:56) Universal and provocative language - (03:53) Prudence and limits on revolution - (05:19) Comparison to other revolutions - (06:47) Declaration as diplomatic statement - (07:23) Spread of the Declaration in Europe - (08:11) Suppression in Russia and Spain - (10:06) British reaction: official response - (11:57) King George III’s speech - (13:57) Parliamentary debate - (16:53) British press reaction - (23:32) Impact on US-British relations - (23:55) French reaction and delayed support - (26:32) Spanish reaction and suppression - (30:43) Summary and long-term impact Notable Quotes - (00:30) "The Declaration of Independence is wonderfully important within the colonies, but internationally it's kind of met with a bit of a yawn.”— Savannah Eccles Johnston - (00:44) "The rest of the world, now they know that this isn't a British civil war, but these colonists think they're actually independent. But mostly it's still a shrug." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (05:53) "This is the place where I think the American Revolution is revolutionary, but it doesn't become global in the sense that the French Revolution does. The French Revolution sparked basically a world war." — Matthew Brogdon - (09:06) "These Germans living in St. Petersburg knew that the Russian government would never put up with them printing the word 'independence' in a newspaper." — Matthew Brogdon - (09:27) “The Spanish government suppressed the Declaration, even though the Spanish are going to play a very important role in the American Revolution. The Spanish will suppress it.”— Savannah Eccles Johnston - (12:23) "No people ever enjoyed more happiness or lived under a milder government than those revolted provinces." — King George III (quoted by Savannah Eccles Johnston) - (18:43) "The unalienable right of talking nonsense." — British magazine editorial aside (quoted by Savannah Eccles Johnston) - (27:53) "It's a bit of a compliment to the British, actually. The country with which we're actually at war has a robust discussion about our claims in its newspapers. The allies that we wind up with in the war do not want this published." — Matthew Brogdon
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 13 | George Washington and the Constitutional Design of Article II
· 27 min
Was the American presidency meant to be weak, or was it powerful from the start? In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston sits down with Dr. Sai Prakash to examine the original design of Article II and how George Washington shaped the presidency in practice. They explore the Vesting Clause, the creation of a unitary executive, and why early Americans ultimately embraced a strong president after rejecting monarchy. The conversation then turns to the modern “living presidency.” Executive power has expanded through precedent, practice, and political necessity rather than constitutional amendment. From war powers to campaign mandates, Professor Prakash argues that today’s presidency is stronger than ever while Congress grows weaker. At stake is a central question. Can constitutional balance be restored, or are we drifting toward government by executive alone? In This Episode - (00:00) Introduction to Dr. Sai Prakash and his forthcoming book on the presidential pardon - (02:11) Washington as commander in chief and father of the Constitution - (03:26) The anti-monarchical moment and weak state executives - (04:36) The Philadelphia Convention and the move to a unitary executive - (06:50) Creating the presidency with George Washington in mind - (07:44) Comparing the presidency to an elective monarchy - (11:27) Washington’s theory of executive authority - (12:39) The Vesting Clause and foreign-affairs power - (15:07) How Article II came to be seen as weak - (17:31) The rise of the living Constitution - (19:09) War powers and presidential precedent - (21:27) Delaying statutory mandates and administrative reinterpretation - (23:24) Is a living presidency necessary? - (25:58) Campaign promises and the idea of a presidential mandate - (27:00) The presidency as law-enforcement officer, not policy engine - (28:30) Congress’s institutional decline - (29:19) Restoring constitutional balance Notable Quotes (06:50) “We kind of created this office with George Washington in mind.” — Sai Prakash (12:39) “The Constitution grants executive power. It’s a suite of powers related to law execution and foreign affairs.” — Sai Prakash (19:29) “The strongest declaration of war is from the mouths of cannons.” — Sai Prakash (25:03) “We can’t wait.” — Referencing modern executive justification for unilateral action (27:00) “The president is meant to be the institution of law enforcement, not primarily about making law.” — Sai Prakash (29:19) “Letting a president get away with usurping another branch’s authority today might be in your short-term interest, but it isn’t healthy for the country.” — Sai Prakash
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 12 | Announcing Independence: How the Declaration Went Viral in 1776
· 37 min
What good is a declaration if no one hears it? After the Continental Congress approved the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776, the real work began: Announcing it to the American people and the world. In this episode of This Constitution, host Savannah Eccles Johnston is joined by Matthew Brogdon to explore how the Declaration of Independence was published, proclaimed, and received in 1776. Together, they trace the Declaration’s journey from Congress to the public square, examining how a fledgling nation used print culture, public readings, and a robust free press to unite the colonies and justify rebellion to the world. Savannah and Matthew walk through the critical timeline from July 2 to July 4, explaining why Independence Day commemorates publication rather than the vote itself. They unpack the importance of John Hancock’s role as the public face of the Declaration, the significance of the Dunlap Broadside as the first printed versions Americans actually read, and why the famous handwritten parchment played little role in the document’s original impact. The episode highlights how the Declaration spread rapidly through newspapers, churches, courthouses, and military camps, becoming as much an oral event as a written one. Public readings mobilized soldiers, artisans, farmers, women, and those unable to read, transforming the Declaration into a shared civic experience. Savannah and Matthew also explore the dramatic colonial reactions from celebrations and statue-toppling to loyalist resistance and rebuttals, revealing a nation deeply divided even at the moment of independence. Finally, the conversation turns to the Goddard Declaration, the first printed version to include the signers' names, produced by Mary Katherine Goddard in 1777. The episode argues that the successful announcement of independence was not just a political achievement, but a triumph of the American free press and a powerful early expression of democratic communication. In This Episode - (00:18) The challenge of announcing independence - (01:04) What’s new about the Declaration? - (01:31) Congress’s role and the importance of eloquence - (02:47) The Declaration’s immediate impact and fading - (02:57) Timeline: July 2 vs. July 4 - (03:28) Why July 4th matters - (05:24) John Hancock’s role in publication - (08:10) The Dunlap broadside: the first printed Declaration - (10:33) Dunlap’s editorial changes and official record - (12:10) The engrossed copy vs. the Dunlap broadside - (15:38) The technology and democratization of the Declaration - (16:11) Distribution and public readings - (17:45) First public readings and military announcements - (19:11) The Declaration’s oral and print spread - (21:07) The Declaration in print culture - (23:20) Speed and reach of distribution - (24:20) Colonial reactions: revolutionary celebrations - (28:19) Colonial reactions: loyalist responses - (32:13) The Goddard broadside: publishing the signers - (35:21) The Declaration’s enduring legacy Notable Quotes - (03:32) “A declaration doesn’t matter unless you make it public.” — Matthew Brogdon - (05:47) “It’s not Jefferson who is the face of the Declaration at first. It’s John Hancock.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (10:23) “It was the eighteenth-century version of going viral.” — Matthew Brogdon - (16:11) “There’s something very democratic about the Dunlap broadsides.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (17:24) “The Declaration was written to be read out loud.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (25:22) “We’ve been tearing down statues since the very beginning.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (35:34) “The Declaration of Independence announcement is a testament and a victory of the American Free Press.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 11 | Not Just Jefferson: How Congress's Red Pen Helped Create the Declaration We Know
