No Way Jose Ep 6: PRETEND, Read the Report
From WANA Presents: For The Record With David McClam · · 16 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
For all of the recipes in the episode and others. Check and join our SubStack
If the information you are looking for is not there, check back as it will be coming soon!If the information you are looking for is not there, check back as it will be coming soon!
In this episode of No Way, José, we examine PRETEND’s treatment of the stolen-phone allegation involving LaDonna Humphrey and compare that presentation with the actual findings documented by the Benton County Sheriff’s Office.
At the center of the episode is a statement from Detective Paul W. Carter after reviewing the phone records supplied by the people accusing LaDonna of filing a false theft report:
“I found no evidence in the phone records to indicate Ladonna Humphrey had falsified her police report.”
That conclusion matters.
This episode follows the evidence through the original theft report, the detective’s analysis of the phone records, PRETEND’s later discussion of the SIM card, and the court proceedings that ultimately affected LaDonna’s ability to defend herself and challenge the judgment against her.
LaDonna maintains that her phone was stolen. Her husband and daughter have supported that account.
The original sheriff’s report documents that on November 8, 2018, LaDonna and her husband, Danny, reported hearing the alarm on their Suburban while inside their home. Danny reported seeing the vehicle’s interior light illuminated, the exterior lights flashing, and a white SUV nearby.
When Deputy Joshua Pierson accompanied them to the vehicle, LaDonna identified several missing items, including her purse, iPhone, identification, payment cards, approximately $280 in cash, and a Garmin GPS.
The investigation later became intertwined with civil litigation because the missing phone had been the subject of expedited discovery.
In February 2019, Anthony Christopher and his attorney brought phone records to Detective Carter and alleged that those records proved LaDonna had continued using the phone after reporting it stolen.
Carter reviewed the material.
His findings did not support that interpretation.
The detective documented three significant issues.
First, he found no outgoing phone usage after the police report was filed.
Second, he identified records indicating that the account had been updated to a different IMEI-numbered device.
Third, he found that the accusation failed to account for the six-hour difference between UTC and Central Time, a discrepancy capable of changing the timeline being presented as evidence.
Those findings formed the basis for Carter’s conclusion that the phone records did not establish that LaDonna had falsified her theft report.
This episode compares that analysis with PRETEND’s Part 3 discussion of the allegation.
Although PRETEND acknowledged that a detective had reached a conclusion favorable to LaDonna, its presentation focused instead on a courtroom claim involving the original SIM card, followed by sarcastic commentary suggesting that the theft account was implausible.
The episode asks whether that presentation gave listeners enough information to evaluate the actual evidence.
An IMEI identifies a device. A SIM card has its own separate identifying information. Carter’s report discussed a change in IMEI, but the material examined in this episode does not contain a corresponding ICCID comparison establishing that the same physical SIM card moved from the allegedly stolen phone into another handset.
That distinction matters.
A joke about a “magical SIM card” does not answer the detective’s findings concerning the time conversion, outgoing usage, or change in device identity.
If PRETEND believes those findings are wrong, the episode argues that the underlying records and technical reasoning should be shown and explained directly.
We also examine LaDonna’s claim that neither she nor her legal team knew Carter’s supplemental report existed until almost a year after contempt sanctions had been imposed and that the…
Back to WANA Presents: For The Record With David McClam · Report a problem