Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The Secret Society of Strangers

SSOSPodAudio

Format:
Podcast
New episodes:
Every two weeks
Typical length:
about 1 hour
Latest episode:
Not rated yet
CosmosOpen at the sourceReport a problemIs this your show? Get a badge

About this show

Secret Society of Strangers digs into history’s darkest and strangest cases: unsolved murders, disappearances, cults, con artists, high strangeness.

Ever gone down a 3am rabbit hole about a murder that shouldn’t have been possible? Questioned a disappearance that violates logic? Wondered how one con artist fooled an entire city?

You found your people.

Lee, Josh, and Jen investigate the cases that refuse to resolve cleanly:

- Unsolved murders where every suspect has an alibi that works

- Disappearances that don’t obey logic

- Cults, con artists, and the people who believed them

- Historical crimes where the official story doesn’t add up

- Cryptids, hauntings, and documented high strangeness

We treat the material as real. We don’t mock the victims. We don’t oversell the weird. We hand you what’s on the record and let you decide what it means — because sometimes the best investigations don’t give you answers. They give you better questions.

New episodes every other week.

A Strange Static Media production. Also from SSM: Side Quest — shorter, stranger, and assigned by C4554NDR4.

Merch: ssos-shop.fourthwall.com (code SSOSPOD)

Got a high strangeness story? ssospodcast@gmail.com

Stay Curious. Stay Strange.

Covers: true crime, unsolved mysteries, cults, paranormal, historical crimes, con artists, cryptids, hauntings

Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at feed.podbean.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.

Recently on this show

Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.

The Secret Society of Strangers is a podcast that examines unsolved murders, disappearances, cults, con artists and paranormal reports, treating them as real. Recent episodes cover Mothman sightings in West Virginia, Madame LaLaurie's New Orleans case, the Pendle witch trials, and the Bennington Triangle disappearances.

Report a problem with this summary

Cosmos

Similar in subject

See the full Cosmos

Similar shows

See all History shows

Explore more

Episodes

  • The Lost Colony of Roanoke

    · 1 hr 1 min

    **EPISODE DESCRIPTION:** The Lost Colony of Roanoke remains America's oldest unsolved mystery. In 1587, 117 English colonists—including 17 women, 11 children, and newborn Virginia Dare—arrived at Roanoke Island. Three years later, they had vanished completely. No bodies. No graves. No bones. John White, the colony's governor, left his family behind to get emergency supplies. When he returned in 1590, he found only a fortress, scattered belongings, and one word carved into a tree: CROATOAN. **Quick apology from Lee:** If you hear me accidentally say "John Smith" instead of "John White" during this episode, my bad—brain glitch. We're definitely talking about John White, the Roanoke governor, not John Smith of Jamestown. Jeremy tried to catch it in editing, but if one slipped through, you know who I meant! Tonight we explore the impossible timeline: How Ralph Lane's 1585 expedition destroyed any chance of peace through the assassination of Chief Wingina (Pemisapan). Why pilot Simon Fernandes abandoned colonists at the worst possible location—sabotage, greed, or Spanish espionage? How the colonists survived the worst drought in 800 years while surrounded by hostile tribes and hunted by the Spanish Empire. We dig into 435 years of archaeological evidence—excavations at Roanoke Island, Hatteras Island (ancient Croatoan), and mysterious mainland Sites X and Y. European artifacts mixed with indigenous pottery. Women's jewelry. Tudor-era items. But zero human remains. The colonists left a clear message telling us exactly where they went. So why can't modern archaeology find a single skeleton? This isn't just another retelling of the Lost Colony legend. This is Dark Reality + High Strangeness—real people, real crimes, and evidence that defies explanation. 🕯️ **Come Curious. Stay Strange.** 🕯️ --- **TOPICS COVERED:** - The Lost Colony of Roanoke complete timeline (1585-1590) - Virginia Dare: First English child born in America - John White's impossible three-year delay - Ralph Lane's war crimes and Chief Wingina's assassination - The George Howe murder and mistaken Croatoan massacre - Spanish Empire hunting Protestant colonists - Fort Caroline massacre and Matanzas Inlet executions - Simon Fernandes: sabotage or greed? - The 1587-1589 megadrought (tree ring evidence) - CROATOAN message and fortress discovery - Archaeological sites: Roanoke Island, Hatteras, Sites X & Y - Manteo and Croatoan indigenous alliance - The missing cemetery mystery - Lumbee DNA and colonial descendants - 435 years of failed archaeology #LostColony #Roanoke #RoanokeColony #Croatoan #VirginiaDare #UnsolvedMystery #TrueCrime #HistoricalMystery #ColonialAmerica #DarkHistory #StrangeHistory #MissingPeople #Disappearance #ParanormalHistory #HistoryPodcast #TrueCrimePodcast #UnexplainedMystery #SSOS #SecretSocietyOfStrangers #ComeStayStrange #ArchaeologyMystery #IndigenousHistory #AmericanHistory #ColdCase #HistoricalColdCase #Mystery #Unsolved #WeirdHistory #CreepyHistory #ForgottenHistory -- **CONTENT WARNING:** Discussion of colonial violence, war crimes, assassination, indigenous genocide, murder of women and children, religious persecution --- **NEW TO SSOS?** Subscribe for weekly deep dives into history's darkest and strangest cases—where real crimes intersect with the genuinely unexplainable. We don't just retell legends. We fact-check folklore and examine evidence through a forensic lens. 🔔 **Subscribe | 👍 Like | 💬 Comment | 🔗 Share** **Find us on all podcast platforms + YouTube** --- **COMING SOON:** Side Quest podcast launches for standalone cryptids, UFO sightings, and paranormal news!

