Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Phrogging, Part 2 — The Denver Spider Man (S2)

From The Secret Society of Strangers · · 42 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

In 1941, a quiet Denver neighborhood became convinced one house was haunted. Lights switched on in empty rooms. Footsteps echoed behind locked doors. A widow fled her own home; her housekeeper quit, certain the place was cursed. They were all closer to the truth than the police — because something WAS in that house. Not a ghost. A man. This week, Lee leads Josh and Jen through the case of Theodore Coneys, the “Denver Spider Man,” who murdered 73-year-old Philip Peters and then lived in the victim’s attic crawlspace for nine months — freezing, starving, three feet above the people hunting for a phantom. It’s the most famous case of “phrogging” in American history, and the realest ghost story Denver ever told.

Stay Curious. Stay Strange.

CTA + LINKS

🎧 Listen & Subscribe:

Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube: @SSOSPodcast | Podbean

☕ Support the Show:

Buy Me a Coffee | Patreon (The Curious / The Strange tiers) | TeePublic (merch)

📱 Follow Us:

Instagram: @secretsocietyofstrangerspod | TikTok: @ssospodcast | Discord (link in description)

📧 Got a High Strangeness Story?

Email: ssospodcast@gmail.com — or DM us on socials. We're listening.

CREDITS

A Strange Static Media Production.

Lee — Writer, Researcher, Editor, Producer

Josh & Jen — Co-Host, Assistant, Creative, Co-Producer

SOURCES

Primary / Archival

- Lowall, Gene. "1942: The Spider Man." In Denver Murders, edited by Lee Casey. Duell, Sloan and Pearce, 1946.

- Sifakis, Carl. The Encyclopedia of American Crime. Facts on File, 1982.

- Denver Public Library Special Collections and Archives — "The Tale of the Denver Spider Man" (2019).

- Trial records, Denver County Court, October 1942.

- Detective James E. Childers interview, Denver Post Empire, February 7, 1960.

Period News Coverage

- The Paducah Sun, July 4, 1954 — "Here's Spine Chilling Story of The Spider Murder and a Ghost."

- Contemporary Denver newspapers, 1941–1942 (Denver Post, Rocky Mountain News).

Modern Coverage / Secondary

- 9News Denver — "Stranger than fiction: the 'Denver Spiderman' and his Moncrieff Place murder" (2019).

- Law Week Colorado — "Denver's Spider Man, 'The Ghost House of Denver'" (June 2022).

- Morbidology — "Theodore Edward Coneys, The Denver Spiderman" (Emily G. Thompson).

- Colorado Public Radio / Colorado Postcards — "Denver Spider-Man" (September 2023).

- HistoricalCrimeDetective.com — "Mug Shot Monday! Theodore Coneys, the Spiderman of Denver, 1941."

- Revisit Denver — "Denver Legends: The Spider-Man" (July 2025).

- Find A Grave Memorial #43200386 — Theodore Edward Coneys.

- Wikipedia — Theodore Edward Coneys (cross-referenced against primary sources above).

Back to The Secret Society of Strangers · Report a problem