Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The Forgotten Files: The Bloody Benders: America's First Serial Killer Family

From Til TRUTH Do Us Part: A True Crime Podcast · · 39 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

On the lonely Osage Trail in southeastern Kansas, a family built a welcome stop for weary travelers. It was a death trap.

Between 1871 and 1873, the Bender family — John Sr., his wife Elvira, son John Jr., and daughter Kate — ran a small inn and general store near what is now Cherryvale, Kansas. To passersby, they seemed like ordinary frontier settlers. Behind a canvas curtain that divided their cabin, they were something else entirely.

Travelers who stopped for a meal were given the seat of honor with their back to the curtain. Then came the hammer to the skull, the slit throat, and a trapdoor into the cellar. Their bodies were buried in the orchard behind the house.

When Dr. William York disappeared in 1873, a search party arrived at the Bender property to find it abandoned. What they dug up would become legend — at least 11 bodies discovered, with estimates as high as 20. The family had vanished without a trace and were never caught.

In this episode of Forgotten Files, we open the case file on America's first family of serial killers. Who really were the Benders — they weren't even all related — and how did a self-proclaimed spiritualist medium like Kate Bender lure victims to their deaths? And what happened to them after they disappeared into the prairie?

This was frontier justice at its darkest.

Back to Til TRUTH Do Us Part: A True Crime Podcast · Report a problem