    Not rated yet
  • Ed Gein - The Plainfield Butcher

    · 1 hr 14 min

    On November 16, 1957, police entered a Wisconsin farmhouse investigating a theft. What they found would traumatize seasoned investigators and change horror cinema forever. Ed Gein's crimes weren't just murders—they were documented reality so disturbing that three iconic horror films (Psycho, Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Silence of the Lambs) drew direct inspiration from his case. The crime scene inventory reads like occult fiction, except every word was true. This isn't folklore. This is the meticulously documented case that proved the most terrifying monsters are painfully, impossibly human. We examine: - The crime scene discovery that made hardened cops physically ill - How extreme isolation and maternal control created America's most notorious killer - Why this case fundamentally changed criminal profiling and forensic psychology - The uncomfortable question: mental illness or pure evil? - How one man's crimes shaped horror culture for generations We go beyond shock value to explore what Gein's case revealed about post-war rural America, untreated mental illness, and why this particular horror resonated so deeply in our cultural consciousness. ⚠️ Content Warning: Detailed discussion of grave robbery, human remains, and psychological abuse. Victims treated with respect while examining forensic reality. 🕯️ Come Curious. Stay Strange. 🕯️ Subscribe, rate, and share if you're part of the professionally curious and academically strange. Hosted by Lee, Josh, and Jen #TrueCrime #EdGein #ForensicPsychology #HorrorHistory #CriminalPsychology #DarkHistory #SSOSPodcast #SecretSocietyOfStrangers

