
The Mess Hall
Menu MattersAudio
- Format:
- Podcast
- New episodes:
- Monthly
- Typical length:
- about 1 hour
- Latest episode:
About this show
The Mess Hall brings you messy conversations about the topics that matter to the food and beverage industry -- the thorny topics that don't have a simple solution and require nuanced discussion, ideas, and thought. Hosts Maeve Webster and Mike Kostyo of food industry consulting firm Menu Matters bring in expert guests -- chefs, anthropologists, beverage consultants, marketing experts -- to dive into one provocative topic each episode. Plus, Maeve and Mike start each show with a look at attention-getting research, data, and news that impacts food industry professionals, and each episode ends with five questions, from "What is your hospitality pet peeve?" to "What is something you've changed your mind about?" This conversational, funny, and thought-provoking series is a must-listen for anyone who works in foodservice or CPG: chefs, R&D, sales, marketing, supply chain, regulatory, nutrition, agriculture, C-suite, and beyond. For more information about Menu Matters, visit menumatters.com
Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at rss.art19.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.
Cosmos
Similar by topic and creator
- Bartalk
Shares the topics Arts and Culture, Business and Food. - Distillers Journal Podcast
Shares the topics Arts and Culture, Business and Food. - QSR Uncut
Shares the topics Arts and Culture, Business and Food.
Similar shows
Explore more
Episodes
What will the vegetables of the future look like?
· 48 min
On this episode of The Mess Hall, we talk to Jill Overdorf, The Produce Ambassador, and Jenny Maloney, Global-Americas Strategic Accounts Manager at Bayer CropScience Vegetable Seeds, about what it really takes to get a new fruit or vegetable from a seed to your plate. Why does it take so many years to breed a new variety? Why does flavor so often come last, behind shipping durability, yield and disease resistance? And if chefs and shoppers want better-tasting produce, who’s going to pay growers to grow it? Jill and Jenny walk us through how climate change is forcing breeders to rethink which crops can survive and where, how technology and AI are speeding up the breeding process, and why storytelling and transparency matter so much in agriculture. We also talk about the push and pull between foodservice and retail, the future of local versus global produce, why some produce is starting to be seen as a luxury, and what it’ll take to make quality fruits and vegetables available to everyone, no matter where they shop or what they can spend. Plus, in our five questions, Jill and Jenny share their food industry pet peeves. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetWhat does the AI backlash mean for the food industry?
· 16 min
On this episode of The Mess Hall, Mike and Maeve take on one of the biggest questions facing the food industry right now: what is AI doing to trust? More and more people are pushing back on AI in food and marketing, with 61% saying they prefer brands that are AI-free. So what happens when a restaurant posts an AI-generated photo of a dish that doesn’t look anything like what shows up at the table? Is a polished, professional-looking image worth it if it makes people question everything else you tell them? Mike and Maeve also talk about how trust works differently from one culture to the next, why the human touch is still at the heart of a great food experience, and what the industry can learn from the rise and fall of the automat. Plus, they look at where AI can actually help, by taking work off the plates of restaurant staff and giving them more time for the people they’re serving, and how brands can build trust with customers who are more skeptical than ever. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetIs quality a luxury?
· 19 min
On this episode of The Mess Hall, Mike and Maeve ask a question that’s been bugging both of them: where did all the quality go? From airline travel to hotels to the food on our plates, it can feel like almost everything has gotten a little worse, a little smaller or a little more frustrating. They dig into “enshittification,” the term coined by writer Cory Doctorow for the way products and services slowly degrade over time, and why the airline industry might be the clearest example of it. How much of this is on brands, and how much is on the rest of us for always chasing the lowest price? Would people make different choices if companies were more upfront about what they’re giving up to keep costs down? And what has all that pressure done to restaurants, food brands and hospitality? Plus, Mike and Maeve look at some early signs that people may be starting to value quality again, with more of them expecting better products at every price point, and talk about why accessible quality, and not just luxury, could be a big opportunity for the food industry. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetAre Restaurants Too Loud?
· 16 min
In this mini episode, Mike and Maeve dig into a surprising finding from Menu Matters’ sensory research: 52% of people say they would give up their sense of sound entirely if it improved their other four senses. People clearly love sound at the table, with sizzling fajitas topping the list of sensory experiences they want most. Yet most diners also rate restaurants a 7 out of 10 for noise, and say their ideal restaurant would sound like relaxing classical music. Mike and Maeve unpack what that tension means for the industry. They cover why quiet has become a luxury, why younger diners raised during the pandemic may be more overwhelmed by noise than we assume, and how alarm-heavy kitchen technology wears on back-of-house staff. They also talk about how operators can design sound on purpose instead of by default. Along the way: a remarkably quiet open kitchen in Saratoga, a no-cell-phone coffee shop policy, and a wide-open opportunity for the first restaurant brand that markets itself on calm. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetHas The Alcohol Industry Lost A Generation?