· 27 min
Who really wrote the Declaration of Independence? Was it Thomas Jefferson’s carefully crafted vision, or the outcome of an intense, compromise-driven process inside Congress? In this episode of This Constitution, host Savannah Eccles Johnston is joined by Matthew Brogdon to examine how Congress transformed Thomas Jefferson’s original draft of the Declaration of Independence into the document the world would come to know. The conversation traces the Declaration’s path from the Committee of Five to the Committee of the Whole, where Congress cut a quarter of Jefferson’s draft. Savannah and Matthew unpack the most significant changes, including the removal of the slavery passage, the shift from emotionally charged rhetoric to a more legal tone, and the deliberate decision to aim grievances at the Crown rather than the British people. These revisions, they argue, were driven by prudence, diplomacy, and the need to persuade both domestic and foreign audiences. The episode also highlights Congress’s surprising additions. References to divine providence and a Supreme Judge of the world were strengthened, shaping a civil religious language that would echo throughout American political life. In the end, Savannah and Matthew argue that while Jefferson’s genius is undeniable, the Declaration is best understood as Congress’s declaration. It is a democratic document, forged through collaboration, compromise, and representation, and a model for how Americans would speak and govern themselves from the very beginning. In This Episode - (00:00) Opening and introduction - (00:17) Background to the Declaration - (01:00) Drafting and committee process - (02:12) Congressional revision process - (03:23) Major edits and reactions - (04:34) Removal of the slave passage - (06:57) Strengthening legal arguments - (07:31) Toning down emotional language - (08:30) Example of emotional language removed - (10:41) Toning down anti-British rhetoric - (12:06) Example of anti-British language removed - (15:07) Summary of major changes - (15:17) Addition of religious language - (16:22) Significance of religious additions - (20:27) Motivations for religious language - (20:45) Is Congress’s version better? - (23:00) Examples of improved rhetoric - (25:00) The Declaration as a collaborative product - (26:44) Conclusion and podcast outro Notable Quotes - (04:25) “25% Congress slashes and burns. I mean, they took a red pen to the thing.” — Matthew Brogdon - (01:34) "So this wasn't just Jefferson's hand. You know, it wasn't like Jefferson the author. Everybody else is a clerk. There's actually quite a lot of collaboration." — Matthew Brogdon - (07:32) “By making it more legally efficacious, some of that means making the document a little more boring.” — Matthew Brogdon - (08:07) "Adam says he defended every word of the draft like he didn't want to see any of this change, as though he grudgingly admits to Abigail later that maybe some of this was prudent, making this less personal, less antagonistic." — Matthew Brogdon - (14:10) “The road to glory and happiness is open to us too. We will climb it in a separate state and acquiesce in the necessity which pronounces our everlasting adieu." — Matthew Brogdon - (22:41) "All the changes seem to be for the better." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (25:05) "Yes, Jefferson is the primary author of the declaration, but it's actually Congress's declaration." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (26:30) “I think the best way to sum this up is with the title of the declaration itself.” — Matthew Brogdon - (26:42) "It's Congress's declaration. It's not the committee's, and it's not Jefferson's. It's not Adams's. It's Congress's declaration speaking for the United States of America." — Matthew Brogdon
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 10 | Frederick Douglass and Martin Luther King Jr.: Two Visions of the Constitution and Equality
· 40 min
How can the same Declaration of Independence lead Frederick Douglass and Martin Luther King Jr. to such different conclusions about the Constitution? In this special MLK Day episode of This Constitution, host Savannah Eccles Johnston is joined by Dr. Lucas Morel, professor of ethics and politics at Washington and Lee University, to delve into how Frederick Douglass and Martin Luther King Jr. interpreted the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the American political order. The conversation traces Douglass’s intellectual evolution from initially condemning the Constitution as a pro-slavery pact, influenced by William Lloyd Garrison, to later embracing it as a “glorious liberty document” capable of delivering on the Declaration’s promise of natural rights and equality. Dr. Morel explains how Douglass came to see the Constitution as fundamentally anti-slavery when read according to its text and purpose, rather than the clouded intentions of its framers. The episode then turns to Martin Luther King Jr., examining how King remained deeply committed to the Declaration’s ideals while growing increasingly skeptical of whether the constitutional order and the American people could fully realize them without massive federal intervention. From I Have a Dream to Where Do We Go From Here, the discussion highlights King’s shift toward arguments for reparations, equality of outcomes, and expanded federal power. Ultimately, Savannah and Lucas ask a profound constitutional question: Which vision better preserves America’s founding principles? Is freedom best secured by equal laws and fair play, as Douglass believed, or by equity-driven reforms designed to correct historic injustice, as King increasingly argued? The episode offers a rigorous, thoughtful comparison of two towering figures whose legacies continue to shape debates over equality, rights, and constitutional meaning. In This Episode - (01:07) Why Frederick Douglass matters - (03:21) Douglass’s early constitutional views and Garrison - (07:37) Douglass’s break with Garrison and shift in views - (07:51) Douglass’s reinterpretation of the Constitution - (12:08) Douglass’s arguments for congressional power over slavery - (13:46) Douglass vs. Lincoln on federal power - (18:41) Principled vs. rhetorical shift in Douglass’s views - (19:53) Douglass and Lincoln as statesmen, not founders - (25:45) MLK’s relationship to the Declaration and Constitution - (27:15) MLK’s shift toward reparations and federal intervention - (28:28) MLK’s critique of colorblindness and equality - (30:30) MLK’s influence on modern equality debates - (31:04) MLK’s reinterpretation of the Constitution - (35:41) Competing notions of liberty and the Declaration - (36:14) Who got it right, Douglass or MLK? Notable Quotes - (07:24) “Douglass believed in the Declaration more than Garrison did.” — Lucas Morel - (00:27:15) "Frederick Douglass can be considered a statesman because of the way he used the English language, the king's English, as it were, on behalf of the principles of the regime." — Lucas Morel - (36:40) “I’ll put all my eggs in the Douglass basket.” — Lucas Morel - (37:08) “Frederick Douglass, as you said earlier, was a true believer in these principles. He believed in them more than most white Americans believed in their principles.” — Lucas Morel - (37:37) “King came to believe what he called this thing called color shock, that there was a way in which color still has this power over people in the United States.”— Lucas Morel - (38:51) “At the end of the day, Frederick Douglass vision overlapped much more closely to Lincoln than Martin Luther King's did.”— Lucas Morel
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 9 | The Collaborative Origins of the Declaration: Unpacking Jefferson’s Role
· 20 min
