Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Return Ward: Murder on Main Street & the Ghosts of Sylvania

From Talking Trash & Tacos · · 28 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

In 1857, Olive Ward disappeared from her home in Sylvania, Ohio. Her neighbors kept asking questions—and what they uncovered became one of the town’s darkest stories.

Sarah and Jessika dig into Return Ward, often called Ohio’s first serial killer, his changing confessions, and the murder that still haunts Main Street.

Then we follow the ghost stories into downtown Sylvania: phantom piano music, a mysterious woman called Isabella, and guests who reportedly woke to find someone standing at the foot of their beds in the Wingate Hotel’s Room 413.

Could these encounters be connected to Olive Ward? We’re getting into the history, the hauntings, and exactly how quickly we’d be checking out.

Would YOU spend the night in Room 413? Tell us your answer—and share your own Sylvania ghost stories.

Back to Talking Trash & Tacos · Report a problem