
True Crime in Real Estate™
Sandi LynAudio
- Format:
- Podcast
- New episodes:
- Several times a week
- Typical length:
- about 40 minutes
- Latest episode:
About this show
So you passed the exam, bought the lockbox, and found a blazer that makes you look trustworthy. Nobody in pre-license brought up Beverly Carter, who went to show a house outside Little Rock in 2014 and never came home. Or Ashley Okland, shot inside a model home in West Des Moines in 2011. That’s the side of real estate this show covers.
We get into agents hurt on the job, vacant houses that turned into crime scenes, brokers who disappeared with everyone’s earnest money, and wire fraud that drains a family’s down payment right before closing. Then the bigger picture, honestly, like redlining, Cabrini-Green, Pruitt-Igoe, slumlords who own entire ZIP codes, and cartels parking cash in luxury condos. Some of it is history and some of it is still happening right now.
True Crime in Real Estate™ is made for agents. If you’re just here for the true crime and want to know why your REALTOR® won’t meet you alone at a vacant house after dark, this is why.
Covers: real estate, true crime, real estate fraud, housing discrimination, military housing, home buying scams, missing persons cases, property law
Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at api.riverside.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.
Recently on this show
Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.
A podcast for agents examining crimes and dangers in the property business, from vanished agents to housing history. Recent episodes cover troop housing neglect at Balfour Beatty, the Bender family inn, the Westfield "Watcher" letters, and the 1986 disappearance of Suzy Lamplugh.
Cosmos
Similar in subject
- MK True Crime
Both cover: missing persons cases, true crime - Giallo Psicologico (Psychological Crime)
Both cover: missing persons cases, true crime
Similar shows
Explore more
Episodes
Ep 18: Balfour Beatty - The Company that Profited by Neglecting Troop Housing
· 44 min
Balfour Beatty Communities, one of the largest private operators of military family housing in the United States, faced allegations that it neglected unsafe or hazardous housing conditions while falsifying maintenance records to collect performance bonuses. The episode opens with families at Tinker Air Force Base dealing with dwellings containing lead paint and asbestos, including an eight-month-old baby exposed to crumbling floor tiles. At Fort Gordon, a military family's daughter suffered serious skin problems associated with mold in their home. Meanwhile, at Lackland Air Force Base, employees were instructed to change repair completion dates and use exceptions to make the company's performance numbers appear better than they were. The company operated under 50-year agreements, managing tens of thousands of homes across dozens of military installations, with bonuses tied to maintenance performance figures that it largely reported itself. Former employees described a system in which repair requests were deliberately delayed before being entered into YARDI, making lengthy waits appear much shorter in official records. Employees who resisted or kept separate records were fired or quit, while managers described pressure from regional leadership to manipulate numbers to protect bonus payments. Investigations and reporting by Reuters and CBS News in 2019 brought the practices to public attention, prompting congressional scrutiny and federal investigations. In 2021, two former managers pleaded guilty to fraud, followed by Balfour Beatty Communities pleading guilty in December 2021 to defrauding the government. The company paid more than $65 million in fines and restitution and was placed under a court-appointed monitor for three years. The managers received probation rather than prison time. However, a 2022 Senate investigation found similar maintenance and recordkeeping problems continued at other installations even after the guilty plea. The episode also examines ongoing allegations at Naval Air Station Key West, where 272 people joined a 2025 lawsuit alleging mold, asbestos, lead paint, and other unsafe conditions in base housing. Balfour Beatty denies the allegations and says it will defend itself. The discussion broadens to poor military housing and barracks conditions in general, then turns to lessons for real estate professionals and property managers. Maintenance incentives based on self-reported numbers require independent oversight, and tenants should document every repair request in writing with dates and follow-up messages. Agents working with military families should explain off-base housing options and help document property conditions before move-in. Listing agents should also examine repair histories for recurring problems and follow applicable disclosure requirements. The central lesson is that property management records must be accurate, maintenance complaints must be documented, and owners must verify the performance information they rely on. Chapters 00:00 The Balfour Beatty Military Housing Scandal 02:24 Falsified Repair Records at Lackland 05:34 The 50-Year Military Housing Contracts 08:30 How Balfour Beatty Made Its Money 10:40 Two Sets of Maintenance Records 12:30 The Employees Who Exposed the Fraud 17:34 The Air Force's Response 20:00 The Lackland Housing Office 23:50 Problems Beyond Oklahoma and Texas 26:00 Reuters Breaks the Story 28:00 Federal Investigations and Guilty Pleas 31:00 The Company's $65 Million Penalty 33:20 The Senate Investigation and Continued Problems 34:00 The Key West Housing Lawsuit 36:00 Military Barracks and Housing Conditions 38:42 Real Estate and Property Management Lessons 40:00 Documenting Repairs and Protecting Tenants Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/truecrimeinrealestate
Not rated yetEp 17: The Bloody Benders - Dinner with a Side of Hammer
· 43 min
The Bender family established a small roadside inn and grocery store on a 160-acre homestead in southeast Kansas around 1870, positioning themselves along the Osage Mission Road, the main route west for settlers traveling with money and valuables. The family consisted of John Bender Sr., his son John Jr., Ma Bender, and Kate, the only member who spoke English fluently. Kate presented herself as a healer and spiritualist, attracting travelers with promises of meals, lodging, and medical remedies (and her good looks). Behind a curtain in their cramped cabin, the family concealed a deadly operation: travelers were seated with their backs to the partition, struck in the head with hammers, and robbed. Their bodies were dropped through a trapdoor into a cellar before being moved to an apple orchard. As travelers began disappearing, suspicion eventually focused on the Benders, particularly after Dr. William York vanished while searching for another missing man. His brothers investigated and learned he had planned to stay at the Bender inn. At an April 1873 township meeting, residents agreed to search the area, but the Benders soon disappeared. Neighbors found their property abandoned, with livestock left starving and the cabin stripped of its belongings. A search uncovered blood in the cellar, several hammers, and evidence of the family's operation. Digging in the orchard revealed the bodies of Dr. York, George Longcor and his young daughter, Henry McKenzie, and several other victims. While some stories number the family's total victims near twenty, confirmed estimates place ten or eleven bodies on the