Cosmos
Podcasts and channels like The Secret Society of Strangers
The Secret Society of Strangers covers: true crime, unsolved mysteries, cults, paranormal, historical crimes, con artists, cryptids, hauntings
About The Secret Society of Strangers: Secret Society of Strangers digs into history’s darkest and strangest cases: unsolved murders, disappearances, cults, con artists, high strangeness. Ever gone down a 3am rabbit hole about a murder that shouldn’t have been possible? Questioned a disappearance that violates logic?
Recently on this show
Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.
The Secret Society of Strangers is a podcast that examines unsolved murders, disappearances, cults, con artists and paranormal reports, treating them as real. Recent episodes cover Mothman sightings in West Virginia, Madame LaLaurie's New Orleans case, the Pendle witch trials, and the Bennington Triangle disappearances.
The Cosmos is the same for everyone. It does not depend on who is looking. It is not symmetric: a show can be near another show without that show being near it.
Rated alike
These shows tend to be rated similarly.
No close matches yet.
Similar in subject
Shows that cover the same subjects as this one, judged from what each show says it covers. This list uses no ratings.

Mugshot Mysteries
Kathryn and GabrielAudioLast show:
Some stories are solved. Most aren’t. The interesting ones refuse to stay buried.
Both cover: historical crimes, cults, unsolved mysteries
Not rated yet
Sinisterhood
Audioboom StudiosAudioLast show:
Sinisterhood is the comedy podcast about all things sinister, covering true crime, cults, cryptids, unsolved mysteries, and strange phenomena.
Both cover: cults, cryptids, unsolved mysteries
Not rated yet
Lights Out
Mile Higher Media & Audioboom StudiosAudioLast show:
Want to explore the darkest depths of humanity and horror, but don’t know how?
Both cover: hauntings, cults, cryptids
Not rated yet
Para(normal)
The Sonar NetworkAudioLast show:
Para(normal) is a weekly entertainment, comedy, and non-investigative paranormal podcast where hosts, Marie Adoranti & Nicolina Savelli share tales of ghostly…
Both cover: historical crimes, cults, paranormal
Not rated yet
The Eclectic: True Crime & Paranormal Stories
Hope - True Crime & ParanormalAudioLast show:
Step into the shadows with The Eclectic, a podcast where folklore, true crime, the paranormal, and bloody history converge.
Both cover: hauntings, unsolved mysteries, paranormal
Not rated yet
Eerily Beloved
Madeline EdwardsAudioLast show:
Eerily Beloved, we are gathered here to explore the backdrop that gave us the iconic imagery of Twilight and the X-Files that some twisted few exploit for darker…
Both cover: hauntings, cryptids, unsolved mysteries
Not rated yet
Where Our Minds Wander
Wes Guay & Beth GuayAudioLast show:
From the creepy attic's dark corners to the very end of a shadow-filled dirt road, our minds wander towards the odd, supernatural and not easily explained.
Both cover: hauntings, cryptids, paranormal
Not rated yet
The Dark Oak
Just Us Gals ProductionsAudioLast show:
Attention all shiver-seekers! The Dark Oak is a weekly thrill and chill inducing mystery podcast.
Both cover: historical crimes, cryptids, unsolved mysteries
Not rated yet
And That's Why We Drink
Christine Schiefer, Em Schulz | Para PodsAudioLast show:
Murder and the paranormal finally meet! Grab your wine and milkshakes and join us every Sunday for some chilling ghost stories and downright terrifying true crime…
Both cover: hauntings, cults, paranormal
Not rated yet
Up at Night
Insomnia NetworkAudioLast show:
Do you love true crime? Mysteries? Unsolved cases? Cryptids? Conspiracies? And generally, anything spooky that keeps you up at night? Well, so do we!
Both cover: cults, unsolved mysteries, paranormal
Not rated yet
Avery After Dark
Avery RossAudioLast show:
Calling all mystery lovers, true crime connoisseurs & supernatural enthusiasts.
Both cover: hauntings, unsolved mysteries, paranormal
Not rated yet
Wife of Crime
Jess & RussAudioLast show:
A true crime podcast hosted by a married couple with a whole lot of NYC attitude and inside jokes!
Both cover: historical crimes, unsolved mysteries, paranormal
Not rated yet
Questions about The Secret Society of Strangers
- What podcasts and channels are like The Secret Society of Strangers?
- On AmigoFish, shows like The Secret Society of Strangers include Mugshot Mysteries, Sinisterhood, Lights Out, Para(normal) and The Eclectic: True Crime & Paranormal Stories.
- What does The Secret Society of Strangers cover?
- The Secret Society of Strangers covers true crime, unsolved mysteries, cults, paranormal, historical crimes and con artists.
- How does AmigoFish choose shows like The Secret Society of Strangers?
- "Similar in subject" lists shows that cover the same subjects. These lists do not use popularity charts.