Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The Mothman of Point Pleasant: Prophecy, Paranoia & the Silver Bridge Collapse

From Mugshot Mysteries · · 59 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

November 15, 1966. Two young couples are driving the back roads near an abandoned WWII explosives plant outside Point Pleasant, West Virginia, when their headlights catch two red eyes near a gate. The thing is shaped like a man, but bigger, seven feet tall, with folded wings and a hypnotic red stare. It chases their car down the highway at a hundred miles an hour without flapping, just gliding. Over the next thirteen months, more than a hundred people will report the same creature. Then, on December 15, 1967, the Silver Bridge collapses at rush hour and forty-six people die. And the sightings stop.

This week on Mugshot Mysteries, Kathryn and Gabriel cover the Mothman of Point Pleasant, and for once they refuse to sit on the fence. They each tell you, flat out, what they think happened, and they do not agree.

We start with the place itself, a spot layered with strange: a Shawnee battlefield, a debunked curse said to have been invented for a 1921 stage play, and the very real West Virginia Ordnance Works, an eight-thousand-acre TNT complex the government built and then abandoned, contaminated enough to become a Superfund site and unstable enough that a bunker actually exploded in 2010. Then the witnesses, and the case that they weren't just drunk teenagers: firefighters, a contractor whose fearless German shepherd ran into the dark and never came back, a churchgoing teenager who saw it in daylight and developed lasting eye problems, and a young mother so frightened she dropped her baby and later needed treatment for acute stress.

We get into the people who chronicled it, local journalist Mary Hyre and New York investigator John Keel, whose grip on the ordinary world seems to loosen page by page in The Mothman Prophecies. And we cover the full cast of weirdness around the creature: the unsettling Men in Black who turned up asking questions in strange, stilted ways, and Indrid Cold, the perpetually smiling "man" a sewing-machine salesman swore contacted him telepathically. Then we put on the psychology hats: mass psychogenic illness, the Dancing Plague, the Mad Gasser of Mattoon, and Jung's archetypes, the idea that a winged figure with glowing eyes is something the stressed human mind may be built to produce.

Then the bridge. We walk the collapse and the chilling NTSB finding that it came down because of a crack barely a tenth of an inch deep in a single eyebar. And then the verdicts. Gabriel believes something genuinely came to Point Pleasant. Kathryn believes the truth is more disturbing: that a frightened community manufactured its own monster and then used it to make sense of a tragedy that was really just neglected infrastructure and random death. We close on what the town became, a Mothman statue, a festival, a museum fifty feet from where forty-six people died.

This is the Mothman of Point Pleasant.

New episodes drop every Mugshot Monday. Search Mugshot Mysteries wherever you listen.

SOURCES:

Contemporaneous reporting from the Point Pleasant Register and the Athens Messenger, including the November 1966 coverage by correspondent Mary Hyre, and the Huntington Herald-Dispatch coverage that coined the "Mothman" name; the witness accounts of Roger and Linda Scarberry, Steve and Mary Mallette, Marcella Bennett, Connie Carpenter, and Newell Partridge; Keel, J., The Mothman Prophecies, 1975, and his investigation and ultraterrestrial theory; Derenberger, W., Visitors From Lanulos, 1971, on the Indrid Cold claims; the records and oral histories maintained by the Mothman Museum in Point Pleasant and curator Jeff Wamsley; the National Transportation Safety Board investigation into the December 15, 1967, Silver Bridge collapse and its finding of stress-corrosion cracking in eyebar 330; historical records on the Battle of Point Pleasant and Chief Cornstalk, and on the debunking of the "Cornstalk curse" as a 20th-century theatrical invention; EPA documentation of the West Virginia Ordnance Works Superfund site; the work of…

Back to Mugshot Mysteries · Report a problem