Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Episode 334 - Johnny Cooney, The Short-Arm Pitcher Who Became a .300 Hitter at 40

From Two Strike Noise - A Baseball History Podcast · · 1 hr 18 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Jeff and Mark wrap up the 2026 World Series and congratulate the Milwaukee Brewers on their first championship. Mark tells the story of Johnny Cooney. Before he signed a pro contract, Cooney threw a perfect game in a Connecticut industrial league hours after his train hit a car and killed four people. A Red Sox deal fell apart because his manager wouldn’t accept a check. He won 14 games for the Boston Braves, then had 13 pieces of bone removed from his left elbow, which left his pitching arm shorter than his other arm. Casey Stengel rebuilt him as an outfielder, and Cooney returned to the majors at 34. He hit .318 and .319 at ages 39 and 40, hit his only two career home runs on back-to-back days at the Polo Grounds, and umpired part of a game when the regular crew was fogged in on Cape Cod. The guys also explain Branch Rickey’s “coconut snatcher” term and compare Cooney’s pitcher-to-outfielder path with Rick Ankiel’s.

Also in this episode: the Rays radio call of the Game 4 extra-innings finish, the check swing strike that ended Game 3, and Kenny Albert filling in for Joe Davis in the middle of colonoscopy prep. MLB is testing restricted outfield positioning in the Arizona Fall League, and Jeff looks at batting averages and stolen bases before and after the shift ban and the bigger bases. Moving the mound back comes up as an alternative. With a lockout looming, Sonny Gray and Nick Martinez become free agents, and the guys consider whether the Mexican League could land MLB players during a work stoppage. Jeff gives the answer to the trivia question on teams that have played in the World Series as both an AL and NL club. Wax Pack Heroes plays its own fall league with 1999 Upper Deck cans and tests three listener-inspired rules.

Topics: Johnny Cooney, Boston Braves history, Casey Stengel, pitcher turned outfielder, Johnny Cooney perfect game, Willimantic American Thread industrial league, Ed Barrow Red Sox, Paul Krichell, hesitation pitch, Van Lingle Mungo, Leo Durocher trade, Boston Bees, Polo Grounds home runs, player umpire 1941, Branch Rickey coconut snatcher, Tommy Lasorda The Artful Dodger, Rick Ankiel, 2026 World Series, Milwaukee Brewers champions, Tampa Bay Rays, Chandler Simpson, Kenny Albert colonoscopy, Joe Davis, Arizona Fall League rule test, outfield shift restrictions, infield shift ban, MLB batting average, bigger bases stolen bases, pickoff limits, ABS check swing, moving the pitching mound back, MLB lockout 2026, Sonny Gray, Nick Martinez, Mexican League, Houston Astros AL and NL World Series, 1999 Upper Deck baseball cards, Wax Pack Heroes, Two Strike Noise

Connect With Us

YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@twostrikenoise Twitch:https://www.twitch.tv/twostrikenoise BlueSky: @twostrikenoise.bsky.social

Email: twostrikenoise@gmail.com

Support a Great Cause: Don’t let your common cards collect dust! Donate them to help spark a child’s interest in the game athttp://commons4kids.org/.

#baseballhistory #mlb #baseball #BaseballCards #TwoStrikeNoise #popculture

00:00 Welcome

01:55 World Series Recap

02:38 Game 4 and Broadcast Rant

05:22 Fall League Rule Experiments

06:46 Do Rule Changes Work?

10:42 Move the Mound Debate

12:07 World Series Trivia Setup

12:44 Colonoscopy Booth Story

14:54 Lockout and Playing Abroad

17:56 Johnny Cooney Origins

19:12 Perfect Game After Tragedy

21:53 Braves Breakout and Injury

26:40 Reinvented as Outfielder

28:38 Dodgers Years and Big Trade

31:48 Late Career Peaks and Umpiring

34:47 Final Seasons and Legacy

38:15 Coconut Snatcher Explained

39:52 Ankiel Wild Pitch Meltdown

40:44 Cooney World Series Trivia

42:16 Wax Pack Heroes

01:13:01 Wrap Up Rules And Contact

Back to Two Strike Noise - A Baseball History Podcast · Report a problem