31 | Colleen Slemmer: The Murder That Sent Christa Pike to Death Row
From Probation Behavior · · 54 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
In January 1995, 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer was attending the Job Corps program in Knoxville, Tennessee, hoping to build a better future for herself. But a confrontation with fellow student Christa Pike would end in an unimaginably brutal murder, leaving Colleen's family devastated and eventually making Pike one of the most notorious women on Tennessee's death row.
What led an 18-year-old woman to commit such a horrific crime? And how did jealousy, manipulation, and group dynamics contribute to the violence? This week, Ally tells Colleen's story, examining the disturbing events surrounding her murder, the investigation that followed, and the circus around Christa Pike’s failed execution in 2026. At the center of it all is a young woman whose life deserves to be remembered for far more than the circumstances of her death.
Before diving into the case, Ally recounts her recent trip to Paris, including a particularly eccentric tour guide at Père Lachaise Cemetery. Somehow, this leads Ally and Abby into a surprisingly philosophical conversation about the evolution of death, burial traditions, and how our relationship with mortality has changed over time. Definitely a different kind of intro this week!
Story starts: 7:57
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior (https://www.instagram.com/probationbehavior)
Join our Patreon (https://www.patreon.com/ProbationBehavior)
Email: probationbehavior@gmail.com
Case request form: Submit a case request (https://forms.gle/ZpkesTmWkUjADjJ76)
Sources
- Tennessee Supreme Court — State v. Pike (1998) (https://law.justia.com/cases/tennessee/supreme-court/1998/pike.html)
- Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals — Pike v. State (2011) (https://law.justia.com/cases/tennessee/court-of-criminal-appeals/2011/e2009-00016-cca-r3-pd.html)
- Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals — State v. Shipp (https://tncourts.gov/sites/default/files/OPINIONS/tcca/PDF/983/shippt.pdf)
- Nashville Banner / Chattanooga Times Free Press — Tennessee prepares to execute Christa Pike for the murder of Colleen Slemmer (https://tfpdev.wehco.com/news/2026/sep/14/tennessee-prepares-to-execute-christa-pike-for/)
- Nashville Banner / Chattanooga Times Free Press — Pleas for mercy and demands for justice (https://tfpdev.wehco.com/news/2026/sep/28/christa-pikes-imminent-execution-attracts-pleas/)
- ABC News Australia — Christa Pike survives lethal injection after decades on death row (https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-10-02/christa-pike-colleen-slemmer-survives-execution-attempt/107211372)
- USA Today / AOL — What happened to Pike’s accomplices (https://www.aol.com/articles/christa-pike-wasnt-alone-her-160314000.html)
- U.S. Supreme Court — Nelsen v. Pike execution-stay order (https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/26a428_4f15.pdf)
- Associated Press — How Tennessee’s failed execution unfolded, minute by minute (https://apnews.com/article/616827e89ef356d726bf8f0b7e5c7185)
- Death Penalty Information Center — Failed execution and earlier warnings from attorneys (https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/news/tennessee-botches-another-execution-despite-earlier-warnings-from-attorneys-christa-pike-was-alive-hours-after-attempt-began)
- Tennessee Department of Correction — September 30 media advisory (https://comptroller.aem.extglb.tn.gov/correction/news/2026/9/30/media-advisory--christa-pike--261368.html)
- WPLN — Governor Lee pauses executions and orders an outside review (https://wpln.org/post/gov-lee-halts-execution-orders-third-party-review-following-pikes-failed-lethal-injection/)
- Office of Governor Bill Lee — Independent review announcement (https://www.forth.news/lists/tngov/CffpSmtfoxQxcCQuegcYC)
- Death Penalty Information Center — Evidence preservation and Pike’s recovery…