Skip to main content
AmigoFish

PROFILE: H.H. Holmes Part 3, 27-Murder Confession & Jack the Ripper

From Terror Talk: True Crime, Serial Killers and Horror · · 39 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Did H.H. Holmes really confess to 27 murders, and was he really Jack the Ripper?

In April 1896, a man waiting to be hanged sold a confession to the newspapers. Then some of his victims turned up alive. More than a century later, his own descendant went on television to say he was Jack the Ripper and got a judge to open his grave. Therapists Shannon and Cathy close the series with the trial, the confession, the gallows, and the question every listener asks: what was he?

0:00 The confession, the Ripper, and the grave

0:36 Welcome, and the Murder Cafe

1:34 Philadelphia, October 28, 1895: Room 676

4:02 Holmes fires his lawyers

4:59 Day two, the dock, and the verdict

5:58 Why prosecutors pick the cleanest case

7:38 Firing your lawyers as a grandiosity tell

9:29 Why the children's evidence was inadmissible

11:05 "One by one they are finding them alive"

11:38 The New York World's invented confession

12:53 The real confession: 27 murders, and who paid for it

14:00 Fact-checking the confession: the victims turn up alive

15:22 "I was born with the devil in me": the line he never said

17:02 Why inflate your own body count?

18:31 The PCL-R, and why we formulate instead of diagnose

20:03 Horror Facts with Holmes

21:23 The formulation: lying, conning and compartmentalizing

24:28 The affective items: "a very lively kind of corpse"

26:16 A parasitic lifestyle and criminal versatility

27:51 What doesn't fit: a planner, not an impulsive psychopath

29:24 Jung's trickster

31:02 The gallows, May 7, 1896

32:32 Ten feet down and a coffin full of cement

33:21 American Ripper and the 2017 exhumation

35:48 What the Penn Museum team found

37:06 Why won't the legend die?

IN THIS EPISODE:

• Commonwealth v. Holmes: Judge Michael Arnold, D.A. George S. Graham, and the lawyers Holmes fired

• Why Philadelphia tried him for Benjamin Pitezel's murder alone

• The New York World's invented confession, and the real one Hearst's New York Journal and the Philadelphia Inquirer ran

• The "victims" who turned up alive

• "I was born with the devil in me," and the newspaper that wrote it

• The gallows at Moyamensing Prison, and Carrie Pitezel's last word

• Holy Cross Cemetery, Jeff Mudgett, Amaryllis Fox, and History's American Ripper

• What the 2017 exhumation found under the concrete

CLINICAL TERMS: Psychopathy Checklist-Revised (PCL-R), Robert Hare, formulation vs. diagnosis, grandiosity, glibness, pathological lying, shallow affect, lack of remorse, parasitic lifestyle, criminal versatility, compartmentalization, malignant narcissism, Machiavellianism, Jung, the trickster archetype

H.H. HOLMES SERIES:

• Part 1: The Man Who Invented Himself (Nov 4)

• Part 2: the victims, Benjamin Pitezel, and the detective who searched two countries for three children (Nov 11)

• Part 3: the trial, the 27-murder confession, Jack the Ripper, and the grave (you are here)

CORRECTIONS

• 15:43: Holmes died in 1896, so he's been "conning the world" for 130 years, not 150.

• 21:10: The gangster convicted of tax evasion was Al Capone (1931). John Gotti was convicted of murder and racketeering.

📚 The full reference list for all three parts is on Patreon.

Two licensed therapists, one forensic psychologist, one clinical LMFT, take apart the minds behind the crimes.

🎧 Support the show and get bonus episodes on PATREON: https://www.patreon.com/cw/terrortalk

📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/terrortalkpodcast/

📘 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/newterrortalkpodcast

🎵 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@dark.psychology.girls?_r=18_t=ZT-99iWlxm05in

🎶 Music by Mannequin Uprising

Back to Terror Talk: True Crime, Serial Killers and Horror · Report a problem