Don't Buy Sony's New 400mm f/4.5 for Birds. Here's Why
From Tony & Chelsea Northrup · · 15 min

The player loads from YouTube only when you click. It uses YouTube's privacy-enhanced mode.
If the video does not play, the owner may have turned off embedding. Watch it on YouTube instead.
Description
Buy the Sony 400mm f/4.5: http://SDP.io/S400f45 Buy the Sony 600mm f/6.3: http://SDP.io/S600f63
Sony's new 600mm f/6.3 and 400mm f/4.5 GM primes weigh less than a bag of sugar — but should you buy them instead of the 200-600mm zoom?
I'm Tony Northrup, and I put Sony's two brand-new ultralight super-telephoto primes through real-world wildlife, birding, and portrait testing in New York City. Both weigh under 1kg (995g and 994g), both are G Master glass, and both cost significantly more than the 200-600mm zoom that covers the exact same focal lengths at the exact same apertures. So is the weight savings worth $1,600+ of your money? I tested it.
What I cover in this video:
600mm f/6.3 prime vs. the Sony 200-600mm zoom at 600mm — the sharpness gap is not subtle 400mm f/4.5 prime vs. the 200-600mm at 400mm — a much closer fight than you'd expect, plus the 1.5-stop light advantage Why the zoom still wins for beginners and for those once-in-a-lifetime close encounters 600mm f/6.3 vs. the $14,000 600mm f/4 — bokeh, light gathering, and why serious shooters still carry the big one Real proof of what light gathering buys you: my moon shot where you can read the tail numbers on a United jet Teleconverter testing — Sony 1.4x and the Viltrox 2x on both primes. Does a TC actually beat cropping? (The 2x results on a 60MP sensor genuinely surprised me.) 400mm f/4.5 for portraits — shooting a model walking NYC streets at 400mm for absurd bokeh balls My verdict on which lens deserves your money — and why the 400mm is a pass for me
Plus a birding tip I just figured out: put your AirPods in. In transparency mode with a hearing test loaded on your iPhone, you'll pick out bird calls and directionality faster than with your naked ears. Sounds counterintuitive. It works.
Bottom line: if you already know you shoot at 600mm, the 600mm f/6.3 is an incredible compromise of size, weight, and image quality. If you've never used a big telephoto, start with the 200-600mm zoom. And the number one thing that improves your wildlife photography isn't sharpness or bokeh — it's the number of hours you have a camera in your hands. These lenses get you out there.
[00:00] Introduction: Testing the new Sony 400mm f/4.5 & 600mm f/6.3 primes vs. the 200-600mm zoom.
[01:16] Wildlife Photography Tip: Using AirPods in transparency mode to hear and track birds.
[02:04] Zoom vs. Prime: Why the 200-600mm zoom is better for finding subjects and beginner wildlife photographers.
[02:52] Sharpness Test: 600mm f/6.3 Prime vs. 200-600mm Zoom (at 600mm).
[03:16] Sharpness Test: 400mm f/4.5 Prime vs. 200-600mm Zoom (at 400mm).
[05:16] New 600mm f/6.3 vs. $14,000 600mm f/4: Weighing the differences in price, weight, bokeh, and low-light gathering capability.
[07:44] Astrophotography & Landscapes: Using super telephoto lenses for moon alignment and landscape photography.
[08:39] Teleconverter Testing (400mm): How the 400mm prime handles 1.4x and 2x teleconverters.
[09:37] Teleconverter Testing (600mm): Using 1.4x and 2x teleconverters on the 600mm f/6.3.
[10:40] 400mm vs. 600mm: Which focal length should you actually buy?
[11:44] Cropping Test: Comparing cropped images from the 400mm and 600mm on distant subjects.
[12:19] 400mm + 1.4x TC vs. 600mm Prime: Which setup gives you better detail at 600mm?
[12:49] Portraits: A fun field test using the 400mm for street portraits in New York City.
[13:30] Final Conclusions: Overall thoughts, value, and recommendations.