
The Starved Rock Murders with Andy Hale
Andy HaleAudio
- Format:
- Podcast
- New episodes:
- Irregular
- Typical length:
- about 50 minutes
- Latest episode:
About this show
In the winter of 1960 three women were found brutally murdered in a cave at the Starved Rock State Park. After months of dead ends, a manhunt ensued that ultimately pinned the crime on a 21-year-old dishwasher at the Starved Rock State Park Lodge, Chester Weger. In spite of contradictory physical evidence and under immense pressure from the police, Chester confessed to the crime. He has spent the last 60 years in prison, maintaining his innocence to this day. Join Andy Hale, a civil rights attorney who specializes in investigating wrongful convictions, as he dives deep into parts of the case that have been left out of previous coverage. As Chester Weger’s attorney, he is actively investigating the case and has won the right to test DNA from the crime scene for the first time in 60 years. If Chester is innocent, this will become the longest wrongful conviction case in United States history. This limited series podcast will re-examine the story you think you know, provide real-time case updates, including DNA testing, and access to documents and photos previously unreleased to the public, to uncover the truth of what really happened in Starved Rock State Park over half a century ago.
Covers: true crime, criminal justice, wrongful convictions, starved rock murders, false confessions, dna evidence testing, genetic genealogy, chicago outfit
Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at anchor.fm. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.
Recently on this show
Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.
This podcast re-examines the 1960 killings of three women at Starved Rock State Park and the conviction of Chester Weger, who maintains innocence; host Andy Hale is his lawyer. Recent episodes cover a clemency hearing, genetic genealogy and the Chicago Mafia.
Cosmos
Similar in subject
- Wrongful Conviction Podcasts
Both cover: false confessions, wrongful convictions, criminal justice - Motive: Mr Lyttle Meets Mr Big
Both cover: false confessions, wrongful convictions, criminal justice - Cold Trail
Both cover: genetic genealogy, true crime
Similar shows
Explore more
Episodes
Blood Lines and Bloodlines: Sally and Johanne Discuss Genetic Genealogy and the Chicago Mafia
· 37 min
Sally Cohen and Johanne Karizamimba take over the mic for two deep dives. Johanne explains how investigative genetic genealogy turns a decades-old hair into a family tree, and what that means for solving cold cases and exonerating the innocent. Sally explores the reach of the Chicago Outfit in the late ’50s and early ’60s, and asks whether the murder-for-hire theory is really as far-fetched as the State claims.
Not rated yetFull Circle Part 2: How the 1960s Set the Stage for a Wrongful Conviction
· 33 min
Part 2 continues with guest Whitny Braun tackling how an innocent man could be convicted of a triple homicide in 1960. From the science of false confessions and Brady v. Maryland to questionable police procedures, cover-ups and corruption, Andy and Whitny examine the troubling evidence, unanswered questions, and facts known today surrounding Chester Weger’s case. This could and should be the longest wrongful conviction in U.S. history.
Not rated yetAndy & Whitny Bring It Full Circle: The Evidence, Theories & Fight for Chester Weger
· 41 min
Andy's original co-host Whitny Braun returns to bring the Starved Rock Murders Podcast full circle. From Whitny’s work helping bring the story to HBO to Andy’s 10 year journey as Chester’s lawyer, they revisit their personal journey, the evidence they uncovered, expert theories, the legal battles, and where the case stands today. Don’t miss this powerful conversation about uncovering the truth.
Not rated yetHere's What Happened: Inside the Chester Weger Clemency Hearing
· 48 min
Andy, Sally Cohen, and Johanne Karizamimba recap the October 6, 2026, hearing on Chester Weger’s petition for posthumous clemency. From emotional testimony and family statements to closing arguments, rebuttals, and the LaSalle County State's Attorney's Office's persistence in clinging to the confession despite all of the new evidence. Get an inside look at the ongoing fight for Chester.
Not rated yetDigging Deeper From Supporters Perspectives | Part 2
· 59 min
In Part 2 of Andy’s conversation with investigation enthusiasts and Chester Weger supporters Steve Mueller and Deanan Herkert, discover how dedicated followers can contribute to the ongoing pursuit of justice. They examine the known and lesser-known evidence surrounding the Starved Rock Murders and discuss the questions that continue to surround the case. Join the discussion and weigh the evidence for yourself. What stands out to you, and what do you make of a cover-up?
Not rated yetSupporters Perspectives| DiscussingThe Starved Rock Murders| Part One
· 1 hr 1 min
Have you been following the Starved Rock Murders case? Piecing together the evidence, researching reports and asking how Chester Weger could have been convicted? You’re not alone. Andy is joined by Steve Mueller and Deanan Herkert, two longtime investigative enthusiasts who have followed this case for years, from visiting Starved Rock lodge to following Andy’s ongoing legal fight for justice. Join Part One of this conversation with fellow supporters, listeners and curious minds who refuse to stop asking questions.