Was Thomas Jefferson the sole author of the Declaration? In this episode of This Constitution, Matthew Brogdon sits down with Holly Megson, senior documentary editor on the Quill Project at Pembroke College, Oxford, to trace how the Declaration of Independence actually took shape inside the Second Continental Congress. Together, they move beyond the familiar image of Jefferson writing alone and uncover the collective effort that produced one of history’s most influential political texts. Matthew and Holly explore the formation of the Committee of Five—Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, Benjamin Franklin, Roger Sherman, and Robert Livingston—and examine what little documentary evidence survives of their work. From Jefferson’s heavily marked “rough draft” to the conflicting memories Adams and Jefferson recorded decades later, the episode reveals how the Declaration emerged amid secrecy, overwhelming workloads, and deep uncertainty about whether independence would even be approved. The conversation also asks a critical historical question: how should credit be assigned? While Jefferson clearly served as the Declaration’s primary draftsman, Holly explains why the document is best understood as a collaborative act of statesmanship, shaped by shared grievances, inherited political language, and editorial interventions from Adams, Franklin, and Congress itself. This episode ultimately shows that America’s most iconic statement of independence was not the product of a single moment of inspiration; instead, it was the result of collective judgment under extraordinary pressure. In This Episode - (00:14) Meet Holly Megson and the Quill Project - (01:13) Why the lone-author myth persists - (01:25) The Committee of Five explained - (02:23) Sources Jefferson consulted while drafting - (03:17) How legislative committees actually write documents - (04:24) What instructions Jefferson may have received - (05:47) Earlier grievances and preexisting language - (07:44) Why Sherman and Livingston fade from the record - (08:52) Adams vs. Jefferson: conflicting memories - (10:10) Jefferson’s response to Adams’s account - (12:58) The crushing committee workload - (14:33) Drafting under wartime pressure - (16:25) Congress edits, Jefferson objects - (17:38) Was Jefferson the author or the draftsman? - (18:44) Why contemporaneous records matter Notable Quotes - (00:46) "Americans sort of walk around with an image in mind that Jefferson sat down in his boarding room and drafted the declaration, showed it to a few people, and then Congress adopted it. And there's a much more complex drafting process." — Matthew Brogdon - (01:46) " There are no records, unsurprisingly, of when they met because of the nature of what they were discussing." — Holly Megson - (07:02) "Jefferson, very helpfully after the Revolutionary War, decided that he wanted to mark [the Rough Draft] document... he doesn't attribute any of the changes to Livingston or Sherman." — Holly Megson - (10:13) "The committee unanimously decided that he should write the draft, refuting the idea of any kind of subcommittee and really reinforcing that. It was a one-man endeavor,"— Holly Megson - (17:53) " Jefferson is definitely the primary author, but if he were an academic, he'd be quite a bad academic. He hasn't properly cited his co-authors." — Holly Megson - (17:39) "I don't necessarily dispute that he was the author. I do think the term draftsman is more appropriate." — Holly Megson - (19:04) “I do think it is important, in summary, to say Jefferson plays the principal role. He is in many ways the draftsman author of the Declaration, but owes so much to the collaborative work that goes on in this committee.” — Matthew Brogdon
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 8 | The Weaver of Our Foundational Fabric: Justice for John Adams
· 38 min
What if the Declaration of Independence wasn’t just Jefferson’s triumph, but John Adams’s victory too? In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon make the case for giving John Adams his due. Often remembered as prickly, pompous, or perpetually overshadowed, Adams was in fact one of the most important and hardest-working architects of American independence. Savannah and Matthew trace Adams’s rise from a New England farmer’s son to the fiercest and most relentless advocate for independence in the Continental Congress. Long before July 4, 1776, Adams was pushing Congress toward self-government, drafting foundational documents, organizing the war effort, and building the coalition that made independence possible. The episode explores Adams’s deep commitment to the rule of law, his principled defense of the British soldiers after the Boston Massacre, and his decisive role in nominating George Washington as commander in chief. It also reveals how Adams shaped the Declaration itself, not just as Jefferson’s editor, but as the strategist who insisted a Virginian write it, helped outline its structure, supplied key ideas and language, and then defended it on the floor of Congress as its fiercest champion. Along the way, Savannah and Matthew unpack Adams’s political philosophy, especially his emphasis on consent, safety, and happiness as the true ends of government, and show how his thinking echoes throughout the Declaration and later American constitutional design. The episode concludes with Adams’s enduring legacy, a founder who may never have been popular, but whose ambition, integrity, and relentless work helped create a nation and who deserves far more credit than history often gives him. In This Episode - [00:10 Introduction and justice for John Adams - [01:20] Adams’s early life and background - [03:14] Personality and public perception - [07:17] Principles and the Boston Massacre defense - [08:23] Role in the Continental Congress - [09:21] Adams’s push for new governments - [12:55] Lee’s resolution and Adams’s advocacy - [15:48] Adams’s personality and coalition building - [18:23] Formation of the Committee of Five - [22:43] Adams’s self-awareness and Jefferson’s drafting - [24:20] The drafting process and Adams’s influence - [27:13] Adams as defender of the Declaration - [28:10] Adams’s language and philosophy in the Declaration - [32:59] Adams’s post-revolution contributions - [34:27] Adams’s legacy and death - [35:28] Adams in popular culture and the need for a monument - [38:04] Conclusion and call for justice Notable Quotes - (00:21) “The theme of this episode is justice for John Adams.”— Savannah Eccles Johnston - (11:07) “Adams pushed Congress in the fall of 1775. We're months, half a year from independence. And Adams is saying Congress should tell states to establish new governments based on the consent of their own people, exercising their own judgment with the idea that they would conduce to the happiness and safety of their constituents and America in general.”— Matthew Brogdon - (18:07) “It does take a person like John Adams who will just ignore the social cues, like ignore all of the social opprobrium attached to being caught making trouble, to actually induce everybody to move, get the job done right.”— Matthew Brogdon - (23:00) “You are a Virginian, and a Virginian ought to appear at the head of this business.”— John Adams - (27:50) “In many ways, yes, Jefferson wrote the Declaration, but it’s Adams’s Declaration too.”— Savannah Eccles Johnston - (34:29)“John Adams deserves a lot more credit for the Declaration of Independence and for the American system of government in general.”— Savannah Eccles Johnston
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 7 | The Declaration and Slavery: The Question 1776 Could Not Settle
· 27 min
