Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Small Hall Baseball Podcast

Aaron LattanziAudio

Format:
Podcast
New episodes:
Every two weeks
Typical length:
about 1 hour 10 minutes
Latest episode:
Not rated yet
CosmosOpen at the sourceReport a problemIs this your show? Get a badge

About this show

Three men who believe The Hall should be small and aren't afraid to let their opinions be known. Join Aaron, Frank, and Josh as they explore national baseball news, news from their beloved Phillies, and discuss topics that span the annals of MLB history.

Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at spreaker.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.

Cosmos

Similar by topic and creator

See the full Cosmos

Similar shows

See all History shows

Explore more

Episodes

  • Episode 100 - Smörgåsbord Part VI: The Curse of Low Modern Standards

    · 1 hr 44 min

    We present to you our 100th episide of the Small Hall Baseball Podcast with Part 6 of "The Smörgåsbord" This episode we will be reviewing yet another set players, but ones that are either currently playing or are recently retired. So many, if not all of these players have been called "future Hall of Famers in interviews and broadcasts, but we took a look at each player and gave our thoughts on their case. Do we think any or all of them are worth future additions to Cooperstown? Thank you all so much for being a part of this journey with us to 100 episodes and I hope we can continue for at least 100 more with you! Each player can be found at the timestamp below: Freddie Freeman - 2:44 Justin Verlander - 13:13 Yadier Molina - 25:45 Clayton Kershaw - 39:12 Mookie Betts - 57:01 Aroldis Chapman - 1:08:41 Nolan Arenado - 1:23:19

    Not rated yet
  • The Length of Careers Looking Much Too Short and Willie Mays Tenure Is Of Highest Import

    · 59 min

    This week we discuss the apparent shortening of careers. Is this just a phantom that has no merit or do careers really seem to be shortening as baseball goes on? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss the 1968 Yaz Batting Title and if modern baseball is trending to lower averages. Will we see consistently lower batting title averages or will the cream always rise to the top? Our Hall of Famer this week is Center Fielder Willie Mays. He is a Hall of Famer so just listen to us rave about the greatness of Mays and you'll hopefully enjoy it as much as we did. In our singlular parting shot this week discusses the poor fundamentals of current baseball play. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring Willie Mays for Blasting Cap Caution, The Clean Air Fund, and Chrysler! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball -13:08 Hall of Fame Discussion - 27:09 Parting Shot - 44:12

    Not rated yet
  • Prospect Importance Is Up In the Air and Hack Willson's Case is Worse For The Wear

    · 1 hr 0 min

    This week we discuss the value of the baseball prospect. Have prospects become less valuable or more so, but in the sense of just being a commodity? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss the legendary Earl Weaver argument with umpire Bill Haller. This segment speaks for itself. We play the audio, but if you'd like to see it in its full video glory, it can be found here: https://youtu.be/FrhmUGRaOwY?si=svKeez4SeUHrtzlK Our Hall of Famer this week is RBI record holder Hack Wilson. His name is often remembered, but are his numbers on the field worthy of his inclusion in Cooperstown? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses the less than admirable conduct of Astros pitcher Hunter Brown. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring Earl Weaver for Coca Cola, tips about box scores, and local Baltimore car deals! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball -16:13 Hall of Fame Discussion - 34:17 Parting Shot - 49:24

    Not rated yet
  • Owners In Sports Changing For The Worse and Addie Joss' Induction Feels Slightly Coerced

    · 1 hr 18 min

    This week we discuss the changing landscape of sports ownership. Have sports owners changed over the years or have they just become different for better or worse? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss the firing of Danny Ozark. Would the Phillies have succeeded with him still at the helm or did Dallas Green have the necessary magic? Our Hall of Famer this week is pitcher Addie Joss. The ten year eligibility requirement was waved for his induction, but were his numbers enough to warrant this waving or is this a head scratcher? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses the career of Tommy John as well as his sport altering surgery. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring Mel Allen for baseball cards, Baseball Hall of Famers for Mastercard, and Bugs Bunny and Sam for Post Cereal baseball cards. Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 21:21 Hall of Fame Discussion - 41:55 Parting Shot - 1:02:22

    Not rated yet
  • Coaches in Baseball Lagging Behind and Mathews Career at Third is Greatness Defined