· 1 hr 9 min
On this episode of The Mess Hall, Mike and Maeve share the hospitality moments that stood out on a trip to Tampa, from a bubble-wrap save in the Columbia Restaurant gift shop to a $50 tableside mozzarella that was well worth the price. Then wine and spirits data expert Alli Meyer joins us to dig into what's really happening with alcohol: whether Gen Z is drinking, how brand proliferation and inventory gluts hurt the category, why wine lists and shelves stopped focusing on what things taste like, why sweet and flavored products get looked down on when people clearly want them, and why smaller bottle sizes might be the fix we're not pushing hard enough. Plus, Alli answers our five questions See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetHow do we build a better convenience store?
· 1 hr 19 min
In this episode of The Mess Hall, Mike and Maeve dig into the freshest data from their 2026 Consumer Needs Mid-Year Update Survey. They share the findings that surprised them most: why younger consumers say 2026 has gone better than expected and what that streak of American optimism means for food innovation, plus they unpack consumer confusion around ultra-processed foods. Then they sit down with convenience store expert Frank Beard to ask what America can actually learn from the Japanese konbini. Frank makes the case that great food doesn't have to mean "bougie" food, that the real opportunity isn't out-competing fast food but filling America's missing street food gap, and that pride is what separates a truly successful store from one that's just offering gas station food 2.0. Plus, Beard offers his take on the trends people are only pretending to like. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetCan we measure food craveability?
· 1 hr 18 min
In this episode of The Mess Hall, Mike and Maeve check in on their 100 Recipe Challenge, a year-long project to cook 100 new recipes from cookbooks they've collected. They compare progress, debate the merits of following recipes to the letter versus trusting your gut, share their favorite and least favorite dishes so far, and go down a rabbit hole on the quest for the perfect pancake. Then they sit down with Beth Kimmerle, founder and CEO of Attribute Analytics, to explore the science of sensory evaluation and how her trained taste panels help food companies translate aroma, texture, taste, and emotion into actionable data. Beth digs into why texture has emerged as the new strategic focus in food innovation, why consumers can tell when their favorite products have quietly changed, and how the explosion of data and AI is reshaping -- and sometimes paralyzing -- product development. The conversation ranges from the National Restaurant Association Show floor to the future of underleveraged senses like sound and smell, the rise of ASMR-driven food discovery, and whether we'll eventually evolve a sixth sense (or grow an antenna) to keep up with a world where almost everything else can be faked. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetHow can we design a better restaurant?
· 1 hr 10 min
In this episode of The Mess Hall, we talk about the importance of play and creativity in our adult lives, which includes in cooking and eating experiences. And we talk with Rebecca Kilbreath, editor in chief of Restaurant Development + Design magazine. She talks about current design trends in restaurants, what the nostalgia trend actually looks like, moving away from same-ification in restaurant design, and how to tell a story in the design of a restaurant. Plus, in our five questions, she talks about the Western novel that had her by the throat. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetDoes the food industry have a language problem?
· 1 hr 1 min
On this episode of The Mess Hall, Mike and Maeve discuss what they learned from recent hospitality experiences in New Orleans and Denver. What can the food industry learn from a bar packed with orthopedic surgeons, a tableside bananas foster, and a prix fixe menu personalized to your likes and dislikes? Then, Mike and Maeve dig into a hot topic: should the food industry stop using the word "consumer"? They trace the surprising political history of the term, debate what to replace it with, and explore how language across the industry, from "ethnic" cuisine to emoji-laden brand messaging to loyalty programs that inspire no actual loyalty, shapes the way real people feel seen, respected, and valued. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetWho decides what your food tastes like?
· 1 hr 3 min
On this episode of The Mess Hall, we talk to Chef Anna Cheely, a flavor science expert and the senior culinary innovation manager at Kalsec, a natural flavors and colors company based in Michigan. How have flavor preferences have changed over the years? What does flavor look like at a time when ultra-processed foods are in the headlines? And how do you even capture the flavor of tom yum soup in a bottle? Plus, we start the episode discussing the joy of cooking and what it means for the food industry. And in our five questions, Chef Cheely tells us her food industry pet peeve. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetWhat does tracking serial killers have to do with understanding cereal bars?