    Not rated yet
  • THE VANISHING VILLAGE OF ANJIKUNI LAKE

    · 52 min

    November 1930. Canadian Arctic. 25 people. Gone. French-Canadian fur trapper Joe LaBelle arrives at a familiar Inuit settlement at Anjikuni Lake expecting warmth, food, and shelter. Instead, he finds something impossible: an entire village abandoned mid-task. Cooking pots still over dead fires. Rifles leaning against tent poles. Personal belongings carefully arranged. And seven sled dogs starved to death—still tied to their posts. But no people. No tracks. No bodies. No explanation. Then Joe discovers the graveyard. Every single grave has been carefully opened. The bodies—gone. Was this a mass alien abduction witnessed by trappers who saw a "cylindrical object" hovering over the frozen lake? An ancient Qalupalik—the Inuit water demon—that lures entire communities to their doom? A sensationalized newspaper hoax that spiraled into one of Canada's most enduring mysteries? Join Lee, Josh, and Jen as we excavate the layers of this Arctic enigma—from the original 1930 newspaper account to Betty Hill's alien abduction theories, from RCMP cover-up allegations to the terrifying Inuit legends that predate European contact by thousands of years. We fact-check the folklore, examine the evidence, and explore why some mysteries persist even when the truth suggests they never happened at all. This episode covers: - Joe LaBelle's chilling discovery in the Arctic darkness - The RCMP investigation and conflicting official reports - UFO theories and the evolution of the story through decades - Qalupalik, Wendigo, and other Arctic cryptids tied to mass disappearances - The Missing 411 connection and modern wilderness vanishings - Why we believe stories that feel true—even when they're not Content note: This episode discusses Indigenous missing persons, colonial violence, and systemic racism in historical investigations. 🕯️ Come Curious. Stay Strange. 🕯️ Like what you heard? Subscribe, share, and tell your fellow conspiracy theorists! 📧 Contact us: SSOSpodcast@gmail.com 📱 TikTok: @SSOSpodcast 📸 Instagram: @secretsocietyofstrangerspod 📘 Facebook: Secret Society of Strangers Podcast All Video & Audio Edited By Jeremy of Schroeder Audio - National Indigenous Women's Resource Center: NIWRC.org - Sovereign Bodies Institute: sovereign-bodies.org - Canadian MMIWG Resources: mmiwg-ffada.ca #TrueCrime #UnsolvedMysteries #CanadianMysteries #AnjukuniLake #Missing411 #UFO #AlienAbduction #Arctic #IndigenousHistory #Cryptids #Qalupalik #ParanormalPodcast #MysteryPodcast #SSOSPodcast #DarkHistory #HighStrangeness

    Not rated yet
  • Eastern State Penitentiary : America's Most Haunted Prison

    · 57 min

    Eastern State Penitentiary wasn't just America's first true penitentiary—it was a revolutionary experiment in breaking the human mind through isolation. In this deep-dive investigation, we explore how Benjamin Franklin and Dr. Benjamin Rush's vision of moral reformation through solitary confinement became one of history's most haunted locations. From Charles Williams (Prisoner #1) entering blind and hooded in 1829, to Al Capone screaming "Jimmy, leave me alone!" in his luxury cell, to Willie Sutton's legendary tunnel escape, Eastern State's 142-year history is soaked in suffering, innovation, and impossibility. We'll take you inside: ✓ The architectural revolution that influenced 300+ prisons worldwide ✓ The brutal reality of the Pennsylvania System's 24/7 isolation ✓ Horrific punishments: the Iron Gag, the Mad Chair, and the Hole ✓ Cellblock 3's medical horrors—tuberculosis treatments and psychiatric observation cells ✓ Decades of documented paranormal activity across all seven cellblocks ✓ Why 60+ paranormal investigation teams visit annually Featuring evidence from Ghost Hunters, Ghost Adventures, and firsthand accounts from staff who refuse to enter certain areas alone. Charles Dickens called it "immeasurably worse than any torture of the body." Modern investigators call it one of the most haunted places in the world. This is the complete story of how America's most progressive prison reform became its most notorious paranormal hotspot—where good intentions created hell on earth, and the ghosts still haven't left. 🕯️ Come Curious. Stay Strange. 🕯️ Hosts: Lee, Josh, and Jen Edited by: Jeremy Schroeder (Schroeder Audio) Find us on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, and everywhere you listen. #EasternStatePenitentiary #HauntedPrison #AlCapone #TrueCrime #ParanormalInvestigation #PrisonHistory #PhiladelphiaHistory #GhostStories #SolitaryConfinement #DarkHistory #HistoricalMysteries #SSOSPodcast