property, including one child. The Benders escaped, and despite substantial state and local rewards, they were never conclusively found or brought to trial. Suspects were occasionally identified and arrested, but no conviction followed. The cabin and orchard were dismantled by relic hunters, and the property remained largely untouched for almost a century. A historical marker and a Bender museum later commemorated the murders, while the murder weapons became part of the Cherryvale Museum collection. In 2020, a man named Bob Miller purchased the 162-acre property at auction because of its historical significance, and worked with the University of Kansas to investigate the site. Archaeological excavations beginning in 2024 uncovered roughly 1,200 artifacts, with researchers continuing to search for the cabin's location and additional graves. The episode closes with lessons for real estate professionals: the Benders deliberately used the property's location and improvements to facilitate their crimes; agents should pay attention to improvements and permits that do not match; and a property's stigma can persist long after legal restrictions disappear. Ultimately, the land's historical story became its greatest asset, demonstrating how the story attached to a property can become more valuable than the land itself. Chapters 00:00 The Bender Family's Roadside Inn 07:32 The Homestead and the Family's Operation 09:13 Kate Bender's Healing Business 12:00 The Missing Travelers 15:34 The York Brothers Investigate 17:49 The Benders Disappear 19:30 Discovering the Crime Scene 21:02 The Search for the Victims 24:30 The Bodies in the Orchard 29:00 The Benders' Escape and the Manhunt 30:41 The Cabin Is Stripped Away 33:00 The Search for the Benders 35:00 The Property's Long History 36:00 Archaeology and the Bender Site 37:00 Real Estate Lessons from the Bender Murders 39:45 When the Story Becomes the Asset 41:41 Closing Discussion and Future Episodes Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/truecrimeinrealestate
Not rated yetEp 16: The Conjuring House - The Real Estate Story Crazier than the Hauntings
· 59 min
The episode revisits the story behind the Rhode Island farmhouse that inspired The Conjuring, beginning with the Perron family, who moved into the 1736 property on Round Top Road in 1971. The family described unexplained disturbances, frightening encounters, and increasingly violent supernatural experiences, particularly involving mother Carolyn. Paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren visited the house, and a 1973 séance allegedly ended with Carolyn being thrown across a room. The Warrens attributed the haunting to Bathsheba Sherman, a real 19th-century woman they claimed had practiced witchcraft and sacrificed a baby. However, historical records reviewed by the Boston Globe revealed no evidence supporting those accusations, that Bathsheba lived elsewhere, died at 72, *AND* had no documented connection to the alleged crimes. The episode distinguishes the family's accounts from verified historical facts and questions how much of the legend was embellished. The farmhouse became a real estate nightmare after The Conjuring premiered in 2013. Previous owner Norma Sutcliffe said the movie's depiction was inaccurate, but nonetheless visitors began trespassing, appearing in her yard at all hours of the night, and harassing her family. She sued Warner Bros., describing the experience as a siege. In 2019, paranormal enthusiasts Corey and Jennifer Heinzen purchased the property for approximately $439,000 and turned it into a destination for ghost tours and overnight stays. Their successor, Jacqueline Nunez, purchased it through an LLC for $1.525 million, financed with a roughly $1.2 million mortgage. The business eventually collapsed after reported incidents, a barn fire, a worker's wage dispute, a stop-work order, and Nunez's entertainment license being denied. After she stopped paying the mortgage, foreclosure proceedings began, setting off an extraordinary dispute involving YouTuber Elton Castee and comedian Matt Rife, Ghost Hunters star Jason Hawes, with competing purchase agreements, questionable legal documents, and a loan that had been sold separately from the property. The final section unravels the ongoing ownership battle. Castee secretly purchased the mortgage debt through an LLC attributed to him, while documents appeared that give authority to sell the farmhouse to Hawes for $1.3 million. A bank subsequently recorded a mortgage discharge despite having already sold the loan, and Nunez's sister challenged the sale, raising questions about her ability to enter contracts. A judge invalidated the initial deed and power of attorney after concerns about notarization, although a second notarized deed later complicated the dispute. Further court proceedings addressed receivership, competing claims, property access, and whether Hawes could complete the purchase without knowing whom to pay. By June, town records listed Hawes as the owner, but Castee's side continued challenging the transaction, including arguing that Nunez's LLC had been dissolved before the deed was signed. The episode closes with the Conjuring House still caught in a legal and financial maze, demonstrating how a famous property's paranormal reputation can generate extraordinary commercial value, and even more extraordinary real estate litigation. 00:00 — The Perron Family and the Haunted Farmhouse 06:41 — The Warrens and the Alleged Haunting 12:00 — Bathsheba Sherman: The Real History 15:47 — The Conjuring Movie and the Owner's Nightmare 19:30 — Turning the House Into a Business 24:30 — The Rise and Fall of the Conjuring House Tours 33:23 — The Foreclosure and the Bidding War 40:00 — Who Bought the Mortgage? 48:45 — Competing Deeds and Courtroom Chaos 55:36 — Who Actually Owns the Conjuring House? TCiRE Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/truecrimeinrealestate
Not rated yetEp 15: "The Watcher" - Creepy Letters Sent to New Owners of $1.3 Million Dollar House
· 59 min
The episode examines the true story behind the infamous “Watcher” case involving Derek and Maria Broaddus, who purchased 657 Boulevard in Westfield, New Jersey, in 2014 for $1,355,657. The family planned to renovate the grand Dutch Colonial before moving in, but just days after closing, Derek discovered a disturbing letter addressed to “the new owner.” The anonymous writer claimed that the house had been watched by their family for generations, and then revealed details about the couple’s children that could only be known to someone who could see and hear what went on in the house and the yard. A second letter arrived weeks later, containing even more specific information about the children, the house’s layout and the “pain” caused by the renovations and changes, and asked what bedrooms everyone would sleep in. The letters completely changed the family’s lives. They NEVER moved into the house, and to try and discover the identity of “The Watcher”, Derek and Maria spent months installing cameras, investigating neighbors, and paying private investigators, former FBI personnel, security specialists, and even a forensic linguist. They ultimately spent at least $100,000 trying to unmask the anonymous letter mailer, but every investigative avenue was fruitless in determining who was responsible. The family eventually listed the house for sale, but insisted that disclosure of the letters be done to not put any future owners through the same ordeal, but not surprisingly, this mostly