Skip to main content
AmigoFish

What Happens When Two Observers Disagree About Now? - The Relativity of Simultaneity and the End of Absolute Time | Sleepy Facts About the Universe

From Sleepy Facts About the Universe · · 27 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! (https://rss.com/podcasts/sleepy-facts-about-the-universe/voicemail)

The word "instantaneous" sounds simple enough until you place it inside Einstein's universe. If you could send a message across any distance with zero delay, you might think you had merely built a very fast telephone. But in the framework of special relativity, an instantaneous message shared between two observers in relative motion does something deeply strange. It arrives before it was sent.

This episode walks through the tachyonic antitelephone, a thought experiment first sketched by Richard Tolman in 1917 and later formalized by Gregory Benford, David Book, and William Newcomb. We examine how the relativity of simultaneity dismantles the idea of a single cosmic clock, showing that two moving observers can genuinely disagree about the ordering of distant events. By combining this geometric reality with any controllable faster-than-light signaling, we see exactly how a closed causal loop forms, turning a pair of innocent messages into a time machine ingredient.

I wanted to understand why physicists treat faster-than-light communication with such profound caution. While working on this episode, I kept returning to one question: if a superluminal device is theoretically possible, what exactly does relativity do to it? The answer is that the obstacle is not merely that light is fast and we are slow. The obstacle is the structure of spacetime itself. We also look at why quantum entanglement does not offer a loophole, and why hypothetical networks of wormholes or warp drives face the exact same paradox.

Back to Sleepy Facts About the Universe · Report a problem