Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Cutting Sugar Without Losing Your Customers: How to Reduce Sugar Step by Step and Keep the Product People Love

From Scaling Your Healthy Food Product · · 17 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Episode Summary #92 A buyer asks you to get the sugar down, so you cut it, and suddenly your regulars are asking, "Did you change something?" In this Better-for-You Formulation episode, Jacinta explains why sugar is doing five jobs in your product, not just making it sweet, and why swapping in a sweetener only fills one of them. She walks through a step-down method using the ETS Method, from locking in your gold standard to a kitchen-table blind test with your real customers, plus what "reduced sugar," "sugar free" and "no added sugar" actually mean on a label. You'll walk away knowing how to cut sugar in small, tested steps your loyal customers won't notice.

What We Cover - [0:00] The granola bar scenario: what happens when you cut sugar all at once

- [1:45] Sugar's five jobs: sweetness, structure, shelf life, browning and body

- [3:45] Two traps: over-correcting to zero and the silent swap

- [4:45] Your non-negotiables: what customers would never forgive you for changing

- [5:00] Evaluate: locking in your gold standard

- [5:45] Transform: stepping down 10–15% at a time

- [6:30] Flavor before sweeteners: vanilla, spices, salt and toasting

- [7:15] Rehiring for sugar's other jobs, and choosing sweeteners like allulose, stevia and monk fruit by the job

- [8:15] The kitchen-table blind test with your regulars

- [9:00] Scale: re-checking shelf life, plant trials and your spec sheet

- [9:30] Label claims: "reduced sugar," "sugar free," "no added sugar" and a heads-up on allulose

- [10:45] What opens up when you get it right, and this week's action

Key Takeaways - Sugar has a job description. Besides sweetness, it gives structure, protects shelf life, creates browning and adds body, so plan a replacement for every job you remove.

- Step down, don't jump. Small reductions of around 10–15% are much harder for customers to notice than cutting a third at once.

- Reach for flavor before sweeteners. Vanilla, warm spices, a pinch of salt and toasted ingredients make a product taste sweeter and keep your label simple.

- Let your customers decide. A simple blind test with a few regulars tells you whether a reduction is safe to keep.

- Know your claim before you print. "Reduced sugar" means at least 25% less than your original, and any front-of-pack sugar claim deserves a regulatory review.

- Upcoming Cohort

Retain Readiness Program — Emerging food businesses with better for you food products looking to expand to other markets.

Starts November 26th | "Limited to 10 Founders"

The Retail Readiness Program is a 6-month program for emerging food and beverage founders, built on the ETS Method: Evaluate your product's readiness and pricing, Transform your production with the right manufacturing partner, and Scale into the retail channel your product is built for. By month six, you'll know exactly which retail path fits your brand and have a roadmap to get there.

👉 Apply to Join here

Cohorts are kept small so every founder gets hands-on support, and spots for the next cohort are limited. Take the Retail Readiness Assessment by November 12th to find out if your brand is ready. 👉 [Take free Assessment here]

Links & Resources - New Book: Building Retail Ready Food Products — Ebook is ready. Preorder to get a signed copy (https://iconworld.co/author/jacinta-kemboi)

- Protein claim episode:What a plant trial actually is Why Skipping it is the most expensive shortcut in food.

- Join Emerging Food Business Newsletter here

Connect With Me - Instagram: @jacintakemboim

- Website: https://camaresearch.com

- Email: info@camaresearch.com

Have a question or topic you want covered on the show? Reach out — I'd love to hear where you're at in your own scale-up journey. Use below link to record and send me your questions.https://www.speakpipe.com/JacintaKemboi

Back to Scaling Your Healthy Food Product · Report a problem