scared away potential buyers. They sued the previous owners, claiming the Woodses knew about the Watcher and failed to disclose the threat, but the lawsuit was dismissed in 2017. Their attempt to tear down the house and divide the property was also rejected after intense opposition from neighbors. A fourth and final known letter arrived in 2017, threatening Derek and Maria with accidents, illness, death, and harm to loved ones while revealing that the Watcher was aware of the family’s efforts to find them. Derek later admitted that he anonymously sent retaliatory letters to some hostile neighbors, but there is no evidence that he was responsible for the Watcher letters. In 2019, the house finally sold for $959,360 (nearly $400,000 below the original purchase price), and the family estimated losses closer to $700,000 when renovations, investigations, taxes, financing, legal expenses, and other costs were considered. The new owners have reportedly never received a Watcher letter, but nobody has ever been charged; the Union County Prosecutor’s Office considers the case open and inactive, leaving the identity of the Watcher unresolved. 00:00 — The Real Watcher Story 03:30 — Buying 657 Boulevard 07:00 — The First Letter 12:00 — The Watcher Knows Their Children 18:00 — The Second Letter 24:00 — Threats Without Direct Threats 28:00 — Living in Fear 32:00 — The Investigation 37:00 — The Lawsuit 42:00 — The Fight to Tear Down the House 47:00 — The Final Watcher Letter 51:00 — The House Finally Sells 54:00 — Who Was the Watcher? Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 14: Realtor to the Stars Bludgeoned by Her Assistant
· 48 min
The episode examines the 2007 murder of Linda Stein, a former co-manager of the Ramones who became a successful Manhattan real estate agent known for selling multimillion-dollar apartments to celebrities. Stein was found beaten to death in her Fifth Avenue penthouse after her personal assistant, Natavia Lowery, told family and friends that Linda was out running or walking in the park. Investigators discovered through building surveillance that Stein had never left the building and that Lowery was the only person seen going to the apartment that day. Surveillance also contradicted Lowery's account of how she traveled, and after questioning she gave several different explanations before eventually confessing to killing Stein. Prosecutors argued that Lowery had been stealing from Stein and had taken more than $30,000 through unauthorized credit cards and ATM withdrawals. They said Stein had discovered the theft and was preparing to confront or report her assistant when she was killed. Lowery later recanted her confession, while her defense acknowledged that she was a thief but argued that did not make her a murderer. The jury convicted her of second-degree murder and grand larceny after about five hours of deliberation, and she was sentenced to 27 years to life. Lowery has maintained her innocence. The episode uses Stein's death to examine the risks real estate professionals take when giving assistants extensive access to their personal and professional lives. Stein's daughters later sued Douglas Elliman, the brokerage where their mother was a contractor, and the temp agency that placed Lowery with Linda, but the claims were ultimately dismissed; the appellate court found that Stein, as an independent contractor, controlled her assistant's work. Sandi Lyn emphasizes that agents should use separate logins and limit assistants' access to critical systems, financial accounts, MLS credentials, electronic signatures, email, and lockboxes. She also recommends cutting off access and involving a bank, broker, or law enforcement before confronting someone suspected of stealing or other illegal or unethical behavior, while brokerages should have policies for complaints involving assistants and understand applicable rules governing background checks and reference checks. 00:00 — The Murder of Linda Stein 04:54 — From the Ramones to Real Estate 08:49 — The Realtor to the Stars 14:40 — Surveillance Reveals the Truth 19:20 — Four Different Stories 25:18 — The Theft Behind the Murder 32:28 — The Defense of Natavia Lowery 34:53 — The Murder Trial 36:40 — The Wrongful Death Lawsuit 40:00 — How Much Access Is Too Much? 42:00 — Protecting Yourself From an Insider 44:00 — What Brokers Should Be Doing Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 13: Suzy Lamplugh, the UK Agent who Vanished at Lunch
· 35 min
The episode examines the 1986 disappearance of 25-year-old British estate agent Suzy Lamplugh, who left her London office to show a house to a man identified in her diary as “Mr. Kipper.” Witnesses saw Suzy with a man outside the property, but she never returned to the office. Her company car was later found abandoned, and her wallet remained inside while her keys were missing. The case became one of Britain's most prominent missing-person investigations, receiving national attention through the BBC's Crimewatch. Investigators eventually focused on convicted murderer John Cannan, who was publicly named by the Metropolitan Police as the man they believed killed Suzy, although he was never charged in her disappearance and no forensic evidence has conclusively tied him to the case. Evidence connecting Cannan to Suzy's disappearance include his use of the nickname “Kipper,” similarities between his behavior and descriptions of the man seen with Suzy, and his later conviction for the kidnapping and murder of Shirley Banks. Investigators have repeatedly searched locations connected to Cannan for Suzy's remains without finding them. However, former Scotland Yard detective David Videcette challenges the entire theory, arguing that Suzy may never have gone to the scheduled showing and that “Mr. Kipper” may not have existed. Forty years later, investigators still have unresolved witness leads, unidentified evidence from Suzy's car, and competing theories about what happened. The case becomes a broader examination of real estate agent safety. Sandi Lyn argues that Suzy followed many of the safety procedures agents are still taught today (recording the appointment, the address, and the person she expected to meet) yet those precautions did not protect her. The episode recommends applying safety procedures consistently to every client, obtaining identification, using services such as Forewarn, meeting strangers in public first, sharing live location, maintaining current emergency information, and documenting warning signs such as stalking or unexplained gifts. The story of Birmingham agent Stephanie Slater, who was kidnapped and held for eight days by a man posing as a buyer, reinforces the risks of meeting unknown clients alone. The episode closes by highlighting the Suzy Lamplugh Trust's decades of work on stalking and lone-worker safety and contrasting Britain's formalized protections with the lack of comparable systems described for American real estate agents. 00:00 — The Disappearance of Suzy Lamplugh 02:30 — The Mysterious Mr. Kipper 06:00 — The Last Sightings 09:30 — The Search for Suzy 12:00 — John Cannan Enters the Case 15:00 — The Murder of Shirley Banks 19:33 — The “Mr. Kipper” Theory 22:30 — A Different Theory of What Happened 25:00 — Forty Years Without Answers 27:30 — What Suzy's Case Teaches Agents 30:00 — The Kidnapping of Stephanie Slater 34:00 — The Suzy Lamplugh Trust Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 12: Flock Around and Find Out - Why is There a Camera Pointed at My Community Swimming Pool?