Did you know that Thomas Jefferson originally wrote a fierce condemnation of slavery into the Declaration of Independence, only for Congress to remove it before signing the final document? And did you know that in 1776, no one was certain whether slavery in America would fade away, transform, or expand? In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Dr. Nicholas Cole, Pembroke College, University of Oxford, explore the complicated world of slavery at the time the Declaration was written. Together, they walk through why Jefferson’s anti-slavery passage was removed, how Americans understood slavery in 1776, and why the institution stood on a very uncertain foundation during the revolutionary period. Dr. Cole explains how the Atlantic world, English legal rulings, gradual emancipation proposals, and the widespread reading of Montesquieu shaped early American thinking. The conversation also explores the financial barriers to ending slavery, the moral and religious arguments circulating in the colonies, and the troubling realities within slaveholder families, including Jefferson’s own. They then discuss figures like George Washington and John Adams and how their attitudes toward slavery reveal a more complex political and moral landscape than many assume. This episode shows how the Declaration of Independence emerged from a moment filled with unresolved questions, intense debate, and moral tension. It challenges the idea that the founders were blind to the contradictions of slavery and highlights how close the nation may have been to choosing a very different path. In This Episode - (00:00) Introduction and episode setup - (01:17) Jefferson’s stricken slavery passage - (01:28) Physicality and emphasis in Jefferson’s draft - (04:29) Context and debates on slavery in 1776 - (06:00) Legal and social shifts against slavery - (09:20) Gradual emancipation and economic obstacles - (12:53) Humanity vs. property: enslaved persons as ‘men.’ - (14:29) Changing racial attitudes and moral regression - (15:38) Jefferson, Sally Hemings, and family complexities - (17:47) Christian and moral arguments against slavery - (19:09) Philosophical and legal arguments on slavery - (21:10) Montesquieu, republicanism, and slavery’s contradiction - (22:08) George Washington, Adams, and founders’ approaches - (25:13) Slavery and the founding compromises Notable Quotes - (06:01) “Montesquieu said you can't really have a republic and slavery, and that the arguments in favor of slavery are illegitimate.” - Dr. Nicholas Cole - (11:08) “But I think there is this real problem that so much money has been loaned in order to allow people to own slaves. And so that makes ending it very difficult.” - Dr. Nicholas Cole - (13:14) “Jefferson knew his property consisted of men. He understood the moral weight of that contradiction.” - Dr. Nicholas Cole - (23:41) “Washington does things as a slave owner that we would find utterly abhorrent, including rotating slaves from his household when he's president and in a state that doesn't recognize slavery.” - Dr. Nicholas Cole - (24:37) “Maybe it's better to speak more about Washington and certainly Adams and less about Jefferson as kind of core founding fathers. Hopefully, we're more Washingtonian and more like Adams, the American political project, than Jefferson.” - Savannah Eccles Johnston - (25:20) “If anybody had tried to use the convention to settle the question of slavery, there would have been no union. That is absolutely clear."- Dr. Nicholas Cole - (26:19) “1776 is murky on the question of slavery, and this actually helps us understand the moment and the document and what it represents and what it led to understand that everything was kind of up in the air.”- Savannah Eccles Johnston
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 6 | The Declarations That Shaped the Declaration
· 24 min
What if the story of American independence didn’t actually begin with Jefferson at his writing desk? What if long before the Declaration of Independence, more than a hundred towns, counties, militias, and even grand juries had already taken matters into their own hands and declared themselves free of Britain? In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon uncover the astonishing world of forgotten declarations that came before July 4, 1776. Savannah and Matthew trace how these early statements emerged from every corner of American life: Massachusetts town meetings, South Carolina grand juries, militia battalions in Pennsylvania, and even groups like the New York Mechanics Union. These weren’t fringe ideas. They were the building blocks of a national identity forming from the bottom up. Long before Congress acted, Americans were already asserting natural rights, condemning monarchy, and proclaiming themselves a new people. They also walk through the most famous example, the Virginia Declaration of Rights, written by George Mason, whose language helped inspire both Jefferson and the later Bill of Rights. Along the way, they explore why virtue, frugality, temperance, and justice were once considered essential political principles, and how Americans gradually shifted from moral to material thinking in the Progressive Era. This episode reveals a powerful truth: America wasn’t created by one declaration. It was created by hundreds of voices speaking the same political language long before the nation was officially born. In This Episode - (00:00) Introduction - (00:52) The Quill Project and early declarations - (01:25) Season of declaring independence - (02:31) Who issued declarations? - (03:31) Examples of local declarations - (04:43) Massachusetts town declarations - (05:51) Elements of declarations - (07:48) Declaration as national restatement - (08:46) Virginia Declaration of Rights - (10:41) Philosophical statements and rights - (11:02) Virginia Declaration’s enduring language - (12:44) Virtue and state constitutions - (16:56) Virtue’s decline in the Progressive Era - (19:23) Common elements in all declarations - (20:09) What does declaration writing say about America - (21:35) Federal character and consensus building - (22:16) Distinctly American rights and traditions - (23:03) Conclusion and further resources Notable Quotes - (00:44) “Politico estimated that there are over 100 such declarations, but now we have them all in one location.”— Savannah Eccles Johnston - (03:37) “There's a grand jury indictment in Charleston, the 23rd of April in 1776, that declares that the local government is, in the opinion of the local government, the American colonies are independent.” — Matthew Brogdon - (05:40) “Thomas Jefferson says, the Declaration is just a statement of the American mind. And quite literally, that's what it is.”— Savannah Eccles Johnston - (07:25) “You should really think of these like a list of elements. Grievances. Independence. Form of government. Statement of political principles.” — Matthew Brogdon - (08:25) “So who really is the spirit of America, Massachusetts? Is it you or is it North Carolina? I'm going for Massachusetts.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (09:22) “That all men are by nature equally free and independent and have certain inherent rights...That's just the philosophical statement of the Declaration of Independence in a little clunkier form.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (23:03) “Let's end with that line that these declarations, both the National Declaration and the State Declarations, the local declaration, the Association declarations, are what constituted America.” — Matthew Brogdon
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 5 | Thomas Paine: Revolutionary, Not Patriot
· 33 min
Did you know the man who wrote Common Sense, the pamphlet that inspired Americans to fight for independence, died alone with only six mourners at his funeral? In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon unpack the fascinating and tragic story of Thomas Paine, a man who helped spark the Revolution but couldn’t find a home in the nation he helped create. They follow Paine’s incredible journey from a struggling English immigrant to one of the most gifted writers of his generation, standing shoulder to shoulder with Franklin, Jefferson, and Hamilton whose words gave the colonies a sense of identity and purpose. Common Sense and The American Crisis didn’t just rally troops; they shaped what it meant to be American. But the same bold, uncompromising spirit that made him a hero would also turn him into an outcast. Savannah and Matthew trace how Paine’s time in France, his open attacks on George Washington, and his controversial book The Age of Reason, where he challenged organized religion, left him alienated and forgotten. Was he a patriot or just a perpetual revolutionary? This episode dives into that question and reminds us how someone can be absolutely right for their moment in history yet completely lost in their own time. In This Episode - (00:00) Introduction - (00:17) Thomas Paine’s early life and arrival in America - (01:02) Paine’s early career in America and Common Sense - (01:24) Impact and success of Common Sense - (01:59) Why Common Sense was so powerful - (02:26) Paine’s attack on monarchy and hereditary rule - (04:13) Biblical arguments against monarchy - (05:15) Paine’s writing style and rhetorical skill - (06:40) The case for American independence and identity - (09:31) Immigrants and the American identity - (10:31) Paine and the naming of the United States - (11:28) Speculation on Paine and the Declaration of Independence - (11:41) America’s duty and revolutionary purpose - (12:17) Providence, history, and revolutionary ideals - (13:07) American vs. French revolutionary ideals - (14:38) Common Sense’s public reception and influence - (15:38) Copyright, authors’ rights, and Paine’s finances - (16:14) The American Crisis and its impact - (18:36) Paine’s decline and involvement in the French Revolution - (20:08) Paine’s imprisonment and rescue - (24:17) Paine’s break with Washington and controversial writings - (25:35) The Age of Reason and alienation from America - (27:01) Paine’s radical ideas on property and universal income - (29:10) Paine’s legacy: revolutionary vs. patriot - (32:23) Lessons from Paine’s life and death Notable Quotes - (02:26) “Paine is an excellent writer. I mean, he's got a claim to being one of the most talented writers of the founding in a generation that boasted Ben Franklin and Thomas Jefferson and Gouverneur Morris and Alexander Hamilton.." — Matthew Brogdon - (02:46) "I think he has a way of identifying the sort of core arguments, the core complaints. I mean, he's anticipating, in many ways, the argument of the declaration, because he's identifying the principal target as monarchy." — Matthew Brogdon - (04:18) “He uses kind of a biblical argument against monarchy, which is very common in this day to do. But given the fact that he doesn't believe in the Bible, this is an interesting thing for him to do.”