Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Oli French & Sally Vivyan: Why and how do foundations spend down?

From Philanthropisms · · 1 hr 11 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Send us Fan Mail (https://www.buzzsprout.com/1862997/fan_mail/new)

In this episode we talk to Oli French (freelance consultant) and Sally Vivyan (Co-Director of Gower Street and Grants Advisor/Trustee to the Sir Ernest Cassel Education Trust) about why and how foundations choose to spend themselves down. Including:

- Are decisions to spend down more commonly about mission, principles or practicalities? Or is it a mixture of all 3 (and how does the balance shift over time)?

- Who tends to make the decision to spend down in an existing perpetual foundation? How do they justify their legitimacy to make this decision?

- How often do people make appeals to the original founder’s wishes or values?

- How many foundations openly share their rationale for spending down? Is this primarily to justify their own decision, or to influence others?

- How important is it to situate a decision to spend down in knowledge of the wider funding ecosystem?

- What are the different methods for spending down?

- Do most foundations increase spending across all existing grantees, focus in on a particular subset of them, or look to fund new things?

- How are debates about spending down related to debates about the need for higher average foundation payout rates (or mandatory minimums)?

- How are payout debates related to debates about foundations investing their assets in line with their missions?

- To what extent do foundations exist in perpetuity as a default, rather than an active choice?

- Would it be enough to shift this norm? (i.e. allow for foundations to be perpetual, but make that more of an opt-in/active choice than it is currently?)

- Is there a risk that discussions of spending down with the philanthropy world become too polarised and polemic (i.e. spending down is the only “right” way, and all others are “wrong”)?

- Is the current focus on spending down merely the latest iteration of a long-standing critical debate about perpetuity, or is there something fundamentally new or different about what we are seeing right now?

- What is driving this focus on spending down? Is it primarily supply-side concerns about philanthropic power, or demand side concerns about the scale and urgency of need right now?

- How do charities view the spend down debate?

- How different is the decision to make a newly-created foundation limited-life from the decision to shift an existing perpetual foundation to a spend down approach?

- Is there any evidence (anecdotal or otherwise) that next generation philanthropists take a different view of perpetuity than previous generations?

- Are there ever valid arguments in favour of perpetuity?

FURTHER RESOURCES:

- The microsite presenting the findings of the spend down group (https://ukspendouts.my.canva.site/)

- ACF Funders Collaborative Hub page for the spend down group (https://www.funderscollaborativehub.org.uk/collaborations/a-collaborative-peer-support-group-for-trusts-spending-out)

- WPM short guide on long-term vs short-term in philanthropy (https://whyphilanthropymatters.com/guide/current-issues-trends/short-term-vs-long-term/)

- WPM long read "What is the Point of Foundations? (https://whyphilanthropymatters.com/article/what-is-the-point-of-philanthropic-foundations-part-3-current-issues/)"

- Philanthropisms podcast episodes on the history of foundations (https://whyphilanthropymatters.com/podcast/philanthropic-foundations-history-role-and-controversy/) and on The Gates Foundation and Timescales in Philanthropy (https://whyphilanthropymatters.com/podcast/philanthropic-foundations-history-role-and-controversy/)

Back to Philanthropisms · Report a problem