I Put These Up. Here's Why I'd Take Them Down.
From The Infamous Ex-Chief · · 20 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
Send us Fan Mail (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2340574/fan_mail/new)
In this first episode of the series on Flock Safety automated license plate reader cameras, the host explains that he asked the East Cleveland city council to fund the technology while serving in law enforcement, and then reviews public records from Ohio law enforcement agencies concerning how officers' searches of the system are documented and audited.
The host notes that, in the contracts he has reviewed, data from the cameras is retained for thirty days, and states his opinion that this level of retention is overreach. He also references a reported ruling by a federal judge in Oklahoma concerning a warrantless search of a month of one person's movements in a comparable system. Flock Safety has stated it expects to appeal. The host does not offer a legal conclusion on that ruling and says a later episode will examine it.
The episode is based on records requested under Ohio's Public Records Act, R.C. 149.43. The host's position is that Flock search records and audit logs are records of the subscribing public office, not of the vendor. Records discussed include:
- A one month audit log from the Medina County Sheriff's Office containing 1,045 rows, and the agency's written responses to six questions. The host reports that most rows lacked a case number, and that the agency stated in writing that the quarterly compliance review had not been conducted and that the issue had been addressed and corrected.
- Reporting on an internal audit by the Reynoldsburg Division of Police. According to that reporting, two former officers left the department after being notified of internal investigations concerning possible misuse of the system. The host's requests to the chief for comment had not been answered as of recording.
- Written responses from Wadsworth, Medina Police, Seville, Montville, Lodi, Medina Township and Brunswick Hills Township, including confirmed camera counts totaling 80 across eight agencies, which the host describes as a minimum.
- A records request to the City of Brunswick dated July 7, an acknowledgment dated July 15, and the host's service of a Court of Claims complaint form on the city under R.C. 2743.75. The host states that nothing has been filed with the court and that the city's response period remained open at recording.
The host also presents instances in which the technology was used in locating two missing older adults with dementia, and describes agencies that responded promptly and candidly.
Important notes
The host does not allege criminal conduct or improper intent by any named or unnamed person or agency. A missing case number on a log entry is not, by itself, evidence of improper purpose, and several agencies explained that their policies allowed a stated reason in place of a case number during part of the period reviewed. No criminal charges were reported in the Reynoldsburg matter. Characterizations of official practices in this episode are the host's opinion based on the records shown. Agency statements are quoted from their written responses, and listeners are encouraged to review the full documents. The Oklahoma ruling is reported as stated in news coverage and is subject to appeal.
Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/c/TheInfamousEx_Chief)