    Not rated yet
  • Inside Heaven's Gate Cult Part 4 : A RECIPE FOR DEATH

    · 1 hr 5 min

    March 1997. A mansion in Rancho Santa Fe. 39 bodies in matching Nike sneakers and purple shrouds. The largest mass suicide on U.S. soil. This is the finale of our Heaven's Gate series - the story of how Marshall Applewhite convinced 38 people that a comet was their spaceship home. ⚠️ Content Warning: Suicide, cult manipulation, death. Call 988 if you're struggling. National Suicide Prevention Lifeline: 988 IN THIS EPISODE: - The Hale-Bopp comet discovery (665 million miles away, visible for 18 months) - Heaven's Gate as internet pioneers (they were web developers before Amazon existed) - Chuck Shramek's Art Bell appearance that validated the UFO hysteria - Inside the "Monastery" - the final months of preparation - The three-wave suicide protocol (March 22-26, 1997) - Rio DiAngelo discovers his 39 dead classmates - Why heavensgate.com still runs today THE SHOCKING TRUTH: Before they were a death cult, Heaven's Gate was a cutting-edge web design company. Their clients included Hollywood production companies and the San Diego Polo Club. They used Java, VRML, streaming video, and advanced HTML in 1996 - years before most corporations. Marshall Applewhite didn't just see the internet as a tool. He saw it as theological proof that humanity had completed its experiment. Time to graduate. Series Conclusion: 25 years. Two leaders. 39 deaths. One comet. This is what happens when the search for meaning meets a broken teacher with absolute certainty. Previous episodes: Part I (The Two), Part II (The Cult), Part III (The Castration) Research sources include FBI files, medical examiner reports, survivor interviews, documentary footage, and archived Heaven's Gate materials. Hosted by Lee, Josh, and Jen. Audio/Video: Jeremy of Schroeder Audio 🕯️ Come Curious. Stay Strange. If you would like to contact The SSOS E mail: SSOSpodcast@gmail.com TikTok : @SSODPodcast (https://www.tiktok.com/@ssospodcast?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc) Instagram @Secretsocietyofstrangerspod (https://www.threads.net/@secretsocietyofstrangerspod?xmt=AQGzB3FghlUjVDI5wjr4Snh8cF97ARo0NKIdqbj9oBASdl0) Facebook: Secret Society of Strangers Podcast Merch available - check out our linktree Full video episodes on our SSOS YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/@SSOSPodcast) National Suicide Prevention Lifeline: 988

    Not rated yet
  • Inside Heaven's Gate Cult Part III: The Test | Castration for Salvation

    · 46 min

    ⚠️ CONTENT WARNING: Suicide, cult manipulation, graphic medical content. Crisis support: 988 What happens when your co-messiah dies? Marshall Applewhite faced total theological collapse in 1985 when Bonnie Nettles died of cancer—after years of teaching they were immortal extraterrestrial beings. This is the moment Heaven's Gate became a death cult. In this episode, we explore the psychological crisis that led to one of the most disturbing chapters in cult history: eight men, including Applewhite himself, underwent voluntary castration. One nearly died when a former nurse botched the procedure in a makeshift operation. Discover how Applewhite's forbidden feelings for male follower Dick Joslyn, his devastating rejection, and his followers' validation created a feedback loop of increasingly extreme acts—transforming personal trauma into theological requirement. This wasn't calculated evil. It was something more human and more dangerous: a broken man so dependent on his followers' approval that he followed them into mutilation, preparing them to follow him into death. Topics: Marshall Applewhite psychology, theological manipulation, cult castration, Heaven's Gate history, cult recruitment, psychological control Sources: FBI files, medical examiner reports, former member interviews, academic research Next time: How Heaven's Gate weaponized the internet and recruited through the World Wide Web. Hosts: Lee, Jen & Josh | Secret Society of Strangers Retry