Not rated yetEvidence Uncovered: The Legal Team Breaks Down the Case
· 58 min
Join Andy and his team, Sally Cohen and Johanne Karizamimba, for an in-depth discussion of their posthumous clemency developments. They break down uncovered witness testimony, examine key details in both new and previously known evidence, and provide insight into their legal strategy. Hear their analysis, the unanswered questions, and what these developments could mean for the verdict. You can join this ongoing pursuit of justice by signing and sharing our Change.org petition. https://www.change.org/p/justice-too-long-denied-sign-for-chester-weger (https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__www.change.org_p_justice-2Dtoo-2Dlong-2Ddenied-2Dsign-2Dfor-2Dchester-2Dweger&d=DwMFaQ&c=euGZstcaTDllvimEN8b7jXrwqOf-v5A_CdpgnVfiiMM&r=NIbeje1u6H9g7JjevOvC_PhZ6kmht94eKuux1IuO3Sk&m=4S3i9sCg4t80Q-lX6tZTFNmdDyY1xk6vPJAu_PwAaC3nMpdWwcT3OjFzes5pY-OG&s=UGLX7HHiz9LUswjv0uspbrcv2oHixuaHqq6PLgzfiIs&e=)
Not rated yetSeason 2. Ep. 1: A Legal Update: The Posthumous Petition for Clemency
· 28 min
Season 2 takes deeper looks into the untold stories in and around the case and Andy's final legal push to secure justice for Chester Weger. In this episode, Andy and Sally discuss the latest legal development, the filing of a posthumous petition for clemency, and what his all means for the quest to prove Chester's innocence.
Not rated yetThe Winders Family Murders - what really happened?
· 29 min
Andy and Sally examine the deaths of William Winders, his wife Patricia, and their three young children, who were all found dead in their Seneca home from gunshots. The murders took place just a week after the Starved Rock Murders and were officially ruled a homicide/suicide conducted by Patricia. But was it?
Not rated yetThe Continuing Coverup: A Discussion with Author Jim Ridings
· 34 min
In this episode Andy sits down with Jim Ridings, author of the new book "Murder at Starved Rock: How the System Framed an Innocent Man," and two discuss how there was a coverup of the true facts in 1960 and how the coverup has continued to the present.
Not rated yetManufacturing A Case Against Chester Weger: The Bogus Scratches Evidence
· 51 min
In this episode, Andy Hale and Sally Cohen reveal and discuss new evidence that demonstrates the State's "scratches" evidence at trial was not credible. They also discuss the Court's application of the wrong legal standard in assessing the "scratches" evidence.
Not rated yetThe Continuing Colossal Coverup
· 1 hr 18 min
Andy and Sally take a deep dive into the Lois Zelensek telephone operator interview and how there was a coverup of the people involved in that telephone call, and how the focus then turned to Chester Weger. They also discuss how the coverup continues to this day.
Not rated yetAn analysis of false confessions: Andy Hale & Sally Cohen discuss the expert report of Dr. Brian Cutler
· 1 hr 9 min
In this episode, attorneys Andy Hale and Sally Cohen delve into the concept of false confessions by discussing and explaining the expert report of Dr. Brian Cutler, who was retained as an expert witness in Chester Weger's case.
Not rated yetA Legal Autopsy, Part 2: Andy Hale & Sally Cohen continue to discuss the recent evidentiary hearing and devastating court ruling
· 54 min
In this episode, attorneys Andy Hale and Sally Cohen focus on some of the key evidence presented at the evidentiary hearing showing Chester Weger's innocence. They also discuss the manner in which the Will County State's Attorney's Office argued the case, and some of the key constitutional violations that occurred.
Not rated yetA Legal Autopsy: Andy Hale & Sally Cohen discuss all the stunning ways the Court got it wrong.
· 1 hr 35 min
In this episode, attorneys Andy Hale and Sally Cohen dissect the stunning court ruling denying Chester Weger's post-conviction petition and walk through several of the court's substantial factual and legal errors. They also discuss the ridiculous manner in which the powerful DNA evidence was disregarded.
Not rated yetAndy & Whitny's Post-Mortem Analysis
· 1 hr 10 min
In this episode, Andy welcomes back his co-host Whitny Braun and the two of them conduct a post-mortem analysis of the case, the bombshell Lois Zelensek memo, and the court's puzzling court ruling denying Chester Weger's post-conviction petition. The journey for justice continues!
Not rated yetHonoring Chester Weger's Memory + The Puzzling Court Ruling
· 47 min
In this episode, Andy honors the memory of Chester Weger and his decades-long battle to prove is innocence. Andy also breaks down the puzzling and disappointing court ruling denying Chester's petition for post-conviction relief, despite the presence of powerful DNA evidence.
Not rated yetThe Evidentiary Hearing: An Update
· 19 min
In this episode, Andy summarizes the evidence presented at last week at the three-day evidentiary hearing and discusses what happens next in the case.
Not rated yetHonoring the Victims: A Step Back Before the Hearing
· 13 min
As the crucial May 2025 evidentiary hearing for Chester Weger approaches, Andy takes a moment to explore the other side of the Starved Rock Murders. In this episode, he honors the lives of the three victims—Mildred Lindquist, Frances Murphy, and Lillian Oetting—and revisits the role of Chester’s original attorney, John A. McNamara. It’s a thoughtful, emotional journey into a pivotal moment in history you won’t want to miss. Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or watch the full episode on YouTube.
Not rated yetOddities & Absurdities
· 36 min
In this episode, Andy discusses a variety of oddities and absurdities in the case including the lineup, the women's clothing, fingerprints, and a suspicious similarity between statements in Chester Weger's "confession" and a description in the Startling Detective Magazine September 1960 edition.
Not rated yet