· 51 min
In this episode Sandi Lyn examines automated license plate reader systems like Flock Safety, and the ways the technology can be misused by law enforcement, private organizations, and homeowners associations. It opens with the case of former police chief Michael Steffman, who allegedly searched the license plates of his ex-girlfriend and her daughter roughly 600 times over a year. The episode explains how Flock has expanded into a nationwide network of more than 120,000 cameras, while selling access not only to police departments but also to HOAs, apartment complexes, commercial landlords, and developers. Reported cases include officers using the system to stalk romantic partners, databases being used for improper and potentially illegal investigations, and audit systems failing to prevent the very abuses they were supposed to catch. The episode then focuses on the consequences not of abuse, but of inaccurate automated alerts and the broader question of whether surveillance technology produces enough public-safety benefit to justify its risks. Multiple incidents are described in which Flock or similar systems allegedly misread license plates or relied on incorrect database information, resulting in armed traffic stops, arrests, and other serious consequences. The episode also discusses a Texas search involving a woman who had allegedly undergone an abortion, as well as concerns about immigration-related searches of Illinois cameras. Counterexamples are presented through research suggesting fixed license plate readers were associated with an approximately 11% reduction in vehicle theft and faster recovery of stolen vehicles, while Flock cites additional research claiming much larger crime-solving benefits. The discussion emphasizes that misconduct involving police databases predates Flock, while acknowledging that automated audit logs can create a digital trail for identifying misuse. The final section focuses specifically on real estate, where Flock cameras installed by HOAs can become an overlooked issue for buyers and agents. A Minneapolis-area buyer reportedly canceled a home walkthrough after discovering cameras at the neighborhood entrance and pool, raising questions about who controls the data, how long it is retained, and whether it can be used to issue fines. The episode notes that traditional HOA disclosures generally do not specifically address private surveillance systems and recommends that agents investigate camera locations, obtain HOA contracts, determine who can access data and how long it is retained, and understand whether the association can impose penalties based on surveillance data. Agents are encouraged to document what they discover and disclose relevant information according to applicable state law, while recognizing that crowdsourced camera maps can be incomplete or inaccurate. The episode closes by comparing the power of a police login with the access potentially held by an HOA board member: the system produces information, but does not inherently distinguish between guilty and innocent people. 00:00 — The Flock Investigation Begins 03:58 — Police Misuse the System 10:42 — When Flock Gets It Wrong 17:58 — The Abortion Search 23:28 — The Case for Surveillance 30:28 — Flock Comes to HOAs 37:18 — The Real Estate Problem 42:48 — What Agents Should Investigate 49:12 — All You Need Is a Login Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 11: Realtor Mayra Velasquez: How Ancestry DNA (maybe) Solved the 2012 Murder of Irasema Chavez
· 24 min
Today’s episode examines the 2012 murder of Irasema Chavez in Arlington, Texas, where she was found stabbed more than 100 times inside her apartment. Surveillance footage captured a hooded figure entering after Chavez opened the door, but the video was too low quality to identify the person. Investigators found a single drop of female blood on a bedroom TV stand that did not belong to Chavez, but the DNA produced no CODIS match. A stolen television, lack of forced entry, and the brutality of the killing suggested Chavez knew her attacker, while an early tip reportedly pointed investigators toward a close friend and her allegedly jealous husband. Police visited their home but after no one answered, they never followed up, and the case remained cold for 14 years. In 2024, Arlington investigators brought the case to the FBI's investigative genetic genealogy program, which searches publicly accessible genealogy databases for relatives of an unknown DNA contributor and builds family trees to identify potential suspects. That investigation eventually pointed to Mayra Velasquez, a licensed North Texas real estate agent. Rather than immediately seek a sample that might alert her, detectives recovered a discarded plastic fork after following her to a restaurant. According to police, DNA from the fork matched the blood found at the crime scene. Velasquez was arrested in July 2026 and charged with capital murder, but she pleaded not guilty and was released on $450,000 bond shortly after. Sandi Lyn stresses that the DNA match does not by itself prove Velasquez committed the murder. Her attorneys argue that the DNA only establishes that she had been inside the apartment, which would not be unusual because the two women were friends. They also challenge the condition and timing of the blood drop seeming fresh hours after the murder took place, the surveillance video's apparent depiction of a man, and the lack of an established motive. The case becomes a broader discussion of how real estate licensing and background checks can create an illusion of safety: records can reveal what someone has previously been caught doing, but cannot establish what an otherwise clean-recorded person is capable of doing or “gotten away with” doing . The episode ultimately leaves the question of Velasquez's guilt to the evidence and a jury while emphasizing the significance of solving Chavez's murder after 14 years. 00:00 — Disclaimer and Intro 03:00 — The Case Goes Cold 10:00 — Investigative Genetic Genealogy 16:00 — The DNA Match 20:00 — The Defense's Case 24:00 — What Background Checks Really Tell Us Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 10: M***** F***ing Killdozer - Marvin Heemeyer's 2004 Rampage and the Real Estate Implications
· 24 min