    · 1 hr 5 min

    This week we discuss the usefulness of coaches in modern MLB. Have they lost their function in a game with millions thrown around or do they still have a purpose? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss Richie Ashburn hitting the same fan with foul balls in the same at-bat. How much has safety changed for fans and how ridiculous is it that this happened? Our Hall of Famer this week is Third Baseman Eddie Mathews. Not mentioned often when discussing all time Third Basemen, is he more of a laugher than most would imagine? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses the bridge burning of MLB with choosing to focus more on streaming. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring Tom Emanski Defensive Drills, Slice Soda, and Upper Deck cards! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 17:17 Hall of Fame Discussion - 34:25 Parting Shot - 48:39

    Not rated yet
  • Trading Deadline Still Relevant Today and Mr. Cub's Greatness Is On Full Display

    · 1 hr 8 min

    This week we discuss the relevance of the trade deadline. Has the deadline become antiquated or does it still have a key roll in current MLB? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss Tom Hughes hitting a solo HR for his team's only run and pitching a complete game. We talk about how much we miss hitting pitchers and which of those were our favorites. Our Hall of Famer this week is Mr. Cub, Ernie Banks. While he has a lot of mystique as Mr. Cub, was Banks a worthy addition to the HOF? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses the terrible Netflix Home Run Derby. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring Ernie Banks for baseball cards and Cubs Baseball as well as Cubs World Series hopes between Craig Robinson and Nick Offerman. Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 14:56 Hall of Fame Discussion - 32:07 Parting Shot - 48:39

    Not rated yet
  • Rookie of the Year Award Missing It's Sheen and Amos Rusie's Case Not Looking So Clean

    · 55 min

    This week we discuss the impact of the Rookie of the Year Award. Is this award actually significant on its own or should it only be looked back upon for further significance afterward or as missed potential? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss Bill Haller umpiring behind the plate while his brother Tom Haller catches for the Detroit Tigers. Should this ever happen and what potential issues could arise? Our Hall of Famer this week is pitcher Amos Rusie. He was a 500 innings pitched machine for a time, but does his 9 full season career survive our scrutiny? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses Bob Feller's "Little Black Book of Baseball Wisdom". Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring Becky G for the WBC, Buck Martinez for Schneider's Hot Dogs, and Larry Walker for All-Star Baseball '99! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 16:25 Hall of Fame Discussion - 27:12 Parting Shot - 41:26

    Not rated yet
  • Cycles and No-Hitters Still Have Import and Joe Sewell's Numbers May Just Fall Short

    · 1 hr 15 min

    This week we discuss baseball performance oddities. Of the well known ones such as the Cycle or a Perfect Game are some more impressive than others and do any of them still deserve the reverence they get? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss Phil Niekro's 3000th strikeout and the knuckleballer as a concept. How hard is it to be a good knuckleballer and is there any room for that kind of pitcher in modern baseball? Our Hall of Famer this week is infielder Joe Sewell. His numbers are good, but in an era such as the 1920s, were they good enough to stand out and included in the HOF? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses the ongoing tension between the players and the owners with the end of the CBA looming. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring Sewell's Cleveland Indians with, "The Ball", Kenny Lofton for Taco Bell, and Jonathan Winters for Channel 43! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 21:22 Hall of Fame Discussion - 40:34 Parting Shot - 55:46

    Not rated yet
  • Manager Quality Hard To Pin Down and Roger Connor's Greatness Deserves More Renown

    · 1 hr 12 min

    This week we discuss what makes good and bad managers in baseball. Is there a secret sauce to being a good manager and why do great players seem to make such bad ones? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss the appearence of 15 year old Joe Nuxhall. He only pitched a single game in 1944, but why is it such a good thing kids that old are not allowed to play? Our Hall of Famer this week is 19th Century First Baseman Roger Connor. His being elected by the Vet's Committee is a rare correction for them, but just how great was he? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses just what made Lou Gehrig such a wonderful anomaly in the history of baseball in terms of his quality of play, but also as a person. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring Harold Reynolds for ESPN2, more Seattle Mariners, and Frank Howard for Nestle Quik! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 25:34 Hall of Fame Discussion - 41:38 Parting Shot - 59:16

    Not rated yet
  • Mascot Relevance Waning With Time and Bob Lemon's Career Up For The Climb?