    Not rated yet
  • Inside Heaven's Gate Cult Part 2: The Classroom | When Evolution Becomes Erasure

    · 43 min

    Part 2: The Classroom | When Evolution Becomes Erasure September 1975. Waldport, Oregon. Population: 2,000. A poster appears on telephone poles: "UFO'S - Why they are here. Who they have come for. When they will leave." That night, 200 curious people walked into a community center. Twenty walked out and never looked back—leaving jobs, families, entire lives behind to become "students" in Ti and Do's cosmic classroom. In Part 2 of our Heaven's Gate investigation, we enter The Classroom. This isn't the story of broken people joining a cult. This is the story of: - John Craig - a Republican politician and ranch owner who walked away from 200 acres and the American Dream - Susan Noel - an RN with a successful career who stopped calling in to work and never went back - Joyce Skalla - a mother of four who kissed her sleeping children goodbye and left letters on the breakfast table - Thomas Nichols - Star Trek's Nichelle Nichols' brother, who disappeared for 20 years while calling himself "the happiest person in the world" This episode covers: - The Waldport meeting that recruited over 20 members in one night - Life in the wilderness: corporate structure meets nomadic isolation - The "side-by-sides" system: psychological monitoring disguised as spiritual partnership - How Human Individual Metamorphosis (HIM) systematically erased human identity - The renaming, the shaved heads, the androgynous uniforms, the military precision - Why "inappropriate curiosity" was a punishable offense - The trust fund that let 48 people live in one suburban house without neighbors knowing - How Ti and Do built total control through structure, not violence We profile the computer programmers, the nurses, the ranch owners, the mothers—educated, successful people who voluntarily gave up everything for a promise of physical evolution into extraterrestrial beings. This wasn't Jonestown's armed guards. This was something more insidious: voluntary imprisonment through belief. Next episode: Ti's death shatters everything, and Do rebuilds the group into something far more dangerous. 🔍 KEYWORDS: Heaven's Gate cult, Marshall Applewhite, Bonnie Nettles, Ti and Do, Waldport Oregon 1975, cult psychology, Human Individual Metamorphosis, UFO cults, cult indoctrination, true crime podcast, paranormal history, Nichelle Nichols brother, 1970s cults, voluntary isolation, psychological manipulation ⚠️ CONTENT WARNING: This episode discusses cult manipulation, family abandonment, and psychological coercion. If you're struggling, call 988. 🕯️ Come Curious. Stay Strange. Subscribe to SSOS wherever you get your podcasts. Share this with someone who thinks they're too smart to be manipulated. Drop a comment: What's the most extreme thing you've done because you trusted someone completely? Follow us: @SSOSPodcast #HeavensGate #TrueCrime #CultPodcast #TiAndDo #UFOCult #HighStrangeness #SSOSPodcast #ParanormalPodcast #WaldportOregon #CultPsychology #TrueStory #1970s

