Cosmos
Podcasts and channels like What Happened to the McStays?
What Happened to the McStays? covers: true crime, missing persons, criminal investigation, us crime, podcast series
About What Happened to the McStays?: In a quiet suburb of San Diego County, a family of four seemingly vanishes into thin air. When investigators search their home, they find the family’s two beloved dogs unattended outside, rotting food left around the house and clothes strewn across the floor.
Recently on this show
Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.
This podcast from ABC News examines the disappearance of a San Diego County family of four, asking whether they left voluntarily or met with foul play. Recent episodes cover a trial, a motorcyclist's discovery in the Mojave Desert, and police narrowing in on one suspect.
The Cosmos is the same for everyone. It does not depend on who is looking. It is not symmetric: a show can be near another show without that show being near it.
Rated alike
These shows tend to be rated similarly.
Bad Things: True Crime
Bad Things: True CrimeVideoLast show:
True crime and mysteries! Run by John, narrated by David! Watch our series "What most likely happened" and "Monstrous Men"
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime, missing persons, criminal investigation.
Not rated yet
Rotten Mango
Stephanie SooAudioLast show:
Rotten but still a little sweet! Rotten Mango is a true crime + all things spooky podcast.
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime.
Not rated yetCrime Stories Uncovered
Crime Stories UncoveredVideoLast show:
Crime Stories Uncovered dives deep into real criminal cases, unsolved mysteries, and forgotten investigations from around the world.
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime, missing persons, criminal investigation.
Not rated yetReal Crime
Real CrimeVideoLast show:
True Crime, Gangsters, Serial Killers And The Most Infamous People In History. Real Crime is the perfect place for the best full length crime documentaries.
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime, missing persons, criminal investigation.
Not rated yet
True Crime Obsessed
True Crime ObsessedAudioLast show:
*** 2026 Webby Award Winner!! *** The true crime podcast YOU NEED IN YOUR LIFE. We recap your favorite true crime documentaries with humor, sass, and heart.
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime, missing persons, criminal investigation.
Not rated yet
Murder, Mystery & Makeup
Audioboom StudiosAudioLast show:
Bailey Sarian, an award-winning true crime enthusiast, beauty influencer, and top content creator, brings to you her critically acclaimed podcast “Murder, Mystery &…
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime, us crime.
Not rated yetNexpo
NexpoVideoLast show:
Exploring the Internet's dark side. Topic submissions: submit@nexpo.tv Business & sponsorship inquiries: partnerships+nexpo@manatalentgroup.com
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime.
Not rated yet
Over My Dead Body
Audible OriginalAudioLast show:
A Hollywood stuntwoman turned personal injury attorney. A handsome disbarred lawyer with a dark past. And an elaborate scheme that leads to murder.
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime.
Not rated yet
Deep Cover
Pushkin IndustriesAudioLast show:
Deep Cover is a show about people who lead double lives. Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Jake Halpern reveals webs of deception and dark underworlds, through…
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime, missing persons, criminal investigation.
Not rated yetABC News
ABC NewsVideoLast show:
ABC News is your daily source for breaking national and world news, exclusive interviews and 24/7 live streaming coverage that will help you stay up to date on the…
Often rated the same way.
Not rated yet
RedHanded
RedHandedAudioLast show:
RedHanded the podcast jumps head first into all manner of macabre madness.
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime.
Not rated yet
The Binge Cases: Doctor Billions
Sony Music EntertainmentAudioLast show:
After Derika Moses injured her back at work, she got her spine fused. But after surgery, her pain only got worse.
Often rated the same way. Both cover: true crime.
Not rated yet
Similar in subject
Shows that cover the same subjects as this one, judged from what each show says it covers. This list uses no ratings.

The Final Hours with Sarah Turney and Kourtney Nichole
Crime HouseAudioLast show:
Sarah Turney and Kourtney Nichole don't just report on true crime, they've lived it.
Both cover: podcast series, criminal investigation, missing persons
Not rated yet
Father Wants Us Dead: Uncle Paul
NJ.comAudioLast show:
Season 2: Uncle Paul is out now. The series called one of the best true crime podcasts of all time (Entertainment Weekly) is back with a new season about family murders…
Both cover: podcast series, criminal investigation, true crime
Not rated yet
Missing: The Unsolved Cases
Forbidden Knowledge NetworkAudioLast show:
Missing: The Unsolved Cases explores real disappearances that remain unresolved, from sudden vanishings to cases with conflicting evidence and unanswered questions.
Both cover: us crime, criminal investigation, missing persons
Not rated yet
The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story
ABC NewsAudioLast show:
The Scream Murder unravels the mystery killing of 16-year-old Cassie Stoddart and the shocking tell-all videotape that was never meant to be seen.
Both cover: us crime, criminal investigation, true crime
Not rated yet
True Crime Couple
True Crime CoupleAudioLast show:
Join married couple Kay and John as they cover some of the lesser known true crime cases.
Both cover: criminal investigation, missing persons, true crime
Not rated yet
Clueless Crime
Clueless CrimeAudioLast show:
We may be clueless, but that won't stop us talking true crime.
Both cover: us crime, true crime
Not rated yet
Bite-Sized Crime
Joy ScaglioneAudioLast show:
If you’re interested in true crime, you’re undoubtedly familiar with infamous names like Ted Bundy, Casey Anthony, and JonBenet Ramsey.
Both cover: criminal investigation, missing persons, true crime
Not rated yet
Weeknight Mysteries Podcast
Weeknight Mysteries PodcastAudioLast show:
Welcome to Weeknight Mysteries Podcast where we discuss mysteries and share our perspectives and opinions. Contact us at: weeknightmysteries@gmail.com
Both cover: criminal investigation, missing persons, true crime
Not rated yet
10 to Life
Annie EliseAudioLast show:
Behind every crime is a victim, a perpetrator, and a story that demands to be told.
Both cover: criminal investigation, missing persons, true crime
Not rated yet
Check The Locks: A True Crime Podcast
John ConnerAudioLast show:
John Conner dives headfirst into some of the wildest, most unsettling true crime cases ever told in a brand-new weekly podcast where you help decide just how terrifying…
Both cover: criminal investigation, missing persons, true crime
Not rated yet
Mysteries and Histories
Georgia MarieAudioLast show:
Join Georgia as each week she talks you through important pieces of history that more people should know about or true crime cases that require more public attention -…
Both cover: criminal investigation, missing persons, true crime
Not rated yet
Crime with Holly
CrimeaHollyAudioLast show:
A true crime podcast with Tiktoker CrimeaHolly! Featuring lesser known cases including the missing, murdered and unsolved.
Both cover: criminal investigation, missing persons, true crime
Not rated yet
Questions about What Happened to the McStays?
- What podcasts and channels are like What Happened to the McStays??
- On AmigoFish, shows like What Happened to the McStays? include Bad Things: True Crime, Rotten Mango, Crime Stories Uncovered, Real Crime and True Crime Obsessed.
- What does What Happened to the McStays? cover?
- What Happened to the McStays? covers true crime, missing persons, criminal investigation, us crime and podcast series.
- How does AmigoFish choose shows like What Happened to the McStays??
- "Rated alike" lists shows that people who rated What Happened to the McStays? tend to rate the same way. "Similar in subject" lists shows that cover the same subjects. These lists do not use popularity charts.