    · 1 hr 1 min

    This week we discuss the relevance of mascots in professional sports. Do they even have a place anymore and should they persist? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss Cy Young reaching 500 wins. This milestone is bonkers and will never be surpassed, but just how unreachable is it? Our Hall of Famer this week is Cleveland Pitcher Bob Lemon. Was his good stretch good enough to warrant a place in Cooperstown next to his rotation mate? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses the post-Thomson firing resurgence of the Phillies and if they dug themselves too big a whole to recover this season. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring Barbasol, William Frawley for Major League Baseball, and Rafael Palmeiro for Viagra. Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 15:07 Hall of Fame Discussion - 29:13 Parting Shot - 45:54

    Not rated yet
  • Early Firings Becoming All The Rage and The Friends of Frankie Frisch Final Day Onstage

    · 1 hr 11 min

    This week we discuss the early season dismissal of Alex Cora and Rob Thomson. Should managers be let go this early and should it included scorched earth for their coaching staff if so? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss the incident that caused the sudden retirement of Jim Eisenreich in 1984. What is the line for heckling athletes and how hard would it be to bring oneself back to the game that caused them such stress? Our Hall of Famer this week is third baseman and final Friend of Frankie Frisch, Freddie Lindstrom. Would this final member of the Triple F club be the only deserving inductee into Cooperstown? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses the 1996 Phillies and their marvelous cascade into mediocrity and then into the abyss before rising back in the early 2000s. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring Baseball Fever, World Series Baseball 2, and Ryan Klesko for Fox Baseball! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 22:14 Hall of Fame Discussion - 38:48 Parting Shot - 54:54

    Not rated yet
  • The Small Hall Smörgåsbord 5: A Good Day To Die Hard

    · 1 hr 22 min

    We present to you Part 5 of "The Smörgåsbord" This episode we will be reviewing yet another set players that are not in the Baseball Hall of Fame, but were suggested by folks on social media as players who should have their case reviewed. We took a look at each player and gave our thoughts on their case. Do we think any of them were oversights and should be in the HOF? Have a listen won't you? This is our fourth set of players and we will review even more in the future. Each player can be found at the timestamp below: Will Clark - 1:44 Roger Maris - 11:17 Bill Freehan - 20:12 Rick Reuschel - 28:40 Mark McGwire - 39:45 Luis Gonzalez - 52:05 Curt Schilling - 1:04:54

    Not rated yet
  • Harry the K's replaced at Citizen's Bank and Robin Roberts Career Enough to Join the Ranks?

    · 1 hr 9 min

    This week we discuss the removal of Harry Kalas' name from an establishment in Citizen's Bank Park. Is this a big deal, little deal, or no deal? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss the debut and career of pitcher Jim Abbott. Its hard enough being a pitcher in MLB, but how much more respect and admiration does one deserve for doing it with a single hand? A lot! Our Hall of Famer this week is pitcher Robin Roberts. He did not turn out to be quite the laugher we expected, but are his great seasons in the 1950s enough to warrant his call to Cooperstown? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses the ABS challenge system and if it is just a continuation of the replay can of worms that can never be closed. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials with all Phillies ads for McDonalds, Levi Jeans, and a gameday promo from 1983! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 21:45 Hall of Fame Discussion - 36:36 Parting Shot - 54:57

    Not rated yet
  • Jurikson Profar Remains Dumb As Can Be and Earl Averill As HOF Worthy As His Eyes Can See?

    · 1 hr 4 min

    This week we discuss the second suspension of Jurikson Profar for a banned substance. How can MLB combat these players continuing to skirt the rules and is the system in place the best we can expect? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss the lifting of the permanent ban for Willie Mays and Mickey Mantle for being casino greeters. The ban was a contentious one in the first place, but do we understand at least a little bit its purpose and was lifting it the correct decision? Our Hall of Famer this week is outfielder Earl Averill. He certainly thought a lot of himself as a player, but do we feel that confidence in being in the HOF was justified? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses thhe elite status of one Bryce Harper and whether or not this is a whole ball of nothing on his part. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials with Starting Lineup figures and Sammy Sosa High Heat Baseball! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 17:54 Hall of Fame Discussion - 31:08 Parting Shot - 46:28

    Not rated yet
  • Media Landscape A Hard Nut To Crack and Billy Herman's Career, Greatness It Did Not Lack

    · 1 hr 1 min

    This week we discuss the media landscape of Major League Baseball going into the future. What really is the best model for baseball and will the owners and players be able to pick one that works for everyone? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss the 1901 rule changes heading into the Modern Era of baseball. The rule changes that occurred have been evergreen and have stuck around until today, which really speaks to the lasting power of baseball as a sport. Our Hall of Famer this week is Second Baseman Billy Herman. This man was a rock solid model of second base consistencey, but was it enough to warrant the Vet's Committee's election of him to the Hall of Fame? In our singlular parting shot this week discusses the MLBPA and how the result upheaval could lead to problems moving into the upcoming negotiations. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials with NES RBI Baseball, Bell of PA Yellow Pages with Mike Schmidt, and Denny's Hologram Cards with Wally Joyner! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 20:33 Hall of Fame Discussion - 32:25 Parting Shot - 47:25

