Conservatives Too Weak for Reality
From The Lucas Bean Show · · 3 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
In 1981, sociologist Jean Baudrillard at the University of Paris Nanterre published Simulacra and Simulation, a book that diagnosed a problem most people wouldn’t recognize for another forty years. Baudrillard argued that modern society was entering a phase in which copies of reality would become more familiar, more trusted, and eventually more “real” to people than reality itself. He called this condition hyperreality. The simulation doesn’t replace reality through force. It replaces reality through repetition. You consume the copy so many times that the copy becomes the original in your mind, and actual reality starts to feel like the counterfeit.
Baudrillard wasn’t writing about one political party. He was writing about an entire media landscape that was beginning to prioritize the production of images over the reporting of facts. But forty years later, one side of the American political spectrum has built its entire culture inside the simulation he described, and they did it so thoroughly that most of them no longer have access to the original.
The Simulation Inventory
Start with what conservatives have been consuming for decades and look at what every single piece of it has in common.
Professional wrestling. WWE is fake fighting. The outcomes are predetermined. The rivalries are scripted. The heroes and villains are characters played by performers who eat dinner together after the show. Nobody is held accountable for anything that happens in the ring because nothing that happens in the ring is real. It is a simulation of conflict designed to produce emotional reactions without consequences. The crowd screams, the villain cheats, the hero triumphs, and nobody gets hurt in a way that matters. Real conflict has stakes. Real conflict has ambiguity. Real conflict doesn’t tell you who the good guy is before the fight starts. WWE does all of those things, and it trained an entire generation to expect conflict to work that way.
Fox News, OAN, Newsmax. These are not news organizations with a conservative editorial perspective. A news organization with a conservative perspective would report what is happening in the world and then interpret it through a conservative lens. These networks don’t do that. They begin with the conclusion their audience wants to hear and then construct a version of events that supports it. They are simulations of news. They have the visual language of journalism, the anchors, the chyrons, the “breaking news” graphics, the panels of guests who appear to disagree but never challenge the frame. The packaging is identical to real journalism. The product is completely different. Real journalism tells you things you don’t want to hear. The simulation never does.
Religion as it functions in conservative American life. Not faith as a genuine spiritual practice, but religion as a system of performance and social belonging. The version of Christianity practiced across MAGA America is a simulation of morality. It has the symbols, the buildings, the language, the rituals. It references the same book. But it produces no moral behavior. It produces moral identity, the feeling of being a good person, without requiring the person to actually be good. Research by Jean Decety at the University of Chicago in 2015 found that children raised in religious households were less generous than children raised in secular ones. The simulation of goodness replaced the practice of it, and nobody inside the system noticed because the simulation felt real enough.
Donald Trump. A simulation of a successful businessman. He inherited his wealth, bankrupted casinos, and was bailed out repeatedly by his father and by banks that couldn’t afford to let him fail. His actual business record is one of consistent destruction. But he played a successful businessman on a television show for fourteen seasons, and the character he played on The Apprentice became more real to his audience than the man sitting in the chair. They don’t worship…