The episode examines the 2004 Killdozer incident through the lens of commercial real estate rather than simply as a notorious crime. It follows the exploits of Marvin Heemeyer, who bought a two-acre commercial lot in Granby, Colorado, in 1992 to use as a muffler repair shop, before becoming embroiled in a years-long dispute with neighboring concrete plant owners over a failed land sale, zoning approvals, property access, drainage, and code enforcement. As permits were approved despite his objections, the conflict escalated from legal appeals into an increasingly personal feud. The discussion highlights a lesser-known detail that challenges the popular narrative: Heemeyer sold the property for $400,000 in 2003, making a substantial profit before secretly spending roughly 18 months converting a Komatsu bulldozer into a heavily armored vehicle. On June 4, 2004, he drove through the wall of his former shop, first attacking the concrete plant at the heart of the dispute before methodically destroying or damaging 13 buildings across Granby. Despite causing millions of dollars in property damage, no one besides Heemeyer was killed or even injured, and the rampage ended when the bulldozer became trapped and he took his own life. The episode concludes by focusing on the real estate lessons rather than the spectacle. The town of Granby intentionally destroyed the bulldozer to discourage it from becoming a monument, rebuilt the damaged properties, and ultimately moved forward while the concrete plant remained in operation. The hosts argue that failed off-market land deals, neighboring property disputes, zoning conflicts, and emotional decision-making can create lasting consequences, emphasizing the importance of written agreements, due diligence, professional representation, and recognizing that real estate transactions involve ongoing relationships with neighbors long after negotiations end. 00:00 Intro & Disclaimer 02:16 Marvin Heemeyer and the Failed Land Deal 05:57 Zoning Battles, Appeals, and Code Violations 09:02 Selling the Property and Building the ‘Dozer 11:43 The 2 Hour Long June 4, 2004 Rampage 5:22 Aftermath and Rebuilding Granby 19:49 Real Estate Lessons Learned from Killdozer Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 9: The 40 Year Scam Disguised as Free Money. Red Flags and Warning Signs To Look Out For
· 20 min
MV Realty's "Homeowner Benefit Program" promised homeowners quick cash (typically anywhere from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars) in exchange for agreeing to use the company as their listing agent if they ever sold their home. According to multiple state attorneys general, the sales pitch minimized or omitted the true terms of the agreement. Buried in the fine print was a 40-year exclusive listing contract that allowed MV Realty to claim a fee if the homeowner sold, refinanced, transferred the property, lost it to foreclosure, or even died. The company also recorded memorandums against property titles, creating clouds on title that homeowners often didn't realize existed until they attempted to sell or refinance years later. The program expanded to more than 35,000 homeowners across 33 states before state investigations began in late 2022. Attorneys general alleged the agreements were deceptively marketed, documents were not provided in advance, contracts were difficult to read, mobile notaries rushed homeowners through the signing process, and many consumers did not understand they were granting long-term rights tied to their homes. A wave of lawsuits and settlements followed, resulting in thousands of agreements being terminated, liens released, restitution for affected homeowners, and new laws in dozens of states restricting or banning similar Homeowner Benefit Agreements. Throughout the litigation, MV Realty denied the allegations, and several settlements were reached without admissions of wrongdoing. Sandi Lyn concludes that this example illustrates the importance of understanding every document before signing, particularly contracts affecting real estate. She emphasizes how consumers can unknowingly surrender significant property rights through complex legal language, while encouraging real estate agents to show the value they provide by identifying warning signs before clients sign on the dotted line. She closes by stressing that agents educate their past clients about emerging real estate scams, maintain long-term relationships as trusted advisors, and focus on protecting homeowners rather than simply asking for referrals or new business. 00:01 Disclaimer and Intro03:00 MV Realty’s “Home Benefit Agreement”07:10 The 40-Year Contract and Property Liens11:30 Nationwide Reach and Consumer Impact15:30 Lawsuits, Bankruptcy, and State Actions20:00 Court Rulings and Settlements24:10 Lessons for Homeowners and Agents28:30 Red Flags and Final Takeaways Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 8: Fraudulent Instinct - The $20mil Real Estate Scam That Happened BEFORE "Maternal Instinct"
· 18 min
The episode examines the case of Taylor Parker through the lens of real estate fraud rather than focusing solely on the widely publicized murder. Before killing 21-year-old Reagan Simmons Hancock and abducting her unborn child, Parker spent more than a year posing as an heiress with a completely fabricated $8 million inheritance while building an elaborate web of fake identities, invented attorneys, forged financial documents, and nonexistent funding sources. She pursued more than $20 million in real estate purchases, centering on a multi-million-dollar ranch in Northeast Texas, while convincing her fiancé, Wade Griffin, that enormous wealth was just around the corner. When the promised inheritance never materialized, the collapsing land deal became the catalyst for an even larger deception: a made-up pregnancy that ultimately ended in murder. The transcript explores how Parker manipulated real estate professionals for months by constantly changing the story behind her financing. Each failed explanation (inheritance, oil and gas royalties, wealthy relatives, or pending wire transfers) was replaced with another faux authority figure or forged document to keep transactions alive. Experienced professionals eventually uncovered inconsistencies after verifying leases, questioning proof of funds, and independently checking the people involved in the deal. Sandi Lyn argues this illustrates a common fraud pattern: urgency, charisma, and the promise of a lucrative commission can cause professionals to delay basic verification steps that would otherwise expose a buyer's inability to perform. The show concludes by connecting Parker's financial fraud directly to the motive for the murder. As her phantom fortune unraveled, the fake pregnancy became the next lie needed to preserve her relationship, eventually culminating in the murder of Reagan Simmons Hancock and her infant. The episode also covers Parker's escalating attempts to obstruct justice after her arrest, including an elaborate scheme to frame another inmate, before reviewing her conviction, death sentence, and unsuccessful appeals. Sandi Lyn closes by emphasizing practical lessons for real estate professionals: always verify proof of funds, independently confirm third-party participants in a transaction, and scrutinize the most attractive deals even more carefully, because sophisticated fraud often looks like the perfect client until it collapses. 00:00 Introduction and the Failed Land Deal02:30 Taylor Parker's Fake Fortune05:10 The $20 Million Real Estate Con08:15 How the Fraud Unraveled11:45 Lessons for Real Estate Agents15:20 The Murder Plot and Misdirection18:30 Jailhouse Schemes and Appeals21:20 Final Lessons and Closing Remarks Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 7: Building a Case - The Bricks & Minifigs LEGO Controversy and Reckless Ben's Battle for Justice
