Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Episode 112: Did the Maya have Elephants?

From Tales From Aztlantis · · 1 hr 7 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

What do ancient Maya carvings, Asian elephants, Egyptian seafarers, and a whole lot of questionable scholarship have in common? Apparently, quite a bit if you ask early 20th-century diffusionists and pesudorarchaeologists.

In this episode of Tales From Aztlantis, Kurly Tlapoyawa and Ruben Arellano Tlakatekatl take a deep dive into the bizarre history of the claim that ancient Maya artists depicted Asian elephants in their monumental artwork. The trail leads us to Donald A. Mackenzie's 1912 book Myths of Pre-Columbian America, recently repackaged as Aztec and Mesoamerican Myths and Legends, and the thoroughly discredited theories of hyperdiffusionism.

We explore how writers like Grafton Elliott Smith and William James Perry imagined ancient Egyptian explorers spreading civilization, religion, architecture, and even artistic traditions across the globe. From supposed elephant trunks on Stela B at Copan to comparisons between Mesoamerican deities and Hindu gods, we examine how superficial visual similarities became the foundation for sweeping claims about Indigenous America's supposed inability to develop complex civilizations independently.

Along the way, we discuss colonial racism, the difference between analogy and actual cultural transmission, Maya artistic conventions, the Baird's tapir, and the dangers of what some critics aptly call "lookership" instead of scholarship.

So, were there elephants roaming ancient Mesoamerica? Or are pseudoarchaeologists once again seeing exactly what they want to see?

listener comments? Feedback? Shoot us a text! (https://www.buzzsprout.com/1720405/fan_mail/new)

This December, I'll be joining Skeptoid Adventures as your guide for The Mysteries of the Maya, where we'll travel through the Yucatán exploring remarkable archaeological sites, uncovering the real history behind the Maya civilization, and separating fact from fiction along the way.

To reserve your spot, all you need is a fully refundable $500 deposit. Your deposit is refundable through August 1, so you can reserve your place with confidence. After Au

Lignum is a haven for culture, rest, and resistance. We believe in celebrating community and honoring the land that holds us. At our urban “milpa,” we practice indigenous science that respects the natural cycles of the region, and most of our workshops are hosted by indigenous and local experts. Every project we do is grounded in collective memory, creativity, and respect for the land and its people.

Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/aztlantis)

Order "NEVER WILL IT BE LOST" and get $5 off! (https://shop.ingramspark.com/b/084?params=lA93rTmYgy8a7KwaoaEbXaP0JfkXqcp6y9sPaqzOdPk)

Support Lignum: A Cultural Haven in Mérida (https://www.gofundme.com/f/support-lignum-a-cultural-haven-in-merida)

Your Hosts:

Kurly Tlapoyawa is an archaeologist, ethnohistorian, and filmmaker. His research covers Mesoamerica, the American Southwest, and the historical connections between the two regions. He is the author of numerous books and has presented lectures at the University of New Mexico, Harvard University, Yale University, San Diego State University, and numerous others. He most recently released his documentary short film "Guardians of the Purple Kingdom," and is a cultural consultant for Nickelodeon Animation Studios. @kurlytlapoyawa

Ruben Arellano Tlakatekatl is a scholar, activist, and professor of history. His research explores Chicana/Chicano indigeneity, Mexican indigenist nationalism, and Coahuiltecan identity resurgence. Other areas of research include Aztlan (US Southwest), Anawak (Mesoamerica), and Native North America. He has presented and published widely on these topics and has taught courses at various institutions. He currently teaches history at Dallas College – Mountain View Campus.

Find us:

- Bluesky (https://bsky.app/profile/talesfromaztlantis.bsky.social)

- ... (https://www.instagram.com/kurly_tlapoyawa/)

Back to Tales From Aztlantis · Report a problem