Skip to main content
AmigoFish

A Doctor Said Nose Breathing Doesn't Matter. Here's the Response.

From Oxygen Advantage® · · 3 min

The player loads from YouTube only when you click. It uses YouTube's privacy-enhanced mode.

If the video does not play, the owner may have turned off embedding. Watch it on YouTube instead.

Watch on YouTube

Not rated yet

Description

At a medical conference in Chicago, a senior professor of medicine stood up and told Patrick McKeown it makes no difference whether you breathe through your nose or your mouth.

In this clip, Patrick recounts that moment - being publicly challenged by a respected, older doctor, with only one other person in the room (Dr. Kevin Boyd) willing to back him up. He then asks James Nestor how he would have responded to the same claim. James doesn't attack the doctor directly - instead, he lays out the case for why the nose exists at all: an intricate, space-consuming system of sinus passages that evolution carefully built into one of the most crowded, precious parts of the human body. His point is simple - if it didn't matter, why would it be there?

James also draws a sharper comparison, pointing to other body parts once dismissed as unnecessary - tonsils, adenoids, the appendix, the spleen - and how that thinking has aged. He's candid that a few years ago, this kind of dismissal would have provoked a strong reaction from him; now, he's more interested in simply asking pointed questions and letting people draw their own conclusions.

A sharp, evidence-based response to a claim that's more common in medicine than people might expect.

🎙️ From the full conversation between Patrick McKeown and James Nestor ▶️ Watch the full episode: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=npGKGtwsTuc

Back to Oxygen Advantage® · Report a problem