Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Can Cops Take Your Gun During a Traffic Stop? | Just Because They Can Doesn’t Mean They Should

From Two Cops One Donut · · 1 hr 45 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Can police temporarily disarm a lawfully armed citizen during a traffic stop?

Under the right circumstances, yes. But lawful authority is not a blank check, and “officer safety” cannot become a universal answer every time a firearm is present.

In this episode, Erik responds to a Texas police officer who argues that officers may frisk a driver, temporarily take a firearm, check whether it is stolen, and return it when the traffic stop is over. Erik agrees that police sometimes have the legal authority to temporarily secure a weapon, but challenges the idea that lawful possession alone makes a cooperative citizen dangerous.

The discussion breaks down the difference between:

- Being armed and being armed and dangerous

- Officer safety and officer convenience

- A legitimate protective measure and a fishing expedition

- Legal authority and professional judgment

- Temporarily securing a weapon and launching an unrelated firearm investigation

The episode examines Terry v. Ohio, Pennsylvania v. Mimms, Arizona v. Johnson, Michigan v. Long, Rodriguez v. United States, Texas Government Code § 411.207, and recent Fifth Circuit firearm decisions.

Erik also reviews a Jacksonville traffic stop in which officers attempted to remove a compliant driver’s holstered pistol and accidentally shot him. The incident raises a difficult question: can a safety measure create the very danger it was supposed to prevent? CAN-CO~1 CAN-CO~1

Matt joins the livestream unexpectedly and adds his perspective as a former officer. Together, they argue that police should act decisively when specific facts show danger, but should not punish lawful honesty, treat gun ownership as automatic suspicion, or turn a routine traffic stop into an unrelated investigation.

The conclusion is simple: when the facts show danger, act. When those facts are absent, use judgment, give clear instructions, watch behavior, manage access, and do not turn a constitutional right into automatic suspicion.

This episode is intended for educational and entertainment purposes only. It is not legal advice.

send us a message! twocopsonedonut@yahoo.com (https://www.buzzsprout.com/1759919/fan_mail/new)

Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=HA5JBLQMNH2SC)

Please see our Youtube channel https://www.youtube.com/c/TwoCopsOneDonut

Join our Discord!! https://discord.gg/BdjeTEAc *Send us a message! twocopsonedonut@yahoo.com 🔗 Visit us at TwoCopsOneDonut.com & https://www.thedonut.tv/ 📧 Contact us at twocopsonedonut@yahoo.com 🎧 Subscribe to us on Apple, Spotify, and Amazon Music at “2 Cops 1 Donut” Donate Here: https://buymeacoffee.com/twocopsonedonut

🔔 *Don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe for more insightful discussions on law enforcement and community safety!* 💬 *Join the conversation in the comments below!*

#TwoCopsOneDonut #PublicSafety #ErikLavigne #firtsresponders

Our partners:

Ghost Patch: tell them Two Cops One Donut sent you and get free shipping on Flex Shield orders! GhostPatchCustoms.com

Insight LPR license plate recognition technology provides 24/7 real-time insight for homes, businesses and neighborhoods. Protect what matters most! Visit https://insightlpr.com/

Retro Rifle: Official Clothing of Two Cops One Donut. Hawaiian Shirts, Guns, and Pop-Culture! head to Retro-Rifle.com tell them we sent ya!

Back to Two Cops One Donut · Report a problem