— Savannah Eccles Johnston - (06:18) "The great joke of monarchy is that it so often gives us an ass for a lion. You know, you start out with a lion and then you wind up with the kids or just not what they ought to be." — Matthew Brogdon - (10:33) "Thomas Paine is, in some quarters, credited with creating the name United States of America." — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (20:02) "T
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 4 | Were the British Really That Bad? The Grievance Politics That Justified the Revolution
· 34 min
How did the Americans go from loyal British subjects to full-blown revolutionaries? Were the British really that bad, or were the colonists simply overreacting? In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon unpack the long and escalating list of grievances that transformed loyal British subjects into determined revolutionaries. Moving beyond the myths of the Boston Tea Party, they trace a history of constitutional conflict, from the Proclamation of 1763 and the Stamp Act to the Boston Massacre. The conversation reveals how British attempts to reassert control, such as closing the Boston Harbor and dissolving local legislatures, were seen not as legitimate governance but as a fundamental attack on a 150-year tradition of American self-rule. Discover the compelling "Dominion Theory" that American colonists advanced as a peaceful alternative to independence, and explore the pivotal moment when Britain's heavy-handed response to protest united the colonies and made revolution inevitable. If you've ever wondered whether the Founders were justified in their rebellion, this episode provides the evidence. Tune in to explore how real grievances, not reckless rebellion, sparked the birth of American independence. In This Episode - (00:00) Introduction - (00:44) Reading the declaration’s grievances - (02:14) First Continental Congress and the Declaration of Resolves - (04:29) Second Continental Congress and taking up arms - (06:36) Lexington and Concord: the first shots - (08:49) Colonial grievances as reactions to British actions - (09:25) Colonial-British relations before the French and Indian War - (10:54) The French and Indian War and its aftermath - (11:11) Proclamation of 1763 and colonial expansion - (12:41) New taxes: Sugar Act, Stamp Act, Townshend Acts - (13:44) Homespun movement and boycotts - (15:54) Boston Massacre and escalating tensions - (16:34) The Tea Act and the Boston Tea Party - (18:37) Internal colonial debate and Sons of Liberty - (20:36) British reaction: the Intolerable Acts - (21:39) Impact of the Intolerable Acts on colonial unity - (22:34) Suspension of local governments and trial rights - (24:13) Quartering of troops and widespread alarm - (25:37) The Quebec Act and religious tensions - (25:58) Why the Intolerable Acts were the breaking point - (28:11) Dominion theory and alternative constitutional proposals - (31:00) Missed opportunities for reconciliation - (33:03) British conduct during the war - (34:04) Conclusion: Were the British really that bad Notable Quotes - (03:21) “The keeping of standing armies in these colonies in times of peace, without the consent of the legislature of that colony, is against the law.” — Matthew - (06:48) “ General Gage... sent out from Boston a large detachment of his army, who made an unprovoked assault on the inhabitants at Lexington.” — Matthew - (13:56) “They would all meet in these spinning clubs and make homespun clothes and really shame other people who were buying any British-made goods.” — Savannah - (16:07) “The propaganda wheels are turning. The idea is not only are they taxing us, but now they’re actually shooting us.” — Savannah - (21:43) “The effect of this is that Boston’s going to starve. It’s a trade economy. You close Boston Harbor, you destroy the economy.” — Savannah - (33:13) “They wound up sending German mercenaries, the Hessians to fight on their behalf, and this actually results in widespread sexual violence against American women.” — Matthew - (34:04) “So to answer the question, were the British really that bad? Yes. Yes, they were.” — Savannah
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 3 | The Folk Origins of Freedom: How Ordinary Americans Shaped the Declaration
· 26 min
Have you ever wondered where America’s revolutionary ideas really came from? Was it the genius of the Founders? What if the story of the Constitution didn’t begin in Philadelphia in 1776, but in colonial homes, small-town churches, and the stubborn belief that no one has the right to rule another? In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon trace the folk origins of American self-government. Through the voices of farmers, ministers, and everyday colonists, they uncover how the principles of liberty and equality were not imported from Europe’s philosophers but born from generations of lived experience. From the self-written laws of the early colonies to the fiery courage of men like Captain Levi Preston, who famously said, “We always had governed ourselves, and we always meant to,” this conversation reveals that America’s Revolution was not just a political one. It was deeply personal. If you think the Declaration of Independence was the start of freedom’s story, think again. This episode examines how the American spirit of self-rule was already alive, thriving, and waiting to be documented. In This Episode - (00:18) Introduction to discussion topic - (00:55) Captain Levi Preston and folk origins - (02:13) Colonial self-government traditions - (04:53) 150 years of self-government - (06:14) Cultural and political ties to Britain - (07:16) Influence of American colonies on Britain - (08:58) Speculation on the empire’s future - (09:39) Radical ideas: No man has a right to rule another - (10:32) Sam Whittemore’s story and individual action - (11:26) “A man can stand up” – Johnny Tremain reference - (13:41) The principle of equality and self-government - (14:48) Folk origins and pervasiveness of the idea - (15:26) Contradictions: Slavery and self-government - (17:28) Revolutionary spread of equality - (18:10) Inherited and revolutionary aspects - (19:25) Washington’s change and sentiment revolution - (20:27) Twin dynamics: Inheritance and improvement - (22:20) Is self-government core to American identity? - (22:28) Tocqueville: Freedom and religion - (24:19) Pragmatic wisdom in the Declaration - (24:33) Recap and folk origins summary Notable Quotes - (01:43) “What we meant in going for those redcoats was this. We always had governed ourselves and we always meant to. They didn’t mean we should.” — Captain Levi Preston - (01:57) “The folk origin of the Declaration, if you will, is to preserve the traditional way of life, which is just to govern yourself, just to be in charge of yourself.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (05:41) “It’s tempting to think of revolution as we start off as British colonies and we gradually become American. Actually, the colonies were very distant, very separate, and very independent from Great Britain in the 17th century.” — Matthew Brogdon - (06:57) “It’s kind of like you’ve been ignored by your parents and now you’re 17 and suddenly they want to be your parents again, and now you’re ready to be independent.” — Savannah - (11:19) “No man has a right to rule another. And you actually brought this up before the podcast, this idea of a man’s right to stand up.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston - (12:34) “We’re fighting so that a man can stand up.” — Matthew Brogdon quoting James Otis - (22:30) “The distinctive thing that Americans did, that no one had done in republican societies before us, was we combined the spirit of freedom and the spirit of religion.” — Matthew Brogdon - (24:40) “The idea of self-government is not new with the Declaration. You said earlier that people didn’t read the Declaration and go, oh really? That’s good to know. No, they already knew this.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 2 | The Black-Robed Regiment: The Preachers Who Fought for Independence
