Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The Materialist : Lisa Yamner

From The Materialist : A Podcast from At Present · · 53 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Can a machine have taste?

Everyone wants to ask Lisa Yamner (https://www.linkedin.com/in/lisayamnergreen/) about taste. She told me so, a little wearily, about four minutes into our conversation. It makes sense. She ran fashion at Google, co-founded The Yes (https://www.instagram.com/theyes/?hl=en) (an early, ahead-of-its-time bet on personalized shopping that Pinterest bought in 2022), and is now building Daydream (https://daydream.ing/), an AI shopping app. If anyone has a view on whether software can know what you should want, it’s her.

Her answer is no, and her reasoning is the thread that runs through this whole episode. Taste, she says, is built from everything you’ve seen, heard, and felt, plus a projection of who you want to be. A machine can do a lot of tasks for us, some better than we can. What it can’t do is feel, and taste is grounded in feeling.

I pushed on this from a few angles, because I’m not sure the line is as clean as it sounds. Where does style come from, if not from the same data a model could ingest? Her honest answer: everywhere. Your mother, a stranger on the street, a shop window, an influencer you half-watched. Which is exactly the kind of diffuse, unlabeled input that models are getting better at every quarter. We didn’t resolve it. I’m not sure it resolves.

The Cashmere Mafia

My favorite moment in the episode is one where I accidentally gave the right answer to a question I didn’t know was a test.

In 2012, Lisa was asked to build a fashion vertical at Google. The context: LVMH was suing Google over trademarks and gray-market goods. Chanel had never posted a video online. Google was selling Hermès with the same pitch it sold Home Depot, and the luxury houses, understandably, weren’t buying. Her job was to get them to run some ads.

She asked me what I would have needed to hear, back when I was selling jewelry in 2012. I answered from the watch side of my life, where I spent years negotiating lineal feet of case space and store adjacencies with Swiss brands. Those fights were never really about square footage. They were about position. A luxury brand pays for Fifth Avenue because Fifth Avenue says something about who the brand is. So the pitch to a luxury house about search can’t be about clicks. It has to be about where you stand and who you stand next to.

It turns out that’s exactly what her team, which called itself the Cashmere Mafia, built in 2012. They called it the Fifth Avenue narrative: search results as a street, your store open 24 hours, in good company.

The lesson I took from it is bigger than Google. Luxury doesn’t resist technology. It resists being told the same story as everyone else. The technology was never the hard part. The translation was.

Context, not personalization

I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about push versus pull. Amazon perfected search for things you need: toilet paper, olive oil, a replacement charger. I have a need, and a multi-trillion-dollar machine delivers it with as little friction as possible. But almost everything At Present sells serves no function other than joy, meaning, and identity. Nobody searches for a need they don’t know they have.

Lisa’s answer is that push is about to get a lot better, and the word she uses for it is context. Personalization, she says, was the word they always used at The Yes. But knowing who you are and what you like isn’t enough. The system also has to know why you’re shopping, where you’re going, and what’s happening in your life. Her example: an app that knows you’re headed to New York in three weeks and asks whether you want new cufflinks before you go. That is a very different kind of push from another email in your inbox.

That’s the bet behind Daydream. Brands hand over their catalogs. Daydream enriches them, turning a black silk dress into something that’s appropriate for a wedding, black-tie adjacent, and right for a New York evening. Then it tries to match that against what it knows about you. The more you…

Back to The Materialist : A Podcast from At Present · Report a problem