· 40 min
An 83-year-old Oregon collector consigned one of the world's largest private Star Wars LEGO collection (worth more than $200,000) to a Bricks & Minifigs franchise, with a contract stating the family retained ownership until each set sold. After corporate repossessed the franchise in 2024, approximately $100,000–$125,000 worth of inventory allegedly remained in the store, but the family was unable to recover it despite providing contracts and inventory records. Police repeatedly classified the dispute as a civil matter, while the family says corporate responded by encouraging them to sue, prompting Brian Mansell to seek help from YouTuber Benjamin "Reckless Ben" Schneider after traditional avenues failed. Ben launched a series of increasingly creative publicity stunts to pressure the company into returning the property, including raffles, mock businesses, coordinated small claims lawsuits, and viral demonstrations that transformed a local consignment dispute into a national story. His campaign eventually led to default judgments after store representatives failed to appear in court. As the battle shifted to Utah, where the new store owners lived, Ben documented repeated police encounters while attempting to serve legal papers. The situation escalated into traffic stops, searches, raids, arrests for stalking and trespassing, and conflicting claims between Ben and the American Fork Police Department regarding the legality and necessity of those actions. The controversy exploded after Ben's documentary surpassed three million views, prompting corporate statements, a court order seeking removal of his videos, and public support from Patreon CEO Jack Conte, who declined to remove Ben's page. Bricks & Minifigs later announced the Salem store's closure and said it had contacted the Mansell family about resolving the matter, while lawsuits and criminal cases remain ongoing. Sandi Lyn concludes that the story is fundamentally about property rights, emphasizing that possession does not equal ownership and that businesses inheriting assets also inherit the legal obligation to safeguard property held on behalf of others. The episode frames the case as a cautionary lesson for real estate professionals and anyone entrusted with another person's property or finances. 00:00 Introduction and the Consignment Contract 04:15 The Collection Changes Hands 08:45 Police Call It a Civil Matter 13:10 Reckless Ben Takes the Case 18:00 Public Stunts and Legal Strategy 24:30 Default Judgments and Viral Attention 29:45 Utah, Police, and Criminal Charges 36:15 Corporate Response and Internet Backlash 40:30 Real Estate Lessons and Final Takeaways Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 6: When Cops Fail, Rangers Lead the Way. The 1989 Ash Street Shootout #TrueCrime
· 26 min
Bill Foulk, an Army Ranger stationed near Tacoma, Washington, purchased a condemned home in the Hilltop neighborhood in 1987 for $10,000, believing the area was poised for revitalization. Instead, the crack epidemic and expanding gang activity transformed the neighborhood into one of the state's most dangerous areas. After repeated calls to police brought little response, Foulk and his neighbors began documenting drug activity themselves. When it escalated to threats against him personally, Foulk invited fellow Rangers to a neighborhood barbecue, and suggested *maybe* they should come armed. On September 23, 1989, tensions erupted into the infamous Ash Street Shootout. Following hours of anticipation, gunfire broke out between roughly a dozen Army Rangers defending Foulk's home and around 20 suspected gang members. Between 100 and 300 rounds were fired during the exchange, yet remarkably there were no fatalities or even injuries officially documented. Investigations never definitively established who fired first, and both sides maintained conflicting accounts. Police initially detained the Rangers but ultimately filed no charges against them, while two gang members with outstanding warrants were arrested, and only one was convicted on unrelated assault charges. The confrontation drew national media attention and exposed Tacoma's inability to control escalating gang violence. The episode concludes by examining the lasting real estate impact of the shootout. Public outrage forced Tacoma to invest in community policing, establish dedicated anti-drug units, and support neighborhood organizations that helped transform Hilltop over the following decades. Foulk's $10,000 investment ultimately became a home worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, but only after years of violence and decades of reform. Sandi Lyn uses the story to highlight an important lesson for real estate professionals: while agents cannot steer buyers, they can encourage meaningful due diligence about neighborhoods, crime history, and local conditions so clients understand the full risks behind a property's purchase price. 00:00 The Bullet Hole on Ash Street 02:10 Bill Foulk Buys Into 1987 Hilltop 05:20 Crime Escalates and Neighbors Fight Back 08:05 Preparing for the Confrontation 11:15 The Ash Street Shootout 16:10 Police Response and Investigation 19:30 Legal Aftermath and Military Consequences 21:45 Tacoma's Reforms and Hilltop's Recovery 24:00 Real Estate Lessons and Final Takeaways Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 5: Inspiration for "Candyman" - The Violent History of Cabrini-Green
· 44 min
