Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Don't Buy Sony's New 400mm f/4.5 for Birds. Here's Why

From Tony & Chelsea Northrup · · 15 min

The player loads from YouTube only when you click. It uses YouTube's privacy-enhanced mode.

If the video does not play, the owner may have turned off embedding. Watch it on YouTube instead.

Watch on YouTube

Not rated yet

Description

Buy the Sony 400mm f/4.5: http://SDP.io/S400f45 Buy the Sony 600mm f/6.3: http://SDP.io/S600f63

Sony's new 600mm f/6.3 and 400mm f/4.5 GM primes weigh less than a bag of sugar — but should you buy them instead of the 200-600mm zoom?

I'm Tony Northrup, and I put Sony's two brand-new ultralight super-telephoto primes through real-world wildlife, birding, and portrait testing in New York City. Both weigh under 1kg (995g and 994g), both are G Master glass, and both cost significantly more than the 200-600mm zoom that covers the exact same focal lengths at the exact same apertures. So is the weight savings worth $1,600+ of your money? I tested it.

What I cover in this video:

600mm f/6.3 prime vs. the Sony 200-600mm zoom at 600mm — the sharpness gap is not subtle 400mm f/4.5 prime vs. the 200-600mm at 400mm — a much closer fight than you'd expect, plus the 1.5-stop light advantage Why the zoom still wins for beginners and for those once-in-a-lifetime close encounters 600mm f/6.3 vs. the $14,000 600mm f/4 — bokeh, light gathering, and why serious shooters still carry the big one Real proof of what light gathering buys you: my moon shot where you can read the tail numbers on a United jet Teleconverter testing — Sony 1.4x and the Viltrox 2x on both primes. Does a TC actually beat cropping? (The 2x results on a 60MP sensor genuinely surprised me.) 400mm f/4.5 for portraits — shooting a model walking NYC streets at 400mm for absurd bokeh balls My verdict on which lens deserves your money — and why the 400mm is a pass for me

Plus a birding tip I just figured out: put your AirPods in. In transparency mode with a hearing test loaded on your iPhone, you'll pick out bird calls and directionality faster than with your naked ears. Sounds counterintuitive. It works.

Bottom line: if you already know you shoot at 600mm, the 600mm f/6.3 is an incredible compromise of size, weight, and image quality. If you've never used a big telephoto, start with the 200-600mm zoom. And the number one thing that improves your wildlife photography isn't sharpness or bokeh — it's the number of hours you have a camera in your hands. These lenses get you out there.

[00:00] Introduction: Testing the new Sony 400mm f/4.5 & 600mm f/6.3 primes vs. the 200-600mm zoom.

[01:16] Wildlife Photography Tip: Using AirPods in transparency mode to hear and track birds.

[02:04] Zoom vs. Prime: Why the 200-600mm zoom is better for finding subjects and beginner wildlife photographers.

[02:52] Sharpness Test: 600mm f/6.3 Prime vs. 200-600mm Zoom (at 600mm).

[03:16] Sharpness Test: 400mm f/4.5 Prime vs. 200-600mm Zoom (at 400mm).

[05:16] New 600mm f/6.3 vs. $14,000 600mm f/4: Weighing the differences in price, weight, bokeh, and low-light gathering capability.

[07:44] Astrophotography & Landscapes: Using super telephoto lenses for moon alignment and landscape photography.

[08:39] Teleconverter Testing (400mm): How the 400mm prime handles 1.4x and 2x teleconverters.

[09:37] Teleconverter Testing (600mm): Using 1.4x and 2x teleconverters on the 600mm f/6.3.

[10:40] 400mm vs. 600mm: Which focal length should you actually buy?

[11:44] Cropping Test: Comparing cropped images from the 400mm and 600mm on distant subjects.

[12:19] 400mm + 1.4x TC vs. 600mm Prime: Which setup gives you better detail at 600mm?

[12:49] Portraits: A fun field test using the 400mm for street portraits in New York City.

[13:30] Final Conclusions: Overall thoughts, value, and recommendations.

Back to Tony & Chelsea Northrup · Report a problem