Skip to main content
AmigoFish

No Way, José: Ep. 7: Fact-Checking PRETEND’s Gypsy Rose Blanchard Series

From WANA Presents: For The Record With David McClam · · 18 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

For all of the recipes in the episode and others. Check and join our SubStack

If the information you are looking for is not there, check back as it will be coming soon!OTHER RECEIPTS FROM THE EPISODE

Associated Press: case and guilty-plea background

PRETEND, Part 5

Epilepsy Foundation: What if the EEG is normal?

PRETEND, Part 4

American Cancer Society: ALL remission criteria

RMHC of the Ozarks: mission and eligibility

PRETEND, Part 1 and Part 2

PRETEND, Part 1 and Part 5

MedlinePlus Genetics: 1q21.1 microdeletion

MSD Manual: factitious disorder imposed on another

PRETEND, Part 6

Cleveland Clinic: FDIA diagnostic criteria

In this episode of No Way, José, we examine Javier Leiva’s PRETEND series about Gypsy Rose Blanchard and ask a straightforward question:

Does the reporting hold up when the medical claims, timelines, and conclusions are checked against the evidence?

This episode is not an attempt to erase Gypsy Rose Blanchard’s responsibility for her role in the murder of her mother. Gypsy pleaded guilty to second-degree murder.

Our focus is PRETEND’s reporting.

Throughout its Gypsy Rose series, PRETEND challenges medical claims, questions historical accounts, analyzes records, and asks listeners to reconsider what they believe about one of the most heavily discussed true-crime cases of the past decade.

That kind of reporting comes with a responsibility.

If you challenge medical information, your own medical explanations need to be accurate.

If you present a number, the timeline supporting that number needs to make sense.

And if you reach a conclusion, listeners deserve to understand how the evidence actually gets you there.

In this episode, we examine several places where PRETEND’s reporting raises serious questions.

Can a seizure only be confirmed by EEG?

In Part 5, Javier states that the only way to confirm a seizure is to capture one on an EEG.

That is not an accurate description of how seizures are diagnosed.

An EEG can be an important diagnostic tool, but seizures may also be diagnosed using medical history, witness accounts, clinical examinations, symptoms, and other findings.

Even a normal EEG does not establish that someone has never experienced a seizure.

This does not prove that Gypsy had epilepsy.

It means the standard PRETEND used to evaluate that question was medically flawed.

Does normal bloodwork disprove a childhood leukemia history?

PRETEND also uses largely normal bloodwork from 2011 while questioning reports that Gypsy had childhood leukemia in remission.

But normal blood counts can be consistent with remission.

A laboratory result from years later cannot independently determine whether someone had leukemia as a child.

If a historical cancer diagnosis is being challenged, the relevant evidence would include the original diagnostic records, treatment records, oncology documentation, and any gaps in that record.

Normal bloodwork years later cannot carry that burden by itself.

Was cancer required to stay at a Ronald McDonald House?

PRETEND also raises the question of how Gypsy could have stayed at a Ronald McDonald House if she did not have cancer.

But Ronald McDonald House programs serve families of seriously ill and injured children, not exclusively children being treated for cancer.

That does not prove anything about Gypsy’s specific historical stay.

It does mean that the supposed mystery depends on a premise that should have been verified before being presented to listeners.

Where does “23 years in a wheelchair” come from?

The opening of the series describes Gypsy as having spent 23 years in a wheelchair.

Later episodes, however, describe a much different chronology, including an account that she regained the ability to walk around age seven after an alleged period of temporary paralysis.

Those accounts do not provide an obvious basis for a 23-year duration.

The criticism here is simple:

If a precise number is going to open an investigative series, the…

Back to WANA Presents: For The Record With David McClam · Report a problem