Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Are the Oriental Orthodox Monophysite? | An Orthodox Assessment

From The Nathan Jacobs Podcast · · 35 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Are the Oriental Orthodox and non-Chalcedonian churches actually Monophysite heretics?

While many assume the Oriental Orthodox heresy is a settled matter of church history, scholar and historian of ideas Dr. Nathan Jacobs offers a far more nuanced assessment. In this episode, Nathan unpacks the Christological controversies surrounding the Council of Chalcedon, exploring why the non-Chalcedonians rejected the council, how their theology remains strictly Cyrilline, and the subtle Nestorian concerns hidden within Pope Leo’s Tome.

Rather than a fundamental conflict over the nature of Christ, this discussion reveals how linguistic misunderstandings, Latin theological influences, and centuries of historical division created a rift that persists to this day.

======================================

Timestamps

00:00 Introduction

00:00:15 Last Chance for the East West Series Offer

00:01:48 Logos Cinema & Supporting Eastern Orthodox Media

00:02:42 Scholar vs. Official Church Stance

00:03:37 The Great Schism vs. The First Millennium Schism

00:04:32 Ecumenical Councils as Curators of Faith

00:06:45 Chalcedon and the Non-Chalcedonian Resistance

00:08:10 Are Non-Chalcedonians Monophysite?

00:09:00 Understanding the Centaur Metaphor (Mingled Natures)

00:10:46 Why Oriental Orthodox Christology Is Cyrilline

00:12:33 The Nestorian Controversy: Two Natures vs. Two Persons

00:15:07 Cyril of Alexandria on Human Nature

00:17:11 Theotokos: Why Mary's Title Matters

00:19:17 Is "One Nature" a Monophysite Term?

00:22:08 The Real Reason for Rejection: Pope Leo’s Tome

00:23:40 Augustine’s Influence on Personhood (Persona vs. Hypostasis)

00:26:30 Two-Person Exegesis in Western Theology

00:28:53 Why Non-Chalcedonians Were Suspicious of Leo's Tome

00:30:15 Did Chalcedon Compromise with Nestorianism?

00:32:45 Why Does the Schism Persist Today?

======================================

Do you like this content? Join Jacobs Premium to get exclusive access to essays, lecture series, monthly Q&A Zoom calls, and our

book club. Use code: LEWIS to get a discount: https://www.thenathanjacobspodcast.com/

Support the East West Series: http://theeastwestseries.com/

======================================

Relevant Links:

​Resurrection Makes No Sense without Deification: https://youtu.be/Pwgm-7d2O2k

The Essential Doctrine the West Lost: https://youtu.be/lO1rAzvK3lQ?si=i_XIBd5lpsoYhTCj

All links:

The Theological Letters (Substack): https://nathanajacobs.substack.com/ (https://www.google.com/search?q=https://nathanajacobs.substack.com/&utm_source=gemini)

Instagram: /thenathaniacobspodcast

X: https://x.com/Nathan.JacobsPod (https://www.google.com/search?q=https://x.com/Nathan.JacobsPod&utm_source=gemini)

Facebook: /nathanandrewjacobs

Academia: https://vanderbilt.academia.edu/NathanJacobs (https://www.google.com/search?q=https://vanderbilt.academia.edu/NathanJacobs&utm_source=gemini)

Listen and please review the podcast elsewhere:

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0hSskUt (https://www.google.com/search?q=https://open.spotify.com/show/0hSskUt&utm_source=gemini)

Apple Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast (https://www.google.com/search?q=https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast&utm_source=gemini)

Back to The Nathan Jacobs Podcast · Report a problem