    Not rated yet
  • MLB Players Look To The World Stage and Ralph Kiner's Peak Does Not Quite Engage

    · 1 hr 8 min

    This week we discuss the whether or not a team should allow their players to participate in international competitions. Teams from MLB or other leagues drag their feet on this idea, but should they just allow these players to go compete? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss the 1920 rule change prohibiting alterations of the baseball. We discuss how effective this change has been, but also how important it is that the change was made at all. Our Hall of Famer this week is outfielder Ralph Kiner. Kiner certainly was a fantastic player for in a short period of time, but was that enough for us to wholeheartedly endorse his inclusion into Cooperstown? In our singlular parting shot this week discuss athlete owned restaurants. Some have succeeded, many have not, but what was the secret sauce to that and why do so many athletes go down this path Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials Wheaties and Ralph Kiner, Griffey Jr with Ichiro, and Buster Posey for MLB the Show! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball -18:47 Hall of Fame Discussion - 37:53 Parting Shot - 55:49

    Not rated yet
  • The 2026 Hall of Fame Ballot Discussion

    · 51 min

    Once Again, that time of year has arrived, the new Baseball Hall of Fame announcement! This episode is dedicated entirely to discussing the results of the most recent BBWAA Hall of Fame ballot. We discussed the 2 BBWAA electees in great detail as well as those who fell short or fell off the ballot entirely. Time Stamps for each section are below: Ichiro: 2:50 C.C. Sabathia: 14:54 Andruw Jones: 13:20 Full Ballot Review and Look Ahead: 21:10

    Not rated yet
  • Winning With No Stars May Be Only A Dream and Jim Bottomley's Career, Does It Have The Right Gleam?

    · 1 hr 2 min

    This week we discuss the whether or not a team in the current baseball landscape can construct a winner without a superstar player. We have seen teams do it in the past such as the 1969 Mets or the 1991 Twins, but do we think its possible now or a dream of a bygone era? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss FDR's 1942 proclamation that baseball should continue during the war. We talk keeping up morale, but also what kind of mood would have happened if baseball had disappeared during such a tumultuous time. Our Hall of Famer this week is first baseman Jim Bottomley. He surely had a string of good years and holds the record for single game RBI, but was that enough for us to allow him to stay? In our singlular parting shot this week discuss the life and career of actor Paul Douglas. He starred in only two baseball movies, but he was certainly someone who lived a fascinating life right until the end. Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials featuring staying optimistic in little league, opening day baseball hype, and Andrew McCutchen for MLB the Show. Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball -22:51 Hall of Fame Discussion - 35:38 Parting Shot -46:47

    Not rated yet
  • Vet's Committee Selection Perplexes Us All and Whitey Ford's Hall Case Is Far From A Close Call

    · 1 hr 4 min

    This week we discuss the Modern Era HOF Committee results for this year. Only one selection for the Hall from the committee, but were we surprised by that selection and should he have been the only one? For our This Week In Baseball, we discuss the standardization of baseball in 1933. It took many years into MLB's existence to make this change and we talk about the difference and the change itself. Our Hall of Famer this week is pitcher Whitey Ford. Not a laugher as his teammate was in our last discussion, but did we believe him to be a no doubt candidate for the Hall? In our singlular parting shot this week discuss the the baffling contracts given out with the a likely looming work stoppage next year. Why would teams do this and what will the rammifications of those decisions be? Enjoy our new crop of weekly commercials all featuring White Ford with Post Cereal, Braniff Airlines, and Campbell's soup! Please join us as we discuss baseball topics and we continue our mission to make The Hall small. We hope you'll enjoy the ride. Timestamps This Week In Baseball - 21:13 Hall of Fame Discussion - 36:26 Parting Shot -52:56

    Not rated yet
  • The Small Hall Smörgåsbord 4: The Quest for Small Hall Peace

    · 1 hr 17 min

    We present to you Part 4 of "The Smörgåsbord" This episode we will be reviewing yet another set players that are not in the Baseball Hall of Fame, but were suggested by folks on social media as players who should have their case reviewed. We took a look at each player and gave our thoughts on their case. Do we think any of them were oversights and should be in the HOF? Have a listen won't you? This is our fourth set of players and we will review even more in the future. Each player can be found at the timestamp below: Al Oliver - 2:00 Dwight Gooden - 9:32 Urban Shocker - 17:28 Dave Concepcion - 26:36 Buddy Bell - 36:30 Bill Dahlen - 43:32 Thurman Munson - 50:00 Tommy John - 1:04:39

    Not rated yet