Sandi Lyn starts this episode with a deeply personal childhood story recalling growing up near violent housing towers in Rockford, Illinois, with the larger-scale history of Chicago’s Cabrini-Green projects as a backdrop. She uses her experience witnessing normalized street-level violence, drug activity, and gang presence as a framework to introduce Cabrini-Green as an amplified version of the same systemic conditions. The episode immediately establishes its central thesis: Cabrini-Green was not an isolated anomaly, but an extreme expression of long-running urban policy failures, concentrated poverty, and housing segregation. The narrative then traces Cabrini-Green’s full historical arc, beginning with its origins as a succession of immigrant neighborhoods (German, Irish, Swedish, and Sicilian communities) that eventually became “Little Sicily,” an area defined by extreme poverty, overcrowding, and organized crime. It explains how the Chicago Housing Authority later built the Cabrini-Green housing complex on this land, which gradually transitioned from white ethnic residents to predominantly Black residents due to housing patterns and segregation policies. The episode highlights escalating violence over decades, including the 1970 ambush killing of two police officers in Cabrini-Green, the 1992 murder of seven-year-old Dantrell Davis, the brutal sexual assault of a 9-year-old girl named “Girl X” to protect her identity, and other high-profile crimes that turned the complex into a national symbol of urban decay and danger. The final portion focuses on the collapse and redevelopment of Cabrini-Green through Chicago’s $1 billion “Plan for Transformation,” which led to the demolition of the high-rises and displacement of thousands of families, with very few returning despite promises of “right of return.” It also connects Cabrini-Green’s legacy to pop culture (notably Candyman) and modern real estate redevelopment, arguing that the land itself, now transformed into high-value property, represents one of the largest wealth transfers in Chicago history. The episode closes by broadening the lens, suggesting that Cabrini-Green’s story is not unique but part of a recurring national pattern where disinvestment, violence, displacement, and redevelopment cycle through urban neighborhoods. 00:00 Warning & Childhood in a Violent City 03:00 Rockford’s Rising Homicide Crisis 06:30 Cabrini-Green as the “Scaled-Up Version” 10:00 Origins: Immigrant Poverty to “Little Sicily” 15:30 “Death Corner” & Early Organized Crime 20:00 Creation of Cabrini-Green Housing Projects 25:00 1970 Police Ambush 28:30 Mayor Jane Byrne’s 1981 Publicity Stunt 31:30 Ruthie Mae McCoy & Candyman Mythology 35:00 Dantrell Davis & Police Misconduct Allegations 38:00 Collapse, Demolition & Displacement 41:00 Redevelopment, Wealth Transfer & Modern Cabrini Site 44:00 Final Reflections: A National Pattern Want to send us a juicy true crime story to cover? Follow and DM us: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@TrueCrimeinRealEstate
Not rated yetEp 4: The Davenport Building Collapse: Unanswered Questions
· 33 min
The episode opens describing the moments leading up to the collapse of the historic Davenport Hotel apartment building at 324 Main St. on Memorial Day weekend in 2023. Residents were living normal lives when the building’s west wall suddenly failed, causing six stories to crumble. Three tenants were killed. Another resident survived after rescuers amputated her leg with her trapped under rubble. The tragedy immediately raised questions about ignored maintenance issues, failed inspections, and warnings that the building was structurally unsafe long before the collapse. Sandi Lyn traces the building’s history, where public records and investigative reports reveal repeated structural concerns dating back to 2020, including denied inspections, incomplete repair plans, water damage, and warnings that the building was unsafe. A masonry contractor claimed Wold rejected a $50,000 repair proposal, instead choosing much cheaper piecemeal repairs that weakened the structure further. After the collapse, investigators concluded the disaster resulted from an inadequately supported wall, combined with long-term structural deterioration. Despite those findings and the deaths, no criminal charges were filed related to the collapse, aside from a minor fine for maintenance neglect. The focus shifts to actions after the collapse, both financially and legally. According to allegations by victims’ families and survivors, Wold began selling off properties to shield assets from litigation. Sandi Lyn details approximately $4.8 million in property sales, including Wold’s riverfront mansion sold for $2.35 million to local real estate agent Kyle Robinson. Robinson listed several of Wold’s commercial properties, and plaintiffs later added both Robinson and QC Rental Group as defendants in the civil litigation, alleging questionable property-transfer arrangements. The host repeatedly states these are allegations of active lawsuits and not proven facts, but the events raise serious ethical and financial questions in the real estate industry. Last, we connect a 2026 drug arrest. Police execute a search warrant at the Bettendorf mansion Robinson purchased from Wold, and allegedly recovered large quantities of drugs and paraphernalia. Robinson was charged with multiple felony drug-distribution offenses, though he remains presumed innocent pending trial. The host criticizes what she describes as parts of the real estate industry culture that prioritizes production and profit over ethics and accountability. The episode closes by returning focus to the victims: the three men who died, Peach Berry who lost her leg, and the displaced tenants. 00:00 Collapse of 324 Main St 03:50 Davenport Building History 05:40 Structural Warnings, Failed Repairs 08:45 The Wall Comes Down 11:20 The Investigations Findings 13:05 No Criminal Charges 14:15 Civil Lawsuits and Asset Transfers 17:10 Bettendorf Mansion Sale 19:10 Kyle Robinson Added to Lawsuit 21:20 Andrew Wold Name Change 22:40 Drug Raid at the Mansion 25:15 Real Estate Ethical Concerns 28:00 Questions, and Closing Thoughts Listeners with corrections, additional documentation, or relevant information are invited to contact the show at solutions@myrealestateco.com. Instagram https://www.instagram.com/truecrimeinrealestate/ (https://www.instagram.com/myrealestateshow/) Sources: https://myrealestateco.notion.site/The-Davenport-Building-Sources-Public-Ref-36a02dfb79718066a258c9bb93aaa340
Not rated yetEp 3: Alex Murdaugh Conviction Overturned, Brennan v Brian
· 57 min
