Qualified Immunity: Protecting Good Cops or Shielding Bad Ones? | Brandon Grable
From Two Cops One Donut · · 3 hr 3 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
Qualified immunity is one of the most misunderstood and controversial doctrines in American policing. Does it actually protect good officers making reasonable decisions, or has it become a barrier that keeps legitimate civil-rights claims from ever reaching a jury?
In this episode of Two Cops One Donut, Sgt. Erik Lavigne sits down with civil-rights attorney Brandon Grable of Clearly Established for an in-depth discussion on what qualified immunity actually is, what it is not, and whether law enforcement really needs it.
Joining the conversation are retired law enforcement officers Matt Thornton, Zoel “Red Dog” Murphy, and Banning Sweatland.
The discussion breaks down qualified immunity without the usual slogans, including the “clearly established law” standard, why a constitutional violation can occur while an official still receives immunity, the difference between qualified immunity and Graham v. Connor’s objective-reasonableness standard, indemnification and who actually pays civil judgments, the difference between civil and criminal accountability, First Amendment cases, police training, the role of the courts, and what could replace qualified immunity if it disappeared.
Brandon also explains why eliminating qualified immunity would not eliminate the protections officers receive when their actions are objectively reasonable, and Erik openly challenges several assumptions he previously held about why officers need the doctrine.
By the end of the nearly three-hour conversation, Erik reaches a conclusion he did not expect when the episode began.
This is not a pro-police versus anti-police debate. It is a long-form attempt to understand how qualified immunity actually works, why critics believe it is fundamentally broken, what legitimate protections police officers still need, and how citizens should be able to seek accountability when government violates constitutional rights.
If you have ever heard someone say “qualified immunity protects bad cops,” “abolishing qualified immunity will bankrupt police officers,” or “qualified immunity prevents officers from being criminally charged,” this episode is designed to separate the myths from the actual legal questions.
Educational and entertainment purposes only. Nothing in this episode should be considered legal advice.
send us a message! twocopsonedonut@yahoo.com (https://www.buzzsprout.com/1759919/fan_mail/new)
Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=HA5JBLQMNH2SC)
Please see our Youtube channel https://www.youtube.com/c/TwoCopsOneDonut
Join our Discord!! https://discord.gg/BdjeTEAc *Send us a message! twocopsonedonut@yahoo.com 🔗 Visit us at TwoCopsOneDonut.com & https://www.thedonut.tv/ 📧 Contact us at twocopsonedonut@yahoo.com 🎧 Subscribe to us on Apple, Spotify, and Amazon Music at “2 Cops 1 Donut” Donate Here: https://buymeacoffee.com/twocopsonedonut
🔔 *Don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe for more insightful discussions on law enforcement and community safety!* 💬 *Join the conversation in the comments below!*
#TwoCopsOneDonut #PublicSafety #ErikLavigne #firtsresponders
Our partners:
Ghost Patch: tell them Two Cops One Donut sent you and get free shipping on Flex Shield orders! GhostPatchCustoms.com
Insight LPR license plate recognition technology provides 24/7 real-time insight for homes, businesses and neighborhoods. Protect what matters most! Visit https://insightlpr.com/
Retro Rifle: Official Clothing of Two Cops One Donut. Hawaiian Shirts, Guns, and Pop-Culture! head to Retro-Rifle.com tell them we sent ya!