Fewer Donors, Bigger Gifts: What the Latest Giving Data Means for Year-End 2026
From The Cause+Effect Podcast · · 36 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
As year-end giving season gets underway, Trent Dunham sits down with Dunham+Co founder and chairman Rick Dunham to look at the newest Q2 2026 findings from the Fundraising Effectiveness Project. The trend from Giving USA is still holding: giving dollars are up 6.6% while the number of donors is down 1.6%. Rick argues that much of the decline is self-inflicted. Only about 11% of new donors give a second gift within a year, and overall retention has fallen to roughly one in four.
The second half of the conversation turns to the church. Congregants are dealing with economic pressure, a midterm election, uncertainty about AI, and an us-versus-them culture. Rick offers a direct challenge to pastors: stop thanking people for “supporting the church” and call them into a shared mission instead. He makes the case that seasons of uncertainty are often when the clarity of the gospel breaks through most powerfully.
Connect with us at https://www.dunhamandcompany.com/
Episode Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
0:35 Welcome and the year-end giving season
2:35 Where we look for giving data
5:13 Q2 2026: Fewer donors, more dollars
6:40 Why donors are pulling back
7:30 The second-gift problem
14:04 Inviting donors into partnership
15:39 Non-cash giving before December 31
18:15 Text as a retention channel
20:35 How church giving is different
21:31 What’s on congregants’ minds
25:53 Stop talking about “supporting the church”
33:16 Gen Z and a renewed hunger for Jesus
34:29 Clarity around the gospel and closing thoughts