· 39 min
What if the American Revolution didn’t begin in the halls of Congress, but in the pews of colonial churches? In this episode of This Constitution, hosts Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon uncover the spiritual and intellectual fire that helped ignite the Revolution. Before muskets were fired at Lexington and Concord, preachers across New England were already preparing their congregations for rebellion, not just politically but theologically. From the sermons of Reverend Jonas Clark to the democratic church governance of the Puritans, and from Jonathan Mayhew’s biblical case for resistance to tyranny to Peter Muhlenberg’s dramatic call to arms, Savannah and Matthew trace how America’s revolution was born in the pulpit long before it was fought on the battlefield. Together, they explore how this Black-Robed Regiment of clergymen bridged faith and politics, shaping the moral vocabulary of liberty that defined the nation’s founding. In This Episode - (00:17) Introduction and overview of “The Black Robed Regiment” - (00:53) Reverend Jonas Clark and the Battle of Lexington - (04:37) Puritan origins of political liberty and separation of church and state - (07:14) How congregational church governance shaped early democracy - (10:21) Thomas Hooker, Connecticut, and the first written constitution - (17:00) Jonathan Mayhew’s sermon and the theology of rebellion - (23:19) Samuel Cook’s fearless sermon after the Boston Massacre - (27:29) Tocqueville, Frederick Douglass, and the moral force of the pulpit - (32:58) John Witherspoon and Peter Muhlenberg — faith in action - (38:06) Takeaway: The Revolution began in the pews Notable Quotes (00:08:44) “Democratic governance in America didn’t begin in politics. It began in the church.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston (00:24:45) “The bravery it took for Samuel Cook to stare down the loyal governor and call him a tyrant… that’s a different kind of courage.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston (00:25:09) “People say religion and politics should be kept separate. But that view ignores our founding. Religion was the spark.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston (00:20:36) “If obedience to rulers who govern on God’s behalf is obedience to God, then obedience to a tyrant would be obedience to the devil.” — Matthew Brogdon (00:23:40) “It’s a dangerous thing when theology fuels revolution, but without it, we wouldn’t have political progress.” — Matthew Brogdon (00:27:55) “Religion in America has always shaped politics—not through force, but through conscience.” — Matthew Brogdon
Not rated yetSeason 3, Episode 1 | 1777: The Crucible That Forged George Washington
· 43 min
Season 3 of This Constitution focuses on the people and events surrounding the making of the Declaration of Independence. What if America’s Revolution had collapsed before it truly began? In this episode of This Constitution, host Savannah Eccles Johnston sits down with Dr. Kevin Weddle, retired U.S. Army colonel, military historian, and author of The Compleat Victory, to explore how George Washington survived the most dangerous year of the war. From the daring crossing of the Delaware to the humiliating loss of Fort Ticonderoga, Washington faced both battlefield disaster and political backstabbing. Yet, in the fire of 1777, he learned to balance three roles at once: front-line commander, national commander-in-chief, and political strategist. Together, Johnston and Weddle trace how Washington’s leadership in this single year transformed him into the indispensable man of the Revolution and laid the foundation for his presidency. In This Episode - (00:11) Introduction and guest welcome - (01:00) The army on the brink: Washington’s retreat through New Jersey - (04:10) The “Ten Crucial Days”: Trenton and Princeton victories - (08:30) Washington’s Fabian strategy and morale revival - (11:20) Saratoga campaign and the fall of Fort Ticonderoga - (15:00) Skyler, Gates, and a command crisis in the north - (20:45) Washington’s reinforcements: Arnold, Lincoln, Morgan’s riflemen - (27:30) Talent management and leadership lessons - (31:10) The Conway Cabal and Gates’ political maneuvering - (36:00) Washington’s confrontation with Conway and political savvy - (39:00) How Washington neutralized rivals and preserved authority - (40:35) Lessons of 1777 for Washington’s presidency Notable Quotes (05:45) “Just pulling something like that off with an army that’s falling apart—bad morale, desertions everywhere—is brilliant. It’s a tribute to Washington’s leadership.” — Kevin Weddle (10:01) “It’s considered the ‘Ten Crucial Days’ of the American Revolution because those two victories really turned things around.” — Kevin Weddle (28:09) “Talent management—that’s exactly what Washington was doing. He knew where the right leaders needed to be, even if it meant sending his best away.” — Kevin Weddle (33:39) “I think this is a brilliant move on Washington’s part… he goes to Congress and says: I am commander-in-chief. Reinforce it. And they do.” — Kevin Weddle (39:57) “By eliminating rivals and strengthening his own position, Washington emerged from 1777 not weaker, but indispensable.” — Savannah Eccles Johnston
Not rated yetSeason 2, Episode 18 | America’s Greatest Invention: Collective Constitution-Making
· 43 min
What if America’s greatest strength wasn’t just its leaders, but the way everyday people came together to shape history? In this episode of This Constitution, host Matthew Brogdon sits down with Nicholas Cole of Oxford’s Pembroke College, creator of the Quill Project, to dig into the overlooked story of America’s founding. Far from being the work of a single “lawgiver” like Solon or Jefferson, the Declaration of Independence and other revolutionary texts were born out of spirited collaboration. From town halls in Massachusetts to Virginia’s Fairfax Resolves, communities debated, revised, and ultimately claimed ownership over the words that would launch a nation. Cole explains how this culture of deliberation, grand juries, militias, assemblies, and conventions set America apart from revolutions elsewhere, transforming ordinary gatherings into the foundation of popular sovereignty. Together, Brogdon and Cole trace how these practices not only produced the Declaration but also laid the groundwork for the U.S. Constitution and federal union. They explore how Jefferson’s draft drew on community voices, and how America’s deliberative spirit still shapes our civic life today. If you’ve ever wondered what truly makes America’s founding unique, this conversation offers a fresh lens and a reminder of the power of collective decision-making. In This Episode - (00:11) Introduction and guest welcome - (00:31) Origins of American deliberation - (02:14) Jefferson and collective authorship - (05:04) Spirit of the American Revolution - (05:51) Colonial and local deliberative traditions - (09:29) Fairfax Resolves and local assemblies - (13:01) Community sense and delay of independence - (14:33) Popular sovereignty and ratification - (15:43) Variety of deliberative bodies - (16:39) Parliamentary law and deliberative procedure - (19:26) Grand juries and public service - (22:02) Distinguishing public bodies from mobs - (24:54) Non-importation agreements and authority - (26:19) Compulsory support and revolutionary action - (28:04) American Revolution’s distinctiveness - (30:06) British and American deliberative traditions - (33:22) Comparisons to English and European precedents - (34:20) Ancient and English precedents - (35:42) Crystallization of deliberative traditions - (37:07) Federal system and popular constitution-making - (38:26) The