· 1 hr 1 min
On this episode of The Mess Hall, we talk to Suzy Badaracco, who went from tracking serial killers to cereal bars. Badaracco's background has taken her from training as a criminalist with the FBI and Scotland Yard to culinary school and studying human nutrition. Today she runs Culinary Tides, where she uses all of those skills to find trends and patterns in the food and beverage industry. On the show we talk about why Dubai chocolate may cheat on his wife with a muffin, why the food industry is one giant crime scene, and the 2026 trend she thinks is way off base. And, in our five questions, she tells us her top pet peeve, which is related to potatoes... See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetWhat do consumers want in 2026?
· 1 hr 19 min
In this episode of The Mess Hall, we start off the show by looking at some of the brands and products that are killing it right now, from a marketing message from a knife sharpening brand to the Savannah Bananas to one of the best hotels we stayed at in 2025. Then we dive into the Menu Matters Consumer Need for 2026 -- consumers are just looking for the food and beverage industry to keep it real. In a world of AI slop and general distrust, how can brands and companies showcase the real human-focused ideas, solutions, ingredients, and products that will resonate in the year ahead? We also look at the five sub-trends that can help you solve for this need, from cutting through the noise to making food experiences more meaningful. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetWhat was the Cracker Barrel uproar really about?
· 54 min
In this episode, we discuss the decline of deviance. From cults to alcohol, movies to car colors, the evidence is clear that society is afraid to take risks. What does that mean for the food industry -- and humanity at large? Then, now that the controversy has subsided, we dive into what the Cracker Barrel uproar was really about. What can brands learn from Cracker Barrel's missteps, what could Cracker Barrel have done to engage new consumers in ways that honored the brand identity, and why should the food industry take their role in consumers' lives more seriously? See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetIs there a place for emotion in the food industry?
· 58 min
In this episode of The Mess Hall, we talk to Chef Rosalyn Darling about whether there is a place for emotion in the food industry. How do you create new food products, menu items, or experiences that solve for human anxiety, or the need for some excitement in our lives? How do you think through the entirety of the emotional experience, including for food industry workers? Is it possible to weave empathy and compassion into a restaurant or retail experience? Plus, we kick off the episode discussing our biggest hotel pet peeves, from privacy door hangers that fall off every time you open the door to the clever solutions that upgrade the hospitality experience. And Chef Darling answers The Mess Hall Five Questions, including a recommendation for another podcast that she thinks will level up your thinking. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetDo taste and flavor even matter anymore?
· 1 hr 21 min
In this episode of The Mess Hall, we chat with Chef Andrew Hunter who is a consulting chef for brands like Wolfgang Puck, Niman Ranch, and Kikkoman. What starts as a conversation about the difference between taste and flavor and whether the two even matter to today's social media-centric consumers quickly dives into a range of topics, from what brand authenticity means to Arby's to Dubai chocolate to whether massive chains will even exist in the future. To kick off the episode, we chat about whether a smoothie should ever cost $30 and discuss our experience trying the ketchup smoothie at Tropical Smoothie King. As always, we close out the episode with our five questions, where Chef Andrew covers everything from his preferred terminology for non-alcoholic beverages to his favorite food-centric TV show. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetWill GLP-1s be the downfall of the food industry?
· 1 hr 18 min
Will GLP-1 drugs like Ozempic and Wegovy spell the downfall of the food industry -- or at the very least the snack food industry? In this episode, we look at the hype around GLP-1 drugs and try to uncover the real learnings for restaurants and food manufacturers. From food noise to portion sizes to what consumers consider to be healthy today, registered dietitian nutritionist and industry expert Pam Smith (a co-creator of the Seasons 52 brand, which created the original mini dessert portion trend) has a messy conversation with Maeve and Mike. Plus, we look at the controversy around Michelin-starred Eleven Madison Park adding meat back to the menu. And, as always, we end with the Mess Hall Five Questions, where Pam Smith shares her opinion on whether a hot dog is a sandwich. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yetHas the food and beverage industry overdosed on nostalgia?
· 54 min
We dive into why Gen Z isn’t hosting parties, discuss the decline of coupons, and our guest Chef Chase Obenchain joins us to have a messy conversation about nostalgia and whether we’ve gone overboard in our pursuit of the past. From bringing back brands from the '90s to the relentless focus on "newstalgia," the food and beverage industry has gone all-in on nostalgic brands, marketing campaigns, and ideas. But does that obsession also mean that true innovation has taken a backseat to rehashed ideas? We cover everything from Cracker Barrel to Pizza Hut to Star Wars in this passionate, messy conversation. Plus, in our "Five Questions," Obenchain shares which fruit he's changed his mind about. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Not rated yet