Why You Should Never Hike the Bennington Triangle
From The Secret Society of Strangers · · 1 hr 13 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
In the dense woods of Glastenbury Mountain, Vermont, people don't just get lost — they vanish. No bodies. No answers. Just a mountain that's been taking people for as long as anyone can remember.
Some places you can only reach on purpose. The Bennington Triangle isn't one of them — you can see it from a college campus, a gas station, a kitchen window.
In Part One, Lee leads Josh and Jen up the Green Mountain to trace how one stretch of Vermont wilderness earned its name: Abenaki warnings about ground that owes you nothing, compasses that refuse to point north, a man-eating stone, the Bennington Monster, and the first documented disappearances that turned local legend into an unsolved mystery.
The hunter found dead with no wounds. The 74-year-old guide who knew the mountain blind and still walked into the dark and never came back. And the case that forced Vermont to build a state police force from scratch — 18-year-old Bennington College student Paula Jean Welden, who walked up the Long Trail one Sunday afternoon in December 1946 in a red parka and was never seen again.
Part One of two.
⚠️ Covers historical events including Vermont's eugenics program. Listener discretion advised.
🕯️ Ex Tenebris, Peregrini — Stay Curious. Stay Strange.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
⏱️ CHAPTERS
00:00 Cold Open — The Triangle You Can Walk To
01:58 Welcome to the Secret Society of Strangers
05:10 Glastenbury Mountain: 26,000 Acres of Nothing
06:21 The Abenaki and the Living Mountain
10:37 The Settlers, the Land, and a Vanishing Population
13:10 The Compass That Won't Point North
16:02 The Man-Eating Stone
18:20 The Dancing Lights
20:50 The Bennington Monster
23:15 Henry McDowell and the Voices
25:30 The Grand Hotel and the Electric Trolley
30:00 The Freshet
32:43 What Vermont Was Doing in the Same Years
34:35 John Harble, 1897
39:46 Carl Herrick, 1943
45:01 Middie Rivers, 1945
51:44 Paula Jean Welden, 1946
1:04:43 The Darkest Theory
1:09:13 End of Part One
1:09:34 Questions for the Strangers
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
🎧 LISTEN & SUBSCRIBE
Podbean: https://ssospod.podbean.com/e/why-you-should-never-hike-the-bennington-triangle/
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/2G0aAYQPPp1wqnqJYetOcZ
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-secret-society-of-strangers-podcast/id1865736210
🛒 WEAR THE SOCIETY — https://ssos-shop.fourthwall.com
Code SSOSPOD takes 5% off.
☕ SUPPORT THE SHOW — https://buymeacoffee.com/ssospod
Every cup helps.
📧 Got a high strangeness story? Somewhere the locals avoid? Somewhere the stories don't quite add up? ssospodcast@gmail.com
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
📌 CREDITS
A Strange Static Media Production.
Lee — Writer, Researcher, Editor, Producer
Josh & Jen — Co-Host, Assistant, Creative, Co-Producer
DISCLAIMER: This episode discusses historical disappearances, deaths, and documented state programs including eugenics. Content is presented for storytelling and educational purposes. Some accounts described are folklore and circulating local legend, not established fact, and are identified as such.
#BenningtonTriangle #Vermont #MissingPersons #TrueCrime #HighStrangeness #PaulaWelden