Quill Project overview - (39:38) Quill Project’s Declaration of Independence work - (41:12) Resource collections and acknowledgments Notable Quotes - (01:00) "Before the American Revolution, most constitutions were the product either of accident and force or the wisdom of a lawgiver. America's different. These things are written by groups of people who deliberate and worry about every word." — Nicholas Cole - (03:01) "All of those things that Jefferson takes credit for are things that he did in concert with other people. He wasn't starting with a completely blank page." — Nicholas Cole - (04:44) "The idea that human beings do their best work when they act together, that feature of American thought in the 18th century, was one of the things that really captured my interest." — Nicholas Cole - (16:54) "There was an idea that there was a proper way for groups of people to behave when they were deliberating together. This often went under the name of something like parliamentary law." — Nicholas Cole - (28:34) "Most revolutions do not look like the American Revolution in this sense. Other alternatives are definitely available." — Nicholas Cole - (38:58) "The Quill Project is an attempt to help people understand these sometimes very extended and complicated processes of deliberation. You can think of it as kind of track changes for historians." — Nicholas Cole
Not rated yetSeason 2, Episode 17 | George Washington: Merit, Power, and the Birth of Civilian Leadership
· 28 min
Did you know that George Washington could have become an American Caesar, but instead chose to walk away from power? Unlike Napoleon or Cromwell, he rejected dictatorship and dynasty, setting the precedent for civilian control of the military, limited executive authority, and the peaceful transfer of power. In this episode of This Constitution, host Matthew Brogdon sits down with eminent historian Jeremy Black to trace Washington’s extraordinary balancing act. From the battlefields of the Revolution to the presidency, Washington navigated fragile institutions, fractious states, and the lure of personal power and, in doing so, set precedents that continue to define American politics. The conversation explores Washington’s role as a “meritocratic monarch,” how he differed from figures like George III, Napoleon, and Oliver Cromwell, and why his restraint proved essential to building a constitutional republic. They discuss the challenges of commanding a multi-state army, the dangers of potential coups, his deliberate retirement, and the legacy of leadership “for country, not party.” They also tackle a deeper question: what does Washington’s example teach us about the relationship between military power and constitutional government? His decision to submit force to law, ambition to restraint, and leadership to the service of the people remains one of the defining features of American constitutionalism. In This Episode - (00:03) Opening and introduction - (00:56) Washington as a "meritocratic monarch" - (02:34) Contrasts with George III and Napoleon - (04:09) Washington’s challenges with Congress and state governments - (05:31) Comparison to the French Revolution and use of force - (07:01) Civilian control of the military: Historical continuity - (08:20) Presidential power and restraint - (09:37) Washington’s post-war precedent - (10:54) Use of force in domestic rebellions - (12:23) Continuity from military to executive leadership - (13:04) Constitutional practices in the Continental Army - (14:48) Managing rivalries and federalism in the army - (16:12) Geographic shifts in the Revolutionary War - (17:25) Washington’s political skills and resource allocation - (19:41) National identity and the crucible of war - (22:29) Army vs. Navy in American political culture - (23:48) Washington’s non-autocratic leadership - (24:32) Washington as American Cincinnatus - (25:56) Washington’s farewell address and peaceful transfer of power - (27:44) Conclusion and legacy - (28:08) Podcast outro and next episode teaser Notable Quotes - (01:00) "I see George Washington as a formative figure in America and an example of the best type of what I call a meritocratic monarch." — Jeremy Black - (04:13) "Washington does this with enormous skill, not in easy circumstances." — Jeremy Black - (08:21) "One of the patterns that derives directly from Washington is that of the subordination of the military to civil authority." — Jeremy Black - (08:37) "Washington was not an American Caesar. He did not create himself as a dictator either." — Jeremy Black - (19:44) "America is born in the crucible of war, because that defines the boundaries of America." — Jeremy Black - (23:06) "The expression of liberty becomes that of serving on land in military forces." — Jeremy Black - (27:35) "I think one could say his politics were for the people, for his country, rather than for himself or his party." — Jeremy Black
Not rated yetSeason 2, Episode 16 | Parties and the Constitution: Why the Founders Feared Parties and Created Them Anyway
· 42 min
How did a political system founded by leaders who warned against factions end up making political parties an indispensable part of democracy? And why has the United States remained a two-party nation for nearly two centuries? In this episode of This Constitution, host Matthew Brogdon sits down with political scientist Daniel DiSalvo to trace the fascinating constitutional and political journey of America’s party system. From Jefferson’s “party to end all parties” to Martin Van Buren’s invention of the enduring two-party model, they unpack the forces that created, shaped, and sustained the parties we know today. The conversation explores how early mechanisms like the “King Caucus” gave way to national conventions, how parties managed (and sometimes suppressed) divisive issues like slavery, and why the two-party system has proven so resilient thanks to first-past-the-post elections, the Electoral College, and state ballot laws. They also tackle a deeper question: how political parties and the Constitution are in constant tension. The Constitution disperses power through the separation of powers; parties try to assemble it to win and govern. That push-and-pull has defined American politics from the 1790s to the present. In This Episode - (00:13) Introduction to Daniel DiSalvo and the study of political parties - (01:16) Founders’ skepticism toward parties and their early emergence - (04:30) State governments’ role in shaping elections - (06:03) The “King Caucus” and constitutional concerns - (09:44) Jefferson’s “party to end all parties” - (10:58) Van Buren’s case for permanent parties to avoid sectionalism - (12:16) National conventions as a political safety valve - (15:19) Tariffs, internal improvements, and keeping slavery off the agenda - (18:18) How parties suppressed abolitionist voices - (20:38) The Republican Party’s rise as the only successful third party - (24:22) Why the U.S. has a two-party system - (26:19) First-past-the-post elections and the Electoral College - (31:13) The appeal (and limits) of the two-party model - (36:00) Consensus politics in a separated-powers system - (39:32) Why parties remain essential to democratic accountability Notable Quotes - (01:23) "Jefferson's opposition didn't last very long. You could say that maybe his statement shows that many statements in politics are in bad faith, since he still hopes to go to heaven, even though he was one of the founders of the first political party." — Dan DISalvo - (02:10) "The Constitution, which sets up all these institutions, doesn't specify a way that these offices are gonna get filled up. So how are you gonna get people to be elected to these offices?" — Dan DISalvo - (03:15) "Parties become the ligaments and the muscles that tie it together, tying citizens to the institutions set up by the Constitution." — Dan DiSalvo - (06:30) "The process for electing presidents became what was then called the King Caucus, which was what these nascent parties in Congress were." — Dan DiSalvo - (13:00) "Van Buren's idea is we're going to take away, get rid of this King caucus, and we're going to have this idea of national conventions." — Dan DiSalvo - (29:00) "The Electoral College system makes it very hard for third parties to get in." — Dan DiSalvo - (32:30) "In our system, you campaign inside your own party to win a primary election, then you campaign on what you think is good." — Dan DiSalvo
Not rated yetSeason 2, Episode 15 | Special Counsels vs. the Presidency: Who Holds the Power?
