Skip to main content
AmigoFish

PROFILE: H.H. Holmes Part 2, Benjamin Pitezel & the Missing Children

From Terror Talk: True Crime, Serial Killers and Horror · · 51 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Who did H.H. Holmes actually kill, and why did a Philadelphia detective have to search two countries to find out?

⚠️ Trigger warning: this episode discusses the murder of children.

In the summer of 1895, detective Frank Geyer walked the streets of Toronto with a photograph and a box of letters three children wrote to their mother, letters Holmes never mailed. Therapists Shannon and Cathy go through the victims the record can support, the insurance scheme that killed Benjamin Pitezel, and the coercive control that kept a mother and her children apart in the same cities.

CHAPTERS

0:00 Frank Geyer in Toronto, 1895

0:50 Welcome back

1:55 Julia and Pearl Conner, Christmas Eve 1891

3:28 Emeline Cigrand, the secretary

4:50 The heavy trunk and the badly typed letter

6:48 Emily Van Tassel, possible victim

8:01 Minnie and Nannie Williams

10:10 Idealization, extraction, erasure

13:52 July 4, 1893: the Ferris wheel and the last sighting

17:35 Anna Betts, claimed but not confirmed

18:07 Expressive vs. instrumental homicide

20:21 Benjamin Pitezel, Holmes's right-hand man

21:07 St. Louis, H.M. Howard and train robber Marion Hedgepeth

23:09 1316 Callowhill Street: the insurance scheme becomes murder

25:04 Fidelity Mutual pays out

25:53 The dark triad

29:07 Horror Facts with Holmes

30:26 Carrie Pitezel and the children

32:46 The children's letters

34:34 Detroit, and "Howard is not with us now"

37:44 Coercive control

41:19 Burlington and the nitroglycerin

42:04 Why children trust the adult they're handed to

43:14 Amnesia, Gilmanton and Georgiana

45:37 Arrested in Boston on a Texas horse theft warrant

46:12 Frank Geyer follows the letters

47:07 16 St. Vincent Street, Toronto

48:18 Irvington, Indiana

49:05 Why did H.H. Holmes kill?

49:57 Next week: the trial

IN THIS EPISODE:

• Julia and Pearl Conner, Emeline Cigrand, and Minnie and Nannie Williams

• Emily Van Tassel and Anna Betts: the names on the legend's list the record can't support

• Benjamin Pitezel, the B.F. Perry insurance scheme, and the $10,000 Fidelity Mutual payout

• Marion Hedgepeth, the train robber Holmes stiffed out of $500

• Carrie Pitezel and her children Alice, Nellie and Howard

• The letters the children wrote home, and the detective who followed them

• Arrested in Boston, November 17, 1894

• What Frank Geyer found in Toronto and Irvington in the summer of 1895

CLINICAL TERMS: instrumental vs. expressive homicide, dark triad, Machiavellianism, narcissism, psychopathy, coercive control, Biderman's chart of coercion, isolation, monopolization of perception, intermittent reinforcement, idealization, discard, attachment

H.H. HOLMES SERIES:

• Part 1: The Man Who Invented Himself (Nov 4)

• Part 2: the victims, Benjamin Pitezel, and the detective who searched two countries for three children (you are here)

• Part 3: the trial, the 27-murder confession, Jack the Ripper, and the grave (Nov 18)

CORRECTIONS• 2:10: Julia Conner's husband was Ned (Icilius) Conner, who ran the jewelry counter in Holmes's drugstore, not a Dr. Lawrence Conner.

📚 The full reference list for this episode is on Patreon.

Two licensed therapists, one forensic psychologist, one clinical LMFT, take apart the minds behind the crimes.

🎧 Support the show and get bonus episodes on PATREON: https://www.patreon.com/cw/terrortalk

📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/terrortalkpodcast/

📘 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/newterrortalkpodcast

🎵 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@dark.psychology.girls?_r=18_t=ZT-99iWlxm05in

🎶 Music by Mannequin Uprising

Back to Terror Talk: True Crime, Serial Killers and Horror · Report a problem