The murders of Maggie and Paul Murdaugh became one of the most infamous criminal cases in South Carolina history because of the Murdaugh family’s decades-long influence over the Lowcountry legal system. For nearly a century, the family held enormous legal and political power in South Carolina through the 14th Judicial Circuit and their law firm, PMPED, while building wealth through lawsuits, land holdings, hunting properties, and real estate investments across the region. On June 7, 2021, Maggie Murdaugh and her 22-year-old son Paul were found shot to death near the dog kennels on the family’s 1,772-acre estate in Colleton County. Paul was killed with a shotgun, while Maggie was shot with multiple rounds from a rifle. Alex Murdaugh, husband and father of the victims, called 911 to report finding the bodies. Prosecutors argued Alex Murdaugh killed his wife and son to distract from mounting financial crimes and public pressure tied to lawsuits from the 2019 boat crash that killed 19-year-old Mallory Beach. Prosecutors said Murdaugh had stolen roughly $12 million from clients and pointed to cellphone evidence placing him near the kennels shortly before the murders, contradicting earlier statements to investigators. The state also emphasized his changing timeline, missing clothing, vehicle data, and lies to police. The defense argued the case was entirely circumstantial: the murder weapons were never recovered, no DNA directly tied Alex to the killings, and investigators mishandled the crime scene. Defense attorneys also pointed to unknown DNA under Maggie’s fingernails, possible alternate suspects connected to threats against Paul, and the use of two separate firearms. Alex Murdaugh was convicted of murder in March 2023 and sentenced to two life terms without parole, but the verdict was later overturned because of misconduct allegations involving County Clerk Becky Hill. Defense attorneys accused Hill of improperly influencing jurors while promoting a book about the case. Jurors testified Hill encouraged them to closely watch Murdaugh’s body language. Hill eventually pleaded guilty to obstruction of justice, perjury, misuse of office, and sharing sealed evidence with a journalist. In May 2026, the South Carolina Supreme Court vacated Murdaugh’s murder convictions in a 5-0 ruling, finding Hill’s actions denied him a fair trial and that extensive testimony about his financial crimes may have unfairly prejudiced jurors. Murdaugh remains in prison on separate financial crime convictions while prosecutors prepare for a retrial. 00:00 Introduction and Overview of the Case 01:15 The Moselle Estate and the Murdaugh Family’s Power in South Carolina 03:05 The 2019 Boat Crash and Mallory Beach’s Death 04:40 Alex Murdaugh’s Extensive Financial Crimes 06:05 The Murders of Maggie and Paul Murdaugh 07:05 Investigation, Trial, and 2023 Murder Conviction 08:15 Becky Hill Allegations and Claims of Jury Influence 10:15 Becky Hill’s Guilty Plea and Court Findings 12:05 South Carolina Supreme Court Overturns the Verdict 14:10 Real Estate Fallout and Sale of the Moselle Property 18:21 Brian’s Argument for Reasonable Doubt 39:23 Brennan’s Argument Supporting a Guilty Verdict 55:06 Discussion of the Investigation and Retrial 56:17 Closing Summary and Current Status of Alex Murdaugh Have a topic you want us to discuss, or want to be a guest on our show? Follow and DM us: Instagram @myrealestateshow on Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/myrealestateshow/?utm_source=chatgpt.com) LinkedIn My Real Estate Show on LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/company/myrealestateshow/?utm_source=chatgpt.com)
Not rated yetEp 1: Booked, Paid, Nowhere to Stay (STR Scams)
· 24 min
True Crime in Real Estate™ is reported journalism. Every name, charge, and figure is sourced from federal court filings, public records, law enforcement statements, and verified reporting. Pending cases are treated as allegations and the accused are presumed innocent until proven guilty. Nothing here is legal advice. Sources: Defendants: Shray Goel, 35 time of indictment, listed addresses Miami, Calabasas, & Milwaukee. Initially charged December 13, 2023, on a separate indictment. Shaunik Raheja, 34 at time of indictment, listed address in Denver. Added in the first superseding indictment, January 3, 2024. Business entities used in the scheme: Abbot Pacific LLC and multiple other host names and LLCs. Charges in the superseding indictment: Conspiracy to commit wire fraud, 13 counts of wire fraud. Goel additionally charged with two counts of aggravated identity theft. Wire fraud and conspiracy each carry a statutory maximum of 20 years federal. Pleas: Goel pleaded guilty to wire fraud. Raheja pleaded guilty to obstruction of justice and admitted lying to federal agents during the 2023 investigation. Sentencing scheduled for late summer 2026. Scheme dates: October 2017 through November 2019. Banned from Vrbo in 2015 prior to that for repeated cancellations and guest complaints, continued under fake host names. Scale: Nearly 100 properties across 10 states. Approximately 10,000 reservations. Approximately $8.5 million in revenue, with about $7 million from Airbnb and about $1.5 million from Vrbo. Plea agreement stipulates a $1.5 million loss figure tied to the wire fraud count. Jurisdiction: United States District Court, Central District of California, Los Angeles. Prosecuting office: United States Attorney's Office, Central District of California. Investigating agencies: FBI Los Angeles Field Office. Assisting: FDIC Office of Inspector General and Federal Housing Finance Agency Office of Inspector General. Defense counsel of record at indictment: Michael G. Freedman, representing Shray Goel. Keri Curtis Axel, representing Shaunik Raheja. Reporting: NBC News, (https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/pair-indicted-alleged-airbnb-vrbo-rental-property-scam-netted-85-milli-rcna132367) Pair indicted in alleged Airbnb, Vrbo rental property scam that netted $8.5 million, January 4, 2024. CBS News, (https://www.cbsnews.com/news/airbnb-vrbo-scam-linked-to-10000-reservations-across-10-states-shray-goel-shaunik-raheja/) 2 indicted in $8.5 million Airbnb, Vrbo scam linked to 10,000 reservations across 10 states. NBC 6 (https://www.nbcmiami.com/news/local/miami-man-indicted-in-8-5m-short-term-rental-scam-with-thousands-of-victims-prosecutors/3197717/) South Florida, Miami man indicted in $8.5M short-term rental scam with thousands of victims. The Real Deal, (https://therealdeal.com/national/2024/01/07/two-indicted-in-8-5-million-nationwide-airbnb-vrbo-scam/) Two Indicted in $8.5 Million Nationwide Airbnb, Vrbo Scam, January 7, 2024. Federal Housing Finance Agency (https://www.fhfaoig.gov/sites/default/files/Two-Indicted-in-$8.5-Million-Nationwide-Airbnb-Vrbo-Scam.pdf) Office of Inspector General First Superseding Indictment, (https://www.scribd.com/document/696673099/Airbnb-Scam-Goel-Raheja-SS-INDICTMENT) United States v. Goel and Raheja, Central District of California. Direct verification: United States Attorney's Office, Central
Not rated yet