    Not rated yet
  • Inside Heaven's Gate Cult -Part 1 : The Two

    · 55 min

    There's a website that's been running for 27 years. HeavensGate.com. Still maintained. Still recruiting. March 1997: Thirty-nine people died believing they were boarding a spaceship. But this story starts twenty-five years earlier—in a Houston hospital, with two broken people who turned their shared delusion into cosmic destiny. This is Part 1 of our 4-part Heaven's Gate deep dive. Marshall Applewhite: Texas preacher's son. Perfect pitch. Perfect shame. A man carrying a secret that 1930s Christianity called "abomination." Lost his marriage. Lost his career. Lost himself. Then a nurse told him he wasn't broken—he was chosen. Bonnie Nettles: Spiritual seeker. Believer in signs. The woman who told Marshall his breakdown was actually his calling. Together they became Ti and Do—The Two. Here's what makes Heaven's Gate different: No violence. No sexual abuse. No money schemes. They promised physical transformation—evolution while alive. NO DEATH REQUIRED. That's what made it so seductive. That's why intelligent people followed. In this episode: Marshall's haunted childhood. His sci-fi obsession. The hospital "resurrection." How two seekers in a van started building a cosmic classroom. And the original promise that would take 25 years to betray. This is the foundation. The beginning of the end. 🕯️ Content Warning: Cult manipulation and suicide discussed. Need help? Call 988. COMING SOON: Parts 2-4 of this deep dive 🕯️ Come curious. Stay strange. SOURCES & FACT-CHECK REFERENCES Primary Sources: - Wikipedia: Marshall Applewhite biographical timeline - Spur, Texas historical records: Birth and early life verification - University of St. Thomas personnel records: Employment termination details - Union Presbyterian Seminary archives: Religious education background Secondary Sources: - TIME Magazine 1997: Comprehensive Heaven's Gate coverage - Washington Post psychological profiles of cult leaders - ABC News 20/20: Former member interviews and family testimonies - Scientific American: Cult psychology and group dynamics research Media Integration Points: - 1930s-40s Texas church and family photographs - 1950s science fiction magazine covers and illustrations - 1960s-70s New Age movement and spiritual gathering documentation - Early Heaven's Gate camping and commune lifestyle footage - HeavensGate.com current website screenshots - 1975 Waldport, Oregon community center and meeting locations

    Not rated yet
  • The Turtle Lake Massacre: Blood on the Prairie

    · 1 hr 0 min

    Some murders are solved quickly. Others linger for decades, their answers buried with the victims. And then there are cases like Turtle Lake—where the truth seems to have been swallowed by the North Dakota prairie itself. In the early morning hours of 1920, an entire family was slaughtered in their isolated farmhouse. Jacob Wolf, his wife, their five children, and even a hired hand—all found dead in a scene so disturbing that hardened investigators struggled to make sense of it. But the brutality was only the beginning. Strange details emerged that transformed this from a tragic crime into something far more sinister: peculiar arrangements of the bodies, whispers of occult symbols, mysterious strangers seen lurking days before, and suspects who seemed to evaporate into thin air. Over 100 years later, the Turtle Lake Massacre remains one of America's most baffling unsolved family murders. The official investigation went nowhere. The community fractured under suspicion. And the questions multiplied: Was this the work of a drifter? A grudge turned deadly? Or something darker that no one wanted to speak aloud? Join Lee, Jen, and Josh as we dig into the blood-soaked soil of this North Dakota nightmare—examining the evidence, the theories, and the eerie details that suggest there's far more to this story than history recorded. ⚠️ CONTENT WARNING: This episode contains detailed discussions of extreme violence, murder of children, and disturbing crime scene descriptions. Not suitable for all audiences. 🕯️ Come Curious. Stay Strange. 🕯️ This is the Secret Society of Strangers.

    Not rated yet
  • Bohemian Grove : Elites,Secrets & Ceremonial Sacrifice!?

    · 58 min

    Every summer, the most powerful men in America disappear into the California redwoods for two weeks. Presidents, CEOs, Supreme Court justices—they all gather at a private club called Bohemian Grove. And what they do there has been kept secret for over 150 years. They wear robes. They perform rituals. They worship a 40-foot stone owl. This isn't conspiracy theory—it's documented history. In this episode, we're diving deep into Bohemian Grove: who's been a member, what actually happens during their ceremonies, the leaked footage that exposed their rituals, and why the world's elite have gathered in these woods since 1872. From the Cremation of Care ceremony to the Manhattan Project's origins, from Richard Nixon's leaked comments to Alex Jones's infiltration—this is the complete story of America's strangest and most exclusive secret society. What's really happening in those 2,700 acres? Let's find out. 🕯️ Come curious. Stay strange. --- Follow Secret Society of Strangers for weekly episodes exploring history's strangest mysteries, unsolved cases, and unexplained phenomena. Hosts: Lee, Josh, and Jen Edited by: Jeremy Schroeder (Schroeder Audio) Find us on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, and everywhere you listen.

    Not rated yet