· 39 min
How should a democracy balance the need for independent investigations of government wrongdoing with the president’s constitutional authority over prosecutions? Where do we draw the line? In this episode of This Constitution, hosts Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon dig into the fascinating and often murky world of special counsels. From their origins in President Grant’s efforts to distance himself from scandals, to the dramatic moments of the Watergate era and the "Saturday Night Massacre," the history of special counsels is anything but straightforward. They break down the creation of independent counsels under the Ethics in Government Act of 1978, a powerful legal framework that was later undone by high-profile investigations like Iran-Contra and the Clinton impeachment. Fast forward to today, and the special counsel role has become a battleground for constitutional debate, raising tough questions about who holds the power to fire them and when. Matthew makes a compelling argument for why prosecutorial power must remain politically accountable, warning against a future where legal battles spiral beyond the courts’ control. They wrap up the episode with a powerful reminder to rethink our reliance on legally ambiguous mechanisms and consider the Constitution’s built-in safeguards, like impeachment, as a much-needed check on power. Tune in for an eye-opening dive into the constitutional tension between justice and executive authority. In This Episode - (00:15) Topic Introduction and definition of special counsels - (01:16) Historical origins: Grant and Roosevelt - (01:57) Watergate and Nixon: The rise of controversy - (03:37) The Saturday night massacre - (06:03) Aftermath of Watergate: Impeachment and resignation - (07:14) Constitutional issues: Executive power and accountability - (09:53) The Ethics in Government Act of 1978 - (11:31) Independent counsel vs. special counsel: Key differences - (12:44) Scope and jurisdiction of independent counsel - (14:35) Controversies: Iran-Contra and Whitewater - (15:05) Supreme Court and Morrison v. Olson - (17:20) Problems with removal and accountability - (20:48) Expiration of the independent counsel statute - (25:38) Return to special counsels: DOJ regulations - (26:52) The Mueller investigation and modern special counsels - (29:12) Removal and oversight of special counsels - (31:51) Unresolved constitutional questions - (33:23) Political vs. legal controls: Impeachment and accountability - (37:38) Checks and balances: Political structure vs. legal process Notable Quotes - (09:07) "The prosecutorial power is a very dangerous power. Even if you can't get a conviction, to bring an indictment and to pursue a prosecution against someone can ruin their life." — Matthew Brogdon - (12:26) "The independent counsel has, quote, full power and independent authority to exercise all investigative and prosecutorial functions and powers of The Department of Justice, the Attorney General, and any other officer or employee of the Department of Justice." — Matthew Brogdon - (34:09) "I think the founding generation expected the impeachment power to be a far more widely utilized power. That's been extremely rare. And I think we've actually underutilized it." — Matthew Brogdon - (37:43) "Checks and balances work best when you lean into their political structure. They're inherently political structure, and they get really murky, and we get lots of problems or potential problems when we ignore that structure in favor of a more legal structure and rely more on the courts." — Savannah Eccles Johnston
Not rated yetSeason 2, Episode 14 | High Crimes or Political Fights? When Impeachment Becomes a Constitutional Battleground
· 28 min
When we hear “impeachment,” most of us immediately think: the President. But what if that’s only part of the story? In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon explore the lesser-known history of impeaching cabinet secretaries and other executive officials, revealing how the process has always been more political than legal. They revisit the case of Secretary of War William Belknap, who resigned in tears in 1876, hoping to dodge impeachment—only to face it anyway. Fast-forward to 2024, and Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas is at the center of a modern-day controversy that reopens the same unresolved questions. Can officials be impeached after they’ve left office? What actually qualifies as a “high crime or misdemeanor”? And who decides? Through historical case studies, sharp legal insight, and a few surprising turns (including George Washington daring Congress to impeach him), this episode digs into how impeachment functions as a tool of accountability—and a reflection of the political moment. If you think impeachment is just about criminal wrongdoing, think again. This conversation will shift how you view one of the Constitution’s most powerful and misunderstood mechanisms. In This Episode - (00:13) Introduction and overview - (00:59) Impeachment process and constitutional ambiguity - (02:52) Impeaching former officials: The Belknap case - (05:32) Impeachment after resignation: Nixon and precedents - (07:50) Trump’s second impeachment and unresolved legal questions - (08:21) Senate jurisdiction and the Blount case - (11:30) Defining high crimes and misdemeanors: Johnson’s impeachment - (13:07) Political vs. legal grounds for impeachment - (15:23) Impeachment standards for judges vs. executives - (16:12) Early impeachment threats: Washington and the Jay Treaty - (17:39) Modern debates: Mayorkas's impeachment and political disputes - (19:19) Impeachment responsibility: Cabinet secretaries vs. presidents - (22:32) Impeachment as a congressional tool - (23:16) Impeachment’s political nature and checks and balances - (24:36) Impeachment vs. criminal prosecution - (27:05) Conclusion: Impeachment’s role in American government Notable Quotes - (00:43) "When it comes to executive impeachments, we have a history of failed impeachments." — Savannah - (03:01) "Can you impeach former government officials? The Constitution does not tell us... This is something that had to be figured out in the moment that it became an issue." — Savannah - (05:10) "I just hope at some point in my life I can find an occasion to look at an office holder and say, you have prostituted your high office out of a lust for private gain." — Matthew - (06:43) "Impeachment is not just about removing people from office. It's also about the possibility of excluding them or disqualifying them from future office holding." — Matthew - (17:05) "Washington was saying, impeach me if you think I can't be trusted and I violated the public interest in negotiating this treaty." — Matthew - (26:29) "One use for impeachment is to remove a president so that he can be successfully criminally charged." — Savannah - (27:07) "Impeachment is a tool in the checks and balances toolbox when it comes to working out disputes between the branches." — Matthew
Not rated yetSeason 2, Episode 13 | Judging the Judges: Impeachment and the Courts
· 30 min
In This Episode In this episode of This Constitution, Savannah Eccles Johnston and Matthew Brogdon explore one of the least understood and most powerful tools in the U.S. Constitution: impeachment. But forget presidents for now, this episode dives deep into judicial impeachments: how they work, why they're rare, and why judges have historically been the ones who get removed. Savannah and Matthew unpack what it means for Congress to wield this political sword, why it's not a criminal process, and how colorful cases like Samuel Chase and Alcee Hastings shaped our understanding of judicial accountability. Along the way, they raise big questions about what "high crimes and misdemeanors" really means—and whether just being bad at your job is enough to get you booted off the bench. - (00:00:13) Introduction to judicial impeachment and constitutional process - (00:01:00) The House indicts, the Senate convicts - (00:02:23) Impeachment is a political, not criminal process - (00:03:42) The Senate as jury and the role of the Chief Justice - (00:05:13) Historical focus: judges, not presidents - (00:05:58) Corruption, perjury, and Florida judges - (00:06:29) Why cabinet members get fired but judges get impeached - (00:07:00) Life tenure vs. good behavior - (00:08:00) Samuel Chase and the partisan bench - (00:10:00) The Jeffersonian purge of the courts - (00:12:00) Why Chase avoided conviction - (00:13:30) Fast forward to Alcee Hastings (and yes, Florida again) - (00:14:30) No conviction? No problem—still impeached - (00:15:20) Hastings’s comeback as a Congressman - (00:17:00) Can you impeach just for bad rulings? - (00:18:13) Defining “high crimes and misdemeanors” - (00:20:00) Bad judgment vs. misconduct - (00:21:26) The Senate is the ultimate check - (00:24:01) The case of Judge Pickering and judicial incompetence - (00:26:05) Balancing judicial independence with accountability - (00:28:00) Why judicial impeachments are so rare and so hard Notable Quotes (00:03:00) "Though this is set up like a criminal trial, it’s important to note this is a political process. This is not a criminal process." — Savannah Eccles Johnston (00:07:05) "You only get to hold this office as long as you behave yourself. And there’s a way to get rid of you if not." — Matthew Brogdon (00:12:25) "Had they impeached Chase, it would’ve telegraphed to the court: if you act like a partisan hack on the bench, we will kick you off." — Matthew Brogdon (00:15:00) "He’s no longer a judge, but Florida elects him to Congress. So I guess… he wins?" — Savannah Eccles Johnston (00:18:57) "High crimes and misdemeanors are not defined in the Constitution. But 'misdemeanor' back then just meant to misbehave." — Matthew Brogdon (00:26:05) "There is a fine balance between judicial independence and oversight by Congress. And impeachment is the only tool Congress has." — Savannah Eccles Johnston Resources and Links This Constitution - https://bit.ly/4fYWnVi Savannah Eccles Johnston - https://www.linkedin.com/in/savannah-eccles-johnston-515a72198/ - https://www.instagram.com/savypolitics/ Matthew Brogdon - https://www.linkedin.com/in/matthew-brogdon-8a21bb89 - https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/people/matthew_brogdon.html
Not rated yet