Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Bringing Potato Onions Back from the Brink — True Seed, Genetic Diversity, and Backyard Plant Breeding with Kelly Winterton

From The Going to Seed Podcast · · 55 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Joseph Lofthouse interviews Kelly Winterton, a pioneering backyard plant breeder whose decades of experimentation helped revive interest in potato onions — a once-common crop that had nearly disappeared from American gardens.

Gardening in a cold mountain valley in northern Utah, Kelly discovered that growing potato onions from true botanical seed could unlock hidden genetic diversity, restore vigor, and produce larger, more productive onions.

His journey began when a few potato onions unexpectedly flowered after years of propagation through bulbs. Kelly planted their seeds alongside his original clones and discovered remarkable differences. Some seedlings produced onions as large as softballs, inspiring years of experimentation with genetics, fertility, and sexual reproduction.

Topics include:

- Potato onion basics: How potato onions differ from ordinary bulbing and multiplier onions.

- True botanical seed: Growing genetically diverse potato onions instead of relying exclusively on vegetative propagation.

- Restoring vigor: How accumulated diseases can weaken cloned crops and how growing from seed can rejuvenate populations.

- Recovering lost diversity: Selecting red, pink, yellow, and white onions resembling varieties described in nineteenth-century gardening books.

- Local adaptation: Developing crops suited to short growing seasons, harsh winters, and regional conditions.

- Day-length sensitivity: How latitude and seasonal daylight influence onion growth and bulb formation.

- Flowering and fertility: The effects of plant stress, propagation history, and growing conditions on seed production.

- Seed storage: Preserving onion seed viability through freezing.

- International genetics: Evaluating 25 potato onion accessions obtained from a Norwegian seed bank.

- Practical plant breeding: Selecting carrots for winter survival and collards for extended harvests.

Kelly recounts how a single white carrot survived a harsh Utah winter when every other plant in its row died. Saving its seeds demonstrated the power of selection, although the resulting woody carrots taught him that hardiness alone does not guarantee good eating quality.

The conversation explores the history of potato onions, including the apparent disappearance of red and white forms from commercial circulation. Kelly recovered some of their characteristics through seed selection, although developing dependable white potato onions remained challenging.

Perhaps the most inspiring lesson concerns expertise. Kelly never intended to become a world authority on potato onions. Through careful observation, experimentation, recordkeeping, and sharing his discoveries, he attracted the attention of gardeners and professional geneticists worldwide.

Joseph and Kelly discuss how ordinary gardeners can contribute to crop conservation. A person working with one crop in a small backyard can uncover genetic possibilities that larger institutions may overlook.

The episode concludes with a tour of Holly Hansen's northern Utah kitchen garden, featuring seed crops, potatoes, fava beans, Jerusalem artichokes, and other locally adapted food plants.

An encouraging conversation for seed savers, backyard plant breeders, and anyone interested in reviving neglected crops through curiosity, experimentation, and care.

Presented by Going to Seed, with Joseph Lofthouse, Kelly Winterton, and Holly Hansen.

Back to The Going to Seed Podcast · Report a problem